News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by muglug on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:44PM (#32698460)
99% of science being published today has no political motivations.

The public perception of science, though, is not dictated by scholarly journals. It's what's discussed on the nightly news or seen in the Facebook news feed, and that often comes with a helping of politics.

We're also seeing a recent uptick in criticism (and also suspicion) of "elites", and academics are generally lumped into that bucket.

And then COVID happened, making everybody an armchair epidemilogist overnight. You could see this play out on Twitter, where accounts with large followings with no previous professed statistical experience started sharing non-peer-reviewed study after study, often drawing inaccurate conclusions.

Scientists continue on, but there's absolutely no putting the genie back in the bottle. Science is political, and we need (a hopefully small number of) scientists to get some decent media training and start explaining their work to the general public.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by faeriechangling on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:09AM (#32698619)
I recall being am amateur epidemiologists suspicious of "elites" and I bet on masks being efficacious while health authorities were pooh-poohing them and came out ahead. I felt the "Elites" were being bias by the ongoing shortage of medical masks into downplaying the efficacy of masks for the general public, which in hindsight, actually seems pretty spot on.

I saw lots of people sharing studies, including before peer review, I mostly didn't see anybody come to a substantively different conclusion from the authors after like the first few months of pandemic confusion had cleared up. I found scepticism and DIY science very helpful this pandemic especially when things were more chaotic.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by mjevans on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:23AM (#32698699)
I'm not sure who to blame for that; but agree it was a mistake.

Stress a lack of evidence (at that time)? Sure.

Stress that N-95 and KN-95 masks must be reserved for hospital workers, and possibly even pre-press banning their sale under emergency commandeering measures? I think we can all guess why that didn't fly politically (it would require admitting there was a serious pandemic).

The public should never be 'lied to' nor 'ticked' (which the people I've spoken with mostly assume was happening with that initial mask stance) and should be treated as adults, possibly ones without a full set of information from expert matters on a subject.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by j7ake on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:56AM (#32698875)
Elites from where ? Japan, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore, and China all pushed for masks.

Usa and other Western European countries were much slower to adopt.

When there are discrepancies in the global adoption, then one can look into political factors.

Also studies from SARS back in 2000 convincingly showed that masks worked.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by gryn on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:18AM (#32698974)
in france at the first they were very much against masks (since just a few months because the start of covid they got rid of the huge reseve they had) until they could restock them back and then suddenly the narrative shifted from "they wouldn't be of usefe to you and you wouldn't know how to use them anyway" to "they are absoloutly mandatory and very simple to use"
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by philliphaydon on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:06AM (#32698923)
It’s weird. Masks have always been known to reduce transmission from a sick person. Keyword being reduce. But the anti mask people, especially on Twitter or Facebook are like “see this study! Masks don’t work” and it’s like yes it wasn’t about preventing you from getting sick, it’s reducing a sick person from spreading. People can be sick and not realise it and spread it so it’s easier to get everyone to wear masks.

Masks and Vaccines are 2 massively misunderstood things during the pandemic.

When I was at school (New Zealand) we learned that vaccines help give the immune system the information to fight a virus. But people in America and Europe have this idea that vaccine is like a shield that prevents you from getting sick entirely and then claims vaccines don’t work…

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by autoexec on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:58AM (#32699167)
> It’s weird. Masks have always been known to reduce transmission from a sick person. Keyword being reduce. But the anti mask people, especially on Twitter or Facebook are like “see this study! Masks don’t work”

I never understood the "masks are useless" claims. I've seen it in lots of forms, sometimes covering all types of masks or sometimes just cloth ones.

We've spent so long teaching people to cover their mouths when they cough specifically because it's been proven to help! We teach little kids to "Vampire Cough/Sneeze" for that very reason. Literally anything you put in front of your virus spewing face hole is going to do some good, but since N95 masks aren't 100% effective every single time it's not worth doing anything to protect the people around you? It really just seems like people looking for any excuse or justification to not be inconvenienced in any way for the benefit of the people around them. Like a very aggressive kind of selfishness I can't wrap my head around. Like people will hurt themselves to avoid doing anything that might help somebody else.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by faeriechangling on Monday September 05, 2022 @09:59PM (#32731801)
Circa 2020, the evidence masks worked for medical professionals was pretty unambiguous, but the issue with masks is think about taking them on and off. You practcially touch your hand to your face every time. Because of this, it has always been less clear that John Q Public pulling their mask aside to talk on the phone or sips a cup of coffee with their reusable mask is doing themselves or anybody else any favours.

