News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by lalaithion on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:03PM (#32856017)
RCV != IRV.

Everyone is reporting this as a failure of Ranked Choice Voting, but it's actually a failure of Instant Runoff Voting. There are other, better, more reliable Ranked Choice alternatives, and any serious expert in voting systems would tell you that IRV has as many weird failures as FPTP.

http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ is a good overview of different methods.

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by twblalock on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:29PM (#32856364)
This whole conversation is a good demonstration of why FPTP succeeds and is popular -- it is easy to understand, and most of the other systems are not. When a voting system is hard to understand, people will tend to see conspiracies and fraud even though there isn't any, and they will lose trust in the system.

With FPTP, every voter casts one vote for one candidate, and the candidate with the most votes wins. Simple.

If you need a website with diagrams to explain the abstruse differences between different voting mechanisms, I think you've already failed. This stuff is certainly of academic interest but the average voter cannot handle it.

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by lalaithion on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:46PM (#32856651)
This is why I endorse STAR voting: https://www.equal.vote/star. The explanation behind it is simple enough for most people to understand, because it's a combination of 5 star ratings, which are everywhere in society, and FPTP.
Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by bena on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:25PM (#32857279)
At worst, you've made single vote FPTP with extra steps. Give your guy 5, everyone else 0. The goal is to get in the runoff and to keep others out. If everyone adopts this strategy, it's the same as FPTP.

At best, you're made RCV/IRV with extra steps. Because still you give your guy 5 stars, but now there's people you do not want at all. They're 0s. Then there are people you're ok with, but would rather have your guy win. They're 1s. That way, if the runoff is between one of your 0s and one of your 1s, you're making sure a 0 doesn't win. Which is exactly RCV/IRV where you've ranked them 1, 2, and 3.

Past that, candidates towards the bottom of the ballot are going to get shafted. There is incredible decision fatigue in having to rank everyone 0 - 5 stars. After a while, you will either give up or just start picking more arbitrarily.

RCV/IRV is fine. Condorcet is fine. Star voting is just bad.

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by godelski on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:36PM (#32858781)
> At best, you're made RCV/IRV with extra steps

I'd argue that every single word in this small claim is wrong.

Scoring isn't equivalent to ranking unless the conditions are that you cannot score two candidates the same and that you must fill in every possible score vale (i.e. rank). Neither of these conditions are true for any cardinal system. You can score candidates the same and you can score candidates with variable distances (e.g. 5,3,2,1. Note there is no 4). This has different embedding properties. You actually can express more information in cardinal this way.

Second, run-off voting is much more complicated. Cardinal systems are determined by argmax of a reduce-sum. Which is trivially parallelizable and only requires a singular election. Run-offs require multi-elections. Even in simple cases like this one, there were 2 elections (and that's with 3 candidates!). This doesn't scale well either.

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by lalaithion on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:42PM (#32857492)
https://www.equal.vote/accuracy

Star voting outperforms IRV on both 100% honest and 100% strategic election strategies.

Decision fatigue is easier for Star than for IRV—just rate everyone you don't care about as a 2, whereas for IRV, if you want to distinguish between "8 people I don't know" and "person I hate", you have to decide on a ranking order for the 8 people.

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by philjohn on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:48PM (#32856684)
But as we've seen in the UK, and the US it leaves a great deal of people, especially those in safe (or gerrymandered) districts feeling unrepresented.

UKIP getting 13% of the vote in a general election, showing a large amount of support, but not winning a single seat is, in my opinion, a travesty (and I vehemently disagree with their platform and what they stand for). It left 13% of the electorate feeling that their views were not represented in any way whatsoever .

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by twblalock on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:54PM (#32856795)
That seems like more of a problem with proportional representation than ranked-choice voting.

If only 13% of voters support UKIP, UKIP would not win elections no matter what kind of voting system you have: ranked choice, instant runoff, etc.

On the other hand, with proportional representation, if a party gets 13% of the vote it would end up with 13% of the seats in Parliament. That's a different type of system, though, and it is hard to reconcile with a per-constituency election system.

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by jacobr1 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:18PM (#32857175)
> That's a different type of system, though, and it is hard to reconcile with a per-constituency election system.

One way to reconcile it is with different legislative bodies. Exchange the house of lords for a proportional body, and keep the commons local to constituencies.

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by pmyteh on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:48PM (#32858235)
FPTP has more failures than IRV in general, they're just less visible because you don't have the ranking data to work out the hypotheticals. That may be good for FPTP's popularity, but doesn't make it a decent voting system.

FWIW I also disagree with the suggestion that people can't handle it. Plenty of countries use ranked or proportional voting systems and their citizens understand how to use them just fine. They may not be able to perfectly optimise their preferences, but then they can't do it in FPTP either (and it's provably impossible to do so in every case whatever the voting system).

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by gamegoblin on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:08PM (#32856079)
In US political vernacular, RCV == IRV. This is just a case of terminology getting warped, but it is what it is.
Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by lalaithion on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:17PM (#32856202)
Yeah, but we should push back against this, lest it poison every attempt at getting better non-IRV RCV implemented.
Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by gamegoblin on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:23PM (#32856272)
I think it's far too late for that.

I don't know if I have ever seen any movement to push back against "wrong" vernacular succeed. Consider the more recent "coronavirus" which is equivalent to COVID-19 in the vernacular, even though it's really just a family of viruses and COVID-19 is an illness caused by a particular coronavirus instance (SARS CoV-2).

Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by fdsjgfklsfd on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:52PM (#32891831)
99% of people who call it "RCV" have no idea how it works. Just call it "Hare RCV" in the same context as "Schulze RCV" or "Minimax RCV" and they'll be forced to confront their ignorance.
Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by jacobr1 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:19PM (#32857195)
Agreed - you can't fight back against labeling by telling people they are wrong. Instead to you must fight-forward with a new proposal going in a different direction.
Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by froh on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:22PM (#32856257)
that's the idea behind falsely mislabeling irv as rcv...
Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the... by godelski on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:39PM (#32858814)
Honestly I have the term RCV. It is a specific type of ranked choice systems and now we have to refer to that class as Ordinal to not be confused with the specific variant. And it leads to a lot of misunderstandings like this.