This depends on jurisdiction. In the U.S., there are tight controls around custody. (In terms of mixing, shares are fungible. If you want to certificate your holdings you can, but it's stupid.)
There are more people making sure BlackRock has the coins than e.g. Coinbase or Kraken.
> they "have" the shares they owe you. But in reality, they don't. As they lent them out.
Lent securities can be recalled by the lender "whenever they want, for whatever reason they want, and they do not have to provide an explanation" [1]. Shares BlackRock owns in street name [2] are owned and controlled by stricter definitions than that which connects a landlord to their real estate.
[1] https://www.bnymellon.com/us/en/insights/aerial-view-magazin...
Lent securities can be recalled by the lender "whenever they want,
for whatever reason they want, and they do not have to provide
an explanation"
Unfortunately, the borrower does not lend the shares to keep them in their drawer. They sell them. If they cannot buy them back, the lender cannot get them back.In the history of post-Securities Act American stock lending, I don't think this has once happened for a public stock. The lender's broker is entitled to buy the stock in the open market at any price (e.g. [1]) and stick the bill to the borrower's broker. The borrower's broker will chase the borrower. But the broker is immediately responsible.
For every share in oversupply there is someone naturally short. Between them and the market are layers of collateral and covenant, from the broker to the borrower to their clearing broker, from the clearinghouse to the banks mutualizing it.
[1] https://www.contractscounsel.com/t/us/securities-loan-agreem... § 13.1(a)
Not sure about that, but we were about a day away from that happening in 2008. AIG lent out high-grade bonds and invested the proceeds into illiquid higher-yield mortgage backed securities:
https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/what-went-w...
AIG's near collapse was partly due to CDS and party due to sec lending.
Could be. I don't know. But I wouldn't expect that there is no risk that a certain thing will happen just because it has not happened for 100 years.
No. This has happened. What hasn't is the lender of the stock not getting their securities back. Those stacked layers of covenant and collateral absorbed the damage.
> I wouldn't expect that there is no risk that a certain thing will happen just because it has not happened for 100 years
The risk isn't zero. But someone worrying about their lent Tesla stock never coming home is in the same category as a freestyle mountain climber becoming paranoid about meteors hitting them.
The risk of stock lending is very low.
Anything you do with a securities broker, the risk of losing something due to the other side of the trade going bankrupt, etc is very very low.
Your broker has to have collateral to support closing your position, likewise for the other side of the transaction. A broker ends up holding the bag if something goes wrong and it’s their fault for allowing a customer to open a position they couldn’t close.
Pardon, what?
Some brokers will lend out your stock holdings (usually it's in T&C or you have the option to opt-in to lending for a cut of the interest) to short sellers
These short sellers sell the borrowed stock and hope its price drops and they can buy it back for cheaper.
As shares are fungible, the borrowed share the short-seller has sold gets bought by someone, so two people "own" the same share. In reality, two people are owed a share by the broker, the broker owns a share, and the broker is owed a share by the short-seller, so everything adds up
The short-seller will have posted collateral and if the price of the stock rises too much the broker will force them to sell the collateral to repay their borrowed stock.
>So now both, you and the other shareholder think they own the same share in Tesla.
If I have an account with a stock-loan feature, and my broker lends a short-seller my share then I no longer own the share. We can tell that because, for example, I no longer have the voting rights associated to the share, and, if a dividend were declared (forget we're talking about TSLA obviously) then I wouldn't receive it from the issuer; but from my broker (who gets it from the short-seller).
The short-seller then sells the share to someone else. They own that share then as the holder of record.
Isn't it all an abstraction by your broker anyhow? They just show you pixels on your screen, that you have "received" dividends. But its not like Tesla sent them to you. Its just an illusion your broker creates on your screen.
The difference between receiving a dividend paid to the beneficial owner of stock and receiving a payment-in-lieu of a dividend is very much not illusory - there can be significant tax implications.
Depends on contract with stockbroker. For example stockbroker i use cannot lend my shares unless i allow it in an amendment to contract, such amendment is required for things like margin trading, but not for basic investing.
> If you combine all the gold people think they own, you end up with an amount of gold that is 100x greater than all gold in existence.
This is true only if you ignore people who 'own' negative amount of gold/shares. If you count all people, you end with true amount.
this was my immediate concern as well
This is the case in the UK at least, you may need to have "Professional Client" MiFID status which means a lot of EU consumer protections don't apply to you
It surprises most people that even your stockbroker, who is supposed to hold "your" shares for you, does not do so. The trick they use is that, yes, initially they buy Tesla shares when "you" buy Tesla shares. But then they 1) mix them with all the Tesla share of other customers and 2) lend them out.
So, by some definition, they "have" the shares they owe you. But in reality, they don't. As they lent them out. And the borrowers sell them to some other "shareholder". So now both, you and the other shareholder think they own the same share in Tesla.
If you combine all the gold people think they own, you end up with an amount of gold that is 100x greater than all gold in existence.
I wonder if we will see the same with Bitcoin?