News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by bob1029 on Friday September 02, 2022 @12:46PM (#32692910)
I worked at the Samsung A2/S2 lines in ATX with a bunch of young Americans back around 2011-2013. I would say they absolutely would.

It's a very high-energy place with more going on than you can ever hope to keep track of. Even if the technology doesn't interest you, the cultural interactions should. You could have some days with Japanese, Koreans and Americans translating 3-ways in a conference room. Opportunities for business travel are probably restricted more now, but when I was there they practically begged us to travel to the Korean sites in hopes that we would learn more faster.

Some roles can be far more exciting than others. Someone has to work security and manage the facilities. That said, all the important roles seem to be the compelling ones too. I don't know of anyone who had a hard time getting another super cushy job after time at Samsung, so it's also great for long term career prospects.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by cxr on Friday September 02, 2022 @04:48PM (#32695543)
I can't corroborate this at all.

I come from a CS background. If you leave school and enter the workforce at SAS, you will be at a disadvantage insofar as you are looking for a workplace that you hope to learn something from or one that you hope reinforces good engineering practices. The semiconductor industry, from the vantage point of an experienced systems thinker, reinforces awful engineering practices. All the things that SE folks take for granted—version control, e.g, as a discipline/tool to name one example, for regression analysis—say goodbye to any of these things, along with any expectation of competence from your colleagues.

The semiconductor industry sources heavily from the defense sector, and this has deleterious, catastrophic effects.

A close friend (from a non-CS engineering background) I know to still be at SAS. We don't talk about finances, but at around 8 years in, I estimate that he just recently (since COVID) crossed the six figure threshold. He's in a fairly senior role. Meanwhile: "What's x86?" — a direct quote from a conversation not too long ago.

He has no real professional experience outside of SAS, was not set up in an environment that rewards "extracurricular" experience, so he doesn't have any of that, either, and he's effectively stuck as a result of the "golden" handcuffs that the path at SAS has led him on.

Don't work in the semiconductor industry, folks. What you can expect to be is a monkey pressing buttons on a machine (that your supervisor—and their supervisor—doesn't understand, and nor will you; you pass butter). Make no mistake: there's an abundance of low-hanging fruit. But you won't have, as Gerry Weinberg put it, "permission" to pick it.

By all means, if your prospects/ambitions look to be something like working for the state/federal government, learning nothing over your career, and cashing mediocre checks for doing mediocre work along the way, then by all means go for it. Otherwise, it is likelier that you'll be hobbled by your time in the industry. And not for no good reason. If I'm evaluating someone and it came up that they'd done any significant time in the world of semiconductors, the net impression it'd have on me (having hash an insider's view of it) would be one worse than if they said that they'd just gotten their degree and had spent the last N years flipping burgers, cf Dan Luu.

Don't do semiconductors, folks.

PS: sorry, drunk.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by assttoasstmgr on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:57PM (#32696178)
You're right, we should encourage the new generation to all strive to become overpaid mediocre SWEs only in it for the quick cash, because the world doesn't have enough shitty food delivery apps. Hopefully I've painted this with a broad enough brush. There is more to a fulfilling career than money.

In fact, an entire generation of SWEs who forgot the concepts of simplicity and efficiency, coding a never-ending avalanche of rubbish bloated apps is why we continually need new silicon.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:41PM (#32697394)
It's not really about quick cash. The truth is just that additional SWEs are right now more useful than additional fab engineers, in the US. It sucks to hear but it's true. There just aren't that many fab engineers necessary. Even TSMC employs a large part of SWE and IC designers, probably close to or more than process engineers.

Fab engineers in the US are fairly disposable because their existence isn't based on market needs but really as a hedge by the US to be independent. That's going to suck for you because TSMC isn't going to value you that much because you're not really business critical, you're just there to get government subsidies. In Taiwan it's another story and it's almost competitive with good SWE jobs.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by galangalalgol on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:08AM (#32698934)
This seems obviously true. It only seems unjust because we have this idea that tasks that are more intellectually challenging should pay more. That isn't how supply and demand work. If you need twice as many typists as are graduating, but only need a quarter of the radiologists that complete residency, well then typists will be paid far more than radiologists. We have an excess of people who want to work hardware, specifically because it is challenging, and that draws interest. So the interesting work is part of the compensation. We accept this as true for game development, it shouldn't surprise us for hardware, or embedded software. It doesn't matter that what you are doing is "harder", we need more bodies slinging fullstack generic buisiness logic than we can possibly educate it seems, so that is what will pay best. As for why we need that many people? I don't have any clue. It really seems like low-code should eventually replace the need for most SWE and drive down wages, but that has been a dream for decades and it hasn't happened yet.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by elcomet on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:46AM (#32699101)
> we have this idea that tasks that are more intellectually challenging should pay more

