reality 1: The www exists. Google indexes it, analyzes it and delivers it to users. Users like certain things, like original content.
reality 2: Google's ranking policies/algorithms influence the web. The "original content" that exists in a world without Google is different to the content that exists in a world where Google ranks such web pages more highly.
Google refuse to see or present themselves in the role that they actually occupy. They avoid thinking of the search algorithm as encouraging or discouraging anything. It's just analyzing.
On youtube, This mindset is even more loopy, because on youtube they actually own the platform. The recommendation engine or whatnot implements what is clearly a new policy, Youtube pretends that there was no policy to change in the first place.
Can you clarify what you mean by this?
As an outside observer, it seems that Google recognizes that their search engine does have a "Heisenberg" effect akin to "measurements of certain systems cannot be made without affecting the system"
E.g. the Google search ranking causes the rise of content farms. Google then fights back with a new revision to the algorithm to downrank them. That constant arms race between various blackhat SEO and Google's new algorithms was commented on many times by Matt Cutts (Google former head of search quality): https://hn.algolia.com/?q=matt+cutts
Another example is the RapGenius punishment by Google to discourage content that tries to game the algorithm: https://www.google.com/search?q=rapgenius+penalty+google+ran...
Google often makes manual human intervention e.g. M Cutts team telling HN they're looking into RapGenius SEO hack: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6956658
Are those are not examples of Google understanding its effect on internet content that tries to game their algorithm?
I think the issue is that Google's algorithm isn't perfect -- and therefore it appears like they don't discourage bad content.
In a sense, I am overstating. Having an anti-spam team is obviously a recognition that SEO/Spam exists and that Google is trying to discourage or mitigate.
But Google is well beyond just attracting spam. Success in Google search rankings is, for many sites, the better part of online success. If Google ranks needlessly wordy recipes more highly than concise & useful recipes... then wordy recipes get written. It's not about ranking recipes anymore... it's about the effects google has on recipes. The recipes get written in a wordy fashion, because of the ranking system... not just ranked because of the writing style. Google is dictating the nature of online recipes with their rankings.
A few years back, Google made changes to youtube's recommendation engine in a way that really "encourages" frequent, regular videos. Viral hits became much less common. The result has been to send many professional youtubers into a frantic grind. There's no point in taking time with a video, or trying weird ideas. It won't go viral anyway. A week off or a couple of flops is harshly punished. There are tens of thousands of these youtubers, basically small businesses.
There's never any reckoning with 2nd order effects. It's always communicated as it is here. I believe this is how Google execs actually think about the issues. As a quasi-spam problem to be mitigated with the next “helpful content update.”
Can you articulate what concrete actions Google could take that would address these 2nd order effects?
>, Google made changes to youtube's recommendation engine in a way that really "encourages" frequent, regular videos. [...] A week off or a couple of flops is harshly punished.
I've seen this repeated many times (especially from Youtubers making videos about "burnout") but the analysis about cause & effect seems incomplete. As one counterpoint, Ben Krasnow "Applied Science" channel slowed down from weekly uploads to a video every few months and yet his views and subscribers went up not down: https://www.youtube.com/c/AppliedScience/videos
Another yt channel that had a year between uploads and the views went up : https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCX7katl3DVmch4D7LSvqbVQ/vid...
My pet theory on the contradictory anecdotes: the Youtubers making videos on a topic with lots of competition from other Youtubers uploading every week -- such as fast fashion clothes shopping -- are the ones that seem to suffer if they slow down. E.g.: https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=zara+haul
However, if you're making videos in niche topics with originality (maybe "weird ideas" as you put it), you won't be penalized by infrequent uploads. Many examples including Technology Connections, Applied Science, etc
So a different conclusion can be reached... if one makes a high quality videos, one can even upload just once a year and the Youtube algorithm won't penalize you.
