News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by lacker on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:34AM (#32746747)
This article doesn't describe the problem very directly. I found this op-ed by a student to be more informative.

https://www.dailycal.org/2022/04/08/a-personal-view-of-uc-be...

Ten years ago, the department graduated roughly 400 students with Bachelor’s degrees in EECS or computer science. This year, the number will probably be 1400, or roughly 15%, of all undergraduates. Almost all of that growth is in the College of Letters and Science CS major.

and more specifically:

The campus provides departments $50 per student-credit per hour to pay for both lecturers and TAs. A student in a 4-unit class contributes roughly $200 out of the student’s overall tuition for these expenses. Yet the actual cost to a department is more than $350 per student for that 4-unit class, forcing departments to find additional funds to cover the upward of $150 per student gap. [...] The EECS department is running an annual deficit of nearly $5 million.

At a high level, this problem is "growing pains" rather than "falling backwards". Computer science is booming at Berkeley, and they can't hire enough TAs to keep up when they are paying so badly. I hope they simply start paying CS TAs better.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by anu7df on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:35AM (#32747192)
Can I ask what it is that costs $350 per hour per student? There is one professor lecturing and a few TAs who work 20 hours a week at max. There are 60-100 students in all the major classes, 20-30 in more advanced ones. What exactly is the cost that leads to $350 per hour per student? Compute and infrastructure costs amortized over many students per year can't be it. Then what?
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by _e1bk on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:53AM (#32747320)
It's $350 per student per semester, rather than hour. The course mentioned in the op-end is a 4 credit-hour course which typically means the class gets $200 per student per semester to host it

Some significant costs come from the massive scales the classes are taught at. This semester, the first required CS lower division class has 1800 students (https://classes.berkeley.edu/content/2022-fall-compsci-61a-0...) and an upper division DBs class has 600 students. (https://classes.berkeley.edu/content/2022-fall-compsci-186-0...).

It takes a lot of TAs to handle student support, which doesn't scale well in practice. The class I teach publishes lots of videos and documentation about how to do the labs, projects, and homeworks, and we also have a forum where students can (to a reasonable extent) help each other out with common questions. However, the classes teach a lot of stuff really fast and you need a lot of TAs doing things like office hours to help students who didn't understand the speedy lecture, or have a particularly nasty time trying to debug an error.

One particularly difficult thing about this scaling is that students typically need TA help all at once. Office hours right before midterms and project deadlines have many students and more bodies are needed just to have good handling of "peak" times

Another aspect of TA cost is that TAs are paid significant amounts of tuition remission for their work, and the department has somewhat of a mandate to ensure any graduate student who wants to TA can get full tuition remission from a 10 hour position or higher (I'm guessing this is somewhat of a symptom of skyrocketing tuition and inadequate aid being foisted on the department to deal with). The department used to get around this by hiring tons of undergrads at an 8 hour level so they wouldn't get remission, but they were sued and paid out millions in backpay as well as paying all TAs a scaled remission based on their hour count. (https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2020/01/16/arbitrator-sa...). Generally an 8-hour TA gets paid around $40 an hour after remission and a 20-hour TA gets paid around $50 an hour. [very rough math read the other comment for harder numbers]

-Am a TA, speaking for myself

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by anu7df on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:38AM (#32748107)
Wait $350 is for the whole semester? So, if a student takes 5 courses per semester it will cost $3500 per year. Why can't the $15000 instate and $44000 out of state pay for this? If even 20% of the tuition is not going for class expenses there is something messed up somewhere
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:01AM (#32748997)
The $350 is the cost to the department in terms of things that scale per student (specifically faculty for teaching, grading homework, etc). The university as a whole has many other expenses.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by downrightmike on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @12:13PM (#32752544)
It can't be a 43 times increase. There is no way that money is not just going to the Admin and Endowment.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by elipsitz on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:46AM (#32747281)
The largest classes (CS 61A and CS 61B) have roughly 1800 and 1600 students respectively during peak semesters.