Why do you have this idea ? I'm not sure it sounds more "just" than saying, for example, that tasks that are physically more challenging should pay more, or humanly more challenging should pay more, etc..

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by galangalalgol on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:31AM (#32702807)
I was constraining the statement to tech work. It does feel to me like roofers in southern summers should get paid like C levels in the valley. But that isn't how the world works and writing a new physics engine for an indie game, while difficult, is not going to pay as much as much as modifying a payment portal ui to get 0.3% more transactions completed. Because of of those things is in far more demand.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by smaudet on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:25AM (#32699009)
I think its somewhere more in the middle - software bloat is getting to legendary proportions (why do I need 16+ gigs of RAM and a modern cpu+gpu to run a calculator that I could buy for 50 cents 20 years ago?), and the software bloat drives the hardware bloat.

The truth is we don't need fab engineers because the applications we need to build require already "solved" hardware problems which are mostly supplied en-masse by a the few, large companies.

But, the deeper truth is that we don't need any of it... I have been recently and somewhat pleasantly surprised by how little I truly need. E.g., a 200$ chrome-book satisfies most of my needs. I have much, much beefier computers, hundreds of gigs of ram and multi-core processor, etc...all a waste. (I work as a software engineer and regularly find myself maxing my cores for things I don't really need).

If I could build my own hardware and have it actually do things, man, that would _useful_. Unlike this giant rickety tower of babel we have built...

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by haggy102 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:48AM (#32699116)
I'm all for sarcasm but please show me a calculator that needs 16GB of RAM. Your input detracts from the original argument and doesn't progress the discussion at all.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by onion2k on Saturday September 03, 2022 @02:02AM (#32699187)
I made a calculator app in Electron once...
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by runnerup on Friday September 02, 2022 @06:11PM (#32696284)
https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/the-birth-and-death...

Recent front page submission comes to mind XD

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by derefr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @03:11AM (#32699503)
Rather than tearing down SWEs for being economically rational actors, how about starting a semiconductor company where people are paid more?
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by formerkrogemp on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:26AM (#32700777)
-> SWEs for being economically rational actors

It's okay just to say that you like the money. You don't always have to use the largest words. It's also okay for someone to say that software engineers are paid lots of money. Perhaps too much.

-> how about starting a semiconductor company where people are paid more?

I'm assuming you're being facetious given the enormous logistical and financial costs of starting a somewhat up-to-date semiconductor company. But, maybe that's the point.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by derefr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:52AM (#32703040)
> It's okay just to say that you like the money.

I'm not an SWE.

> You don't always have to use the largest words.

Some words have specific meanings, rather than just being longer synonyms for short words.

> Perhaps too much.

Again, no. This was my point — this is like saying that the solution to homelessness is to take away the homes of everyone with homes, so that everyone is now equally homeless.

Don't pay the people who are already getting a good deal less; pay the people who are currently getting a bad deal more.

> I'm assuming you're being facetious given the enormous logistical and financial costs of starting a somewhat up-to-date semiconductor company.

No. Just fucking do it. Start another company that's less complex but is an obvious money earner; get rich; reinvest your wealth into a semiconductor company. Should only take 10 years. If you care, do it.

If Elon can do it — and Elon is not the smartest man — you can do it too.

(To be clear, you don't have to start a company that competes in the wider semiconductor market; you just have to start a company that competes in a niche. Like, for example, 5G radios. But your goal does have to be to compete; getting acquired means you no longer have control over your own business strategy, incl. profit margins, and therefore can no longer make your company "the one where people get paid well.")

