Not sure about that, but we were about a day away from that happening in 2008. AIG lent out high-grade bonds and invested the proceeds into illiquid higher-yield mortgage backed securities:
https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/what-went-w...
AIG's near collapse was partly due to CDS and party due to sec lending.
Could be. I don't know. But I wouldn't expect that there is no risk that a certain thing will happen just because it has not happened for 100 years.
No. This has happened. What hasn't is the lender of the stock not getting their securities back. Those stacked layers of covenant and collateral absorbed the damage.
> I wouldn't expect that there is no risk that a certain thing will happen just because it has not happened for 100 years
The risk isn't zero. But someone worrying about their lent Tesla stock never coming home is in the same category as a freestyle mountain climber becoming paranoid about meteors hitting them.
In the history of post-Securities Act American stock lending, I don't think this has once happened for a public stock. The lender's broker is entitled to buy the stock in the open market at any price (e.g. [1]) and stick the bill to the borrower's broker. The borrower's broker will chase the borrower. But the broker is immediately responsible.
For every share in oversupply there is someone naturally short. Between them and the market are layers of collateral and covenant, from the broker to the borrower to their clearing broker, from the clearinghouse to the banks mutualizing it.
[1] https://www.contractscounsel.com/t/us/securities-loan-agreem... § 13.1(a)