News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by locallost on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:20AM (#32605908)
The electricity you don't spend is electricity you don't need to produce. We don't really need electricity, we need to do useful stuff with it. Doing laundry with electricity is useful, as is having a computer network. Are massive glowing screens in the middle of the night useful? That would be a very long discussion, but I say no because any local usefulness is outweighed by their negative impact overall.

Saving electricity is just as useful as adding new capacity, and it's faster, cheaper and easier. As a comparison, the US spends about twice as much electricity as Germany per capita [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_electrici...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by hbossy on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:49AM (#32606725)
Actually they are as you need to maintain some base load on a grid.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _ph_ on Friday August 26, 2022 @11:39AM (#32608901)
No, only if your grid is composed of "slow" power plants, you have to. That is why for a long time, all night-time energy usage was encouraged, to raise the base load. Ironically the outcome is used as an argument against renewables as it "but what about the base load"? :p

And if not completely dominated by slow power plants, there is always enough load on the grid to keep it stable. Especially in a day and age where there is a lot of storage, which can absorb some excess power production.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by locallost on Friday August 26, 2022 @12:24PM (#32609453)
If I understood correctly, I don't think it's a good idea to waste energy to cover base load. It can be used for useful things instead.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by foepys on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:28AM (#32605529)
Only 24 of 56 French nuclear reactors are currently producing power, for various reasons. Less than half.

Germany's coal and gas power is currently helping to power France. 4.3% of Germany's power generation is being exported to France at this very moment.

https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/FR

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by TomK32 on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:17AM (#32604971)
Bigger problems in Germany are the lack of big power lines between the North and South and of course the reluctance to build more wind energy. Especially Bavaria has been shooting its own feet several times, even built a gas power station a few years back and now it's in a bit of a panic...
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by turing_complete on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:21AM (#32605013)
You cannot power a country with wind power alone. Even if you want to build wind turbines, you need nuclear, gas, or coal to back them up.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:35AM (#32605106)
No, but you can power something like 70% of a country with wind power alone. Add in some solar and a few hours worth of storage and you can go 90+%. Add a few days of storage and you reach two nines. A few weeks for more nines.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tpmx on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:42AM (#32605167)
"Add a few days of storage"

This is very non-trivial and will take decades longer than building nuclear power.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:43AM (#32605179)
Building enough nuclear power plants to power a country also takes decades and is very non-trivial. The quicker we reach 90% carbon-free, the more carbon budget we have left to figure out the remaining 10%. Renewables are the quickest, cheapest way to do that.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tpmx on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:44AM (#32605187)
The research and tech actually exists for large scale nuclear power. It's essentially a solved problem, unlike large-scale energy storage.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mqus on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:49AM (#32606116)
But if we look at actual nuclear projects in finland and france, they are expensive and mostly failing and take far too long (think decades, not years). End storage of fuel rods is also not a solved problem of nuclear power, esp. in germany.

So I would rather take the fast-to-build solar and wind plants and research "large scale" energy storage alongside. Storage also does not have to be large-scale, you can just subsidise a lot of decentralized storage and invest in more flexible energy consumers (aka wash your clothes when the sun is shining).

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:46AM (#32605201)
We can always create methane or ammonia from hydrogen. That's a solved problem. The only research left to do is to bring down the price.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:57AM (#32605300)
You can do hydrogen, but ammonia production is like 16% efficient?
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:11AM (#32605406)
Efficiency is less important than cost. Maybe ammonia is so much easier to transport and store that it's worth the efficiency penalty.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:34AM (#32605564)
If I have this right, Ammonia is 2x more expensive than petrol per tonne, and has half the energy density of petrol, so it seems to be 4x more expensive?

I am not sure how to compare with hydrogen, as you say costs for it are in storage and transportation

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tpmx on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:55AM (#32605283)
I.e. the "only" remaining problem is to do it at large scale at a reasonable cost.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:15AM (#32605435)
Right now there is little demand for storage because we don't have sufficient renewable generation capacity. It is no surprise that storage technology hasn't been deployed at large scale and is still relatively expensive. But since we know how to build MW scale electrolyzers it's really just a matter of building more of them.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:49AM (#32606729)
>Building enough nuclear power plants to power a country also takes decades

People in Germany said these things 10 years ago too. If Germany had started building nuclear in quantity 10 years ago then they would be coming online now and would get cheaper with each new plant. Instead you will have crippling and deindustrializing power prices for years to come.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:05AM (#32606937)
If we had continued building renewables in quantity ten years ago we would be in much better shape now too. Unfortunately we did neither.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Saturday August 27, 2022 @08:44AM (#32618346)
I don’t believe it is possible to run Germany on only renewables

1) without massive subsidies

2) without huge investments in storage tech (research and production)

3) without building solar/wind in outside places like North Africa

Nuclear fission solves all of those problems and is a known ( and safe) technology.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Monday August 29, 2022 @08:41AM (#32637444)
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by fyvhbhn on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:15AM (#32605438)
Large scale nuclear power with current tech isn't feasible, because of the lack of good uranium sources
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:24AM (#32605499)
To be fair, we could build breeder reactors.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:51AM (#32606758)
This is an insane take, there is plenty of uranium globally. Whoever says otherwise is lying.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by fyvhbhn on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:38AM (#32608120)
There may be plenty of uranium. However there isn't plenty available for easy extraction.

"Is nuclear energy green" Sabine Hossenfelder

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:50AM (#32608268)
I respect Sabine but I am skeptical about the paper she puts forth about limited uranium supplies.

See the late Prof. MacKay’s work on the subject, considering fast breeder reactors to reuse the fuel and ocean extraction of uranium: https://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_164.shtml

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by fyvhbhn on Friday August 26, 2022 @04:57PM (#32612675)
I am talking about current tech, not Future tech
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:21PM (#32614306)
Breeder reactors and seawater mining are current tech.

Also, this seems like an extreme luddite attitude. Imagine refusing to use a steam engine because nobody has demonstrated infinite coal reserves exist.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by SyneRyder on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:20AM (#32605914)
Tesla seems to have done it pretty quickly for South Australia:

https://electrek.co/2018/05/11/tesla-giant-battery-australia...

Elon promised "Tesla will get the system installed and working 100 days from contract signature or it is free." And then had the entire thing connected and powering the South Australian power grid in just 63 days:

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/mar/10/elon-musk...

I'm fairly confident that 100 days is less than decades.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by DavidPeiffer on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:46AM (#32606091)
That project was 200 MWh.

1 day of Germany electricity consumption is on the order of 1,400,000 MWh, something like 7,000x larger. A "few days" of electricity storage would take orders of magnitude longer to build and deploy, even if we worked on Elon's most optimistic timeline.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by hnbad on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:52AM (#32605261)
The best time to build storage would have been fifty years ago. The next best time is now.

We need power supply now, yes, but we will still need storage decades from now. So building them now is vital. Yet we aren't doing that. That's a problem.

We literally have no time left, yet at the current course we'll be in the same situation in 2030 or 2050 as we are today and we'll keep making the same excuses.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by freilanzer on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:56AM (#32605293)
> will take decades.