If one youtuber produced a 32-minute video per month and got 500,000 views while another produced eight 4-minute videos per month and averaged 200,000 views per video, who do you suppose gets the most ad money? I'd wager the latter.
Black box or not, google are creating these systems, analyzing, optimising and implementing them. It's indeed hard or impossible to trace back individual examples and their whys. But the macro effects are visible and choices are made.
It's just easier to "blame the computer," internally or externally. It's just like bank employees merge always blame "regulations." In fact, whatever they are blaming is a policy created to implement that bank's compliance framework which exists to satisfy the regulator's goals and the bank's goals." Most of the time, the underlying regulation is distantly removed from whatever piece of bureaucracy is annoying the customer or employee. But, if it can be blamed on the regulator, it will be.
It's just easier, if at all possible, to blame an immovable and mysterious force rather than the more likely culprit: humans doing a bad job.
Google is already scraping bits of website content and showing it to the user as a "featured snippet". Nobody is going to write short pages if Google can already rob you of a click so easily.
If it is a hidden algorithmically social function then of course it will be gamed.
But IRL there are certain people whose advice and recommendations you value and those whose you ignore. And in other cases you can easily ask the source of other information to find out if it is high value or not. MLM is the gamification of the IRL social structure and it's fairly easy to opt-out.
That's what search needs, a way to see the path information took to be presented to you and a way to filter it.
Unfortunately right now, so much of the best information is in Facebook groups, post and comments. The interface there is absolutely horrible though and not designed to provide you information, but to maximize the amount of ads that come across your screen.
The same is true for video information. It's not easily searchable or digestible. The web peaked when information was predominantly text form and not fragmented into walled gardens.
Appending site:news.ycombinator.com instead of Reddit?
Can you create a fake account with a verified credit card number, verified phone number, passport, drivers license, account history consistent with human usage, Google One subscription, etc.? You probably can, but doing it at-scale is going to be quite costly.
Quite cheaply
Enormous swathes of the platform are filled with gossip channels (politics, crypto, stonks, celebrities, music) hosted by clout chasers desperate to be seen as authorities on that topic.
Of course there can be good content inside of these categories, but you can generally tell which channels are "optimized for engagement", i.e. run like a business, and those are more amateurish and perhaps more authentic.
> Are you writing to a particular word count because you've heard or read that Google has a preferred word count? (No, we don't).
https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2022/08/helpful-co...
a) dont summarize other sites
b) dont write overly long articles just to make google happy
It's a shame a) is never helping with b)
Anyway, from what I've heard, that's the reason recipe sites have started posting 4 pages of drivel about the dish before getting to the actual recipe.
Or so I've heard, I don't really have any good sources for this, could just be hearsay
Or, Google Analytics. Or Google ads. Or, if you return to Google and try other links for the same query. Or if you return to Google and refine the query (e.g., a new search where the term is within a predefined threshold of word vector similarity)
There are plenty of ways to approximate time spend on link.
E.g. if a link to your page is shown to the user in search and they don't click or they return to search page too quickly, Google sees this as a signal that the result was not helpful.
The update literally says they are working to get rid of the type of useless content you are talking about.
Happiness meta-rule: Throw electronics away, use analog equivalents instead.
Google prolly cannot earn money simply by featuring high quality stuff like Wikipedia or nerd websites. Usually SEO farms spend money on Google to earn money. So that's why search really cannot improve in my opinion due to this conflict of interest.
In an ideal world, such an endeavor would be supported by governments all around the world (or a single "Earth government"), with yearly updates to keep up with the state of the art.
I've started just closing the tab. I don't give a shit that a certain country planted oranges and it gave them naval superiority, I want to know what types of oranges there are!
In fact it seems like Google worked better when wikipedia was almost always the first result on various topics
What I mean by rambling is if you type something like "types of oranges" and suddenly land on a page where some dude is clearly just filling up paragraphs for google like "so you want to learn about oranges? an orange is a great type of fruit. here's a bunch of text about oranges being described in historic literature"