But that kind of thing hardly seems to be the problem of mixing too many people together, it is simply a flaw in the system.
Of course the initial problem might have been that the system could only be some lowest common denominator of all the systems it tries to combine, making it almost impossible to create something good.
I find it interesting that there are therefore two interesting problems: how to set up a stable currency, and more importantly, how to set up a decision process that produces good results and doesn't alienate everybody.
Of course, I'm just relating what I've been reading. I can tell you it's been quite alarming and yet strangely placid. Like watching a slow-motion train wreck.
I didn't mean the number of people. I meant the idea of smashing up lots of different systems of government and cultures through byzantine layers of bureaucracy instead of just replacing them with a centralized government (which would have worked very well, probably, but it was politically unfeasible)
Apart from going to these countries and open a bank account or have actual money under the mattress, how would this work?
My bank allows me to have accounts in USD and GBP (I actually have some money on each) but if the euro blows, and there is a bank freeze and mandatory 'exchange' of euros to whatever your local coin is, I would think these accounts would also be affected (something like exchanging the USD to EUR at current rate, and then changing the EUR to escudo or dracma)
I looked at forex but I'm in no way qualified to understand how the hell that works.
To a first order approximation, every country is printing money in a beggar-thy-neighbour approach to increasing competitiveness. But when the malaise is global, that doesn't exactly work well.
I'd consider the Canadian and Australian dollars, but they're both way over valued right now because of their political and economic stability. They have no where to go but down I think.
I suppose even the US has different parts with different economic cycles and different economic strength.
Your point about the US is valid. However as their national debt is $15 trillion they aren't exactly a model economy.
Why are people so obsessed about the debt of sovereign governments these days?
Think about it like this: there is (virtual) money in MMO games. Gold in World of Warcraft, ISK in Eve Online, or whatever. In an in-world accounting sense, this money is a debt (liability) of whoever runs the system. But it is ridiculous on the fact of it to worry about the total amount of money in those systems.
So why is their this obsession with the debt?
The most immediate reason is this gut reflex of "it needs to be paid back". But what one has to realize is that, for a monetary sovereign, paying back the debt is just exchanging one type of liability against another. The debt is money that has already been spent. Paying it back does not create new financial assets, it is just an asset swap. Why on earth would that be problematic?
The other objection is that the interest paid on debt causes an undue redistribution of wealth. That point is one of ignorance: a monetary sovereign effectively sets the interest rate that it pays on its outstanding debt - that is what the monetary policy of the central bank is about.
Seeing the true nature of money is initially scary, and perhaps this is what stops many from a deeper understanding. I can only hope that future generation will make fun of us for the way we are thinking about money.
That is one reason why people had high hopes for Europe: today it seems unthinkable to have a war between states of Germany (they don't have their own military either). Perhaps one day it could be as unthinkable to have war between European states.
Countries which tie their domestic currency directly to the US's include Panama, Ecuador, and El Salvador. Namibia ties its currency to South Africa's (or rather, to the Multilateral Monetary Area).
Other monetary unions exist. The CFA franc has been around for 60+ years and the East Caribbean dollar has been around for 45+ years.
Those seem like counter-arguments to the idea that monetary policy should be "set on a country by country basis."
Since countries do yield domestic currency in favor of a shared currency, it's apparent that there are advantages to doing so. Why do none of those apply to the EU?
I know that I like how I can use the same currency in Germany, France, Spain, and Ireland without having to change money each trip. While I don't like stopping in Denmark, which has their own domestic currency.
The idea of for a country to appear credible by using a golden straightjacket. It's usually used by countries coming out of hyperinflation phases. And that policy has badly failed before in Argentina.
if you mean centralized government of the Empire - i'd not agree, there were other big Empires in the Europe which preserved, instead of solved/improved, the problems. If you mean Napoleonic wars, when i'd agree and add WWI and WWII.
There is a lesson here about taking systems of people and trying to mash them together without acknowledging the necessary pain. I'm concerned that now we're in the end game, and more and more complex strategies are just going to make things worse. I would never advocate any kind of violence, but there's a good reason why Napoleon was the one person who did the most to modernize Europe.
The general consensus seems to be that a recession is already under way, and the contraction will continue until this all gets straightened out.