We already had decades, so where is it?

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tlocke on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:35AM (#32605108)
If you build enough renewables, then there comes a point when at times you're generating more than is needed immediately. That surplus electricity can be used to make hydrogen gas by electrolysing water. The gas can be stored indefinitely and burned to generate electricity when needed. So with enough renewables, no fossil fuels are needed.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by dmytrish on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:53AM (#32605264)
In theory, yes, it's possible to store renewable energy for later consumption, but this is not the case right now and rollout of any storage technology might take years without certainty that it will work well. In the current situation, it's either blackouts, or gas/coal, or nuclear when there's no sun and wind.

On the other hand, I can understand why the current situation is like this: Germany boldly betted big time on renewables getting cheap enough, they made it work with backfill options available at the time. I just wish energy storage was tackled sooner as well.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by MauranKilom on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:10AM (#32605398)
> The gas can be stored indefinitely

Storing hydrogen is far from trivial. It's a bit like trying to store water when you're only allowed to build tanks out of paper.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by Maakuth on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:47AM (#32605213)
This is not false, but the economics are not good for the full round trip. There are efficiency losses in the conversion both ways and hydrogen storage is not fun as it is very low density and due to small molecule size, prone to leaking through almost anything. Probably a lot of hydrogen will be produced this way during renewable peaks, but mainly it would be for industrial processes that need it.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by eldaisfish on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:37AM (#32608097)
this "around the corner" argument is getting tiresome. We have a climate emergency NOW. We are actively hurting our future by continuing to emit carbon NOW. We already have a solution to that problem in the shape of nuclear power.

Instead, we wait on renewables and storage to run the grid at some indeterminate point in the future.

The debate on this issue really is toxic and frustrating. We need all solutions working NOW, not tomorrow, and one of those solutions is widespread nuclear power.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by fyvhbhn on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:37AM (#32605131)
This isn't true.

You could even power the world just from renewables

https://innovationorigins.com/en/researchers-agree-the-world...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by immibis on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:45AM (#32607446)
That's false. You can't power a country with one source of wind power in the manner to which they have become accustomed. Which is the same justification for so many bad things throughout history, be it wars for resources, to making battery-farmed workers pee in bottles because Jeffrey couldn't bear to have one fewer personal yacht.

If people had grown up with variable supply of electricity, they would have no problem with it today. It's only the transition from something better to something worse that causes riots.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by disgruntledphd2 on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:28AM (#32605051)
Wind, solar and pumped storage gets you a long way, to be fair. We definitely need some nuclear, but it's far too expensive to rely on.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:34AM (#32605560)
Germany doesn't have much potential for pumped storage. It can work in a country like Norway, but not in Germany.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by Ygg2 on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:58AM (#32605305)
You could if there was an energy efficient, cheap, and widely available storage.

Such storage is right now domain of unicorns and pixie dust.

Other solution include near loseless transmission of power between sunny and shaded side.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by cardanome on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:09AM (#32605389)
The German Green Party was basically founded on anti-nuclear sentiment. The older members see it as their absolute life goal to stop nuclear power. They would rather see everything burn to the ground than change their mind.

As long as they are in government any compromise will be difficult.

Also, the situation in Germany is much worse than people from the outside think. Our best-case scenarios actually plan for pretty brutal energy saving cuts. People will be fully expected to wear multiple layers of clothing in their own homes because apparently having a warm home is now considered a luxury.

Other than hoping for a early peace in Ukraine I don't really anything that could solve the issues. I guess we will just have to tough it out.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by DocTomoe on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:51AM (#32606132)
> Other than hoping for a early peace in Ukraine I don't really anything that could solve the issues. I guess we will just have to tough it out.

Don't worry. The government is setting up all the right parameters for a revolution to replace them. Large parts of Germany, especially in the already government-critical east, are dependant on gas. Let October be the first cold month that hits us ... and the first grandma who decides she can't afford heating and freezes to death at night will make a splendid spark that will topple our pro-Ukrainian resolve.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:37AM (#32606605)
So you think Germans will not blame Russia for problems caused by the lack of Russian gas?
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by cardanome on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:36AM (#32608086)
Russia claims it would deliver as much gas as we need if we were to open Nordstream-2 though.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @11:08AM (#32608509)
The same Russia invading Europe on its eastern borders? Hasn’t dependence on Russian gas earned some suspicions among ordinary Germans?
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by DocTomoe on Friday August 26, 2022 @12:29PM (#32609513)
Actually, Russia has a track record of being a reliable provider of gas in worse situations than we are in today, reaching back to times when the Cold War was at its hottest. Outside of big media and some very ideologically-kosher circles, public opinion seems to be 'leave us our peace about that whole war business, make sure energy prices are sinking to an acceptable level again', with the mood becoming more explosive with every news article that tries to get us into the NATO party line.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:28PM (#32614346)
The Cold war never involved a large scale Russian invasion. Do you really think Russia will stop at the Polish border if they make it that far?
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by DocTomoe on Saturday August 27, 2022 @04:25AM (#32616990)
I think you may forget about Afghanistan, 1979.

And yes, I really think that. I do not think many sensible people believe in a looming Russian invasion of Germany.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Saturday August 27, 2022 @08:39AM (#32618312)
Ok but what about Poland? Germany is obligated to defend Poland, Romania, Lithuania, Latvia, etc. You honestly think Russia will not invade them? Or that Germany will not be obligated to spill blood in their defense?
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by DocTomoe on Saturday August 27, 2022 @05:40PM (#32623494)
> Ok but what about Poland?

Given how deeply ungrateful the Polish government has been towards the rest of Europe, especially Germany, in the last twenty years or so, pulling the evil German Nazi card whenever their will was not completely fulfilled while at the same time leeching off mostly Germany-originated monies, they can go suck it for all I care.

> Germany is obligated to defend Poland, Romania, Lithuania, Latvia, etc.

Nope. Read the relevant contracts. Nowhere in it it says that we need to "defend" anyone. NATO Article 5 states that an attack on one of the member states would be considered an attack against them all - and countries have endured attacks without retaliating (See: USS Liberty incident).

> You honestly think Russia will not invade them?

Not in the immediate future. Russia is overextended as it stands, they are obviously unable to stage another war for quite some time.

> Or that Germany will not be obligated to spill blood in their defense?

Also, we are not obligated to spill blood in defence. NATO Article 5 just states that we must take an action that we consider necessary - and not to aid the affected party member - but to restore peace and stability in Europe. If an aggressor blitzkrieged say Estonia, the whole thing was over in 24 hours, and everyone remaining was convinced that that's the end of it, peace and stability would return without any action necessary. Also, actions can be very little., they could be a strongly worded WhatsApp message to the aggressor.

This ambiguous meaning has been put in by the US, by the way, supposedly because they themselves thought it was not a good idea to sacrifice New York for Paris.

And Article 42(7) TEU only talks about "mutual aid" in case of armed conflict, which can be as little as sending some rice crackers.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by jillesvangurp on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:55AM (#32607578)
You make it sound like it's just the greens. In reality, it was a conservative Christian Democrat lead government that decided to get rid of nuclear power. Together with SPD, the socialists. Both are moderate parties and quite representative of the German attitude towards nuclear. There hasn't been a government without either SPD or CDU leading it. No other party has ever supplied a chancellor in post war Germany. And you'd be wrong to assume FDP is very pro-nuclear.

