News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by GekkePrutser on Friday August 12, 2022 @06:16AM (#32436467)
So now the price will go up, and it'll be worthwhile growing mustard seeds again.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by bell-cot on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:24AM (#32439127)
Ah, no. You probably should talk to a real farmer about current crop prices vs. futures prices, the capital & other costs of trying to switch from growing Crop A to Crop B, lead times, inelastic demand, and how many farmers have been wiped out (bankruptcy & liquidation) due to a series of "it sounded good at the time" decisions.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by Dylan16807 on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:23PM (#32441502)
They mean it in an average sense, not advice to particular farmers.

It will make sense for some to switch, and some will.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by roenxi on Friday August 12, 2022 @08:32AM (#32437528)
Which is cool and all, but the side effect of this all is less people would be able to eat mustard. Prices going up is often inevitable but hardly a win.

It'd be interesting to have an accounting of what end-of-the-day benefits people got for giving up their mustard.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by mminer237 on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:49AM (#32438622)
I feel like mustard should be such a small portion of a person's budget that the price could double without affecting his ability to purchase it.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by roenxi on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:03AM (#32438818)
Then the price will more than double. If there was 100 tonnes of mustard consumed last year and there is 90 tonnes available this year, then the price rises until people stop buying about 10t of mustard.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by mminer237 on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:10AM (#32438917)
Temporarily, yeah; but long-term, it's correct that this will incentivize more mustard growing.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by roenxi on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:05PM (#32445877)
In this context, if land is being redeployed to grow bio-energy crops then there will be less mustard consumed. There is not an infinite amount of farmland, farmers and capital available to grow things - if resources are being directed away from food to biofuels then there will be less food.

The market will find an equilibrium, but it will involve people giving up mustard because the cost is too high. They have to - there is less mustard. Someone will have to give up consuming mustard and in the medium term it is going to be prices that are the mechanism. That is what prices going up generally mean - the market is shaking some people out so they stop using a product. In the short term I see they have a sign saying "only 1 mustard" or something like that.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by atwood22 on Friday August 12, 2022 @11:58AM (#32440448)
Why is there an incentive to grow more mustard? Subsidies have shifted the supply curve for mustard. The opportunity costs of growing mustard have increased due to subsidies for other crops. Now less mustard is grown and a new equilibrium price is set. The old amount of mustard will never be grown due to the shift in the supply curve from subsidies of other crops.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by Dylan16807 on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:38PM (#32441694)
The "more" was relative to 90 tonnes.

You're correct that the new equilibrium would be below 100.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by lotsofpulp on Friday August 12, 2022 @08:56AM (#32437802)
The solution to the side effect of poor people having to consume less due to higher prices is always redistributing wealth so poorer people have more money to spend. Preventing price movements simply hampers the ability for market participants to allocate resources properly to meet the desires of the populace.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by jaywalk on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:00AM (#32438773)
Give poor people more money > prices go up > poor people can't afford stuff > give poor people more money > prices go up > ...
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by lotsofpulp on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:54AM (#32439551)
You missed the step where you take money from richer people, and then give that money to poorer people.

Across all goods/services, that means richer people would be able to consume less, and poorer people would be able to consume more. Whether or not people sacrifice eating Dijon mustard is up to them.

The goal is not to guarantee Dijon mustard for everyone, the goal is to mitigate how poor poorer people are.

The other way to bring down Dijon mustard prices is for the government to increase supply of Dijon mustard, or remove whatever is restricting supply of Dijon mustard.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by WalterBright on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:06AM (#32438864)
You've just described college tuition!
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by lotsofpulp on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:57AM (#32439586)
No. College tuition is lend people unlimited amount of taxpayer’s money with no underwriting -> colleges increase prices as much as possible without getting too much political blowback in the immediate term. And then taxpayers eat the loss via loan forgiveness or decreased purchasing power of the USD as interest rates and repayment terms are continuously relaxed.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by WalterBright on Friday August 12, 2022 @11:14AM (#32439820)
Sounds the same to me.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by lotsofpulp on Friday August 12, 2022 @11:16AM (#32439849)
Would you rather be given money or lent money?

It would be a pretty big difference to me.

Lending money today instead of giving money lets leaders and voters today to punt sacrifices to tomorrow’s taxpayers, and of course inflates college tuition prices so the borrowers have reduced purchasing power, as well as future users of the currency.

That is the whole reason lending for college tuition became a thing. Some genius figured out how to cut taxes today while still being able to say they are helping expand access to higher education to poor people and college students.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by mikepurvis on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:03AM (#32438819)
In theory yes, and I think we probably see this effect with things like home-buyer credits, low interest rates, etc all contributing to pushing up the cost of houses.