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by formerkrogemp on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:24PM (#32706722)
> Don't pay the people who are already getting a good deal less; pay the people who are currently getting a bad deal more

I can agree with this, definitely. I still don't think that it's that easy to start a semiconductor company for the average person considering the requisite expertise and scale of capital necessary. However, outside of the basic accounting, it's not really my area of expertise.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by gonzo41 on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:22PM (#32698004)
It's not the SWE's fault that the market pays for crap. If anything, good for them for making hay whilst the sun shines.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by quantum_state on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:10PM (#32697932)
I would like to second your observation. Fundamentally, the entire IT industry is mostly ruined, by Moore’s “law” … the mess of the IT ecosystem in almost every large enterprise is evidence.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sgarland on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:37PM (#32698103)
Source: I was a supervisor in Cleans at SAS for two years, with my only qualification being I was a submarine nuclear operator previously, which is what that hiring manager was looking for. There are a lot of ex-nukes at SAS. Anyway.

You're correct that their software practices, by and large, are absolutely atrocious. In general, I found that if a team had people who could code, they'd just write their own programs and stay in the Shadow IT realm. I taught myself JS/PHP/SQL while I was there, and built a shitty CRUD app to replace some even worse Excel sheets others were using.

However, from SAS' perspective, they aren't making software. All of the machines have their own control systems (which are usually running XP and are terrible), and they need tools that can connect to those, retrieve data, dump it into a DB, and run queries on it. It never needs to leave the site, you don't have to worry about surprise traffic, and scaling issues are never going to get to the point of needing thousand-node clusters or the like. What they have works.

Re: pay, IME engineers of any kind would start at ~$80K fresh out of college, which in 2017 wasn't that bad for Austin. Engineers also got promoted very quickly. Yes, pure software jobs rapidly outpace SAS salaries. Hell, I went from a supervisor role making $86K to an Associate SRE role (I have 20 years of hobbyist Linux experience, I just never did anything with it - also I got a Master's in SWE while I was at SAS) elsewhere, and immediately went past $100K.

It's a fascinating company that is also incredibly stressful, the pay isn't as good/fast as others, and to my knowledge remote work doesn't exist. Still, someone has to do it, else we wouldn't have chips. Also, they employ some _crazy_ intelligent PHds. They just exude brilliance. It's awe-inspiring watching them talk through problems.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by mensetmanusman on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:33PM (#32695962)
This is like saying don’t go into medicine because you have to be a resident nurse along the way.

Semiconductor fabrication is the most advanced engineering humanity has ever attempted, so you will reach your threshold eventually solving problems that might not have answers (depending on your role). Not everyone wants to do that though, and the world needs implementers and those focused on details.

Pay? Could be higher for sure.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:52PM (#32696139)
They were giving anecdotes of "fairly senior people" and talking about the incompetence expected of managers, which is not analogous to a resident nurse.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by e63f67dd-065b on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:48AM (#32698833)
I’ve heard it describes as a nerd trap: salaries are low and working conditions meh precisely because nerds want to work on the most advanced engineering humanity has ever attempted.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by galangalalgol on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:36AM (#32699050)
Its only a trap if you walk in unaware. If you acknowledge part of your pay is being excited by your work, then it's a choice. We don't expect game development to pay the same as writing payment portals for a faang, even if it's harder, because we understand the task itself is part of the exchange. Jobs people enjoy will always pay less than those they enjoy less, given they both have the same qualifications.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by verall on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:14PM (#32695791)
Not every semicon is SAS, I've heard similar things as what your friend has said about them though. No offense but your post comes off as someone who has spent their whole life in software and has no experience in semicon.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by cxr on Friday September 02, 2022 @06:33PM (#32696454)
Maybe I didn't succeed at getting it across, but my anecdotes about SAS are not only by proxy. (I.e. my friend's experience and that alone.) I worked there.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by throwaway5959 on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:10PM (#32697195)
So you’re critical of others for working at a place you have worked at? How does that work?
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by lostlogin on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:47PM (#32697429)
Surely this is the best way to review a workplace? What method is better?
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by throwaway5959 on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:50PM (#32697441)
I’m talking about the hypocrisy of holding it against someone for having worked somewhere that you yourself have worked at, not the industry itself.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by lmz on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:04PM (#32697880)
> for having worked somewhere that you yourself have worked at

Their friend also stayed there for 8 years while the poster presumably quit sooner.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by pts_ on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:48AM (#32698834)
This person should be flagged for bias in interviews.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by imgabe on Friday September 02, 2022 @07:18PM (#32696836)
I think you’re looking at this from the wrong perspective. If your other option is to be a FAANG software engineer, sure, do that instead.

