News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by cardy31 on Saturday August 20, 2022 @11:03AM (#32532532)
The point about society-level threats paying better than Silicon Valley is a good one. I often look around in the tech industry as a programmer and wish I could be paid well to do something that actually matters, instead of just keeping kids addicted to social media.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by 7thaccount on Saturday August 20, 2022 @05:17PM (#32535204)
Nothing outside of like SV, finance, or being a doctor is probably going to get you $300k and above. However, you can do some important work and make above $100k in a fairly inexpensive area if you want.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by tene on Saturday August 20, 2022 @06:03PM (#32535547)
Having worked in SV for so long, it's hard to really imagine what this would actually look like.

What are some examples of important work with decent pay in an inexpensive area that a SV tech worker could be good at?

Re:The silence of risk management victory by 7thaccount on Saturday August 20, 2022 @10:32PM (#32536905)
If you work with electric utilities or various regulatory entities (the wholesale power industry is pretty large) you'd be making well north of $100k as an individual contributor (engineer, technical analyst, software engineer, operator, economist... etc) if you have about 8 or more years of experience. If you live in any of the southern states, a house is easily findable in the $180-$250k range. That's better than having to buy a $1.5M home on a $300k budget. You can expect to work around 40 hours per week with some occasional rough patches depending on the job.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by danuker on Saturday August 20, 2022 @07:48PM (#32536144)
> finance

Compound interest is the eigth wonder of the world.

Knowing what will be profitable in the future is analogous to knowing what problems will plague humanity.

And investing for future profit equates to mitigating them.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by iamthepieman on Saturday August 20, 2022 @07:23PM (#32536025)
Defense contracting is somewhere in between. Whether that's better than the three industries you mentioned is up to you.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by darkerside on Saturday August 20, 2022 @10:18PM (#32536843)
Lawyers and small business owners can go on that list
Re:The silence of risk management victory by 7thaccount on Saturday August 20, 2022 @10:40PM (#32536946)
Yeah. Should've added certain skilled trades like plumbers and electricians as well.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by colechristensen on Saturday August 20, 2022 @11:26AM (#32532711)
To be fair there are plenty of jobs in SV which aren’t tied to advertising or social media.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by dinvlad on Saturday August 20, 2022 @12:00PM (#32532988)
Highly-paid jobs? Would be good to hear some examples.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by PheonixPharts on Saturday August 20, 2022 @02:39PM (#32534229)
Sure! You can build infrastructure for companies that sell advertising or social media (which is... also advertising)

Alternatively you can work for one of the companies burning through VC money selling products/services at a loss who need to advertise those services so they can sell more and more quickly to create the illusion that one day they will be able to generate more than they spend! Don't worry too much about the loses the VCs will just make it up in their investments in advertising companies and companies selling infrastructure to advertising companies.

Huh, something sounds weird about that setup, well good thing money is cheap!

Re:The silence of risk management victory by jacquesm on Saturday August 20, 2022 @04:27PM (#32534935)
I think that's the opposite of what the GP was asking for.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by brazzy on Saturday August 20, 2022 @06:34PM (#32535741)
Yes, it was pretty obvious sarcasm.

Well, just goes to show that sarcasm is always bad for factual debates.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by buscoquadnary on Saturday August 20, 2022 @02:42PM (#32534256)
I make around $120ish working for a non-profit. I mean it's not SV money but no matter how much money I make I am eventually be lying on my death bed and the only thing I will have to comfort me will be the memories of good I left in this world, so I do it and am grateful I make a very comfortable living doing something positive.

I'll also say that the idea of "Make lots of money now and then I'll give back later and retire early and enjoy my life" is a very risky proposition, you never know what tomorrow might bring a car crash, cancer, who knows?

> And he spake a parable unto them, saying, The ground of a certain rich man brought forth plentifully: And he thought within himself, saying, What shall I do, because I have no room where to bestow my fruits? And he said, This will I do: I will pull down my barns, and build greater; and there will I bestow all my fruits and my goods. And I will say to my soul, Soul, thou hast much goods laid up for many years; take thine ease, eat, drink, and be merry. But God said unto him, Thou fool, this night thy soul shall be required of thee - Luke 12:15-20

Re:The silence of risk management victory by xxpor on Monday August 22, 2022 @11:51AM (#32553211)
>I make around $120ish working for a non-profit. I mean it's not SV money but no matter how much money I make I am eventually be lying on my death bed and the only thing I will have to comfort me will be the memories of good I left in this world, so I do it and am grateful I make a very comfortable living doing something positive.

