News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by moomin on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:21PM (#32430491)
They ignore much larger sums. The real reason they’re targeted is that, quite simply, they’re unable to fight back. It’s the equivalent of searching for your keys under the streetlight.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:47PM (#32430842)
> they ignore much larger sums

Not really [1]. When you make more than $500k, your audit rate doubles from the national average of 0.25%. It doubles again at $1mm and more than doubles once more at $5mm.

EITC-only returns are audited around the frequency (0.77%) of someone making $500k to $1mm. I'm not sure why $1 to 25k is audited at the same frequency as $500k to $1mm. But given "from fiscal years 2010 to 2021, the majority of the additional taxes IRS recommended from audits came from taxpayers with incomes below $200,000" and that "EITC audits are primarily pre-refund audits and are conducted through correspondence," it seems--very roughly--closer to the optimum than the headline suggests.

[1] https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-22-104960

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by koheripbal on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:42PM (#32431467)
It's important to remember that an "EITC correction" != "audit", despite the parent assuming all audits are equal.

Correcting a simple error might never even involve a human IRS auditor. It's as simple as an automated letter going out and instructing someone to correct an obvious mistake (this happened to me).

Never spoke to anyone - just submitted the correction. There should be no limit to audits that are nearly-automated, regardless of whom they target.

Audits that require an investigator are far more effort and those investigative resources need to be proportioned by the expected return on investment. ...and while that will likely tend more frequently to the rich, it shouldn't necessarily be so.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:45PM (#32431491)
https://www.taxaudit.com/irs-letters/irs-letter-cp75a-sample...

This is what a typical audit of EITC looks like. It is literally "send us some forms and some proof like a birth certificate showing you're the parent of the child you're claiming".

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by int_19h on Thursday August 11, 2022 @10:10PM (#32434060)
If it's so automated, why require people to submit tax returns at all? Just calculate everything and send them the breakdown along with the check.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by drewbug01 on Thursday August 11, 2022 @10:49PM (#32434261)
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by koheripbal on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:05PM (#32441288)
This is obviously wrong. The reason is that they need people to affirm ALL sources of income, not just their W2.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by int_19h on Saturday August 13, 2022 @04:20PM (#32453417)
If this is obviously wrong, then how and why does it work in most countries other than US? Most people don't have sources of income other than employment (or other sources that are similarly transparent to the tax authorities already). Most tax systems, accordingly, are structured around that, and only those who have unusual income sources have to submit documentation about them.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by marwatk on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:27PM (#32430561)
This is addressed in the article:

> A critical limitation in the IRS’s ability to audit millionaires is the availability of IRS revenue agents. Only this class of auditors, given sufficient training and experience, are qualified to examine complex tax returns – the types of returns typically filed by high-income individuals and large-scale businesses.

> With severe budget constraints, IRS has tended to trade off the replacement of revenue agents with hiring more tax examiners. These certainly are paid less, but they are also less knowledgeable. While revenue agents used to outnumber tax examiners, this has slowly shifted over time.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by wongarsu on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:32PM (#32430628)
I'd be interesting to see how the ratio of revenue agents to tax examiners would shift if the IRS would get a portion of discovered tax fraud back into their budget.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by syspec on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:35PM (#32430683)
There's no way that's a good idea. See police departments + (civil asset forfeiture and small town speed traps)
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by TAForObvReasons on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:36PM (#32430695)
Looked into this years ago in a semi-related discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21874358

https://www.finance.senate.gov/ranking-members-news/irs-budg...

> IRS Research Division estimates in the 2003 GAO report, however, placed returns for activities such as tax enforcement at more than ten – and in some cases more than 20 – dollars collected for every dollar spent. Phone calls to follow up on tax debts owed were estimated to return 13 dollars for every dollar spent. Audits by mail returned as much as 11 dollars for every dollar spent. Using the overall rate of a four to one return, this year’s $100 million budget cut translates to a $400 million loss.