A 20 hour TA is paid ~$2250/mo for approximately 4.5 months per semester, plus ~$7000/semester in tuition remission (so ~$17k). $350 is the total cost for the whole semester per student. 17k/350 is about 50 students per TA, which sounds about right (and even that is a higher than ideal ratio). There are other costs too, but these are the some of the highest.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by Ekaros on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:56AM (#32747812)
That makes it look like that the cost of tuition is entirely the fault here. Lower that by half at least and numbers start to make lot more sense.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by anonymousDan on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:00AM (#32747857)
Wow, that is an insane number of students. I shudder at the thought of marking all those exams!
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by elipsitz on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:23AM (#32748395)
Grading was actually pretty fun. I kind of miss it! Exams are scanned and then graded electronically, which makes it less of a hassle. It’s still a lot of work, but you have an army of TAs to do it.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by idontwantthis on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:10AM (#32747437)
Are the TAs grad students? I got $10/hour and nothing else as an undergrad TA.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by elipsitz on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:11AM (#32747449)
Some are, almost all in the introductory classes (including me) and many in the upper division classes are undergrads.

(u)GSIs at Berkeley are paid particularly well compared to other schools, I think in large part due to the TA union (UAW 2865).

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by idontwantthis on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @11:49PM (#32760946)
Man, my university cost twice as much too.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by kkylin on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:27AM (#32747567)
Things being what they are in the USA, the cost of a grad TA may also include the cost of healthcare. Plus most grad students would be charged out-of-state tuition, which can be quite a bit higher than the in-state rate.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by elipsitz on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:20AM (#32748373)
Ah yeah, I believe the student health plan is part of it, but I can’t remember the cost.

For tuition remission, it’s only the in-state amount, even if you’re out of state.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by wbl on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @09:51AM (#32750624)
Every grad student becomes a CA resident after the first year.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by fsckboy on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:45AM (#32747270)
maybe he meant "credit hours" which is a different thing, I think a 4 credit course means that classes meet 4 hrs a week, but the $350 is for the entire semester or the quarter.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by daniel-cussen on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @08:11AM (#32749557)
Yes colleges should break out Tuition into salaries of faculty and administration.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by elipsitz on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:31AM (#32747156)
Correction— the author of the op-ed, Nicholas Weaver, is a former lecturer in the EECS department at UC Berkeley.

And a personal insight, as a former uGSI (TA) in the department, the problem isn’t paying TAs enough. The pay is actually quite high for a student job (especially when you factor in the fact that in-state tuition is paid for). But the course budgets simply aren’t high enough to hire the sheer quantity of TAs that would be required to handle all of the students who want to take the classes.

I was involved in hiring some semesters, and there were always more people we wanted to hire than the budget would allow. I believe the situation has only gotten worse since I left.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by lacker on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @12:25PM (#32752709)
That makes sense. So as a system we need to be spending more money on TAs, but not to raise their hourly pay, per se, mostly just to hire more TAs.

You are also correct that the author is a former lecturer. Too bad it's too late for me to edit the comment.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by TigeriusKirk on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:48AM (#32746825)
There's a great deal of missing information in that accounting. With what they've provided, it's not clear that they need to pay TAs more.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by jxramos on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:04AM (#32746934)
Aha, that makes more sense now. I was almost going to say is this really news? I thought the concept of an "impacted" major was a pretty old definition--it basically means there are more applicants than there are spaces. But this other bit of information about a growing slice of the student body pie electing for a hot and lucrative major.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by murphyslab on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:23AM (#32747089)
This reminds me of my alma mater. The provincial government previously had funded $X/student. Then they changed it to a fixed grant. Meanwhile, enrollment continued to expand; the institution saw the expansion as serving the public. Soon enough, the government cut back the university's funding, which cut the operating budget. Eventually the Faculty of Science was looking at a $10 million shortfall; the equivalent of an entire department's budget. So they cut back on student spaces to the old $X/student allocation. One would hope that the public would notice and speak up in response, asking their politicians to properly fund education.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by forrestthewoods on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:59AM (#32746898)
What a sad and embarrassing state of affairs. :(

Tuition is $14,000 for in-state and and a laughable $44,000 for out-of-state. And they can’t find an extra $150 per student? Fire one worthless administrator and the $150 gap is completely covered. Voila!

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by aidenn0 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:17AM (#32747493)
I'm sure the typical student takes 280 credits per year...
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by bhaney on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:38AM (#32746766)
> I hope they simply start paying CS TAs better.

Impossible. Students definitely don't pay more than $50 per credit hour in tuition, so there's nowhere for the university to get the additional funds from.

Edit: This was sarcastic

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by learndeeply on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:05AM (#32746944)
UC Berkeley has a $6 billion endowment. It's not impossible, but improbable.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by apengwin on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:24AM (#32747103)
the government and taxes presumably. I think higher education is a wonderful public investment with great returns.