For the vast swathes of the country where the available jobs are some mix of retail/warehouse low wage drudgery, long haul trucking, drug dealing / fraud / other crime, or welfare, working in semiconductors might be a welcome and attractive option.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by californical on Friday September 02, 2022 @07:24PM (#32696883)
“Better than welfare or crime” doesn’t really sell me that it’s a great option
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by nickff on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:01PM (#32697113)
We should compare people's actual options, and not fall victim to the nirvana fallacy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:44PM (#32697415)
Sure but people able to be process engineers on the caliber of those at TSMC are likely to be able to get good SWE jobs if they really wanted to. We're talking about highly qualified jobs here, un Taiwan a lot of those are gonna have PhDs+.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sdvsa on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:51PM (#32698505)
People that create the factory flow, maybe. But I’d argue it’s a pretty different set of skills. People that run the flow, definitely not.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:18AM (#32698671)
Some of those that maintain and make sure some machines are working correctly do have very advanced degrees, but I agree most aren't as qualified. However, these aren't the people the video is talking about nor the people that will be difficult to recruit.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by ekianjo on Friday September 02, 2022 @09:58PM (#32697844)
phD are not what they used to be
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:19PM (#32697990)
If you can get a STEM PhD you can probably get into FAANG. Sure they're not what they used to be, they're still difficult to get. And they require many of the same skills as modern programming interviews.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by ekianjo on Saturday September 03, 2022 @02:02AM (#32699183)
> nd they require many of the same skills as modern programming interviews.

I don't know, I have seen numerous PHDs who can't competently write any piece of code, I'm beginning to think it's a feature, not a coincidence.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:17PM (#32703318)
That's because their job isn't really to write code, it's to do something else. But if you can get a PhD you can probably learn how to leetcode. A lot of them don't really care much about being able to write good code.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by jprd on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:01PM (#32697112)
You're replying from a place where you have OTHER options.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by novok on Friday September 02, 2022 @09:54PM (#32697817)
The vast majority of people who are smart enough and have the work ethic to finish an EE degree are also smart enough to become a FANG engineer. EE is harder than computer science by far.

So for the set of people who can be fab engineers, live in the USA and speak English, yes, the FANG engineer option is always there.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sdvsa on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:48PM (#32698477)
As an EE I can assure you that’s not true. Also, many jobs at a fab don’t require a bachelors. Often they will want a relevant associate degree though.

Here’s an example: https://www.ziprecruiter.com/c/HRL-Laboratories/Job/Wafer-Pr...

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:30PM (#32703471)
That's not really the jobs that are most problematic. As the video mentions, Intel fixed this issue for them by setting up training pipelines from community colleges for these jobs. The issue is moreso for the positions requiring more advanced education.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:29PM (#32703452)
EE isn't necessarily harder than CS, it just really depends on the school. CS degrees are extremely variable while engineering degrees are much less so. I agree with the rest of your argument though.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by novok on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:47PM (#32709266)
In my school in Canada it had one extra class per semester and I think took 5 years. It was known as a place where you didn't have a life and you were buried in coursework and not really expected to get great grades because of the workload.

I remember a professor sympathetically talking about how little clusters of people just split up the homework load together like it was a team project from random classes and then tell each other how to solve it to each other to save time.

CS was just another science degree in comparison.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by Spooky23 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @01:34AM (#32699044)
Yes, but if you didn’t go to the handful of acceptable schools, it doesn’t matter much how smart you are.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by fathrowaway12 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @04:10PM (#32705603)
They interview people from everywhere. Literally everywhere. They basically have tapped the whole market worth of talent.

