News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by jfim on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:52PM (#32796448)
Out of curiosity, why would it be plumbing? There should be enough capacity to handle both fresh and black water, considering the high occupancy of typical office buildings.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by wronglebowski on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:08PM (#32796498)
I learned this when my company leased the floor of a big office building in Philly. You can do almost anything you want, except for with plumbing. Especially bathrooms. Despite having almost 150 desks there is a limit of 3 sinks, 6 stalls, 2 urinals, and 6 hand washing sinks. Full stop.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by jfim on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:15PM (#32796523)
Wow, thanks for sharing, I stand corrected.

I wonder what causes these buildings to have such restrictions on plumbing. Maybe it's like elevator shafts where they eventually take up a lot of space if the building is very tall.

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by zdragnar on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:17AM (#32797038)
It's more an issue of volume. People showing, doing laundry, cooking etc use significantly more water, so the pipes entering and leaving the building need to be sized differently.

Conversely, adding more toilets, for example, may also pose a challenge. My dad helped design the plumbing system for a rebuild of a football stadium. One of the final tests was to have a bunch of volunteers go to every sink, toilet and urinal in the building and turn them on / flush them simultaneously to ensure that water pressure stayed high and the drain pipes didn't back up.

Adding more toilets in a building not meant for them can be a big deal right after lunch / around "busy" times... Some may not be able to flush or overflow if the pipes can't handle the extra activity.

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by johndoughy on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:28PM (#32796576)
> Despite having almost 150 desks there is a limit of 3 sinks, 6 stalls, 2 urinals, and 6 hand washing sinks. Full stop.

Who instituted the limit? Was it in the lease terms, city ordinances, or something else?

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by zwkrt on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:38PM (#32796621)
I assume the pipe leading in and out of the building have a maximum capacity that was designed for office (i.e., no showers, washers, kitchens).
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by wronglebowski on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:56PM (#32796694)
I didn’t get that involved but was told it wasn’t a matter of cost. There were very limited hookups that could be moved slightly for the sinks. Bathrooms could not be moved or modified in any way. I assume it’s a limit on the overall building in/output.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by jessaustin on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:46PM (#32801162)
There were very limited hookups that could be moved slightly for the sinks.

This means you couldn't chip up the concrete slab to place new pipes, the way we could in e.g. a strip mall. This is an understandable limitation, because the integrity of slabs is important for tall buildings.

However, this wouldn't be a limitation in a residential remodel. They aren't going to mess with the slab or the pipes in it. They're just going to lay everything over the top of the slab. If the new toilet is 40' from the utility shaft, that is 3" for the pipe plus 5" for the fall. Add an inch for the floor itself. Average residential ceilings are much lower than average office building ceilings, so there is definitely at least 9" to spare.

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by dylan604 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:44AM (#32797137)
It's all roses when you're living on the top floor. If you're on any other floor, waste water from other people's units will be flowing through your space. The lower your floor, the more of other people's waste will be flowing. I know this from experience of living in a building converted from commercial warehouse to residential. SSOL for those in Dallas
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by danans on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:07AM (#32796998)
Plumbing for both fresh and black water in many office buildings are limited to specific areas for high capacity restrooms, so you might have a large supply to one spot. That's not practical for housing, in which each unit needs its own plumbing.

Retrofitting all that additional plumbing is expensive.

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by chiefalchemist on Sunday September 11, 2022 @08:09AM (#32798942)
But grey water is different, yes? Couldn't it be held in holding tanks and then allowed to flow out during off hours?

Toilets are obviously a different story. But as long as no one is shitting in their kitchen or bathroom sink the water flow post-usage can in theory be managed.

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by danans on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:00AM (#32800162)
> Couldn't it be held in holding tanks and then allowed to flow out during off hours?

I don't think it's a timing issue. The issue is that the fresh and wastewater plumbing simply doesn't exist in the places you'd expect in housing, so there can be a significant cost to adding it, beginning with just figuring out where you can run it through the existing spaces.

A holding tank and whatever pipes then are used to empty it are still plumbing, and even more complex than regular plumbing, unless you are suggesting that people would haul their own waste out periodically.

Also recall that wastewater pipes need to be at least slightly angled so that they drain properly using gravity, further constraining their potential paths. This can be quite difficult to design even when remodeling a regular house.

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by chiefalchemist on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:18PM (#32800905)
Not sure I agree. The other comments seem to say that office buildings are designed for a certain amount of water capacity. So even if you supplement (?) and add nodes (?) there's still a bottleneck of capacity. So, if water collected in tanks on each floor then it can be dripped out (so to speak) to not exceed capacity.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by danans on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:17PM (#32805699)
Even if total wastewater disposable capacity was the issue (which would be surprising considering the highly correlated toilet use in many office buildings after breakfast and lunch), the more fundamental problem is that the drain pipes are not distributed in a way conducive to residential use, or put another way, most people don't want communal bathrooms.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by MichaelZuo on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:01AM (#32825189)
Drains need to be sloped to the riser pipe. And in nearly all offices thats concentrated in the middle, which implies a huge slope for drains coming from several dozen feet away.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by xeromal on Saturday September 10, 2022 @11:57PM (#32796698)
It's probably very expensive to retrofit a large office building to provide plumbing in every new unit. Most floors only have a handful of bathrooms and probably 1 or 0 showers.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by refurb on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:16AM (#32797034)
Because most office buildings have plumbing run up a narrow corridor, rather than branching out on each floor, as you would need to serve plumbing to separate units.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by pwinnski on Sunday September 11, 2022 @02:42PM (#32802146)
Many office buildings have a single bank of toilets per floor. If a given floor is subdivided into n apartments, n-1 of them are probably not proximal to the existing toilet plumbing, so it's an expense, at least.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by grp000 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:56PM (#32796458)
You need to run plumbing through the floors to every unit. The floors are structural.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by quickthrowman on Sunday September 11, 2022 @02:25AM (#32797293)
You can drill dozens of 10” holes through a concrete floor in a commercial office tower. The structural part of the floor are the tensioned cables inside the concrete, as long as you dont’t sever those, you can drill a ton of holes without impacting the structural integrity.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prestressed_concrete

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by grp000 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:04AM (#32798613)
I used to work in concrete construction, doing post tensioned and SOMD for elevated slab. Coring might be simpler for SOMD, but post tensioned has such a high density of cables that I don't think it would work.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by loonster on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:16AM (#32800324)
Commercial buildings tend to have very high ceilings. Maybe build a raised floor and put the plumbing under there.
Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by tzs on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:29AM (#32799913)
Could you run vertical pipes on the outside in back of the building, and run horizontal pipes through space between adjacent apartments that you specifically leave for that purpose when converting the interior?

If you need intermediate pumping stations or holding tanks due to the height of the building, those could be inside adjacent to the outside pipes.

Re:Empty offices are becoming apartments in Texas’s big cities by Ekaros on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:16PM (#32801400)
I have also been thinking of this, but shouldn't they have quite a bit height? So you could easily install the needed plumbing in there.