I assume with FedNow (same as if I were to transact using debit cards), money leaves my bank account more or less immediately when a charge happens. That means if someone manages to fraudulently charge something, I am out that money (up to $25,000!) until the dispute process is resolved.
Also, do I really want the central bank to have a record of all my transactions? Not sure I do.
Since then, I've only used a debit card very sparingly and usually more as an ATM card in the event I need cash.
Second, this happened circa 2004-2005. In the US, at the time, all card use was magnetic strip swipes. Debit cards occasionally used a pin at terminals equipped to do so; but, it wasn't a requirement and most use didn't involve the pin. As an example: a grocery store terminal at the cash register might require your pin; but, if you paid the bill at a restaurant, it would get swiped like any Visa/MC.
At the time, in an online setting, asking for additional information like CVV or using address for AVS wasn't standardized so not all merchants required anything beyond a card number and expiration date.
In that era, nearly everyone I knew had experienced a debit card or credit card stolen and used in this manner--and those with debit cards paid the extra price of actually losing our money for a time.
The issue is that you can process most debit cards through the credit network without the PIN for convenience.
That said, PIN isn't terribly secure either; for a common 4-digit PIN, there are only 10,000 possibilities. Too many to test by hand, but trivial to automate if you have access to the algorithm. And for the first PIN cards, the data was on a trivially readable magnetic strip. So if you have the algorithm and the contents of that mag strip, it's trivial to just run through all possibilities. That algorithm was a closely guarded secret, but still, security by obscurity isn't great, so later they replaced the mag strip with a chip that doesn't spill its contents so easily.
So not all 2FA is a guarantee for good security.
Canada has had low-cost Interac debit cards for a long time, and although they've been very popular, merchants generally don't impose any credit card fees.
Also, even Canadian online businesses generally don't bother implementing payments with Interac online, so for online shopping it's not even an option.
Perhaps some of this will be better at US scale.
The fee rates are pretty dramatically different.
Every single app/store/site is gonna be begging you to enroll in fednow and will be offering 2-3% discounts/bonus points for any purchases made through it.
FedNow will get adoption as a replacement for ACH / Check writing. Paying bills and getting paid. Instant deposits of paychecks will a big benefit to a lot people living paycheck to paycheck. It will displace a bunch of Zelle market share.
I could see it being useful for interbank transfers and for bank to billing (e.g. credit cards, etc.)
Unless things have changed in the last 20ish years, if you accept credit cards you’re not allowed to charge different prices for CC vs non-CC payments (although there are apparently some carve-outs for gas stations).
Here are the Visa rules for it. https://usa.visa.com/support/small-business/regulations-fees...
Basically you can add a small surcharge amount, but nothing more than the actual cost of the transaction.
[1]: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/new-rules-el...
As a side note, many government services aren't allowed to eat the transaction cost, so they actually do pass the cost to the consumer (e.g. when I pay my annual car registration, an ACH (electronic check) payment is the same as paying cash in person, but a credit card has an additional fee tacked on.
They absolutely have.
Basically you get a similar cost.
Consumers already have a choice that has lower interchange fees to merchants (but also has way less chargeback protections) and that’s a debit card.
My guess is that they'll just raise their prices to include the fee no matter how the customer offers to pay for something.
Can they? I was under the impression (unverified) that they are under contract to provide the same prices for CC customers as they do for cash or debit card.
I believe there are a few states in the US left where merchants can still be required to charge the same, but in most places in the US that's not the case.
The no-surcharge terms are plainly anticompetive and should have been reigned in a long time ago. But customers get really mad about extra fees and think it's the merchant that is ripping them off and not Visa/Mastercard.
I think you can also advertise the credit card price and offer a cash discount.
Debit cards still have transaction fees, though lower ones I believe, so they usually get the same price as credit cards, but none of the benefits like points.
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohio_v._American_Express_Co%...
> FedNow is an instant payment service for both individuals and businesses. Once launched, the initial transaction limit will be $25,000. This means that FedNow be more useful for small businesses and retail payment needs until it is widely adopted and the transaction limit grows.
> In early 2022, the Federal Reserve released pricing and fee details for their real-time settlement network. Because FedNow is government-operated, it’s mandated to break even and not turn a profit. A possible advantage of this is that FedNow may offer more competitive pricing than other payment systems, which encourages widespread adoption at a faster rate.
Merchants can pass the CC surcharge through; I’d expect them to do so when a very low cost immediate settlement option is available. This will allow consumers to self select if they want the benefits of paying with a credit card (but paying for the privilege). Credit can be extended if needed by a financial institution, without using CC rails. Net 30? BNPL? Special financing arrangement? Pick your poison either prior to or after value transfer has occurred. The innovation is utility priced financial infrastructure, cutting out the rentseekers mentioned.
(my note: it’s about five cents per FedNow value transfer transaction)