Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the...
by twblalock on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:54PM
(#32856795)
That seems like more of a problem with proportional representation than ranked-choice voting.
If only 13% of voters support UKIP, UKIP would not win elections no matter what kind of voting system you have: ranked choice, instant runoff, etc.
On the other hand, with proportional representation, if a party gets 13% of the vote it would end up with 13% of the seats in Parliament. That's a different type of system, though, and it is hard to reconcile with a per-constituency election system.
Re:Alaska Ranked Choice Voting Cast Vote Record [JSON at the...
by jacobr1 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:18PM
(#32857175)
> That's a different type of system, though, and it is hard to reconcile with a per-constituency election system.
One way to reconcile it is with different legislative bodies. Exchange the house of lords for a proportional body, and keep the commons local to constituencies.
UKIP getting 13% of the vote in a general election, showing a large amount of support, but not winning a single seat is, in my opinion, a travesty (and I vehemently disagree with their platform and what they stand for). It left 13% of the electorate feeling that their views were not represented in any way whatsoever .