Imagine 20 dollars per dollar spent, that's the type of unicorn investment that basically every VC hunts for.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by DavidPeiffer on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:07PM (#32431075)
> Imagine 20 dollars per dollar spent, that's the type of unicorn investment that basically every VC hunts for.

It's frustrating that every business person who has ever lived would absolutely throw money at that formula if it was part of their business, but that's not politically popular because the IRS costs money to operate.

Mathemarically it makes sense to go until you hit 1:1. If we increased enforcement until, say, 4 dollars collected for every 1 spent in each of the major categories, the deterrent factor would probably help people be more honest in times of dishonesty, naturally helping the problem for the following year.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by ghaff on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:17PM (#32431191)
>Mathemarically it makes sense to go until you hit 1:1

Maybe mathematically. But realize that the targets of the audits are probably bearing at least as much of the cost burden of the audit as the IRS whether they did anything wrong or not. And you'll almost certainly cost a lot of people who made honest mistakes a lot of money.

So, no, it's not at all clear that the IRC should be revenue-maximizing.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by powerhour on Thursday August 11, 2022 @06:01PM (#32432302)
If they become more efficient because they get a larger budget, that would very publicly contradict a lot of campaign messaging.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by RhysU on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:20PM (#32431233)
> Mathemarically it makes sense to go until you hit 1:1.

Nah, until we get better returns on other endeavors for the same dollar.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by patrick451 on Thursday August 11, 2022 @08:13PM (#32433397)
We can go a step further and let the individual auditors get a commission too. Revenue will sky rocket and surely this will attract the best, brightest and most ethical. Conflicts of interest be damned.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by lostcolony on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:26PM (#32430550)
They don't ignore much larger sums; larger sums are much harder to automate detection of. So with the limited amount of manpower they have, far fewer are identified.

They can send a letter asking for documentation for everything the automated system flags. The automated system detects "simple" cases at a far higher confidence ratio, which tends to be lower income. Once you get upper income, with all manner of complicated itemized deductions, the confidence of the automated system is much lower, and the effort to ask for appropriate documentation, and verify it, is much higher, for a much lower expectation of return (since, again, low confidence from the system).

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by LorenPechtel on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:49PM (#32430866)
And the rich guy probably has a CPA filing their taxes. It's quite unlikely there will be anything in there that's easily detected.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by ghaff on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:57PM (#32431634)
Or that is a flat-out mistake. You're right that wealthier people probably aren't going to commit obvious fraud like "forgetting" a 1099. But, assuming they are not deliberately committing fraud, their CPA will probably not make any obvious errors either.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by mindslight on Thursday August 11, 2022 @05:15PM (#32431800)
I wouldn't be so sure about that. I just got a letter from the IRS pointing out an error in an amended return my CPA had filed, presumably with the help of software. They tallied total taxable income to a nonzero amount, but then put a zero for the tax due on that amount. I missed it on my own review because it was one of many returns I had to file.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by ghaff on Thursday August 11, 2022 @05:30PM (#32431960)
Hence probably. I have no doubt CPAs like every professional including developers make mistakes. Although I assume they're probably mostly obvious one which can be corrected fairly easily. I'm also sure there are outliers.

>I missed it on my own review because it was one of many returns I had to file.

Honestly, I look through my returns but they're way past the point where I could find most errors even though my finances aren't especially complex.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:59PM (#32430987)
No; it's simpler than that. Tax fraud doesn't distribute by income; it distributes by nature of income, and the ease with which that income is validated.

Some really large proportion of Americans are basically W-2 filers taking the standard deduction. These Americans have no opportunity to evade taxes.

Most income tax fraud probably takes place in the area of passthrough businesses and other areas where tax verification isn't simply a problem of reconciling what employer A (or brokerage B, for dividends and stock sales, or bank C, for interest) said they paid to person P with what person P reported on their return.

TL;DR - it's hard to execute a fraud when the IRS already has the corresponding 1099s on-file for you.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by Kye on Thursday August 11, 2022 @08:52PM (#32433638)
This will probably change with the 1099k requirement dropping to $600 nationwide. Or it'll further overwhelm the IRS.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by prepend on Thursday August 11, 2022 @09:41PM (#32433915)
> These Americans have no opportunity to evade taxes.

