News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:41PM (#3239470)
I know that a lot of people were sad that we switched from +word to "word" to do an exact match for a word.

The good news is that we're rolling out a "literal mode" that will search for exactly the words you typed. It does a verbatim match with your words, so it turns off things like spelling corrections, stemming, synonyms, optionalized terms, and so on. I think we saw multiple proposals for this on Hacker News, so thanks for the suggestion.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by redthrowaway on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:57PM (#3240757)
Still waiting on being able to search for punctuation. Being able to search for "$. ruby" or "$_ perl" or "$: << '.' ruby" would be super handy.

edit: Just realized "$_ perl" actually does work. It would be nice, however, if we could search for these kinds of terms generally and not just in specific case.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by dncrane on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @12:41AM (#3241997)
I launched a search engine that does exactly this just over a week ago, you can see it here: http://symbolhound.com/

I freaked out when I saw this headline and thought it meant google had finally decided to implement this feature a week after my launch.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by redthrowaway on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @03:07AM (#3242287)
That's freaking fantastic. Shame it didn't get much notice on proggit. I'll resubmit it at a busier time and share it on G+ and whatnot. You might want to submit it here yourself, so you can answer any questions people might have and let the community get to know you. Try submitting it with the "Show HN:" heading. Send me an email (in my profile) when you do submit it and I'll be sure to swing by and give it one of the critical first upvotes.

Really cool tool; thanks for that.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by dncrane on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @09:54AM (#3243279)
Thanks! I do plan to post it on HN, I just want to wait until it's a bit better (right now stackoverflow dominates the results, so I need to adjust the ranking system and index more sites).

BTW, I don't see your email in your profile.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by redthrowaway on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @02:04PM (#3244523)
>BTW, I don't see your email in your profile.

Sorry about that. I would have thought putting it in the email field would have made it visible. I've put it in the about field now.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by wladimir on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @06:13AM (#3242665)
Great! Nice, simple and easy. It can even search for negative numbers without interpreting the - as "exclude". A literal search engine, without Google's well-meaning "intelligence" can be useful in many cases.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by polshaw on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:42PM (#3241809)
1000 times this. I have been waiting a decade to be able to search for '1/2' or '6' 3"' or '£3.50' (not necessarily numbers, you get the point i'm sure), and i was dissapointed to find this post wasn't announcing that.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by slavak on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @03:56AM (#3242389)
This. Half my kingdom for this feature.

One of the biggest problems I have with Google search at the moment is when I need to look up specific functions or symbol names. If I'm looking for documentation on g_find_str, the LAST thing I need is to see results that contain "... are going. Find string is a ..."

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by gtani on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @08:40AM (#3243046)
That's great, Google does n-grams/symbol search finally. Tho 'f# "|>" ' is way less common than "$_ perl", doesn't work yet.

And i think the folks that did, e.g. hoogle took some time to get it right for 1 language

http://www.haskell.org/hoogle/

http://scalex.org/

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by redler on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:02PM (#3239579)
Matt, do you know if there are any plans to once again allow the mixing of exact match with the regular fuzzier search functionality? It's great to have exact matching back, but I often found it a useful strategy to build the search loosely, then refine with +specifics. Perhaps something like this, in exact match mode:

  ~run ~sprint ~hurdle nike
could be the equivalent of the old:

  run sprint hurdle +nike
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Xuzz on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:11PM (#3239629)
You still can do that, you just have to use "quotes" "around" "the" "words" instead of +putting +the +plus +sign +before +each +word. This just lets you get that type of search for every word easier.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by DanBC on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:12PM (#3239639)
Isn't

    run sprint hurdle "nike"
what you want?
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by redler on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:27PM (#3239727)
Yes, and of course that works fine. It's just the ease of using an inline prefix to modify the term, rather than enclosing it in quotes. We're mourning the loss of the +.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by davorak on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:10PM (#3239620)
Yes please allow something like this, mixing verbatim with fuzzier search functionality is powerful.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by ElbertF on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:00PM (#3240498)
I'm not seeing the change yet, will we be able to use "verbatim:hello world" to do an exact search? I don't see myself navigating through the sidebar each time I need to find something specific.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by bromley on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:34PM (#3240651)
Yes, please, verbatim: or similar would be great, especially for use on a mobile.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by JonnieCache on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:53PM (#3241154)
This is a good idea, it will allow us to use the string interpolation address bar search functionality we all love in our favourite browsers.

In general, nice one google for once again keeping an ear to the ground.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by bambax on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:06PM (#3240221)
Although "sad" with where Google search is (was) going isn't the right term, I am now very much unpissed, so many many thanks for this.

