News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by thesuperbigfrog on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @08:23AM (#32649440)
Model Cores/Threads Boost10 / Base Frequency Total Cache PCIe TDP SEP (USD)

AMD Ryzen 9 7950X 16C/32T Up to 5.7 / 4.5 GHZ 80MB Gen 5 170W $699

AMD Ryzen 9 7900X 12C/24T Up to 5.6 / 4.7 GHZ 76MB Gen 5 170W $549

AMD Ryzen 7 7700X 8C/16T Up to 5.4 / 4.5 GHZ 40MB Gen 5 105W $399

AMD Ryzen 5 7600X 6C/12T Up to 5.3 / 4.7 GHZ 38MB Gen 5 105W $299

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by account42 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @10:50AM (#32651184)
It seems we are stuck at 16C/32T for desktop CPUs for a bit longer. I guess most things that scale beyond run even better on GPUs. But not all! I wonder if we will get non-"Pro" Threadrippers this generation?
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nabakin on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:26AM (#32651563)
There's really no point in going beyond 16 core CPUs. Games only use 4 cores, maybe 6 cores max. Which means for games, you want to maximize performance-per-core and don't care about having more than 8 cores. More than 8 cores is only useful for very few use cases where the task is very parallelizable or you care about power consumption efficiency and some of those cores are efficiency cores.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by zer0-c00l on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:33AM (#32651634)
I make use of all the cores on my Threadripper regularly for multi-process parallelism. Large compiles regularly saturate all my cores. Development against multiple Kubernetes clusters also makes it beneficial to have a ton of cores.

So there is definitely a use case, it’s just maybe not for you

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by wtallis on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:47AM (#32651776)
Your Threadripper also has a lot more DRAM bandwidth than can be economically provided on a mainstream motherboard. 16 cores is a reasonable limit for AMD's mainstream platform, and going beyond that would require more expensive motherboards and a bigger, more power-hungry IO die—exactly the wrong direction for them to be moving with this product segment.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by zer0-c00l on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:57AM (#32651882)
Umm Threadripper CPUs have historically been on their own sockets/mobo platforms. They aren’t drop-in replacements for the mainstream CPUs. The grandparent comment was wondering if we’d get Threadrippers in this generation, which has nothing to do with “this product segment,” whatever that means
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nabakin on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:37AM (#32651668)
I didn't say there were no use cases, I said there were

> very few use cases

The average person is not compiling programs or dealing with Kubernetes.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nightski on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:49AM (#32651807)
The average person is not buying a 7950 so I have no idea what you are getting at.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nabakin on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:16PM (#32652112)
I get the confusion, I meant the average person buying these CPUs is not compiling programs or dealing with Kubernetes.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nightski on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:26PM (#32652220)
I don't know. Typically the 5950/7950 is not targeted towards gamers. It sacrifices single core performance for more cores. Usually it's more of a prosumer audience that actually do need those attributes.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nabakin on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:38PM (#32652345)
I've been seeing these CPUs marketed as next gen gaming CPUs but maybe I'm wrong
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nightski on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:29PM (#32652891)
Yes the 5900/7900 but those have 12 cores. The higher end 5950/7950, which has a higher core count, actually perform slightly worse in games and are targeted towards a prosumer.

Don't get me wrong, they still work amazingly well for games. It's just that they sacrificed some performance in those chips for the higher core count so it only makes sense they'd want to push that further.

But my guess is they don't want to compete with their threadripper line. Unfortunately those come much later in the product cycle so we'll probably be waiting some time for a Zen 4 threadripper.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by willis936 on Friday September 02, 2022 @09:42PM (#32697740)
7950X has more L3$ per CCX and higher single threaded clock, so I'm not sure why you think the 7900X would perform better in games.
[dead]
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nabakin on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:28PM (#32652245)
Maybe I wasn't clear. 24 or 32 core CPUs are only useful for the select few who are running a lot of intensive and parallelizable computations. The majority of people buying these mainstream CPUs do not get any more use out of a 24 core CPU than a 16 core CPU and yet would be paying hundreds of dollars more. It would only make sense to have these kinds of CPUs for server-grade or otherwise specialized tasks which do not fall under the mainstream performance line of CPUs as seen and talked about here. That is why I think AMD will go no further. There is no benefit, only cost to the kind of mainstream consumers who are buying these CPUs.