Not saying this is your job of course, but there are PLENTY of non-profits in this world that are actively making the world worse off. Non-profit == good is just as bad as Profit == bad.

For an example, just look at the AIDS Healthcare Foundation in LA. Some of the worst people in the country.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by colechristensen on Saturday August 20, 2022 @07:19PM (#32536006)
Sure, my current gig is making software for banks. Previously I’ve worked on managing medical records.

There are people working on robotics, working on medicine, biology, rockets, software for people’s real problems, tools to enable other businesses, all sorts of things.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by dinvlad on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:29PM (#32574305)
High salaries though? :-)
[dead]
Re:The silence of risk management victory by dang on Saturday August 20, 2022 @07:53PM (#32536167)
You can't do this here, so we've banned you.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The silence of risk management victory by tene on Saturday August 20, 2022 @06:11PM (#32535602)
I desperately wish there was a country I could move to where civilization actually invested meaningfully in things that actually matter.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by cirgue on Saturday August 20, 2022 @08:48PM (#32536425)
Get involved in local government and get your friends to do the same. State and municipal governments do most of the actual investment in infrastructure, even if the money might in part be federal, and that’s where the decisions get made. Your vote and voice matter, and the players involved eat at the same restaurants you do, go to the same gyms, and live in the same parts of town, for the most part. If you show up to city council meetings you’ll get to know people.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by rr808 on Saturday August 20, 2022 @09:30PM (#32536623)
USA has lots of jobs that pay enough to live on that matter. You wont earn 300k as a teacher but you'll earn enough to live, and you'll earn more than if you "do a job that matters" in a poorer country.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by nextos on Saturday August 20, 2022 @07:55PM (#32536175)
Maybe the practical way to do this is to start non-profits, e.g. via YC, and ask for donations from SV.

Some urgent areas include assessing biological and climate tail risks.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by refurb on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:51AM (#32537744)
You mean “things that actually matter [to me]”?

Or are you suggesting there is only one set of things that universally matter to all humans?

Re:The silence of risk management victory by GrumpyNl on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:36PM (#32533769)
Why is it always about the payment, why not choose a job you love doing?
Re:The silence of risk management victory by GeneralMayhem on Saturday August 20, 2022 @03:23PM (#32534531)
It's about both, but the magnitudes matter. Would you do a job you love doing for free? Assuming the answer is no, then to paraphrase Churchill, we’ve established what kind of people we are; now we’re just haggling over the price.

Am I willing to take a 10% pay cut to work on things that are good for society instead of selling ads? Sure. 25%? Probably. But those aren't the magnitudes we're talking about. Total comp for a senior-to-staff level engineer at FAANG (or anyone competing with them) will be, let's say, 500k/year, plus best-in-the-world benefits. Total comp for government or charity work rarely cracks 100k, and even tech companies that are focused on good rather than profit, maybe 200.

And it's not like the FAANG jobs are bad - day-to-day, they're incredibly interesting. There's lots of fun stuff to build with smart people. The only problem is the background existential dread. It's also hard to argue that they're actively harming humanity in a lot of cases - maybe this line of reasoning works on potential Raytheon or Palantir employees, where the delta in morality is much greater, but convincing people to go from neutral-ish to good is harder than convincing them to go from bad to good.

So the question you're asking is, are you willing to take a 60-80% pay cut to possibly do a less interesting job, in exchange for moral fulfillment and knowing that you're helping humanity? You might think the answer is yes, but I think it's hard to fault people for whom it isn't.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by kortilla on Saturday August 20, 2022 @04:10PM (#32534828)
> maybe this line of reasoning works on potential Raytheon or Palantir employees

The people who work at Raytheon or Palantir think they are less harmful than the people who work for Google/Facebook. Nobody who has decided to work there thinks they are just drone striking children.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by twic on Saturday August 20, 2022 @05:55PM (#32535483)
Some people who work at Lockheed Martin wrote the software for the missiles being fired by Ukrainian HIMARSs. They might even be quite proud of that.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by thephyber on Saturday August 20, 2022 @08:03PM (#32536230)
I bet they conveniently don’t care that Russia can use those HIMARS which remain after territory is take from Ukraine.

Not enough people look at both sides of the ledger when it comes to the ethics and morals of their work.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by _kbh_ on Saturday August 20, 2022 @09:02PM (#32536500)
> I bet they conveniently don’t care that Russia can use those HIMARS which remain after territory is take from Ukraine.

