News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:44AM (#32605618)
> While this is true, they have always been in favour of shutting down nuclear power plants and now they would have the opportunity to reverse this course, but they don't.

Because nuclear does not make sense. The financial risk of accidents at a Fukushima or Chernobyl scale is too high (as no insurer will take on that risk, the taxpayers will have to pay for it, and as the Ukraine invasion and the fighting around Chernobyl shows, disaster plants are a danger for decades!), a lot of the uranium comes from questionable sources (Russia and Khazakhstan [1]), and Europe does not have permanent storage solutions for the nuclear waste [2].

Renewable energies already make up 41% of our electricity generation, it could be 100%.

> What's so catastrophic about France? Despite all the troubles they currently have, their CO2 emissions per kW are still a fraction of Germany's.

For the sake of not spamming around the same text, I consolidated the list of issues here in a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32605337

As for the CO2 emissions: yeah because the CO2 everyone else in Europe generates to compensate their nuclear issues is not counted in their CO2 budget but ours.

[1] https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/nuclear/where-our-uraniu...

[2] https://www.br.de/nachrichten/wissen/atommuell-die-suche-nac...

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:58AM (#32606197)
> Because nuclear does not make sense.

Assuming your three points would be solved, would you be in favour of nuclear power plants? Or what exactly would need to change?

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:02AM (#32606235)
I would of course not be in favor of nuclear power. A new nuclear plant takes well over a decade to build - it makes way more economical sense to build renewable power plants because they can be ready far faster and pose less danger and waste to our children.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:15AM (#32606359)
> I would of course not be in favor of nuclear power.

Ok, let's say I could convince you that it is possible to store nuclear waste safely, and show you that building up wind power takes at least as long. Could I convince you then?

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:37AM (#32606604)
No, because of the financial risks involved in constructing, operating and getting rid of them. The costs associated with Fukushima are estimated to be at least 200 billion dollars [1], Chernobyl 235 billion dollars [2].

Even leaving out disaster scenarios: A modern EPR nuclear power plant is at ~1.6 GW [3] at a cost of 11 billion euros, taking a decade or more to build, and about a billion dollars to tear down [4]. A wind park half the size costs two billion dollars in two to five years [5], has less risks in construction, no risk at all of a catastrophic failure, and assuming 80€/kWh in teardown costs [6] 16 million € for the teardown.

That means wind power at a capacity factor of 0.4-0.5 [7] (meaning, you need two of them to achieve the same available capacity to the grid on average) is half as expensive as a nuclear power plant even when ignoring the efficiencies that building at scale brings with it and has virtually no risks attached. Financially, it's absolute irresponsibility to go nuclear.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK253929/

[2] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/article/chernobyl...

[3] https://taz.de/Finnischer-Reaktor-geht-ans-Netz/!5829751/

[4] https://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/energie/energiewend...

[5] https://renewablesnow.com/news/construction-starts-on-800-mw...

[6] https://www.bmwk.de/Redaktion/DE/Parlamentarische-Anfragen/2...

[7] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volllaststunde

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:48AM (#32606722)
You can't compare the price of a wind park with the price of a nuclear power plant, because the wind park does not offer base load. A wind park without base load is pretty useless. Base load is far more valuable. So if you say a power plant costs 12 billions, it is a steal compared to a two billion wind park. Most people will rather have electricity 24/7 than occasional electricity for 1/6th the price.

Beside that, in another comment you had a long list of things you say is required to make EE feasible. You need to include the price of all these things in your calculation.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by mschuster91 on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:55AM (#32606802)
> You can't compare the price of a wind park with the price of a nuclear power plant, because the wind park does not offer base load.

Agreed that base load is valuable... but why not go and reduce the amount of base load by both directly saving on load (e.g. by insulating houses or getting rid of advertising) and by making the base load that absolutely remains more flexible (e.g. by upgrading to a truly smart grid that can dynamically regulate consumption of loads)?

And for what it's worth, you can additionally also go and build even more wind energy. In times of ample wind, the now infinitely cheap electricity can be used in electrolysis to generate hydrogen as a base chemical for the industry and fuel for those very few applications that definitely need a combustion process (e.g. glass and metal foundries).

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tehbeard on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:22AM (#32607149)
The only people who are more "trust us, it's just around the corner" than fusion folks are the renewables only folks and their hair brained schemes to avoid the base load question.

Complicating the grid with smarts, given how well that's gone with IoT?

We've thrown a low carbon option under the bus because of sloppy Soviet engineering.

The coal and gas we are stuck with due to "greens" no nuclear stance has caused more harm to humanity than our sum total nuclear incidents, even counting non power incidents such as orphaned radiotherapy sources or ignoring procedures at irradiation facilities.

Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by tjansen on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:15AM (#32607061)
All these things are not enough. In 2015, there was an hour when wind power only generated 0.2GW. Hydro and biomass will probably never exceed 10GW combined. Even if you radically reduce the electricity needs down to, let's say, 35GW, you would still have a gap of 25GW. You can't build enough wind power to get this on a day without wind. You need another power source.
Re:German digital signage ban prompts confusion by dontlaugh on Friday August 26, 2022 @10:39AM (#32608123)
I was with you until here.

The waste was never the main problem and contemporary nuclear power plant designs don't share many of the other downsides either.