> aren’t even the actual use cases for a high core workstation CPU.

I was talking about 16 core CPUs in general which also includes laptop CPUs. Another reason why 16 cores makes sense for a general consumer CPU is because of the power efficiency gains with efficiency cores in laptops.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by slimginz on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:11AM (#32651408)
tbf, a lot of things still haven't been optimized for when AMD introduced >4 cores with first gen Ryzen. I'm running a 5950x and unless I'm doing something like 3D rendering I rarely notice more than ~8 of my cores ramping up at a time.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by tadfisher on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:04PM (#32651981)
Sounds like you need to install Gentoo. Excellent replacement for space heaters in winter time.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by account42 on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @03:43AM (#32659479)
Unfortunately most packages spend more time during the configure step or other ~single threaded parts than actually compiling stuff in parallel when you have that many cores. You can compile multiple packages in parallel but doing that without running out of memory when you do get to a couple of big packages is tricky.

Ideally, portage would take memory (including ramdisk) requirements of packages into account when scheduling builds (some packages do check for free memory) and ask as a make jobserver [0] (with patches for non-make build systems to support jobservers) to always fully use the available resources.

[0] https://www.gnu.org/software/make/manual/html_node/Job-Slots...

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by ac29 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:54PM (#32652545)
Raptor Lake is rumoured to go to 24C/32T. 16 of 24 the cores are efficiency cores though, we'll see how that compares to the all performance core design of Ryzen 7000.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by adrian_b on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:46PM (#32653050)
There is little doubt that Intel Raptor Lake will be better than AMD Raphael at single-threaded tasks, because both will have about the same clock frequency, but Raptor Lake will have a higher IPC.

There is also little doubt that AMD Raphael will be better than Intel Raptor Lake at multi-threaded tasks, even if they now have the same number of threads. The reason is that AMD is made with the much more efficient TSMC process and the consequence is that at equal power consumption the AMD CPUs will reach much higher clock frequencies.

This is the essential difference between single-threaded and multi-threaded tasks, during the former the performance is limited by the maximum turbo clock frequency, while during the latter the performance is limited by the clock frequency at a fixed power consumption, which depends more on the manufacturing process than on the microarchitecture of the CPU.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by ZuLuuuuuu on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @10:29AM (#32650942)
Interesting that TDP increased from 65W on Ryzen 5 5600X to 105W on Ryzen 5 7600X, even though 7600X uses a newer process.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by neogodless on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:16AM (#32651461)
Connect all the data points:

* Zen 4 is more efficient (up to 74% more efficient at 65W)

* Zen 4 will be used for desktop, server and mobile chips

* Ryzen 7000 is clocked a good bit higher than Ryzen 5000

* On the desktop, higher maximum clock speeds for single and multi-core workloads are desired

* The higher TDP is to allow for higher clock speeds for single and multi-core workloads on the desktop

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by pier25 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:18AM (#32651488)
> Zen 4 is more efficient (up to 74% more efficient at 65W)

So the TDP doesn't scale linearly?

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by qball on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @06:15PM (#32655859)
Not when it comes to clock speed.

Note that the total power a CPU draws is proportional to its capacitance (fixed) * its frequency * the square of its voltage + some other stuff that's generally the same across CPUs of the same generation.

But that doesn't quite tell the whole story, either; as you increase the frequency you also have to feed more voltage to the CPU to keep it stable for signal-processing reasons (a higher voltage means more difference between 0 and 1, and when you're right on the edge of it not working that will make the difference between a successful compute and a crash).