Due to their long range HIMARS don’t have to be anywhere near the front line to be used. It’s pretty unlikely that any would be captured and even if it looked like they could be they could easily destroy them.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by Shugarl on Saturday August 20, 2022 @05:45PM (#32535408)
>. Raytheon or Palantir employees, where the delta in morality is much greater, but convincing people to go from neutral-ish to good is harder than convincing them to go from bad to good.

Did palantir do shady things ? I now that the CEO got in trouble for looking down on poor people ( or something along those lines ?), but is there more ?

Re:The silence of risk management victory by thephyber on Saturday August 20, 2022 @08:09PM (#32536254)
Does Palantir publicize what projects they work on for DoD, DoJ, IRS, ICE, Treasury/Secret Service, etc? Why do you think people in a democratic (yes, I know, Constitutional Republic) should not be able to know about what secret projects are being performed with their tacit approval, in their name, with their tax dollars?

It’s not exactly fair to criticize a company because of what they aren’t telling us, but that goes with the territory.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by chowells on Saturday August 20, 2022 @06:16PM (#32535634)
Now? The name of the company is Palantir. That's not an accident. They're telling you exactly what they do, what they always have done, and always will do. If you're comfortable selling surveillance technology to abusive governments, that's up to you. But this isn't some surprise new thing.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by DiggyJohnson on Saturday August 20, 2022 @05:45PM (#32535405)
As the sibling comment also said, I don’t think the the difference in ethics of working for Facebook/Google vs Palantir/Raytheon as obvious as you state. I would have to think pretty hard about this, but my knee jerk moral evaluation has them all about equal.

Not to criticize you directly, but just sharing this perspective.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by thephyber on Saturday August 20, 2022 @08:11PM (#32536265)
I think the fact that Facebook and Google are lumped in here as if they are in the same business is a fault in your comment’s logic and your sibling’s.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by vegetablepotpie on Saturday August 20, 2022 @02:24PM (#32534116)
In my case I work for a defense contractor and make decent money. I could work for another company doing more meaningful work. But I almost certainly would make less money. This would cause me to fall behind my peers pay scale wise. This is not terrible, as I live well within my means, but this impacts my future pay, and the money I can set aside for investing. If I take that step now, I’d be leaving a lot of personal wealth on the table.

But if I build up enough investment wealth to pay for my life in the future, I could take on more meaningful work in the future. If I leave for meaningful work now, I may be making money at that pay scale trajectory for the rest of my career, similar to how people who graduated in 2008 have never caught up to their peers wealth wise.

I think it comes down to control about your financial options. Relinquishing income puts you at a disadvantage.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by throwawaysleep on Saturday August 20, 2022 @02:44PM (#32534262)
The honest answer nobody will give.

They like the idea of doing something good, but not enough to sacrifice much for it.

I am the same way. I work on boring as heck ad tech and security stuff.

I could do much more interesting work, but I would make less. Interesting and beneficial to the world is even less.

I won’t even sacrifice pay for interesting.

This is the same with climate change. Emergency? Many will say so. Enough of an emergency not to fly to Thailand this winter or not buy a monster house? Nope.

I am the same way. I consider climate change a problem. But I’m also likely going to eat beef every day for the rest of my life in a meal or two.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by OrvalWintermute on Saturday August 20, 2022 @04:32PM (#32534966)
>This is the same with climate change. Emergency? Many will say so. Enough of an emergency not to fly to Thailand this winter or not buy a monster house? Nope.

I think many of us common folks have fairly low energy demands.

But, the same set that goes to Davos, and is preaching to us about cutting our consumption, is the same that has the private jet, 3 mansions and a football field sized yacht.

I'm so over the entitled elite telling us what to do.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by nine_k on Saturday August 20, 2022 @05:50PM (#32535443)
My honest and obvious answer: because my family (wife, kids) need the money.

It's always a balancing act though. I won't go to do a job I loathe, because I won't stick there for long enough. I choose jobs that I'm fine doing, and pass many jobs that I might love doing but which won't pay the bills.

I was fortunate enough to have a job I outright loved, and which also paid well; it lasted 3.5 years. I'm immensely happy to have had such luck.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by bagels on Saturday August 20, 2022 @02:42PM (#32534252)
I want to retire comfortably. I'm probably going to be alive for a long time after I'm no longer employable. Money can make this possible.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by rexpop on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:58PM (#32533924)
The Sheriff will evict me at gunpoint if I don't pay the exorbitant rents in regions with an active job market.
[dead]
Re:The silence of risk management victory by rexpop on Saturday August 20, 2022 @03:58PM (#32534756)
> Did you think many people would not roll their eyes

On the contrary, it's your cavalier viewpoint which is in the global minority.

