News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by collegeburner on Monday August 15, 2022 @04:56PM (#32475259)
hot take of the day: NAT is (mostly) a shitty idea. we can give everything a WAN ipv6 and a private LAN address. devices should maintain their own firewalls and if defense in depth is required, the router should maintain a firewall that blocks incoming by default but still give everything its own address.
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by asimops on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:01PM (#32476015)
I agree that NATv6 is a bad idea, but imo we neeed firewalls on the router. Because on paper a endpoint firewall is a good idea, because you take that with you even when you change the network, but...

then there is the Windows firewall:

- Applications that punch their own holes, like steam

- Windows which grants itself inbound exceptions and reenables them if you disable them

- A non standard filtering order (deny is always defore allow, not in order)

And then there are all those born in the 80s people that were told on LAN parties to "just disable the Windows firewall" and kept doing so.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by bob1029 on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:21PM (#32476233)
> And then there are all those born in the 80s people that were told on LAN parties to "just disable the Windows firewall" and kept doing so.

You caught me. I think a firewall on the router is absolutely essential regardless of NAT scenarios.

With the understanding that you have an entire generation of computer users who equate that internet box with some degree of safety, you will find less friction with some tweak to that experience. You can still call it "port forwarding", block all inbound by default, and keep most of the same UX.

I personally like to operate my home network like a DMZ. Being able to reach any computer from any other without screwing around with networking is very convenient to me. I operate with an all-or-nothing trust model on my LAN. Having some centralized firewall helps a lot with this.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by em-bee on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @03:26AM (#32480140)
i would like to know why anyone would disagree with the parent comment.
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by johnklos on Monday August 15, 2022 @09:02PM (#32477949)
Firewalls are only necessary for OSes that open ports without good reasons and without good controls. In other words, your reaction is justified if you think Windows is normal and an example of how things should be.

The rest of the world, though, knows that you don't just randomly open ports without good reason and without ways to turn off services.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by clysm on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @09:40AM (#32482564)
> The rest of the world, though, knows that you don't just randomly open ports without good reason and without ways to turn off services.

Perhaps you should inform the IoT community.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by autoexec on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:47PM (#32475855)
> devices should maintain their own firewalls

This is insane. I don't want to have to learn, document, configure, and patch a different firewall on every internet connected device I own. That's a total nightmare. Computers can have their firewalls managed at the domain level. How is that support to work for bluray players, game consoles, light bulbs, phones, echo devices, door cams, thermostats, and kitchen appliances?

Nope. At a minimum everyone should have a stateful firewall at their edge making their devices impossible to reach/scan from the internet at large. Home routers that defaulted to using NAT made that dead simple.

On the rare occasion you really need something open to the entire internet it can sit in your DMZ. If I ever do make the move to using IPv6 on my network I'll likely continue to use NAT

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by collegeburner on Monday August 15, 2022 @08:06PM (#32477456)
do you have to "learn, document, configure, and patch" a firewall on ur home router? most ppl just plug it in bc it's configured to work.
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by autoexec on Monday August 15, 2022 @08:44PM (#32477783)
Yes? My configuration isn't complex enough at home to require my own documentation, but I absolutely had to read what the manufacturer provided, configure the firewall for my needs, and update the firmware. I don't think anyone should just throw a router in front of their network and think "This will just work!" - I mean, it might "work", but what is it leaving open? What is it logging? Who can access it?

Home routers have gotten pretty good about sane defaults these days, but at a minimum I'd be disabling UPnP and looking over what those defaults are before trusting it to protect my network.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by collegeburner on Monday August 15, 2022 @11:58PM (#32479046)
which is literally the same situation as if you had a device local firewall? sensible defaults and you learn to configure for stuff you want to change.
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by autoexec on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @12:07AM (#32479097)
Except that I have to check defaults and configure my home router once and I'm done (for a while at least). If every single device on my network had it's own firewall, each with their own settings, capabilities, and defaults, I'd have to configure and check the defaults for every device on my network.

You could argue that having one edge device running a checked and configured firewall means that you don't have to worry about the firewalls installed on every other device on the network, but anyone who has networking experience will know better. Problems are bound to come up on the internal network if nothing else and troubleshooting issues becomes a lot more complicated!

Also, if we're counting on every IoT product to come with its own embedded firewall you can be sure many of those are going to be so poorly thrown together that they introduce more security problems than they solve. This is a class of products that has earned a horrible reputation in terms of security.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by atemerev on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:19PM (#32475527)
Like I have said in another thread, if you misconfigure a firewall, the network usually works, but not secure. If you misconfigure a NAT, nothing works, and your error is clearly visible.

I don't see a way to fix this (and configuration errors are common).

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by unethical_ban on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:58PM (#32475993)
Fix it with user experience.

Routers should have dashboards that give easy status of firewall configuration ala Windows firewall: Green for no inbound rules (or whitelisted rules) and yellow/red for non-checked rules.

Routers could even have LEDs or status displays like some higher end Ubiquiti prosumer products have, showing firewall status.

Routers could have a user-accessible API and Windows client that shows status on a taskbar item.

The technical solutions are there, but I don't have faith ASUS and co will build a competent product.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by atemerev on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:08PM (#32476098)
The technical solutions will not work, as there are many, many possibilities to make a mistake. Misleading router UI, copying the configuration from somewhere else and forgetting to update it, moving a computer to another network, just forgetting to enable a firewall (in many cases it is impossible to set up a IPv4 network without a NAT precisely because IPv4 addresses are rare — but it is perfectly possible to do it with IPv6, and it will be insecure by default).

Secure systems are robust against user mistakes (and even middlemen mistakes). A NAT is one such system. Alternatives do not work like that.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by throw0101a on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:32PM (#32476353)
> The technical solutions are there, but I don't have faith ASUS and co will build a competent product.

The last time I was looking for a home router I specifically went for Asus because their default firmware is pretty good, and third-party options are available:

* https://www.asuswrt-merlin.net/features

Currently running an RT-AC68U.

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by ipdashc on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:09PM (#32475406)
While I mostly agree, there's definitely the issue of readdressing if your ISP changes your IPv6 prefix. In NATted IPv4, you can maintain your own eternally consistent internal address scheme, regardless of what's going on "outside". But in IPv6, if your dynamic IP changes, all your devices get new addresses. I can definitely see the value in creating a stable internal address layout on IPv6, as this article says.

Of course, I have no idea how often an ISP actually changes your IPv6 prefix. In an ideal world, it'd never change...

Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by unethical_ban on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:56PM (#32475966)
The article's main topic is on NPTv6, which would supercede NAT as the tool for maintaining internal addressing.
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by ipdashc on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:29PM (#32476315)
Yeah, that's what I'm saying :) I thought the parent comment was saying that NAT was bad and NPTv6 was bad, but maybe I was mistaken.
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by staringback on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:14PM (#32475464)
ULAs at least solve this problem for all networking that doesn't have to be internet facing
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by anamax on Monday August 15, 2022 @05:20PM (#32475534)
People change ISPs....
Re:NAT still exists for IPv6 by ipdashc on Monday August 15, 2022 @06:30PM (#32476331)
For sure, but that's a predictable event that you can plan for and get ready to renumber your network / handle the renumbering.

A dynamic IP change can just happen without much warning, and enjoy possibly spending an hour befuddled before you realize what happened.