Are there any examples on the climatic record of the Gulf Stream collapsing to help shed some light on the potential outcomes?
But forget the Gulf Stream, you should learn more about the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation (AMOC)[0], which also could be shut down. There is geological evidence that such a shut down would turn the Atlantic ocean anoxic, literally turning the ocean toxic.
This isn't some wacky, doomer fantasy scenario, this has happened multiple times in Earth's history when CO2 levels and temperatures have risen and been responsible for multiple mass extinction events[1]. It's also worth pointing out that the AMOC is already showing evidence of weakening [2]
A good overview of this paleontologist Peter Ward's Under a Green Sky.
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_meridional_overturnin...
[0] http://www.angel.net/~nic/jegers-mentoen-annihilator.html
I can already hear them screeching.
I'd not predict the future like that. No one knows certainly what will happen if the Gulf stream collapse