News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by proc0 on Monday September 05, 2022 @05:12PM (#32729541)
Elves are supposed to be a different species of humanoid, so making them more human-like by thinking they're supposed to be a certain way that humans are doesn't feel like the source material. It's important to adhere to that source because they are using the name for recognition. They could have just made a new fantasy story with short hair elves, and I think that would have been judged on its own.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by rimunroe on Monday September 05, 2022 @05:52PM (#32729924)
In the source material they look pretty much just like Men. The most consistent difference seems to be their height (they’re taller than Men) and the fact that their bodies don’t really age at the same rate. There’s never any mention of them having pointy ears, or any other obvious physical characteristic.

I think there are several places across the Silmarillion and other books where it’s mentioned that some Men are mistaken for Elves. If I recall correctly, this happened with Túrin, who was given the name Adanedhel (“Man-Elf”), which he got because he was so alike to them.

The Wizards are given the appearance of old men, but the Men think that they’re elves. Gandalf’s name comes from the Old Norse for “wand/staff elf”. In-universe, in the north he was known as “The Elf of the Wand”, because Men mistook him for an Elf.

Also, I’m not sure that calling them a “different species” is accurate. They certainly can produce offspring with Men just fine.

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by proc0 on Monday September 05, 2022 @08:41PM (#32731212)
Then i guess don't give them pointy ears. I remember reading they had long hair, regardless they are called something different and have completely different lives.

> They certainly can produce offspring with Men just fine.

While true, in fantasy all kinds of mixes are possible that result in creatures like minotaurs, half-orcs, half-demons, half-dragons, etc., and those are obviously not human.

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by rimunroe on Monday September 05, 2022 @11:52PM (#32732620)
> Then i guess don't give them pointy ears.

Not giving them some distinguishing physical characteristic sounds like a great way to make the work more difficult to understand. Personally I don’t mind the change.

> I remember reading they had long hair, regardless they are called something different and have completely different lives.

Some of them had long hair, but presumably others don’t. I’m not aware of any part of the Legendarium which suggests all elves had long hair. That would seem like an uncharacteristic thing for Tolkien to write about them.

> While true, in fantasy all kinds of mixes are possible that result in creatures like minotaurs, half-orcs, half-demons, half-dragons, etc., and those are obviously not human.

This is not D&D. As far as I know, there’s nothing in the Legendarium suggesting there can be unions of anything other than Men and Elves, Men and Orcs, and Elves and Maiar.

A union of an Elf and Maia happened exactly once, and is a bit of an odd becuse Maiar choose the physical form they take. Melian presumably clothed herself in the body of an Elf, at least as far as mattered.

The Men and Orcs thing is unusual in two ways. One is that it’s not explicit how they were combined. Saruman did it… somehow, but the implication is that it was through his art (magic). yhe other is that, depending on the day, Tolkien considered Orcs to be anywhere between corrupted Elves/Men, fallen Maiar, or something like animals. He wasn’t ever comfortable with the ramifications of any of these different origins had, but I think that at the time of writing Lord of the Rings, the idea was that they were corrupted Elves. I’m not super sure on that though. Either way though, I can see a lot more philosophical justification for Men and Orcs being crossed than Men and dragons, balrogs, or anything else that isn’t an Elvish/Mannish being.

Anyway, this is a long way to say that just because it happens in other fantasy settings doesn’t mean it applies here. Tolkien thought about this kind of stuff a lot, and wrote extensively on it. If you’re interested in reading more about this kinda thing, I highly recommend the History of Middle Earth series of books, especially Morgoth’s Ring, which deals a lot with the nature of existence (both physical matter and things like souls) in the Legendarium.

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by wrp on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:22AM (#32733192)
> ...there’s nothing in the Legendarium suggesting there can be unions of anything other than Men and Elves, Men and Orcs, and Elves and Maiar.

Tolkien, Race, and Racism in Middle-earth[1] has a long section discussing this. Tolkien regarded elves, men, hobbits, dwarves, and orcs all as races of one species, who thus could interbreed.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Tolkien-Racism-Middle-earth-Robert-St...

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by rimunroe on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:05AM (#32735422)
Thanks! That was the impression I had, but as I was writing the comment I realized I couldn’t recall any specific line that made me think that all the children were basically the same species (though I did know that Hobbits were counted among Men).
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by proc0 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @08:13PM (#32744814)
Fair points. Sure, pointy ears I guess is expected, although I think they could definitely make it work otherwise. Regarding the races, it seems there is a vagueness to the lore which means an opportunity to stay within Tolkien and still expand it with these types of questions (what it means to be human, etc). This is one way they could work with what already exists while adding something new.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by rimunroe on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @09:46PM (#32745457)
The situation is more complicated than that though. The apparent vagueness is not a sign that there is wiggle room, but rather that there are existing contradictions the author didn’t manage to resolve. The reason the origins of the Orcs changed so often is because Tolkien laid down some pretty hard boundaries in his world as to what it meant to be an Elf/Man/Dwarf, what Melkor was able to do (not capable of independent creation), free will existing, Orcs always being evil, and his desire to maintain consistency with his Catholic faith regarding salvation.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by elcamino44 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @12:42AM (#32732926)
But because of a vague memory about something you read sometime (which looks like it was wrong), the presence of short-haired elves breaks your immersion and damages your enjoyment of the show?
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by proc0 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:43PM (#32744605)
Ok, well I'm just alluding that there's probably source material around certain differences. I wouldn't mind short-haired elves, but personally I'd want some justification that makes sense within the story since it deviates from what is previously established.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by t6jvcereio on Monday September 05, 2022 @10:33PM (#32732051)
> I remember reading they had long hair,