I think though that it’s extremely obvious that it’s very likely the general public could take certain actions to make the efficacy of their mask use similar to that of medical professionals, but the interpretation of the data early on was simply “the general public shouldn’t use masks”. This was obviously nonsense, and I interpreted the data as meaning I should carefully use masks.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by origin_path on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:43AM (#32702316)
"It’s weird. Masks have always been known to reduce transmission from a sick person."

No they have not. That's why you think it's weird - if you look at the state of mask science pre 2020, you will find a whole lot of nothing. There's no evidence masks have ever been able to stop respiratory disease.

After 2020 the space was flooded with nonsensical studies claiming efficacy but they all have rather large and obvious problems e.g. CIs that include zero or even worse problems, but the reason scientists pretty universally pooh-poohd at masks at the start had nothing to do with shortages. That was a lie retconned into their claims later and wow, was it ever successful at confusing people. No, they said that because there was no actual scientific evidence to point to. There still isn't.

"it’s like yes it wasn’t about preventing you from getting sick, it’s reducing a sick person from spreading"

The idea of a magical one way mask is also completely unsupported by any scientific evidence and in fact by now strongly refuted by it, because there is lots of evidence masks have no effect on COVID. It was invented out of nothing to justify forcing everyone to wear masks even if the risk to them was minimal to none.

"But people in America and Europe have this idea that vaccine is like a shield that prevents you from getting sick entirely and then claims vaccines don’t work"

Yes I wonder why they think that, after all, they were only told the vaccine was a shield against getting sick and spreading it by the guy who runs Pfizer, the president of the USA, public health officials in every country, etc. People are so totally unreasonable, aren't they? But I see from a sibling comment you weren't aware of that, so why are you so confident about all the other things you think you know?

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by philliphaydon on Saturday September 03, 2022 @02:03PM (#32704417)
Yeah I remember sars and the outcome of that. Why do you think asia is much more prepared than the west?

There’s a reason why China was buying up all the masks and such and shipping it all back in the early days.

But seems like I’ve struck a nerve from someone who probably is anti mask anti vax.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by origin_path on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:29PM (#32716157)
China wasn't "buying up" all the masks because most masks are made in China to begin with. I don't know why they think masks are so great. It isn't to do with science because otherwise people could point to the compelling and clear research evidence that masks work, and there wouldn't be so many counter-examples where masks had no effect.
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by philliphaydon on Monday September 05, 2022 @01:26AM (#32720857)
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-09-17/behind-ch...

Clearly you don’t know what you’re talking about.

Which makes sense since you don’t even read the studies you claim “prove masks don’t work”

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by thedrbrian on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:33AM (#32699041)
When you hear the terms 100% effective and the president says if you get vaccinated you won’t get covid , you can see where the confusion comes from.

https://www.usnews.com/news/politics/articles/2021-07-21/ap-...

And then you get Whitty and his infamous 4000 deaths per day graph.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8908503/Was-lockdow...

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by philliphaydon on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:41AM (#32699076)
:-| didn’t know Biden said all that. I’ve kinda stepped back from reading American politics for the last couple of years cos it’s so depressing.
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by muglug on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:33AM (#32698754)
There were many people posting links about hydroxychloroquine and Ivermectin and discussing efficacy in the presence of scant information. Also lots of discussions around R0 etc.
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by AbrahamParangi on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:52AM (#32698856)
The story of hydroxychloroquine is much misunderstood. People remember it as “Trump’s horse dewormer” but it was one of the first potential treatments to emerge in the Chinese standard of care in the early stages of the pandemic. That fact, combined with the “fog of war” and that we know hcq is well tolerated in humans makes it a fairly reasonable bet.

The bet being wrong is a separate matter to whether or not it was reasonable. Conversely, I would argue the early anti-mask messaging was unreasonable based on similar logic (well bounded and low costs, potentially high benefits).

The conclusion that I know some people took away from it is that critical thinking is not an evolutionarily favored trait in certain administrative roles.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by wikitopian on Saturday September 03, 2022 @08:33AM (#32701222)
Yup.

The wisdom of locking down toddlers and children for years on end was also a spot where the uppity rubes were correct and all the science wizards were disastrously incorrect.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by seydor on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:54AM (#32698860)
You remind me of this EU project officer who wanted us to tweet more for our project. And set up a Linkedin account. And maybe an instagram account too (we could also crosspost in our lab's facebook). We had to fight her to stop using google analytics to track the website visitors.