You might not get an interview at any given company in a particular year, but you should be able to get some interviews over a couple years if you have decent GPA or work experience. You probably won't be placed on a top-notch team, but you'll get in.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by leetcrew on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:51AM (#32702389)
this may have been true at some point in the past, but it certainly isn't now. most of the engineers I work with have degrees from schools I had never heard of before meeting them. my team just hired a new grad that didn't even have any internships in school. it's not hard to get an interview at FAANGs these days. the difficult (or "luck-required") part is actually giving good solutions to four out of five algo problems, each in 45 minutes.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by md2020 on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:10AM (#32702581)
To offer a different point of view, I'm a software engineer at ASML in the US. I can only offer the experience I've had on my specific team, and I've heard that this does vary between teams, but we do follow normal software industry practices. We have version control. We have automated regression testing, and unit tests for everything we write. We do Agile and use Jira (with all the same gripes that everyone else has about those). I made $90k here right out of my undergrad, and got a raise one year later (this year) to be over $100k.

Could the tooling be better? Sure. Our version control system is pretty old, but the company has made a massive push over the last few years to modernize all of it, and when we transition to that at the end of this year I think we'll be in a pretty great spot. Some teams are already using the new tooling and it has gotten very positive reviews. I have a great relationship with my team and my manager. I get to work on interesting stuff (mostly embedded systems), and I've had the opportunity to learn a small part of one of the most advanced machines humans have ever built.

I'll say the thing about getting people from defense is true, but not so much in software. If anyone has other questions feel free to just ask.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by cxr on Sunday September 04, 2022 @06:44AM (#32711681)
I'm talking about making chips, not being a software engineer that happens to work in the same building as people making chips (or the building where people work on making machines that make chips). SEs showing up and saying things were fine at their SE job doesn't move the needle on this topic. Purdue's semiconductor degree program for EEs is only incidentally relevant in that case.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by mysticpimp on Sunday September 04, 2022 @12:38PM (#32714843)
For the most part, Fab engineering is beyond boring and exploitative. I quit my PhD because it was excruciatingly boring, all you do is click ON/OFF on a big machine that deposits metal, and I realized, that this was what I'd be doing for 100K a year. On paper it sounds like you're doing some genius work manipulating atoms, but really it's actually quite mindless and boring, which is part of the reason the physics departments don't do this work anymore, only EE, since physics does the actual cool stuff. I think it's somewhat related to the fact that these degrees have almost no americans, and are full of foreigners that really need a visa. As an american, it made no sense to do this work, given that there are much more interesting and lucrative options.

But going back to your point, there are certain areas within semiconductor manufacturing that are software engineering jobs. They tend to be closely related to what's called physical design in the design part of making a chip. Or EDA coders. It's a cool area. But the bigger part of semiconductor manufacturing is working in a fab, which is atrocious grueling work, which is quite boring and dangerous.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by manimino on Friday September 02, 2022 @07:40PM (#32696973)
Ahh, "SAS" here refers to Samsung Austin Semiconductor.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by jimbokun on Friday September 02, 2022 @06:06PM (#32696249)
> but at around 8 years in, I estimate that he just recently (since COVID) crossed the six figure threshold.

Better than most people.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by jason-phillips on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:56PM (#32696177)
sxr's posts about Samsung Semiconductor always strike me as being particularly bitter. The thing about chronically bitter people is that they're implacable.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by cxr on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:51PM (#32698507)
The nice thing about the trick used in this comment is that it basically allows the person making it to just decide to believe whatever they want—and you hardly even notice it doesn't contain anything substantive about the real topic at hand or that it carries a personal attack as its payload, right there in the open but under the radar.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by jason-phillips on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:28AM (#32698720)
I'm full of tricks, cxr. You'll get used to it.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by cxr on Monday September 05, 2022 @03:58AM (#32721668)
I know and I am.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by nixass on Friday September 02, 2022 @06:03PM (#32696224)
Drunk is not an excuse for such a crappy view on the world
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by matheusmoreira on Friday September 02, 2022 @06:59PM (#32696688)
Why? Maybe the world really is that bad.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by klooney on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:57AM (#32701920)
Dan Luu worked in semiconductors and spoke quite highly of his time there.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by cxr on Sunday September 04, 2022 @06:55AM (#32711738)
Dan Luu worked for one of the semiconductor industry's customers. He didn't work at S2 or another chipmaker. (He also explicitly mentions that he was lucky to work at Centaur starting out, but that's besides the point—since, again, Centaur is not a chipmaker.)