The current government features SPD (labour), the Greens, and the FDP (conservative). They have their work cut out but it's not an impossible job.

Nuclear might get a temporary and short extension of life in Germany but that 8GW is not going to matter a whole lot relative to the tens of GW of gas that are used for electricity and the many GW more that are being used for heating. The numbers just don't add up. Short term it helps as a stop gap solution but long term there's a need for many tens of GW of additional capacity. Most of that inevitably is going to be wind and solar. Gas is a complete non starter at this point. And coal is quite expensive and coal supplies also are a bit tricky as most of that actually also came from Russia.

The Ukrainian crisis is basically succeeding in making the Germans go cold turkey on gas and coal in a hurry. It's going to be disruptive and expensive but they are going to get it done much earlier than they were originally planning even a year ago. The disruption will be mainly to industry which will suffer most of the consequences of high prices and limited availability of gas. However, that will cause industry to respond by investing in reducing their dependency on those energy sources. Once that takes effect, the transition is permanent. Probably, ten years from now, most coal production in Germany will be gone; most gas heating and electricity will be gone and what little remains will be powered using expensive imports. Some of which might still come from Russia.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by cardanome on Friday August 26, 2022 @12:30PM (#32609526)
> Most of that inevitably is going to be wind and solar. Gas is a complete non starter at this point. And coal is quite expensive and coal supplies also are a bit tricky as most of that actually also came from Russia.

Wind and Solar have the drawback of not being a constant or reliable source of energy. Yes, they provide cheap and clean energy but not always when you need it.

Yes, the solution would be to save the energy when you need it BUT we don't have that, yet. I really hope we will figure something out but we need not face reality: The tech is not there yet. It might take decades that we don't have.

This is so frustrating to argue with people. Like, I really like your optimism but we don't have a saving solution. We have some ideas but scaling them up towards the scope that we actually need is not easily done.

I really wish you were right but the facts don't add add.

> However, that will cause industry to respond by investing in reducing their dependency on those energy sources.

Since when do they know that they should be transitioning to other sources? Decades? What have the done? Nothing.

As long there are other countries with cheap gas I am not so optimistic. Yes, some will make the transitions, other will move production to other countries and lot's of them we will simply lose. The next years will be brutal.

Only when the international community actually starts to take climate change and dependence on gas more serious will we see some change.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:34AM (#32606569)
> The German Green Party was basically founded on anti-nuclear sentiment.

As an American it is not hard to see how these hardened anti-nuclear activists in Germany benefit Russia. It is also not hard to see the close political and historic proximity between the Soviet Union and the Green party.

It seems that average Germans do not make that connection. Why?

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by foepys on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:16AM (#32607079)
This is revisionist history and your completely false accusations put it near Russian propaganda territory. I challenge you to find even a single proof for what you wrote.

The Greens were the only party calling for embargoes against Russia to stop importing Russian gas all together in 2014 when Russia annexed Crimea. They also opposed Nord Stream 2 from the beginning. They inherited the clusterfuck the conservatives left them when they got elected in 2021 and now have to deal with what they have.

The conservatives killed the German solar industry (world leader at the time in the 2000s) and also killed the wind turbine industry shortly after. Reason? China was cheaper.

The Greens were also the first to call for weapons for Ukraine while other parties struggled to even make statements.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:03AM (#32607702)
Russian propagandists would accuse Russia of secret interference in European politics?

Of course evidence on these matters is going to be hard to find.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/jun/19/russia-s...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by foepys on Friday August 26, 2022 @11:17AM (#32608628)
Your "proof" is not supporting anything. Environmentalists can be anybody.

Russia didn't want Germany to utilize fracking gas because this would mean that Germany doesn't need Russia anymore. The Green party opposes any gas where possible. Just because Russia financed a few fringe groups doesn't mean that the Green party is in bed with Russia.

https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/nord-stream-2-die...

This clearly proves that in June 2021 the Greens already predicted what would happen in 2022 and opposed the opening of Nord Stream 2 because of geopolitical and security risks.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by someguydave on Saturday August 27, 2022 @08:40AM (#32618323)
My thread was about anti-nuclear propaganda, not anti-gas.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by yodelshady on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:22AM (#32605022)
Also Germany: repoens, I believe approx. 8 GW, coal plants.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/juliecoleman/2022/07/08/germany...

I'm sorry, but this is hearfelt: the German greens are climate criminals. And they were fully warned of exactly this situation decades ago, so no, they have zero "circumstances forced our hand" defence.

You knew, and you chose to burn coal anyway.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:33AM (#32605095)
> I'm sorry, but this is hearfelt: the German greens are climate criminals. And they were fully warned of exactly this situation decades ago, so no, they have zero "circumstances forced our hand" defence.

The Greens have not been in government for the last sixteen years. It was the conservative governments under Merkel and particularly the environment and later economy minister Altmaier who openly celebrated reducing buildout of solar power [1].

As for nuclear power: any talk about lengthening their operation is utter madness. There are no fuel rods and the reactors haven't had their security checkups because they were scheduled to be shut down - and just look at France just how catastrophic nuclear power actually is (ETA: I substantially detailed that in a daughter comment, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32605337).

The government has little other choice than to keep the coal burners running at this point, as the Merkel governments have done everything in their power to hinder renewable energy buildout, and the Bavarian CSU has sabotaged cross-country high voltage power transmission lines.

[1] https://www.n-tv.de/politik/Einbruch-bei-der-Photovoltaik-ar...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:21AM (#32605474)
> The Greens have not been in government for the last sixteen years.

While this is true, they have always been in favour of shutting down nuclear power plants and now they would have the opportunity to reverse this course, but they don't.

The Greens have been founded as an anti-nuclear party. In the 80s, they even demanded to replace nuclear power with coal (https://twitter.com/MoormannRainer/status/143529774448733801...). Shutting down nuclear power plants is obviously more important to them than the climate.

> and just look at France just how catastrophic nuclear power actually is.

What's so catastrophic about France? Despite all the troubles they currently have, their CO2 emissions per kW are still a fraction of Germany's.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:44AM (#32605618)
> While this is true, they have always been in favour of shutting down nuclear power plants and now they would have the opportunity to reverse this course, but they don't.

Because nuclear does not make sense. The financial risk of accidents at a Fukushima or Chernobyl scale is too high (as no insurer will take on that risk, the taxpayers will have to pay for it, and as the Ukraine invasion and the fighting around Chernobyl shows, disaster plants are a danger for decades!), a lot of the uranium comes from questionable sources (Russia and Khazakhstan [1]), and Europe does not have permanent storage solutions for the nuclear waste [2].

Renewable energies already make up 41% of our electricity generation, it could be 100%.

> What's so catastrophic about France? Despite all the troubles they currently have, their CO2 emissions per kW are still a fraction of Germany's.

