News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by seibelj on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:15AM (#32733571)
If you had a ladder stretching all the way into space, you could climb it without needing any rocket propellant
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by kurthr on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:28AM (#32733648)
Or a sky hook that rotated at the rate of the earths rotation.

On the moon it's just about doable with current technology and realistic levels of mass.

Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by forgotpwd16 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:25AM (#32734789)
>On the moon it's just about doable with current technology and realistic levels of mass.

Will be interested if you have any studies on it.

Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by kurthr on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:17AM (#32746622)
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by forgotpwd16 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:59AM (#32748983)
Very cool articles (and basically the entire blog). Thanks!
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by ncmncm on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:14AM (#32734716)
Or, better, a sky ring. Weighs a bit more, but is an easier target. And the structural stresses work out better.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by BenjiWiebe on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:42PM (#32741326)
If you are talking a rigid ring circling the earth, don't forget your attitude jets.

Paging Larry Niven...

Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by ncmncm on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:42PM (#32742928)
No, that idea was just dumb.

A ring with a diameter matching your skyhook's length might seem to need 22/7 times the mass lofted to orbit, but the stresses on it are much less complicated, so it may be lighter than that. You may imagine one rolling around Earth, dipping to 100 km and flinging off whatever grabs on at up to 10 mi/s.

BTW, I calculated that the tensile strength of the material of any rotating ring, whether girdling the sun like Niven's, or just orbiting the regular way like a Halo or Culture "orbital", must be enough to support against its inside surface "gravity" a full radius's length of the material.

So, a ring rotating to provide 1G and taking 24hrs to do it (so days are the right length), would have to be about 2M km in radius. It would therefore need to be made out of something that could support a 2M km long constant-thickness cable against 1G, or more than 100x as strong as what you would need for an earthly space elevator.

A ring of 100 km radius rotating so that its tangential velocity matches earth orbital velocity less earth's rotation, 7.5 km/s, accelerates anything that latches onto it at 560 m/s^2, or 55 G. One at 1000 km radius would pull 5.2G, a little less strenuous for puny humans; they would need to endure it for a few minutes until flung off. That one would need to be made of stuff that could hold up 5200 km of itself, which might be just within range of what we can make.

Methods for dodging satellites are left as an exercise for the reader.

Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by Sharlin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:42AM (#32733745)
Yes; however, going up is not helpful without also going sideways fast enough, and it’s the latter part where almost all of the propellant is spent.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by MichaelCollins on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:32AM (#32734832)
We're all going sideways already, since the earth spins. Climb the ladder up to about 22 thousand miles and you'll be in geostationary orbit.

The catch is that nobody can actually build a ladder strong enough. Space elevators from Earth require sci-fi materials.

Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by knodi123 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:18AM (#32738286)
> The catch is that nobody can actually build a ladder strong enough.

Yes, we've ruled out aluminum and wood. But don't give up! Got any single-crystal graphene? That might work!

https://www.azom.com/article.aspx?ArticleID=16371

Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by taneq on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:01AM (#32735395)
I wonder how much it would help to have jets built in to the elevator which add support using compressed gas or something being pumped through the elevator from the ground? Then it would directly support the structure and also give the option of reacting to outside disturbances.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by Sharlin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:32PM (#32741169)
The ideal gas law tells you what happens when you do work on a system of gas molecules (in this case against the force of gravity).
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by taneq on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @06:42PM (#32744134)
What are you thinking of? Yeah, compressing the air at the base will increase its temperature, and then the pressure (and so temperature) will reduce as it gets higher, but it’s still going to be at a higher pressure than the air outside and so can provide support and reaction mass.

You might even be able to take advantage of this by chilling the compressed air before it goes into the beanstalk, so that it absorbs heat from the surrounding air on the way up. Or have separate pipes with one carrying methane to burn as fuel. Lots of options to evaluate.

Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by andylynch on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @06:51AM (#32735331)
Also when it fails expect the lower end to fall and wreck everything in the area underneath. Which with that length will be a lot! The insurance bill would be … astronomical (see what happened in the Foundation TV show for an example).
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by Sharlin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:29PM (#32741127)
Modern space elevator designs (starting from Brad Edwards’s NIAC study in the early 2000s) propose something much closer to a tether than a tower, maybe some hundreds of tons in total mass and shaped like a gossamer-thin ribbon. The worst-case failure mode of such a design would be rather anticlimactic.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by mburee on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:50AM (#32733801)
Just need to go a bit further, like, almost 36000km
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by mellavora on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:46AM (#32733769)
True, but you might get hungry or thirsty on the way. I wonder how much water you could carry?
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by Sharlin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:03AM (#32734292)
Considerably less than you need to carry in a rocket (separated to constituent atoms to be recombined and pushed out the back)!
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by betwixthewires on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:40AM (#32733736)
And you'd expend the same amount of energy climbing it as you would propelling yourself upward with fire.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by breakyerself on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:43AM (#32733747)
No because you could run it using electricity transmitted up the ladder. So you wouldn't need to expend energy to carry fuel up the ladder.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by pfdietz on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @08:06AM (#32735974)
Unless the ladder is made of superconductive unobtainium, this will not work (resistive losses kill you).

"Real" versions of this scheme would use laser power beaming. Of course, a "real" version of the scheme would also need hefty rockets on the passenger vehicle to keep them from dying if the vehicle fell off the ladder (or if the ladder broke). The rockets are needed to either slow the vehicle before atmospheric entry (so the deceleration is not fatal) or thrust sideways to put the passenger pod into elliptical orbit that just misses the atmosphere. The delta-V needed at the worst case altitude is non-negligible.

Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by betwixthewires on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:39AM (#32734513)
I imagine the words "climb the ladder" to mean literally climbing a ladder.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by moring on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:08AM (#32733913)
Would you? A rocket needs to use propellant for the time it stays in the gravity field, i.e. just to "stay still", while clinging to the ladder does not need propellant.
Re:The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012) by baq on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:20AM (#32734746)
going up is the easy part, high school students can do it. going sideways fast enough to not fall back... that's the hard part.