As such, when you're trying to make a CPU and want to chase clocks, you get bit twice: first by the increased frequency due to physics, and twice by the (square of the) increased voltage requirements for stability. So running at 6 GHz and requiring 1.2V to get there is significantly more expensive power-wise than running that same processor at 4 GHz and only needing 0.8V.

The only real way to fix that is microarchitecture, of course; the trick with Intel in particular is that they've been milking the same architecture they came up with in 2007 and aside from adding some Atom cores to its latest models have done basically nothing but shrink the die so it's natural that they're falling behind now.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by neogodless on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:20AM (#32651505)
TDP isn't something that scales.

> TDP stands for Thermal Design Power, in watts, and refers to the power consumption under the maximum theoretical load. [0]

It's basically a ceiling.

[0] https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000...

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by pier25 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:26AM (#32651557)
Yeah very poorly phrased on my part, sorry.

Since you mentioned "up to 74% more efficient at 65W" what I meant is if the perf per watt (and hence the temp) doesn't scale linearly with the amount of work.

The 7700X has about double the TDP of the 3700X but about a 50% increase in perf.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by neogodless on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:32AM (#32651613)
That is correct. I think it's always been the case that as clock speeds increase, power draw and heat generation accelerate (diminishing returns).

When you're comparing 7700X to 3700X, are you talking about performance at the same TDP limits, the same clock speed, or maximum performance?

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by pier25 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @02:12PM (#32653317)
I'm comparing max perf and TDP.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by sliken on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:08PM (#32652034)
AMD could cap the 7600X at 65 watts, would that make you happier?

Perf/watt has substantially improved, as have capability (like double the memory speed, double the memory channels, and double the PCIe bandwidth).

Sure if power and cooling are available it clocks up higher, but you don't have to. Most BIOS will let you control the clock speed if you want.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @05:08PM (#32655090)
> AMD could cap the 7600X at 65 watts, would that make you happier?

Even more, you can cap the 7600X at 65W. All AMD cpus have configurable TDP, the advertised number is the default. Going above is overclocking, but dropping it is within spec. If you do it, your cpu will just use less power under load and be a bit slower.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by sliken on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @12:26PM (#32664537)
Indeed, the nice thing is power use grows quickly with clock, so even something like 5GHz vs 5.5GHz can allow a chip to run a fair bit cooler, and since there's various bottlenecks like memory latency that the performance difference will be less than 10%.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by KSS42 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @10:43AM (#32651082)
Partially due to PCIe5 and DDR5.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by baobob on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @10:47AM (#32651139)
The entire chip is probably just one giant fully utilized vector unit by now
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by pier25 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:17AM (#32651469)
The TDP of the 7700X is almost double the 3700X I own but from the benchmarks it seems there's about a 50% perf increase in SC and MC.

The 7700X is about 20% faster than Apple's M2 in SC perf in Cinebench R23.

https://www.cpu-monkey.com/en/cpu_benchmark-cinebench_r23_si...

https://www.cpu-monkey.com/en/cpu_benchmark-cinebench_r23_mu...

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nabakin on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:48AM (#32651793)
I wish they had an 8 core option that maximized the performance-per-core possible. I don't have much use for a 16 core CPU.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @05:10PM (#32655103)
There will almost certainly be a 7800X3D before spring, that will probably be pretty close to what you want.
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by neogodless on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:50AM (#32651816)
I'm confused. Why wouldn't the 7700X 8-core CPU work for what you're suggesting?
Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by tadfisher on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:02PM (#32651951)
The 7700X is one 8-core CCD, which won't clock all cores as high as two 8-core CCDs with half the cores disabled.

Personally I think the trade-off in cross-CCD computation is worse than the slightly lower all-core clock for the kind of workloads that benefit most from 16 threads, but I could see the benefits of higher all-core clocks for desktop use cases like gaming.

Re:AMD Launches Ryzen 7000 Series Desktop Processors with Ze... by nabakin on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:53AM (#32651844)
Lower boost clock speed than the 7950X