But has it been studied that this is actually how this plays out with a low-level consumer good like mustard?

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by celtain on Friday August 12, 2022 @11:58AM (#32440444)
Well, that's part of the solution. The other part of the solution is on the supply side: finding ways to reduce prices through improved productivity, trade, removing unnecessary regulations, fostering competitive markets, etc.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by SllX on Friday August 12, 2022 @11:31AM (#32440051)
It’s a good food with good properties. As a stand-alone product it probably wouldn’t matter but this is in the context of food prices already going up across the board and healthy food generally being closer to the premium end of the price scale.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by beowulfey on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:20AM (#32439081)
It’s mustard, and there are still other kinds. I’m personally not worried about it.

I think we’ll have a lot more of these sacrifices coming up in the next thirty years that will hurt a lot more. Coffee is the one that I’m most worried about.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by jfim on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:24AM (#32439142)
The other kinds of mustard are not really substitutable. It's as if Coca Cola disappeared from store shelves in the US, and someone said it's fine because there's still Fanta and Sprite.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by JasonFruit on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:59AM (#32439609)
I'm not really sure your analogy helps; in either case, there are people who would agree that it matters, and people who would be baffled that anyone could get wrought up over it.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by bobthepanda on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:14PM (#32440645)
What makes the example unhelpful? Coca Cola and associated brands are probably one of, if not the most internationally prolific brands of consumer product in the world. I don’t even drink much soda now and even I remember what they tasted like years ago, or at least the fact that they taste wildly different.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by hammock on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:00PM (#32440481)
Replace Coke and Sprite with Trump and Biden. Now we’re talking
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by hammock on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:14PM (#32440644)
If the price increase weren’t due to a subsidy, that would be true. Instead, a subsidy creates a sustained shortage.

Unless something else (not price action) increases the demand for mustard, its price will not move back to equilibrium. This concept is in Econ 101 (albeit one of the less intuitive concepts taught)

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by Dylan16807 on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:29PM (#32441586)
Well first off they didn't say the price will move back, they said the shortage will end. Now that it costs more, more supply can be obtained.

But also it's likely that when the equilibrium point moved, farmers (or other parts of the supply chain) overshot it. That puts us in a price spike, so even if the new normal is higher than the old normal, if you check during a spike you should expect the price to go down.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by GekkePrutser on Saturday August 13, 2022 @06:22AM (#32448454)
I'm the OP and yes you explained what I meant to say very well.

All foodstuff prices are going up now anyway. And tbh, mustard is like 0.1% of my food budget so if it goes up a bit or even triples in price I won't think twice about it.

I just meant that this will force a new equilibrium, subsidy or not, people will keep growing mustard.

And of course tackling climate change is also a big priority, and renewable fuels are a good option for things that can't be electric (e.g. planes).

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by nephanth on Monday August 15, 2022 @04:08PM (#32474734)
In Burgundy (where Dijon is) at least, growing grapes for wine is probably way more profitable than mustard seeds
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by bottled_poe on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:28AM (#32436904)
Hmmm.. that’s not how supply vs demand works though
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by SimplyUnknown on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:46AM (#32437032)
How so? Supply goes down while demand is the same --> Price goes up --> Profit margin for the farmer increases --> Profits of mustard > profits of rapeseed --> Farmer produces mustard instead of rapeseed. This is exactly the consequence of supply and demand.

The only noteworthy fact is that we got in this situation because it was not a completely free market but a regulated market due to subsidies for rapeseed, artificially increasing their profit margin.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by bottled_poe on Friday August 12, 2022 @08:26PM (#32445604)
Because demand isn’t the same. Changing the price affects the demand.
Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by viridian on Friday August 12, 2022 @08:12AM (#32437297)
This is exactly how a price shift in the supply demand curve works in basic macroeconomics.

If you price shift a good upwards and the demand remains static, yield per good increases and then supply should increase as suppliers willing to supply at the new price is greater than supplier willing to supply at the old price.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by bottled_poe on Friday August 12, 2022 @08:29PM (#32445620)
> demand remains static,

How can this be an assumption? Of course demand will respond to price.

Re:A shortage of Dijon mustard in France by viridian on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:27PM (#32451343)
Demand is a slope, not a point. Price increases left shift demand, prices decreases right shift demand. This is because more people are willing to buy a good at a cheaper price than a more expensive one.

In this context demand is the total desire of the market to consume that good at all, represented by a slope that has an inverse relationship with the price axis.