For the sake of not spamming around the same text, I consolidated the list of issues here in a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32605337

As for the CO2 emissions: yeah because the CO2 everyone else in Europe generates to compensate their nuclear issues is not counted in their CO2 budget but ours.

[1] https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/nuclear/where-our-uraniu...

[2] https://www.br.de/nachrichten/wissen/atommuell-die-suche-nac...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:58AM (#32606197)
> Because nuclear does not make sense.

Assuming your three points would be solved, would you be in favour of nuclear power plants? Or what exactly would need to change?

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:02AM (#32606235)
I would of course not be in favor of nuclear power. A new nuclear plant takes well over a decade to build - it makes way more economical sense to build renewable power plants because they can be ready far faster and pose less danger and waste to our children.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:15AM (#32606359)
> I would of course not be in favor of nuclear power.

Ok, let's say I could convince you that it is possible to store nuclear waste safely, and show you that building up wind power takes at least as long. Could I convince you then?

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:37AM (#32606604)
No, because of the financial risks involved in constructing, operating and getting rid of them. The costs associated with Fukushima are estimated to be at least 200 billion dollars [1], Chernobyl 235 billion dollars [2].

Even leaving out disaster scenarios: A modern EPR nuclear power plant is at ~1.6 GW [3] at a cost of 11 billion euros, taking a decade or more to build, and about a billion dollars to tear down [4]. A wind park half the size costs two billion dollars in two to five years [5], has less risks in construction, no risk at all of a catastrophic failure, and assuming 80€/kWh in teardown costs [6] 16 million € for the teardown.

That means wind power at a capacity factor of 0.4-0.5 [7] (meaning, you need two of them to achieve the same available capacity to the grid on average) is half as expensive as a nuclear power plant even when ignoring the efficiencies that building at scale brings with it and has virtually no risks attached. Financially, it's absolute irresponsibility to go nuclear.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK253929/

[2] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/article/chernobyl...

[3] https://taz.de/Finnischer-Reaktor-geht-ans-Netz/!5829751/

[4] https://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/energie/energiewend...

[5] https://renewablesnow.com/news/construction-starts-on-800-mw...

[6] https://www.bmwk.de/Redaktion/DE/Parlamentarische-Anfragen/2...

[7] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volllaststunde

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:48AM (#32606722)
You can't compare the price of a wind park with the price of a nuclear power plant, because the wind park does not offer base load. A wind park without base load is pretty useless. Base load is far more valuable. So if you say a power plant costs 12 billions, it is a steal compared to a two billion wind park. Most people will rather have electricity 24/7 than occasional electricity for 1/6th the price.

Beside that, in another comment you had a long list of things you say is required to make EE feasible. You need to include the price of all these things in your calculation.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:55AM (#32606802)
> You can't compare the price of a wind park with the price of a nuclear power plant, because the wind park does not offer base load.

Agreed that base load is valuable... but why not go and reduce the amount of base load by both directly saving on load (e.g. by insulating houses or getting rid of advertising) and by making the base load that absolutely remains more flexible (e.g. by upgrading to a truly smart grid that can dynamically regulate consumption of loads)?

And for what it's worth, you can additionally also go and build even more wind energy. In times of ample wind, the now infinitely cheap electricity can be used in electrolysis to generate hydrogen as a base chemical for the industry and fuel for those very few applications that definitely need a combustion process (e.g. glass and metal foundries).

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tehbeard on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:22AM (#32607149)
The only people who are more "trust us, it's just around the corner" than fusion folks are the renewables only folks and their hair brained schemes to avoid the base load question.

Complicating the grid with smarts, given how well that's gone with IoT?

We've thrown a low carbon option under the bus because of sloppy Soviet engineering.

The coal and gas we are stuck with due to "greens" no nuclear stance has caused more harm to humanity than our sum total nuclear incidents, even counting non power incidents such as orphaned radiotherapy sources or ignoring procedures at irradiation facilities.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:15AM (#32607061)
All these things are not enough. In 2015, there was an hour when wind power only generated 0.2GW. Hydro and biomass will probably never exceed 10GW combined. Even if you radically reduce the electricity needs down to, let's say, 35GW, you would still have a gap of 25GW. You can't build enough wind power to get this on a day without wind. You need another power source.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by dontlaugh on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:39AM (#32608123)
I was with you until here.

The waste was never the main problem and contemporary nuclear power plant designs don't share many of the other downsides either.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by YawningAngel on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:54AM (#32605276)
Can you elaborate on the problems with France? If I were in government in France I'd be thrilled with nuclear power as an investment right about now
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:03AM (#32605337)
> Can you elaborate on the problems with France?

80% of their power is generated by nuclear. Of their nuclear plants, way over half the fleet has been offline for months because of inspections and sometimes substantial damages from age-related corrosion issues [1], and the other half is severely limited or cut off as well because the rivers that they depend on for cooling can't keep up [2]. And since the entire continent is a single synced grid, someone has to cover the gap, and that's German gas peakers [3].

Unfortunately, European energy markets operate at the "merit order" principle [4] which means that the highest bidder on the spot market sets the price for everyone else - which means while gas peaker plants generate extremely expensive energy for France, the operators of any other type of plant get the exact same high price leading to billions of euros in excess profit for them [5].

France also has another problem, and that's the EPR design that has led to severe budget and time overruns. Not just generic issues, but massive design defects [6]. They bet on Flamanville replacing a bunch of the aged plants, the bet failed, and no one knows when that reactor will finally come online. Flamanville was projected to cost 3.3 billion euros and be ready in 2012 - current estimates are at 12.7 billion euros at the least and a start in Q2/23 [7], and other EPR projects are just as bad.

[1] https://www.france24.com/en/france/20220825-france-prolongs-...

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/aug/03/edf-to-redu...

[3] https://www.swr.de/swraktuell/baden-wuerttemberg/suedbaden/w...

[4] https://www.focus.de/finanzen/boerse/merit-order-wie-ein-gut...

[5] https://www.derstandard.de/story/2000137852348/gas-und-oelpr...

[6] https://www.express.co.uk/news/science/1645421/energy-crisis...

[7] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/edf-hopeful-end-sigh...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by ZeroGravitas on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:54AM (#32605701)
Long term, the merit order makes sense.

All those plants make the max price, so if you can think of a way to cheaply generate power when it is expensive you get paid the high gas price up until all gas is removed from the market.

Short term, if a war or embargo is driving up gas prices, it still makes sense to charge high prices, because that gives people an incentive to not use electricity and so saves on the restricted resource.

But, this will really hit the poor or businesses that use a lot of gas through no fault of their own.

Since we are all in this together, the people earning the extra money should get it redistributed to the people. But some rich and powerful people think that sets a bad precedent, so they'll try to make poor people suffer as much as they can before doing it.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by extropy on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:04AM (#32606260)
Are you sure all plants get to sell at spot price?

Doesn't that encourage collusion to generate artificial scarcity - all participants benefit from it?

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by ZeroGravitas on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:41AM (#32606642)
Yes, this is actually why the Tesla Big Battery in Australia was so cost effective, it stopped gas plants from manipulating the prices:

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/feb/06/how-tesla...

