The trilogy was great because of the writings of Tolkien. Peter Jackson did his best respecting that and telling Tolkien's story, not his own. I think that's why they were successful.
What's the point of adapting a source material if you think it should be changed to begin with? Just don't adapt it... but of course they want the massive fanbase even though they're not acknowledging why it's big in the first place.
Laughable statement. Where did Gandalf hit Pippin when they talked to Denethor in the books? That was in complete contradiction with the Gandalf from the books so please dont tell me this was faithful in any way.
The movies are great, but by no means some sort of gold standard of faithful adaption of the source material.
As far as I can tell, outrage over controversial changes to the IP (e.g. Game of Thrones, The Last of Us 2, Star Wars 7-9) is _positively_ correlated with popularity.
The Star Wars Trilogy critically flopped and only 5x their budget compared to +20x for the original trilogy.
The follow up Star Wars content didn't really work out besides the Mandalorian maybe.
The Foundation series is a complete flop as well.
And all of 10 people would have watched it. IP is for name recognition more than anything else. What percentage of people who watched the Peter Jackson trilogy actually read a book from the trilogy? I'd bet way less than 50%.
Jackson didn't adhere 100% to the source material either. There are length lists, including many substantial non-narrative related changes, for[1] each[2] film[3].
[1]: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings:_The_F...
[2]: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings:_The_T...
[3]: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings:_The_R...