How is "literal mode" different from what "allintext:" promised? And is there an option to turn this on permanently?

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by brador on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:06PM (#3239596)
This isn't really the solution we were looking for Matt.

Can we replace the + operator with something else? How about¬? We don't use that very often to the point I don't even know what it's called, but it's there on the keyboard in one keypress.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:11PM (#3239627)
I'll pass the feedback on. Part of the issue with + is that it turned out a lot of people were mistyping queries with + when as far as we could tell, they weren't trying to match an exact word. Getting further off the beaten path with a more rare character might help though.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by sc00ter on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:49PM (#3239840)
Surely simpler soultion would have been to respond to a search for "+this is a +search" with:

Showing results for this is a search Search instead for +this is a +search

As google does for other "typos".

Failing that, a replacement for + would be welcome. I can't imagine many people type, for example ^word or =word - allowing use of a symbol that indicates promotion of that word word in the search terms, they way + did.

The difficulty will be reeducating the (presumably quite large number of - even if proportionally a small percentage of googles user base) people who have been using + in searches for the last 10-15 years (I'm almost positive this concept existed in other search engines before google) that + isn't + any more, and please use this other symbol instead.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by bh42222 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:33PM (#3240357)
Currently Google offers me the ability to change the background image on the Google home page.

How about the ability to use something like Google "classic" with the old way of using the + sign?

Hide it as an off-home page selection, that way only people who really want it will choose it.

I'd also be interested in something similar for an "advanced search syntax" mode. Probably not very useful for the majority of people, but could be something a minority might be very passionate about.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by mh- on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:25PM (#3240853)
What about the equals sign?

=exactstring

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by jaylevitt on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:39PM (#3239774)
Exclamation point? (!this !word !exactly, !darnit!) Or a double exclamation point if that's still too common...

It really was nice to be able to control which words were verbatim and which weren't. Quotes are perfectly logical but just a pain to retrofit onto a query you're refining.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by dfc on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:31PM (#3241264)
Westlaw search syntax would be awesome!!!
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by botker on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:25PM (#3239715)
That's the symbol for logical negation, which would make it a confusing replacement for +.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Gormo on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:45PM (#3241126)
That character is most often used as a logical negation operator, so it may be confusing to use it as a force-inclusion operator for search.

It's also almost never found on standard US keyboards, which is why the tilde is often used as a logical negation operator in it's place.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by georgemcbay on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:10PM (#3239617)
Speak for yourself. I've been wanting this solution for years.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by bambax on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:08PM (#3240235)
> This isn't really the solution we were looking for

What? Yes, yes it is. Please don't take it away now!

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Xuzz on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:09PM (#3239616)
Not on US keyboards, I don't think.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by hessenwolf on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @04:15AM (#3242430)
I've looked all over my German keyboard, with its crazy-assed bracket locations, and I don't see it anywhere.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by bobbles on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @06:16AM (#3242671)
My UK keyboard has it left of the '1' key above the qwerty keys
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by hessenwolf on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @11:35AM (#3243767)
I have carat and a little circle. The bastards.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by nknight on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:26PM (#3239718)
Depends on your OS. ¬ is a quick alt+l on any Mac. However, it's the symbol for logical negation[1], and thus probably not a great substitute for +.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C2%AC

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Natsu on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:12PM (#3239947)
On Windows, you have to do Alt+0172 to get a ¬ unless there's some shortcut I don't know offhand.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by ctdonath on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:04PM (#3239583)
Thank you. Irritation has been growing that I can't search for what I want without fielding all kinds of "well what about this variant..." results, without even + prefix and "" squishing into some unwanted twist. Would be nice to make (at least as an option) Verbatim mode the default, with a link provided per search to show variants.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by jerrya on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:17PM (#3241409)
Can you confirm or discuss more about what this does to the "filter bubble?"

In two windows of the same browser, I typed gyros, one immediately offered me an instant search result of gyros Phoenix (where I currrently am), the other window, in verbatim mode offered me gyros, gyroscope, and gyros recipe.

(Don't ask me why I tried gyros as my search example.)

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Matt_Cutts on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @12:32AM (#3241971)
I believe verbatim mode turns off personalization, and it looks like it turns off localization as part of that. So the query [yoga] shows local places to do yoga for me, but in verbatim mode I don't see that.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by InclinedPlane on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:44PM (#3240111)
Out of curiosity, how does google judge search result quality? It seems as though search is trending toward the idea that more results are better, when usually the opposite is true.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by moultano on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:15PM (#3241217)
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by tamersalama on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:49PM (#3240132)
A bit speculative: this is more related to Ad revenue. A wider spectrum of search results means more Ad variety and the ability to serve more advertisers per search query.