> The big gas generators – even though they have 10 times more capacity than is required – have systematically rorted the situation, sometimes charging up to $7m a day for a service that normally comes at one-tenth of the price.

> (You can read reports on how they do it here, here and here, and for a more detailed explanation at the bottom of this story.)

> The difference in January was that there is a new player in the market: Tesla. The company’s big battery, officially known as the Hornsdale Power Reserve, bid into the market to ensure that prices stayed reasonable, as predicted last year.

> Rather than jumping up to prices of around $11,500 and $14,000/MW, the bidding of the Tesla big battery – and, in a major new development, the adjoining Hornsdale windfarm – helped (after an initial spike) to keep them at around $270/MW.

> This saved several million dollars in FCAS charges, which are paid by other generators and big energy users, in a single day.

> And that’s not the only impact. According to state government’s advisor, Frontier Economics, the average price of FCAS fell by around 75% in December from the same month the previous year. Market players are delighted, and consumers should be too, because they will ultimately benefit.

Of course, just decent regulatory oversight can stop this kind of thing too, but fossil fuel producers seem to be really against that kind of thing for some reason.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by YawningAngel on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:30AM (#32605535)
Thanks, those are very cogent criticisms I wasn't aware of and I appreciate you taking the time to source them thoroughly
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:51AM (#32605245)
"look at France just how catastrophic nuclear power actually is"

I assume you are referring to power plants that has to shut down due to low water levels?

If the powerplant is designed with a source of eater in mind, it will have tp shut down when the water is gone. It does not matter if the plant is oil, coal or nuclear.

Plenty of nuclear powerplants use seawater for cooling, and none of them had to shutdown.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:10AM (#32605399)
> I assume you are referring to power plants that has to shut down due to low water levels?

It goes way worse than the drought. For the sake of not spamming around the same text, I consolidated the list of issues here in a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32605337

> Plenty of nuclear powerplants use seawater for cooling, and none of them had to shutdown.

Plants at the seawater border are vulnerable to floods as a result of extreme weather conditions, we've seen the consequences of that in Fukushima. Additionally, being close to the sea means the plants are vulnerable to the rise of sea water, which is a risk for the future.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by hnbad on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:50AM (#32605238)
I'd say it's the fault of neoliberalism (which certainly has a foothold in parts of the CDU/CSU and all major parties really, not just the FDP) that most infrastructure projects of the past decades have been limited to a few failed prestige projects (powerlines just aren't as sexy as a massive airport nobody can use) but it's the fault of the Greens (not specifically the party but the general political movement it stems from) that we're at a point where we are stuck with coal because nuclear is no longer an option.

I'm not saying it's bad they protested nuclear. Nuclear needs to go, too. It's just bad that they hyperfixated on nuclear because it's easier to scare people about it and that they didn't ensure we get rid of coal first. Scaring people about nuclear was child's play after Chernobyl if the threat of the Cold War wasn't enough (as the public already conflated nuclear power and nuclear weapons). The coal industry's political power is much greater in Germany tho and taking it on would have meant finding a way to bridge the cultural gap between blue collar Kumpels and the more college educated Birkenstock crowd.

Hopefully FFF and XR are finally doing some of the work now but sadly the opposition has also gotten better at its game and that Kumpel at his Stammtisch beer will most likely make bad jokes about "Greta" despite not batting an eye if you ask him to sign a petition to shut down all nuclear plants.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:56AM (#32605289)
I really believe Neoliberalism has kneecapped the West, our infrastructure is basically stuck in 1980's, which is when the ideology took hold.

In UK, since we privatised water companies, they have not built a single new reservoir, they are basically operating 30 year old infrastructure, dumping sewage in rivers and paying themselves dividends in the billiona

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:06AM (#32605364)
We don't need nuclear. Even with decades of conservative sabotage, we generate ~41% of our electricity needs [1] on a renewable basis. Imagine we had used the last sixteen years to go all-in on renewables - we wouldn't need to kowtow in front of any dictatorship. No Qatari gas, no Russian or other dictatorship uranium, nothing.

[1] https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/themen/klima-energie/erneuerb...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:23AM (#32605490)
The amount of electricity generated over the course of a year is irrelevant without storage. We could generate 1000% of our energy needs and still not have enough, if we generate 2000% in summer and 0% in winter.

We need to generate 100% of our energy needs every single hour. Renewables are practically incapable of doing this on their own. They can reduce the use of fossil fuelds (or nuclear power), but not replace them.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:47AM (#32605641)
> We need to generate 100% of our energy needs every single hour. Renewables are practically incapable of doing this on their own. They can reduce the use of fossil fuelds (or nuclear power), but not replace them.

Install enough windmills across the entire coastal areas of Europe, add thousands of kilometers long cross-continental UHVDC links like China does [1] and even winter won't be a problem.

Besides: using biomass / biogas fuel for conventional burner plants is climate neutral, and the supply is enough to cover half of the deliveries of Russia [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-voltage_electricity...

[2] https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/technologie/biogas-stat...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:55AM (#32606170)
> Install enough windmills across the entire coastal areas of Europe,

That's completely unrealistic. There are times when in all of Europe there is little to no wind. Certainly not enough that one region can provide enough power for all of Europe. Maybe it's possible in China, I don't now their climate, but even they are planning to increase the number of nuclear power plants.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:19AM (#32606401)
We need a complete transformation of our power usage in any case, both to save energy demand and to make the grid more flexible:

- insulate buildings so that they better retain heat. This one is massive - over a third of all energy consumption goes towards buildings [1]!

- promote heat pumps (either to air or ground) because these are far more energy efficient for air conditioning and hot water generation

- help poorer households to save energy - especially those who can't afford to replace their 20 years old fridge which consumes over double the power that a modern appliance needs [2].

- resilient grids with photo-voltaic energy generation on every roof and distributed battery storage

- smart grids that can (dis)incentivize large loads like water heaters or electric vehicles automatically based on grid generation capacity

- more incentives for high-energy consuming industries to act as a dynamic power sink or to operate only in times where energy is plentiful

- shut down street lights at night or make them smart to only be alight when needed - lighting consumes about 0.7% of the total power consumption [0], but as it runs at night where solar power is offline by definition, its impact on base load is worse.

- completely ban advertisements using lighting at night

Ideally, we would have continuous renewable or at least climate neutral-ish generation power (geothermal, tidal, running water power, biogas and waste incineration and whatever is the sum of the lowest-ever-available-wind power) to cover the base load, and have consumers smartly adapt on current electricity prices.

[0] https://www.strassenbeleuchtung.de/index.php/technik/34-grun...

[1] https://www.dena.de/themen-projekte/energieeffizienz/gebaeud...

[2] https://www.verbraucherzentrale.nrw/sites/default/files/2022...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:38AM (#32606614)
Just a few comments:

- the things you list are insanely expensive (just keep that in mind next time you say that nuclear power is expensive... you also need to figure these costs in when comparing to EE, because you wouldn't need to do this with nuclear)

- PV with battery storage is great for autarky and reducing fossils, but won't reduce the need for base load after a week without sun in winter, when all the batteries are empty..

