News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by __MatrixMan__ on Saturday August 20, 2022 @12:57PM (#32533479)
Given that there are many people who work for defense contractors, and for middling pay, I think we can safely say that plenty of people would not let their morals stop them.
Re:The silence of risk management victory by filoleg on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:08PM (#32533574)
I don't think the comparison here is valid even in the slightest, and I am not even talking about it from the "terrorist groups and defense contractors are not morally equal" angle at all.

I simply think that the venn diagram of people willing to do software dev work for a defense contractor like Boeing or Raytheon and people willing to do software dev work for the cartels/terrorist groups is not even close to approaching a full circle.

Sure, most people willing to do software dev work for the cartels/terrorist groups are probably totally morally ok with doing work for a defense contractor. But I am willing to bet that most people willing to work for a defense contractor will not feel morally alright working for the cartels/terrorist groups even in the slightest.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by lupire on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:40PM (#32533796)
The "terrorist" thinks they are defense contractor and that Raytheon is the terrorist. It's fully symmetric.

The difference is that many or most won't cross borders to work for the opposing team.

ISIS has many engineers.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by kortilla on Saturday August 20, 2022 @04:17PM (#32534871)
Maybe for some of the terrorist groups, but it’s certainly not the case for people working for the cartels.

There is no “both sides” argument to working for a group that just wants to get filthy rich using brutal violence, bribery, and disregard for the downsides of hard drug addiction. The cartels don’t have a recruiting story of bringing justice to the oppressed, etc. It’s just opportunity for money and power for people with limited opportunities otherwise.

Totally orthogonal to recruiting for “mission focused” orgs like terrorist groups.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by thephyber on Saturday August 20, 2022 @08:22PM (#32536301)
> The cartels don’t have a recruiting story of bringing justice to the oppressed,

Two points.

You pivoted from terrorists to cartels. You clearly don’t realize that cartels actually get their info and their purpose from protecting (or at least doing enough visible work to appear to be protecting) the average person in their territory. Sure, not all cartels work this way, but even if not initially, they eventually buy their info this way.

And, yes, terrorist groups absolutely do try to claim they are fighting for justice. They are just targeting a different demographic than you have in your mind. The children of parents killed by US defense contractor weapons. The religious zealots convinced of whatever religious transgression. The clash of values. There are plenty of political platforms, and they all can be recruiting stories.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by kortilla on Monday August 22, 2022 @04:55PM (#32557100)
> You pivoted from terrorists to cartel

No I didn’t. Read the thread. It lumped both together.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by JackFr on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:11PM (#32533596)
Can we somehow find a middle ground between saying “Thank you for your service” every time we see a uniform and writing off the entire military and defense industry as immoral?
Re:The silence of risk management victory by Spooky23 on Saturday August 20, 2022 @03:04PM (#32534393)
It’s a projection of guilt, immaturity or ignorance.

Everything is awful, except for what pays your mortgage. The world is about shades of grey, not black and white.

That applies to all peddlers of moral indignation. The most strident patriots are usually pasty old men who bear no cost for their actions.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by pessimizer on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:34PM (#32533752)
Maybe for a hypothetical military or defense industry, but not for the ones that we have, who will tear through five children to get to one "terrorist."

edit: this is even a problem for people who write FOSS (unfortunately leading to some of them putting moral clauses in licenses), never mind those taking a check from some of the worst people in the world.

Re:The silence of risk management victory by lupire on Saturday August 20, 2022 @01:48PM (#32533845)
"Thank you for your service" seems like a good middle ground. The people in service aren't the ones making the strategic decisions of who to attack.