I'll engage with your dismissive, bad faith argument for the sake of earnestly inquisitive bystanders: no, we are not "forced to work" but we are compelled to do so under an economic systems which, at its leaf nodes, enforces noncompliance with violence. Try thinking through a few nth-order consequences of chronic unemployment.

As for the "particular job" aspect, no it's not that one (1) "particular job" is the requisite, but to attain particular living standards, one can't realistically look outside categories of jobs that share particular aspects. So think of it not as "a particular job," but rather a particular category of jobs which pay enough, in the right regions, for the right qualifications.

So, really, I am referring to a limited category and a structural eventuality, while you are referring to "a particular job at gunpoint." I think your extrapolations have imported greater histrionics than my original post.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by Brian_K_White on Saturday August 20, 2022 @04:08PM (#32534813)
I don't see a single invalidation of my ridicule.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by Sinidir on Saturday August 20, 2022 @05:16PM (#32535198)
Then you're blind.
[dead]
Re:The silence of risk management victory by pbourke on Saturday August 20, 2022 @10:09PM (#32536799)
I see someone taking a rhetorical device literally. The point the person that you responded to was making, obviously, is that the cost of living - and in particular of housing - is high and rising in many areas with strong tech job markets.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by Brian_K_White on Sunday August 21, 2022 @12:23AM (#32537403)
I described the gunpoint as imagery right in the first comment. "such image". Imagery is not literal, it's image.

A ridiculous image that is not justified, because as you point out yourself by using the words rhetorical and literal, sherrifs and guns play no part in their reaaon for choosing to work in a particular field or location.

It's just a stupid attempt to make their choice into some kind of palpable emergency they are helpless to affect.

It's ridiculous and deserves ridicule.

But what's curious is why anyone would try so hard to defend it?

Re:The silence of risk management victory by rexpop on Sunday August 21, 2022 @08:34AM (#32539520)
If you're actually curious, you won't insult the only person who can satiate your curiosity.

But, you're not "curious" in good faith. You're a verbally abusive ideologue.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by Brian_K_White on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:06PM (#32542142)
I said it's curious not I'm curious. I observed something. I didn't request something.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by rexpop on Sunday August 21, 2022 @08:33AM (#32539517)
Do you think Sheriffs carry rhetorical guns, or do you not realize that they enforce evictions?
Re:The silence of risk management victory by Brian_K_White on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:02PM (#32542096)
I think the set of possible things is not limited to these two things you have arbitrarily presented for some reason.

For instance, one of the infite things which are neither of those things, is that there are no evictions or sherrifs or guns that play any part in a software developer's housing arrangements, because they simply moved long before it gets to that point.

There are people who get themselves into that position, but they are surely not the kind of smart lawyer coders who make valid arguments on HN right?

If you're here, trying to argue something at all, then one presumes you think you're generally on top of things and not an idiot, right? Well, then does a smart rational person just sit there in a place they can't afford for the weeks or months it takes before serriffs come, and do so at gunpoint? You do realize they don't just start with that right? That there are many letters and notices, and mere pieces of paper over the course of several weeks to months before LE comes, and even when they do they don't actually point guns at you unless you barricade yourself in and resist or something.

You can't invoke a STUPID hyperbolic image like that and at the same time lay any claim to have any sort of valid point to argue, considering this whole thread is about taking high paid developer jobs which they don't give out to idiots. But they do give them out to people who seem to think everyone else are idiots that don't know self serving hyperbole when they see it, and are such huge fragile babies they can not under any circumstances tolerate having this pointed out.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by Victerius on Saturday August 20, 2022 @12:02PM (#32533006)
Why don't terrorist groups hire the best chemical engineers to engineer chemical weapons? Or the best bioscientists to engineer the deadliest plagues? Or the best hackers to engineer the best computer viruses?

Or not even the best, just average/competent enough scientists and engineers?

Phrased a little differently, would you accept being paid a life-changing amount of money in exchange for anonymously engineering a deadly threat to some people far from home and knowing you could get away with it? Would you let your morals stop you?