- things like heat pumps that replace fossils will increase electricity consumption. I think current estimates are that electricity consumption may increase 50-100%.

- there is just not a lot of potential for additional renewable base load in Germany. Bio gas, hydro, geothermal.. they are all pretty must at their limits. there is just no way around either burning fossils, using nuclear or having an insane amount of storage.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:04AM (#32606913)
> - the things you list are insanely expensive (just keep that in mind next time you say that nuclear power is expensive... you also need to figure these costs in when comparing to EE, because you wouldn't need to do this with nuclear)

We absolutely need to do this anyway and fast, because there will not be any massive amount of new nuclear power going online - even if we were to start out a buildout offensive in nuclear plants, it would take ten to fifteen years at best, and we need to conserve as much energy as we can in the meantime.

> - PV with battery storage is great for autarky and reducing fossils, but won't reduce the need for base load after a week without sun in winter, when all the batteries are empty..

Which is why industry needs to be incentivized to shut down in such times. China does it by force, we can offer financial incentives.

> Bio gas, hydro, geothermal.. they are all pretty must at their limits. there is just no way around either burning fossils, using nuclear or having an insane amount of storage.

Biogas has a lot of potential, as well as geothermal. We just need to get going after 16 years of sabotage by the conservatives.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:33AM (#32607295)
> We absolutely need to do this anyway

No. Only if we want to be the only major country in the civilised world that doesn't use nuclear power despite having not enough hydro power.

> would take ten to fifteen years at best,

This is extremely optimistic for wind power, and even more for rebuilding the electricity grid. Even if you can somehow shorten the planning processes: We are in the middle of a workers shortage and a supply-chain crisis. Who should build all these wind parks? And all the other things you listed, like building isolations and heat pumps. Shut down universities and require everybody to work in construction for a couple of years?

> we need to conserve as much energy as we can in the meantime.

Why? What's the outcome? Kill the economy? Who should pay for all these things?

> Biogas has a lot of potential, as well as geothermal.

Biogas needs agricultural land and thereby competes with food, and thus has other implications. Geothermal would be nice to have, and I think everybody agrees on that, but it's going nowhere. And as far I know not only in Germany, but everywhere.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by FredPret on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:58AM (#32607615)
Ban ads at night? Insulate our houses even more? Turn off the street lamps? All so we can run our civilization on literal windmills? When we have nuclear that is both safer and cleaner than this ancient technology? Incredible.

It’s like you’re not really pro-climate, but trying to accomplish the secret objective of limiting the scope of human existence. I am reminded of the anti-human religious folk who see humanity as a sinful scourge.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by dontlaugh on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:43AM (#32608167)
China's energy policy is indeed one of the few rational ones. But besides vast improvements in renewables, transmission and storage, China has also invested in new better nuclear designs.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by permo-w on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:47AM (#32605217)
what blame do the Christian Democrats have for this?
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by freilanzer on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:55AM (#32605286)
If you blame them for everything you will be at least partially correct more often than not.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by the_mitsuhiko on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:19AM (#32604984)
Power issues in Europe will be big enough going into the winter that the few German nuclear power plants will likely the least of our issues.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tpmx on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:30AM (#32605070)
"We are going to have a severe lack of energy, so shutting down nuclear power plants is likely the least of our issues"?

I'm afraid I don't follow the logic here.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by the_mitsuhiko on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:50AM (#32605241)
Shutting down the German nuclear power plants does not help the situation obviously but right even turning them on now is not going to help us at all over the winter. First of all not enough energy gets generated from there in the grand scheme of things, secondly they would not be operational in time.

If you want to look for more nuclear to turn on, have a look at France where less than 50% of nuclear power plants are currently generating energy.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:36AM (#32605120)
Homes are heated with gas, not with nuclear power. Industrial processes run on gas, not on nuclear power.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by throwaway742 on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:56AM (#32605290)
Yes, but if you can use less gas for electricity generation you have more for the other uses. Germany has other sources of gas besides Russia (e.g. Norway). The goal isn't to completely stop using gas at all, but rather to reduce dependence on Russia who only supplies 30% of German gas.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by BjoernKW on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:46AM (#32605210)
Problem is, without nuclear power, they will have to resort to generating power from natural gas instead of using that gas for heating, which will in turn have problems compound.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:48AM (#32605223)
Right now gas plants are running to stabilize the grid in France...
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by BjoernKW on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:55AM (#32605285)
That may be true, but that's orthogonal to the entirely home-made problems Germany is facing right now. While not a complete solution, using the remaining nuclear plants is an obvious stopgap measure to at least alleviate those problems in the short term.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by phh on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:02AM (#32606248)
Uh, as far as I know, that's forever been the case? Nuclear is too slow to react to events, so we always need some safety margin that gas can provide?
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by the_mitsuhiko on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:36AM (#32606600)
France's issues with nuclear are long lasting. They are running only 24 out of 56 power plants today and a lot of that outage is ongoing for many months. France is a net importer for almost a year I believe which is untypical for the country which normally exports cheap nuclear electricity.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by phh on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:37AM (#32608102)
Yes, France's current situation fucking sucks. However my answer was for this message:

> Right now gas plants are running to stabilize the grid in France...

As far as I know, gas plants have always been used to stabilize grid in France.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by phh on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:00AM (#32606215)
If there's no gas, most homes can heat with electricity. Turn on your oven, your gaming console, your TV, open your fridge's door, etc. Also as I understand it, it's much easier to do rolling blackouts on electricity than on gas, so gas will be more likely to fail for a long time than electricity.

Most industrial processes can be stopped without endangering people.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by adrianN on Saturday August 27, 2022 @12:50AM (#32615821)
If people need to start heating homes with electricity, half a dozen old nuclear plants won't save us. You underestimate how much electricity it takes to heat a homes with resistive heaters.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by hnbad on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:37AM (#32605128)
To be fair, the problem with nuclear power in Germany is bigger than that the existing nuclear plants are being shut down. It's actually a good idea to shut them down eventually as they're old and inefficient. Calling them "fully functioning" is a bit of a rose tinted glasses type of situation.

The bigger problem is that Germany doesn't have any more recent nuclear power plants due to public pressure and instead just extended the lifetimes of the existing ones for decades to compensate. We could have built better and SAFER nuclear power plants but because that would have lost voters we instead had to extend the lifetimes again and again.

All polluting industries have their own tactics to deflect public attention. In Germany coal succeeded at deflecting that attention towards nuclear. The Ruhr region has a romanticized nostalgia for its history of coal mining whereas most people associate nuclear power with Chernobyl (or more recently Fukushima, which really just culturally echoed the existing memories of Chernobyl), the nuclear bombings of Nagasaki and Hiroshima and the threat of global thermonuclear war while being smack in the middle of the Iron Curtain (almost literally, with the Berlin Wall separating both sides of the conflict).