Unfortunately we can't train 100% of people to understand all the science that gets published. That's why scientists need to learn to trust each other and communicate to the public as a single body, not as individual scientists. How they are going to do that, that's internal to the body of scientists. Politics has broken scientific unity, fix it.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by UIUC_06 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:30AM (#32699036)
> communicate to the public as a single body, not as individual scientists

That's a laudable goal. You will never, never get any body of scientists, or any other class of people, to agree on their overall goals for society, so if science IS indeed political, you've lost already.

On the other hand, if they only have to agree on what the data and logic tell us, that's still hard, but it's much closer to being achievable. It requires everyone to take a deep breath and say "I might be wrong but this is what I think, and here's why." And then listen.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by UIUC_06 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:33AM (#32702829)
Since it's too late to edit that, I'll add this as a reply:

If you ("you" being a scientist) are explicit that your "science" is in service of your political agenda, then you've accomplished this:

Anyone who disagrees with your agenda will reject your "science"

As we saw with vaccines & lockdowns.

On the other hand, if they trust you to just report what the data says, even when you don't like it, then you have a chance of not being vilified.

So there you have it: if you want to stand above the Twitter mob and be believed, you have to earn back the public's trust.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by pksebben on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:37AM (#32699052)
I found that missive (regarding politics and it's influence on the scientific community as a whole) conspicuously.. missing.. from this article. It's not so much about how politics affects the outcomes of science, imo, but how politics shapes what science is capable of in the first place.

I'm immediately reminded of how deeply skewed towards treatment (rather than curing) pharmaceutical research is, because of our economic structure.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by XorNot on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:45AM (#32699094)
This is a fiction pushed by quacks. There are no cures being suppressed by "big pharma" because treatment makes more money.

It's a convenient "just so" story people who don't work in bioscience love, told with all the certainty of "did you know you swallow 8 spiders a year on average".

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by pksebben on Saturday September 03, 2022 @02:33AM (#32699336)
I'm not claiming suppression, just noting that economic incentives are misaligned, and noting that we, as a society, have in our toolbelt a whole host of treatments, and only a handful of cures.
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by rayiner on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:26AM (#32698713)
It’s a cop out to blame “nightly news” or “Facebook news.” They just republish and mock stuff like this: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/modern-mathematic...

I don’t disagree that most science is pretty non political. But it’s also true that the contact surface that a large swath of America has with “science” is through publications like Scientific American, scientists who go on TV, social “scientists,” etc.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by jakelazaroff on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:46AM (#32698821)
The article you linked is not what the discussion is about, though. Yours is referring to the impacts of discrimination on the people within the scientific community. The original article is about the effect of bias on the results of the research.
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by rayiner on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:19AM (#32698985)
People rely on crude indications of trustworthiness. When you run an article titled “Modern Mathematics Confronts Its White, Patriarchal Past”—in reference to a field that’s chock full of brown people and Asians—it’s a signal.

(Isn’t it funny how you never see article headlines talking about how post-modern philosophy was invented by white people?)

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by jakelazaroff on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:51AM (#32699130)
Are we really about to pretend there’s no basis in reality, though? I literally have older relatives who were told — very explicitly! — that they should stay out of what we would now call STEM fields because it “wasn’t for Jews.” So what’s not sitting right with articles like this?
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by rayiner on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:29AM (#32700797)
We can talk about it without adopting the rhetoric of critical theory (“math confronts it’s white, patriarchal past”) as the Scientific American article does. Critical theory is designed to meld analysis and political advocacy and it’s distinctive terminology is part of that advocacy.

I’m not making a gratuitous reference to critical theory by the way. Your example illustrates the problem. According to critical theory, “Jews are white.” So where does your example fit in? Also, math as a field is full of Indian and Chinese people. How does it make sense to label it “white?” Under critical theory, it’s “white” because Black people are underrepresented. Critical theory compels a mode of analysis that groups people a certain way, focuses on certain kinds of discrimination or power relationships to the exclusion of others, and all for distinctly political reasons.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by tptacek on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:45AM (#32709927)
You appear to be the first person in this particular thread to bring up "critical theory". How is anybody supposed to discuss anything with you if you're just going to find the weirdest thing anybody has ever said and then demand that they reconcile their own words against it? You win: you found something stupid that somebody said, once.
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by dionidium on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:10PM (#32715893)
This is a tendentious characterization of what's being called out here, which is an article in a prominent periodical discussing viewpoints that are increasingly supported by the heads of elite institutions at the behest of significant percentages of the political left. It's not just, "something stupid that somebody said, once."
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by tptacek on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:20PM (#32716029)
I mean, you're just illustrating the same thing I criticized Rayiner for doing. He wasn't talking to someone who was supporting or expounding critical race theory. The person he was talking to mentioned that he had relatives excluded from the sciences because they were Jewish, and Rayiner hit him over the head with "critical theory". He wrote a bad comment. So did you. It doesn't have to be a bigger thing than that.
[dead]
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by boomboomsubban on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:02AM (#32698574)
Here's 20 articles from the September edition of Geology, zero seem to be political. https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/geology/issue

August also seems politics free, though I'm too lazy to check five issues to see if it's 99%

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by hayst4ck on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:12AM (#32698638)
The problem with the person you're responding to, is that they are a layman. They think what they read in magazines or see on Facebook is science.