Re:The silence of risk management victory by __MatrixMan__ on Saturday August 20, 2022 @12:57PM (#32533479)
Given that there are many people who work for defense contractors, and for middling pay, I think we can safely say that plenty of people would not let their morals stop them.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by filoleg on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:08PM (#32533574)
I don't think the comparison here is valid even in the slightest, and I am not even talking about it from the "terrorist groups and defense contractors are not morally equal" angle at all.

I simply think that the venn diagram of people willing to do software dev work for a defense contractor like Boeing or Raytheon and people willing to do software dev work for the cartels/terrorist groups is not even close to approaching a full circle.

Sure, most people willing to do software dev work for the cartels/terrorist groups are probably totally morally ok with doing work for a defense contractor. But I am willing to bet that most people willing to work for a defense contractor will not feel morally alright working for the cartels/terrorist groups even in the slightest.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by lupire on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:40PM (#32533796)
The "terrorist" thinks they are defense contractor and that Raytheon is the terrorist. It's fully symmetric.

The difference is that many or most won't cross borders to work for the opposing team.

ISIS has many engineers.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by kortilla on Saturday August 20, 2022 @04:17PM (#32534871)
Maybe for some of the terrorist groups, but it’s certainly not the case for people working for the cartels.

There is no “both sides” argument to working for a group that just wants to get filthy rich using brutal violence, bribery, and disregard for the downsides of hard drug addiction. The cartels don’t have a recruiting story of bringing justice to the oppressed, etc. It’s just opportunity for money and power for people with limited opportunities otherwise.

Totally orthogonal to recruiting for “mission focused” orgs like terrorist groups.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by thephyber on Saturday August 20, 2022 @08:22PM (#32536301)
> The cartels don’t have a recruiting story of bringing justice to the oppressed,

Two points.

You pivoted from terrorists to cartels. You clearly don’t realize that cartels actually get their info and their purpose from protecting (or at least doing enough visible work to appear to be protecting) the average person in their territory. Sure, not all cartels work this way, but even if not initially, they eventually buy their info this way.

And, yes, terrorist groups absolutely do try to claim they are fighting for justice. They are just targeting a different demographic than you have in your mind. The children of parents killed by US defense contractor weapons. The religious zealots convinced of whatever religious transgression. The clash of values. There are plenty of political platforms, and they all can be recruiting stories.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by kortilla on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:55PM (#32557100)
> You pivoted from terrorists to cartel

No I didn’t. Read the thread. It lumped both together.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by JackFr on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:11PM (#32533596)
Can we somehow find a middle ground between saying “Thank you for your service” every time we see a uniform and writing off the entire military and defense industry as immoral?
Re:The silence of risk management victory by Spooky23 on Saturday August 20, 2022 @03:04PM (#32534393)
It’s a projection of guilt, immaturity or ignorance.

Everything is awful, except for what pays your mortgage. The world is about shades of grey, not black and white.

That applies to all peddlers of moral indignation. The most strident patriots are usually pasty old men who bear no cost for their actions.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by pessimizer on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:34PM (#32533752)
Maybe for a hypothetical military or defense industry, but not for the ones that we have, who will tear through five children to get to one "terrorist."

edit: this is even a problem for people who write FOSS (unfortunately leading to some of them putting moral clauses in licenses), never mind those taking a check from some of the worst people in the world.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by lupire on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:48PM (#32533845)
"Thank you for your service" seems like a good middle ground. The people in service aren't the ones making the strategic decisions of who to attack.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by marcinzm on Saturday August 20, 2022 @05:43PM (#32535393)
Even if you were fine with it in theory there is a massive risk to it in practice.

In essence you're giving up most legal protections (since you've got as much to lose as anyone else if the police catch you) while working with people who likely have no moral issues with killing you. Will they pay you or will they kidnap your family and cut off someone's toe every time you complain?

Re:The silence of risk management victory by JackFr on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:08PM (#32533572)
Non-state actors typically don’t have life changing amounts of money.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by markvdb on Saturday August 20, 2022 @02:07PM (#32533996)
Some do, but even if they wouldn't, there's still state terrorism.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by sinenomine on Saturday August 20, 2022 @12:33PM (#32533262)
Just an idea: you could always prep for an algo interview and jump ship from developing infra for google.com to developing infra for the next generations of cures in https://www.isomorphiclabs.com/
Re:The silence of risk management victory by dinvlad on Saturday August 20, 2022 @02:20PM (#32534083)
Out of curiosity, which TC ranges do you normally offer?
Re:The silence of risk management victory by bagels on Saturday August 20, 2022 @02:40PM (#32534238)
Spoiler, they aren't likely to offer 500k in liquid comp.