Cloudflare is what Google was 20 years ago.
The cycle can only break by decentralized protocols.
I disagree. The cycle can break by breaking up the monopolies so that one company doesn't control everything, and allow free market to expand.
Competition keeps people from being evil. Evil only happens when there's no reason for them to NOT do evil things.
Google was fine until they became the top dog and nobody could even compete.
The only alternative is regulatory intervention, which is unlikely to happen, however much you may want it to happen.
I don’t agree. People generally don’t steal, but if they have no food, they will resort to theft to survive. Competition can prevent some ill effects of monopolistic tyranny, which I think is what you’re getting at here, but it breeds other evils.
Cloudflare is already much worse. It's relentlessly centralizing the whole Internet.
When using standard SNI (SNI is used so you can have multiple domains on the same IP address) your connection to the server is not encrypted until after the hostname of the server you are requesting is sent at which point the server knows which cert to use to encrypt the rest of the traffic. So you can pull the host header out of the pre-encrypted traffic and look at which site the user is connecting too.
1) When the webserver you are accessing uses services that terminate TLS before the origin server (Cloudflare and CloudFront to name two) then the operators of those TLS terminators might be able to see which pages on that site you visit
2) You might be able to determine which page someone is accessing via side channels, for example if example.com/naughtypage.html always returns a page of a certain size which is determinable you can presume they connected to example.com/naughtypage.html if the returning data matches that size.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Server_Name_Indication
> The desired hostname is not encrypted in the original SNI extension, so an eavesdropper can see which site is being requested.
So think of it like other forms of protection where 2 is better than 1 just in case that one fails.
Well, actually it doesn't, since ping time is not particularly important to me, but in theory.
My webhost would be a terrible replacement for Cloudfare's main product, which maybe you're talking about, as it needs a worldwide presence. This product is a VPN for your phone.
Pointing out that the company will revolve is not a criticism.
I do think it's kinda funny they are trying to oust your ISP and insert themselves, as the keeper of traffic logs. Either way, I guess we're going to choose a big corporation to trust.
Lastly, I don't think your point stands, when the quote says "we won't sell your data, EVER" (my emphasis)
It's a weak promise and a valid criticism.
> We believe privacy is a right. We won't sell your data, ever.
"We, the people who make up this company now, but not in the future, PROMISE."
I notice they didn't say "we don't keep the data."
According to the comments, this is just wireguard. I deployed my own on a webhost and I use that, probably to the same effect. I guess I have to trust the webhost not to go snooping in my private logs, but that's a whole lot more targeted and requires a lot more effort.