I think there’s a lot of opportunity related to kids. Deductions and credits vary and can be mistakenly or willfully claimed.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by gist on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:09PM (#32431088)
> The real reason they’re targeted is that, quite simply, they’re unable to fight back.

I think there is a misunderstanding of what an 'audit' means. It can be as simple as a letter from the IRS (after their analysis alerts them) asking that certain documents be provided to support a deduction or otherwise. The IRS is not conducting large scale audits on people with low incomes it would not be feasible there is not enough to even dig into.

What the government (in this particular case for the EITC) should be easy for the taxpayer to reply with info needed to dispute the claim.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by biomcgary on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:49PM (#32431533)
I got a tax bill for more than a hundred thousand dollars when I sold my primary residence a few years ago. No taxes were actually owed due to the primary residence carve out for capital gains. The sale had been reported to the IRS by a couple different entities (realtor and title company, IIRC) with a few dollar discrepancy, so the transaction was not merged, even though they for the same address (and single family home). I wrote the IRS a nice letter and they eventually replied that they were closing the case. Sometimes "unpaid" taxes are due to limitations of the IRS, which has historically had very legacy software (not sure if that has been fixed recently).
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by bryanrasmussen on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:48PM (#32430853)
no, the searching for the keys under the streetlight joke is funny because you will never find the keys under the streetlight no matter how nice it might be to search for them with a good light source, whereas you will be able to relatively easy find small sums of money and make people it from the poor families under discussion here.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by worik on Thursday August 11, 2022 @04:59PM (#32431652)
> you will never find the keys under the streetlight

That is a strong statement! It is not true, some times that is where they are.

Actually if it is the only place you could find them (the rest of the street is too dark, you do not have a torch to see or fingers to feel....) it is an optimal, albeit dismal, strategy

Loving digression.....

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by bryanrasmussen on Thursday August 11, 2022 @05:09PM (#32431740)
evidently you used the phrase without familiarity with its origin?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect

>A policeman sees a drunk man searching for something under a streetlight and asks what the drunk has lost. He says he lost his keys and they both look under the streetlight together. After a few minutes the policeman asks if he is sure he lost them here, and the drunk replies, no, and that he lost them in the park. The policeman asks why he is searching here, and the drunk replies, "this is where the light is".

Hence, the drunk and the policeman are never going to find the keys under the streetlamp because they were lost in the park.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:25PM (#32430541)
> They ignore much larger sums.

Source? What category of stuff the IRS ignores adds up to more than $20 billion?

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by ribosometronome on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:35PM (#32430692)
https://www.crfb.org/blogs/primer-understanding-tax-gap

The IRS estimates there's a net tax gap of $554 billion in 2019. They break it down into 5 categories with values from 2011-2013 that all are over 20 billion each: underreported income, over/misreported adjustments, underpayment, non-filing, and other underreporting. They note that their 2011-2013 estimate failed to include underreporting of offshore wealth and wealth going through pass through entities, which resulted in a tax gap of $33 billion per year to the 2011-2013 estimate and 46 billion for 2019.

Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by wizofaus on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:36PM (#32430702)
Given the total collected is over 4 trillion it's not hard to imagine other categories worth far more than 20 billion.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by moralestapia on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:26PM (#32430558)
Bit of a tangent but, why $20BUSD?
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:30PM (#32430601)
$20bn is the estimated annual cost of fraudulent or otherwise improper Earned Income Tax Credits, which is the primary audit scope for low-income tax payers.
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by thrdbndndn on Thursday August 11, 2022 @03:28PM (#32430574)
>EITC errors/fraud cost the public purse $10-20bn a year
Re:IRS audits poorest families at five times the rate for ev... by moralestapia on Thursday August 11, 2022 @05:41PM (#32432058)
Oh that's right, my mind wandered a bit :l