Spending time in academia and reading articles in a field you know something about makes it clear they are quite far from science.

So when you said "publish science" you meant what shows up in academic journals, while when the other person said "publish science" they were thinking of an article written primarily for the purpose of engagement. The same idea probably wasn't being referenced.

Sadly, it falls on academia's shoulders to understand this problem (that before a layman sees anything "sciency" it's filtered through people who need to get an emotional reaction to drive engagement, and that defines the public perception of science) and put the work into ameliorating it. Sadly, it's a conflict of interest that probably helps procuring funds.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by klipt on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:07AM (#32698603)
Geology is more of a hard science so harder to make political.

Softer science like social science or psychology seems easy to politicize though. "Studies show that people need <my favorite policy> to truly be mentally healthy"

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by muglug on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:26AM (#32698712)
There are a lot of hard sciences!

Mechanics / Electromagnetics / Thermodynamics / Kinetics / Inorganic Chemistry / Electrochemistry / Analytical Chemistry / Earth Sciences / Anatomy / Botany / Biology / Zoology / Neurobiology / Marine Biology / Embryology / Ecology / Palaeontology / Genetics / Cell Biology / Ethology / Astronomy / Meteorology / Geology / Atmospheric Sciences / Glaciology / Climatology / Structural Geology

Most psychology papers are also fairly difficult to politicise. Like, try to politicise this: https://www.pnas.org/eprint/WREBM4QSJCM8MUAMJXEH/full

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by klipt on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:20PM (#32703977)
> try to politicise this

Okay!

"human learnability of abstract network representations"

Which humans? Did they test it works equally well for all races and genders and body shapes, or is their model of human learning biased to work best for buff white men and is inferior for everyone else?

What's in the abstract network representations, are they truly neutral, or are we just helping humans to learn from biased data that will make them subconsciously more racist/sexist/heightist?

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by babypuncher on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:25AM (#32698707)
Climatology is a hard science yet it is also one of the most politically debated in popular media.

I think the real factor here is whether or not a large cohort of people find inconvenience in what the scientists of a given field are saying

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by wumpus on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:24AM (#32699007)
Geology is 100% political when it is talking about climate change.

Imagine how political geology was when it was the major proof against the world being created in 4004 BC.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by bigbillheck on Monday September 05, 2022 @01:18PM (#32726699)
> Geology is more of a hard science so harder to make political

Go tell it to a young-earth creationist.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by harry8 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:06AM (#32698595)
Geology is the only science you're aware of?

Try psychology, sociology, medicine, climatology and the things in this direction. I probably agree with the broad thrust if the politics in those fields and that isn't the point!

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by reikonomusha on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:06AM (#32698594)
Do you have examples of reputable journals publishing politically motivated results? Or even just some significant examples from the arxiv?
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by futuretaint on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:37AM (#32698774)
here's the HN comment chain from last week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32595083
Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by futuretaint on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:36AM (#32698767)
Here's the Nature article from last week which was surprising to many inc Hacker News https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-022-01443-2

re: hard sciences, the scientific community's refusal to accept the covid lab leak hypothesis stands out IMHO. School shutdowns/mask mandates for pre-k and public schools is another politicalized issue.

Re:Science is political, and that's a bad thing by phantom_of_cato on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:07PM (#32703219)
> 99% of science being published today has no political motivations.

That's probably not true. Based on the charts here [1], it is safe to say that at least 20-30% of successful NSF grant applications have political/ideological terms used in the abstract.

Maybe more importantly, it's really hard to know how much research isn't being done or published because of the current political climate.

> And then COVID happened, making everybody an armchair epidemilogist overnight.

Well, I don't see that as a bad thing. Blind trust in authority isn't an admirable quality in my books. Also, the other option really was to become an armchair epistemologist. You had to somehow make decisions.

> Science is political

But it shouldn't be. At least not this much. We have choice to encourage or discourage that.

[1]: https://www.cspicenter.com/p/increasing-politicization-and-h...