Similar with PoW. For both PoW and PoS, the proper response is to socially coordinate forking out the censoring block producer majority (like with the Bitcoin UASF that was threatened over much less egregious miner misbehavior). PoS improves on PoW here in two ways:
1. Non-censoring PoS block producers can have a tiny meatspace presence compared to PoW mining operations, which makes it easier to physically evade pro-censorship forces
2. It's more effective to coordinate a direct confiscation of the censoring PoS block producers' on-chain capital investment, compared to making miners' equipment partially obsolete by coordinating an ad-hoc redesign of the PoW algorithm
https://nitter.net/dystopiabreaker/status/156071598642414796...
It's only when the majority is colluding to reorg the chain that the transaction can be censored.
I'm assuming (like in the last tweets of the linked thread) that pro-censorship forces who can arrange for the supermajority in PoS to censor transactions can also arrange for the majority in PoW to not build on any uncensored head of the chain, i.e. they can mandate "always reorg."
Or how wearing a UASF baseball cap worked as part of a social coordination movement against power-tripping miners.
> It should only be a bootstrapping mechanism towards trustless behaviors, not the mechanism to cancel each other on-chain.
Yes
Censorship of transactions because of OFAC is already happening in PoW mining.
https://twitter.com/takenstheorem/status/1560690035955011585...
In PoS majority of validators has to actively approve a block containing "illegal" transactions, leading to permanent censorship.
The exact interpretation of validation vs mining responsibility in face of law and passive vs active is fuzzy , but it leaves miners is better legal position.
I do agree this is probably the most concerning thing that Tornado Cash sanctions have shown us. Still don’t think the energy cost of PoW is worth it, and would rather see PBS and crList solve this problem.
PoS is tyranny of the majority: You cannot take your business elsewhere.
In POW there are only block producers, and producing a block requires actively choosing transactions and transaction ordering.
Ethereum POS includes an additional attestation step where validators confirm that they have seen blocks without exercising any control over the contents of those blocks.
But this is exactly what PoW miners do when they extend the chain: every block is a vote for all previous blocks in the chain.
It's an extremely nuanced topic, and it was extensively discussed in the last core-developer call on Thursday. Every single operator has been warned that going against the fork-choice rules could, and ultimately will, result in social mitigations against spec-deviating behavior.
This could be set of socially executed slashings of validators that don't respect the fork-choice rules, or an honest-minority executed hard-fork that effectively causes misbehaving validators to bleed until they start respecting the protocol's rules.
I could be wrong on multiple counts, especially regarding re-orgs, but this is how I've understood the issue.
For example, if a US-based CEX that operates in New York has a slashing event, that brings regulatory consequences from NYDFS, regardless of the reason for the slashing.
What you call a "self-hosted bitcoin wallet" is just knowing some combination of bits that happens to be the private key that gives you the ability to sign transactions for some Bitcoin. How do you make it illegal to know something? What if I tell you my private key, does that mean you are then suddenly violating payments laws? What if you stumble upon it by accident?
Technically any string of 32 bytes is a valid private key that can hold Bitcoin. There just might not be any Bitcoin in the address associated with it at this time. What if I "know" a random string of 32 bytes, am I then suddenly in violation of laws when someone randomly deposits Bitcoin to the corresponding address?
The legal difficulty is that the action of having or holding Bitcoin (or mostly any cryptocurrency) is something that has no physical representation and is purely information based.
Mining or making transactions is a different story altogether. These require, amongst other things, that you send specific digital information across the internet which is certainly something that can be made illegal.
Yannis Varoufakis, London, circa 2017
Either crypto follows the law or it gets banned. IMO this was inevitable.
I personally believe in apolitical decentralized money winning against fiat which is governed on the whims of central bankers and crony capitalism. Every system where technology brings fairness, power to all, and hard rules wins. This will not be an exception. It is the separation of money and state, not very dissimilar from church and state, monarchy and nationhood etc.
This is true and always and trumps whatever your software says is meaningless if there is any conflict ("you and what army" is a very valid question.
Now, the law (a court) can of course allow your software and might even enforce a contract bases on your software
In good systems the governed people have a say in how those laws are created. In Bad ones it's literally whatever one person mutters with a mouth full of breakfast cereals and headaches.
The endings of proper monarchies weren't always simple and nice events - if that is the magnitude of change you have in mind.
Non Fiat money has been the norm pre unpegged Fiat. It's been around for 2-3k years at least, whereas unpegged Fiat is 50 years old. I'm surprised we find the fall of Fiat as hard to imagine:)
I know from the US perspective often legal tender concepts are brought into the definition of fiat but the legal tender concept doesn't quite exist in the same way in a lot of other countries.
1) impossible to confiscate
2) fixed supply and issuance rate - can't just print it away when the fed wants
3) instant permissionless transfer so the government can't interject. If you think they can be trusted, might want to read about executive order 6102
4) not backed by another asset eg gold (say). This is great because gold is extremely hard to transfer physically and easy to confiscate. Read about how Nixon refused to allow dollar convertibility for gold for foreign nations which was the condition for Bretton woods agreement ie where all nations agreed to use dollar as a global reserve freely exchangeable for gold. Also read about how FDR outlawed private ownership of gold when the US had printed more money than their gold reserves and needed to fix their books.
Decentralized community decree is awesome. You don't have a central actor making rules that support themselves. Christine Lagarde has no way to get the euro out of the deficit hole. See this snippet from an interview: https://youtu.be/p-X-mIuDYFw. In a balanced system, the debt would be loaned from and owed to a market participant who cares about their money being returned, not this bizarre broken system where central banks print and then owe to themselves
The people's interest imo is in fairness to all not asset owners who aren't as affected by money printing etc
The law isn't sacrosanct, but of course it needs to be followed. It is malleable and comes from lawmakers who may or may not represent the interest of the people, unwittingly or otherwise
From the perspective of world history, this is a BFD. The monetary system of the past 80 years has been controlled by the ruling class of a ~150-300M person nation. The crypto economy imposes uniform rules on ~3B people, which is an order of magnitude greater complexity, and should see further specialization and gains from trade for those that participate in it.
It's estimated that ~50% of staked value is held by US companies. These companies are going to have to make an impossible choice. Either:
1. Sign transactions coming from the sanctioned addresses, inviting the wrath of OFAC.
or:
2. Refuse to sign these transactions.
2a. If between 33% and 66% of the network refuses, the network will penalize dissenters by slashing their staked coins, until they no longer have a 33% stake. Billions of dollars of customer funds could be lost.
2b. If > 67% of the network refuses, transactions can be successfully censored. Now we no longer have decentralized ETH, we have "USA coin", where the government can censor anyone with a quick email to Brian Armstrong.
I don't see a way out. It doesn't look like the network is actually decentralized enough to handle a nation-state attack. This was not an issue with the old proof of work scheme. I'll be amazed if the merge is not delayed while they work on a solution to this.
EDIT: If Coinbase does lose that money, you could say the network is operating as designed in the presence of a hostile validator. But a LOT of people are not going to be happy with the result.