When I mentioned Dan Luu, I was specifically referring to the recent thunderstorm on Twitter where he mentioned the uncanny valleyness of doing work for unsexy companies and that it's actually more like a blemish on your résumé than a non-zero positive contribution.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by derefr on Saturday September 03, 2022 @03:13AM (#32699507)
> The semiconductor industry sources heavily from the defense sector

What does this part mean, exactly? Are photolithography lasers just repurposed Naval anti-aircraft lasers or something?

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sudosysgen on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:33PM (#32703487)
The skillset is fairly similar and people move from one industry to the other
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by Der_Einzige on Friday September 02, 2022 @06:59PM (#32696689)
All this because Intel couldn't pay market rate for SWEs. Lol
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by formerkrogemp on Saturday September 03, 2022 @07:44AM (#32700895)
-> A close friend (from a non-CS engineering background) I know to still be at SAS. We don't talk about finances, but at around 8 years in, I estimate that he just recently (since COVID) crossed the six figure threshold. He's in a fairly senior role. Meanwhile: "What's x86?" — a direct quote from a conversation not too long ago.

-> He has no real professional experience outside of SAS, was not set up in an environment that rewards "extracurricular" experience, so he doesn't have any of that, either, and he's effectively stuck as a result of the "golden" handcuffs that the path at SAS has led him on.

-> Don't work in the semiconductor industry, folks. What you can expect to be is a monkey pressing buttons on a machine (that your supervisor—and their supervisor—doesn't understand, and nor will you; you pass butter). Make no mistake: there's an abundance of low-hanging fruit. But you won't have, as Gerry Weinberg put it, "permission" to pick it.

-> By all means, if your prospects/ambitions look to be something like working for the state/federal government, learning nothing over your career, and cashing mediocre checks for doing mediocre work along the way, then by all means go for it. Otherwise, it is likelier that you'll be hobbled by your time in the industry. And not for no good reason. If I'm evaluating someone and it came up that they'd done any significant time in the world of semiconductors, the net impression it'd have on me (having hash an insider's view of it) would be one worse than if they said that they'd just gotten their degree and had spent the last N years flipping burgers, cf Dan Luu

All I'm understanding from this is not "don't go into the semiconductor industry" but rather that you're an awful friend to be trash talking your friend. It seems like you just called their career a waste of time and implied your friend to be more poor (since when was 6 figures not a decent amount of money?) than you and less knowledgeable ('what is x86'). I'm sure you'll agree that your friend is neither poor nor stupid, as you seem to imply here for their working in the semiconductor industry. I'm sure your friend would be delighted to know that they're a monkey pressing buttons without any knowledge of what's going on or that you estimate a fast food worker has a better background for transitioning to software engineering.

You haven't talked to your friend about finances, but you can magically estimate their savings? I understand that you might be able estimate within an order of magnitude based on context, but you don't know how much this person has saved nor do you seem to consider that they might spend their money on personal emergencies, sick family members, or kids. That your estimation of your friend's savings should be taken as evidence for poor compensation in the semiconductor industry is laughable, honestly. But, hey, I at least appreciate your earnest opinion.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by leetcrew on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:58AM (#32702462)
"crossed the six figure threshold" likely refers to salary. this is pretty easy to estimate based on title if the person works at a large, well-known company. but otherwise, you're right. you can't possibly estimate an ordinary person's net worth without intimate knowledge of their investments, spending habits, etc.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by formerkrogemp on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:20PM (#32706688)
-> "crossed the six figure threshold" likely refers to salary. this is pretty easy to estimate based on title if the person works at a large, well-known company.

You're right. I appreciate the correction. I didn't think of that as referring to the salary.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by sillystuff on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:10PM (#32697193)
Many years ago, I interviewed at a company that manufactured equipment used by fabs. My impression was of a very stressful environment.

Their latest equipment had some issues that were only showing up on production lines, so they wanted engineers to babysit the equipment at the fabs, and write patches on the spot for any issues observed. They repeatedly stressed how much money their customers lost for any downtime, and how there must not be downtime.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by gopher_space on Friday September 02, 2022 @03:16PM (#32694707)
> Some roles can be far more exciting than others. Someone has to work security and manage the facilities.

This would be an interesting employer for many trades.