Every single individual has long hair? What, not a single one of them cuts their hair? I call bs

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by proc0 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:57PM (#32744694)
I mean if I had glorious elven hair, I would probably not cut it. Also short is one thing, but in RoP the elf Arondir has a military buzz cut, which raises more questions.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by Rebelgecko on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:51AM (#32733387)
Some of the elves look like they use an electric razor. I suppose maybe they have a magic obsidian or something, but it's kind of distracting.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by bjtitus on Monday September 05, 2022 @07:21PM (#32730666)
> They could have just made a new fantasy story with short hair elves, and I think that would have been judged on its own.

And all of 10 people would have watched it. IP is for name recognition more than anything else. What percentage of people who watched the Peter Jackson trilogy actually read a book from the trilogy? I'd bet way less than 50%.

Jackson didn't adhere 100% to the source material either. There are length lists, including many substantial non-narrative related changes, for[1] each[2] film[3].

[1]: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings:_The_F...

[2]: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings:_The_T...

[3]: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings:_The_R...

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by proc0 on Monday September 05, 2022 @08:31PM (#32731143)
> What percentage of people who watched the Peter Jackson trilogy actually read a book from the trilogy?

The trilogy was great because of the writings of Tolkien. Peter Jackson did his best respecting that and telling Tolkien's story, not his own. I think that's why they were successful.

What's the point of adapting a source material if you think it should be changed to begin with? Just don't adapt it... but of course they want the massive fanbase even though they're not acknowledging why it's big in the first place.

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by ekianjo on Monday September 05, 2022 @11:40PM (#32732557)
> The trilogy was great because of the writings of Tolkien. Peter Jackson did his best respecting that and telling Tolkien's story, not his own. I think that's why they were successful.

Laughable statement. Where did Gandalf hit Pippin when they talked to Denethor in the books? That was in complete contradiction with the Gandalf from the books so please dont tell me this was faithful in any way.

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by cygx on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:55AM (#32734241)
Sauron became a floating eyeball and characters were made into caricatures of themselves (Denethor) or forced to undergo 'character growth' not present in the books (Aragorn, Faramir).

The movies are great, but by no means some sort of gold standard of faithful adaption of the source material.

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by ShamelessC on Monday September 05, 2022 @09:48PM (#32731706)
Do you really think they won't get a massive fanbase just because of the outrage of a couple thousand anonymous strangers on the internet?

As far as I can tell, outrage over controversial changes to the IP (e.g. Game of Thrones, The Last of Us 2, Star Wars 7-9) is _positively_ correlated with popularity.

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by LunaSea on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:32AM (#32734467)
Fans have completely abandoned GoT after the last season.

The Star Wars Trilogy critically flopped and only 5x their budget compared to +20x for the original trilogy.

The follow up Star Wars content didn't really work out besides the Mandalorian maybe.

The Foundation series is a complete flop as well.

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by proc0 on Monday September 05, 2022 @10:14PM (#32731903)
I think it's not as big as it could have been. They might still be successful in terms of views (although that's yet to be seen), but I think that might be because a lot of people are giving it a chance. We'll see how it does towards the end of the season.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by ShamelessC on Monday September 05, 2022 @11:51PM (#32732615)
I'm not saying it will or won't be popular. I'm saying the quality of the writing according to "proc0" is not going to have any impact on the situation.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by oblio on Monday September 05, 2022 @09:57PM (#32731784)
> What percentage of people who watched the Peter Jackson trilogy actually read a book from the trilogy? I'd bet way less than 50%.

You optimist. Probably less than 5% :-)

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by Tagbert on Monday September 05, 2022 @10:31PM (#32732035)
Long hair was not really a defining characteristic of Tolkien elves. It seems like a pretty minor point to base a criticism on.
Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by mpeg on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:26AM (#32734045)
I find it ridiculous to refer to "source material" as if it was gospel. Amazon owns the rights for this tv show, and therefore anything they make is new source material.

Just like how in the Marvel cinematic universe Spiderman's MJ is mixed race and not a redhead, Thanos in the comics doesn't care about halving the universe's population, he wants to kill as many as he can to court the embodiment of Death, or most of the Eternals are gender and race swapped from their comic versions.

Elves are now closer to humans, and they can be black, but the old material with white, tall, long haired elves is still there for you to enjoy... is it really a big deal?

Re:Amazon putting a three-day pause on reviews for Rings of ... by proc0 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:14AM (#32747014)
The source material is subject to criticism as well, but it should also be given credit. The reason we're even talking about it is because the books were really good and had a huge impact around the world. It's no coincidence that movies based on books tend to be great. Authors think through their world in detail which serves as a foundation for the screen adaptation. Deviating from this is risky, as directors have different skills, and more than likely they won't write a better world and dialogue than a renown author.

This was very clear with Game of Thrones with George RR not being able to finish his saga, and this being so obvious after season 4 (or 5). The quality dropped dramatically and it all crashed and burned by the last season. Had they planned it more carefully, so that George was in charge of the story until the end, I think we would have seen the most successful fantasy show of the century.