I don't know to what extent the coal industry is actually involved in this, but there is an almost patriotic attitude towards coal plants in contrast with the horrified panic surrounding nuclear. Meanwhile solar is mostly seen as a way to cut down on electric bills by installing pannels on your own roof and wind power is a "blight on the countryside" and "health risk" (because of noise pollution, strobing shadows and of course killing migratory birds). Some of this seems to be finally changing but the "man on the street" will likely still prefer coal over all other forms of energy for no good reason.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by lispm on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:45AM (#32605199)
> The bigger problem is that Germany doesn't have any more recent nuclear power plants due to public pressure

France hasn't either and they don't have public pressure against it. The are still trying to build a single one, being a decade late and billions more expensive.

> or more recently Fukushima, which really just culturally echoed the existing memories of Chernobyl

Currently we think about the nuclear fleet in the Ukraine which is literally under fire from Russia.

We are not far away from a new Fukushima, but this time in Europe.

https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/both-working-reactors-o...

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/aug/25/zaporizhzhia-n...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by phtrivier on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:04AM (#32605345)
> they don't have public pressure against it

There _is_ public pressure against nuclear, but it's at 50/50 vs support for nuclear. It has become a mostly partisan topic.

> We are not far away from a new Fukushima, but this time in Europe.

Except we technically _already_ had "Fukushima in Europe" 40 years ago, and for most people, life just went on.

I agree that if anything goes bad a the Ukrainian plant (FSM forbids), the politicians who have been pro-nuclear in the past few years will have a hard time keeping face, and the sentiments would change, and the experts would spent some unconfortable interviews.

However, I can not blame government for being even more scared at Union-wide blackouts than at a local incident at a plant.

The latter is horrible, and puts you at the mercy of winds, but _has been managed in the past_.

The former gives me worst nightmares (than the other scenario that also gives me nightmares.)

Let's all remember it made _sense_ to live in Pompei in 79.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by lispm on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:33AM (#32605553)
> but it's at 50/50 vs support for nuclear

where is the pressure in France against nuclear? I can remember civil war like situations at construction sites in Germany years ago. A political movement that spawned a new party which now is, again, in a ruling coalition.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by phtrivier on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:35PM (#32631809)
In the French version of the same party (EELV), as well as in at least one of its main "coalition" partner (LFI).

In the left-wing press in general (Liberation, Le Monde and Le Canard Enchaîné are _patently_ antinuke).

In the minds of french people, also, who are very ambivalent about the topic (as measured by... The nuclear industry itself [1])

In regular demonstrations against the Bure waste disposal project, and In general snarkiness about the nuclear plants producing exactly as much current during maintenance as solar panels during the night.

Now, to be fair, this split is more 30% against, 30% for, and 30 % "does not care and is happy to have relatively cheap electricity and no major incident for the last 60 years".

The side that is mostly against nuclear is also very good at _not_ winning elections.

Far right could very much have decided to go antinuke too, but for some reason they decided being anti wind was a better bet.

The rest of the country is in this weird middle stage were it's not popular to be pro nuke if you want to score with girls at parties, but you'll kinda be anyway.

[1] https://www.bva-group.com/sondages/francais-nucleaire-sondag...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by lispm on Sunday August 28, 2022 @05:24PM (#32632198)
> is happy to believe to have relatively cheap electricity

FTFY

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:01AM (#32605325)
> Currently we think about the nuclear fleet in the Ukraine which is literally under fire from Russia.

The 1938 Yellow River flood (Chinese: 花園口決隄事件, literally "Huayuankou embankment breach incident") was a flood created by the Nationalist Government in central China during the early stage of the Second Sino-Japanese War in an attempt to halt the rapid advance of Japanese forces. One million dead.

So by that logic you should be against hydroelectric dams, becauae they've been used in warfare for centuries.

One would think the chief problem in that equasion is war, not infrastructure

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by throwaway742 on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:00AM (#32605310)
Hasn't Zaporizhzhia been under Russian control for a while now? Why would they be shelling themselves? That doesn't even make sense.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _kbh_ on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:59AM (#32605754)
> Hasn't Zaporizhzhia been under Russian control for a while now? Why would they be shelling themselves? That doesn't even make sense.

Because the Russians are trying to disconnect the plant from the Ukrainian grid or cause a disaster they specifically said they could cause a disaster if they wanted to.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by fuoqi on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:33AM (#32605556)
>Currently we think about the nuclear fleet in the Ukraine which is literally under fire from Russia.

It's hilarious how the Western politicians and mass media seriously blame Russia for shelling a nuclear plant which it controls for a number of months. And a lot of people either blindly trust this narrative, or intentionally spread misinformation with the sole goal to demonize Russia as much as possible. It reminds me how Donetsk rebels were blamed for shelling of civilians in territories which they control.

It clearly shows how far we are in the post-truth world. Even a tiny bit of critical thinking is enough to understand who truly does the shelling, but titles like "Ukrainian Army shells a nuclear plant" are too inconvenient for the current political climate.

As far as I know, the goal of shelling (which for the time being does not target the reactors or the spent fuel storage) is to discourage Russia from disconnecting the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant from the Ukrainian grid and connect it with the Russian grid instead.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _kbh_ on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:02AM (#32605775)
> And a lot of people either blindly trust this narrative, or intentionally spread misinformation with the sole goal to demonize Russia as much as possible.

No one needs to demonise a country that commits genocide and has its military rape children, the Russians are plenty good at demonising themselves.

> As far as I know, the goal of shelling (which for the time being does not target the reactors or the spent fuel storage) is to discourage Russia from disconnecting the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant from the Ukrainian grid and connect it with the Russian grid instead.

The goal of the shelling _is_ to disconnect the power plant, the Russians are shelling the plant to try and cause issues with the connection to the Ukrainian grid which they successfully did in the past couple days.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by gdy on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @08:48AM (#32649708)
"and has its military rape children"

Yeah, right. The woman spreading these accounts got finally fired.

"... also accuses her [Lyudmyla Denisova] of having focused too much on media work, and on describing sexually motivated crimes in gratuitous detail as well as the raping of children in occupied territories. However, some of these accounts, he said, had not been verified, which had harmed Ukraine's reputation and distracted media attention from other, proven crimes and problems." [0]

[0] https://www.dw.com/en/why-ukraines-human-rights-chief-lyudmy...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _kbh_ on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @09:33AM (#32650209)
> Yeah, right. The woman spreading these accounts got finally fired.

You're speaking like the Russian army is some sort of pillar of society that would never do a thing.

We know that they regularly rape, torture and commit war crimes. In multiple cities in Ukraine. This isn't really disputable they even brag on camera about wanting to commit genocide and even castrate people on camera.

Here's an article on the crimes they have committed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_violence_in_the_2022_Ru...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by gdy on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:33PM (#32654098)
The wikipedia article you are referring to doesn't even mention rape of children.

It, however, contains this paragraph: "Lyudmyla Denisova, Ombudsman in Ukraine for human rights, "speculated" that sexual violence was being used as a weapon of war by Russian forces.[15][23] Denisova was fired from her position in the end of May, 2022. She later admitted to making "“exaggerated” reports of sexual crimes by Russian soldiers in order to get Ukraine more weaponry.[24]"

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _kbh_ on Thursday September 01, 2022 @09:01AM (#32675682)
Its true that it doesn't mention child rape but it mentions rape and torture of plenty of others. The point I was making is that its not like Russia likes to abide by either the Geneva convention or sway away from committing war crimes.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by gdy on Thursday September 01, 2022 @10:09AM (#32676408)
No, you were trying to disprove "a lot of people ... intentionally spread misinformation with the sole goal to demonize Russia as much as possible" and were caught spreading misinformation.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _kbh_ on Friday September 02, 2022 @09:02AM (#32690184)
> No, you were trying to disprove "a lot of people ... intentionally spread misinformation with the sole goal to demonize Russia as much as possible" and were caught spreading misinformation.

They rape, torture and commit genocide. Just because there was one instance of someone being fired doesn't make everything said after false, theres other accounts of child rape too.

For example this article was posted on the 21st of august - https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2022-08-21/russia...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by gdy on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:25AM (#32691227)
Yeah, right, because Denisova was the only Ukrainian person who was lying to get Western help for Ukraine.

The only source this article cites is written answer of Ukrainian prosecutor general’s office and even it mentions only single anonymous case of coercion of 16 year old girl. Which is one too many if true.

Note, that's the same Ukrainian prosecutor general’s office that for eight years failed to investigate the death of 42 people burned alive by Ukrainian nationalists in Odessa [0].

Please read the wikipedia article on atrocity propaganda [1] and how it's been used for ages.

Having said that, I do believe that war crimes inevitably happen in all wars, even in ones waged by 'enlightened and civilized West' [2].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Odesa_clashes

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atrocity_propaganda

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brereton_Report

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _kbh_ on Saturday September 03, 2022 @06:17AM (#32700415)
> Having said that, I do believe that war crimes inevitably happen in all wars, even in ones waged by 'enlightened and civilized West' [2].

The difference is for Russia the war crimes are a every day thing and expected of Russian soldiers, in the west it’s a big deal when they happen, investigations happen and people even sometimes get charged.

Russia commits genocide regularly in Ukraine and some of them even state it’s the purpose of the war.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by gdy on Saturday September 03, 2022 @11:43AM (#32702953)
And you prove these outlandish statements with what, exactly?
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by actionfromafar on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:11AM (#32605844)
But why don't they just cut the connection at the plant. Agreed about demonizing themselves, they do.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _kbh_ on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:12AM (#32607017)
> But why don't they just cut the connection at the plant. Agreed about demonizing themselves, they do.

This assumes Russia is a rational actor, they could want to do it and try and have leverage to blame the Ukrainians they could want to do it and try and cause a disaster and blame the Ukrainians.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by actionfromafar on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:59AM (#32607636)
That's very rational, actually. Not very nice, though.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by fuoqi on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:19AM (#32605902)
>No one needs to demonise a country that commits genocide and has its military rape children,

"Genocide" became a meaningless word because it's used willy-nilly similarly to "terrorism". Even if we are to trust number of civilian deaths reported by Western and Ukrainian sources it's really far from being "genocide". IIRC in relative terms, the US invasion of Iraq with subsequent fight against ISIS is closer to "genocide" than the invasion of Ukraine.

And as for "rape children", it's yet another blatant demonization. The lies became so toxic, Zelensky even had to fire Denisova, the person responsible for distributing most of such claims without properly supporting them with evidence. Most of "Russian soldiers rape children" articles you read in the Western media were citing Denisova.

>The goal of the shelling _is_ to disconnect the power plant

Oh wow... Are you incapable of critical thinking? Like at all? Russians can always physically cut wires in the territory they control.

If they wanted, they could've easily bombed every substation in Ukraine with its missiles. But because they do have some humanitarian considerations, they don't do it (unlike some other countries). As we can see, Russia has no techincal trouble bombing stationary objects as far as the westernmost Ukraine.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by _kbh_ on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:04AM (#32606920)
> "Genocide" became a meaningless word because it's used willy-nilly similarly to "terrorism". Even if we are to trust number of civilian deaths reported by Western and Ukrainian sources it's really far from being "genocide". IIRC in relative terms, the US invasion of Iraq with subsequent fight against ISIS is closer to "genocide" than the invasion of Ukraine.

Genocide has a definition and even basing our assertions of just what Russia is admitting that they are doing they meet the definition of genocide, its not meaningless it just has a broader definition then most people know.

You can read the definition of genocide from here.

>> https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/genocide.shtml

>> In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:

>> Killing members of the group;

>> Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;

>> Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;

>> Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;

>> Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.

You could argue about some of the points but Russia _proudly_ admits they are kidnapping Ukrainian children and forcibly relocating them to Russia. So they meet point 5 of the UN definition of genocide.

> And as for "rape children", it's yet another blatant demonization. The lies became so toxic, Zelensky even had to fire Denisova, the person responsible for distributing most of such claims without properly supporting them with evidence. Most of "Russian soldiers rape children" articles you read in the Western media were citing Denisova.

There are multiple counts of different atrocities that the Russians had committed if you want to discount the child rape go for it, but we plenty of evidence of Russia raping plenty of people in Ukraine.

> Oh wow... Are you incapable of critical thinking? Like at all? Russians can always physically cut wires in the territory they control.

Are you incapable of discussing something in a civil manner?. Please read the guidelines for hacker news https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

> If they wanted, they could've easily bombed every substation in Ukraine with its missiles. But because they do have some humanitarian considerations, they don't do it (unlike some other countries). As we can see, Russia has no techincal trouble bombing stationary objects as far as the westernmost Ukraine.

Yes the country that is levelling cities, kidnapping and forcibly deporting children, and raping women (and allegedly children) has 'humanitarian considerations'.

Russia regularly uses civilian deaths as a part of its war machine they are trying to do it to Ukraine like they did it too Chechnya in Grozny. It's why they force civilians to stay in the cities they capture.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by BurningPenguin on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:06AM (#32605372)
> there is an almost patriotic attitude towards coal plants

As a German, i'm wondering where you got that idea from... Because pretty much every poll i know of, is in support of turning off coal plants.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by jamil7 on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:45AM (#32605632)
I think both can be true and it might be more region specific. My girlfriend was born in the Ruhrgebiet and a lot of her family and friends family worked in the coal industry and were well taken care of when the plants were shut down. While they're not pro-coal or wouldn't poll that way I think there probably is more of a sentimental connection to it than to nuclear which that generation tends to associate with Chernobyl.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by hnbad on Saturday August 27, 2022 @12:57PM (#32620898)
That's not a contradiction though. Yes, there is broad popular support for renewables and until earlier this year gas probably also had a better reputation than it deserved, compared to coal.

But culturally, especially in the Ruhr region, coal has the benefit of nostalgia whereas nuclear has always been scary. Of course nowadays most "coal" is actually lignite and there is some resistance against lignite mining destroying large swathes of the landscape whereas the industrial architecture of "black coal" mining has become a national heritage. But lignite is still benefitting from some of that "black coal" nostalgia.

It's probably worth adding that these perceptions not only vary by region but also by socioeconomics and politics.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by martin_a on Friday August 26, 2022 @05:46AM (#32605206)
Stupid whataboutism.

Those signage displays are creating lots of light pollution and consume lots of energy. It's a good thing to shut those down, no matter how much energy we have/create.