I'm annoyed by Google's search quality by the day. I'm starting to use DuckDuckGo more (unless there are other alternatives).

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by moultano on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:06PM (#3240527)
I know it's tempting but please don't speculate like that, it raises my blood pressure. :)

Google keeps ranking changes completely siloed from the ad side of the company, and the decision makers about ranking changes don't see statistics about how it might effect ads. We don't even have a way of collecting that data. (At least as far as I've ever seen.)

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by tamersalama on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:52PM (#3240737)
I couldn't resist the speculation temptation :)

Correct me if I'm wrong; When I'm searching for (unquoted) "Canadian equivalent to SOPA Bill". I'm getting results about Soap, Telenovela, Spas, Dishwasher Soap, TV shows (and 1 related hit). The result, as you mentioned, could be ranked independent of Ads, but the Ad spectrum is wider (Soaps, Spas, Soap operas, TV shows, etc...) [I'm not getting any in this particular case].

If it's restrictive search (quoting each word - sigh!), the search result quality is slightly better (first 3 hits), but the potential of Ads is also low.

I know you put the user first - but wouldn't you speculate in my case?

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by tomkarlo on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:24PM (#3240844)
I'm not sure that logic works. You're assuming that the Ads are matched to the query in the same way that results are matched to the query - that a more restrictive query necessarily translates into fewer ad matches.

There's another possibility which is that the ads are the query and the search query is in fact their match result. In that case, adding or removing quotes within the search query might not have any impact on the ads being shown.

Don't know which way it works, but it seems to me the latter would be better for showing ads without having any negative impact on search results.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by moultano on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:03PM (#3241367)
Ads has a very sophisticated system of matching ad topics against queries. That's how they make the big money. :) I work in search though, so I don't really know anything about how it works except at an extremely high level. I'd be really surprised if that sort of effect actually happened though.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by fred_nada on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @04:13PM (#3245099)
Moultano: I 100% believe google keeps ranking changes siloed from the ad side, but Google 100% favors its own properties within its search results so you can't be surprised that someone thinks this way? Here are some examples for you that need major changes in my opinion.

www.google.com/#hl=en&q=san+francisco+restaurant+reviews www.google.com/#hl=en&q=hollywood+cauldron

-when i previously used google for retail reviews I would just bypass all of your results to get to yelp. sometimes trip advisor.

-look at those youtube video results for the 2nd query. So off the mark, but you guys keep them in there because it is good for google. it doesn't help your users and makes you look bad. I don't know what you guys are thinking.

I use Bing for 95% of my searches now. For tech searches I still think you guys are better, but for everything else I use Bing.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by wooster on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:18PM (#3241414)
Thanks Matt. This helps with at least one of my complaints about the direction Google search has been heading.

(Now if you'd just eliminate that godawful slow URL redirector on result links…)

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by pasbesoin on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:44PM (#3240419)
I seem to recall reading in prior discussion on this that +foo included stemming while "foo" does not? (And, therefor, some people were unhappy with "foo" not just due to the syntax change but also due to the difference in behavior.)

Some other people in this thread have suggested ¬ as a substitute (and no, it's not on a typical U.S. keyboard). Others point out that ¬ means negation in a typical context. Do you folks index backticks? If not, what about backtick? I guess that wouldn't be too *NIXy; however, most keyboards seem to have one, and if it's not currently indexed, might be a choice. (It's also "sort of quotish", in nature.)

P.S. Hmm... Backtick could cause unexpected results in the case of someone pasting a single quoted value from Word, or similar. Might not be the common, though, and I never did like Word's "smart quotes", anyway. ;-)

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by goblin89 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:49PM (#3241140)
Nice, now search personalization can be turned off!

> With the verbatim tool on, we’ll use the literal words you entered without making normal improvements such as <...> personalizing your search by using information such as sites you’ve visited before

Personally, I appreciate this more than allowing to search for exact matches. Hopefully ‘filter bubble’ just became less… bubbley. =)

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by beernutz on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:30PM (#3240339)
I always used the + to mean "the following word or quote surrounded string HAS to appear in the result text".

Was this incorrect?

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by walropodes on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @06:17AM (#3242672)
Could you guys consider bringing out a case-sensitive search feature sometime?
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by tamersalama on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:51PM (#3240145)
Why aren't you allowing for both; The original +prefix as well as the quotes?
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by kitsune_ on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:45PM (#3239817)
finally... and thanks.
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by drivebyacct2 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:41PM (#3241634)
Why does this query not do what one would expect.

    halo -"halo 2" -"halo 3"
Also, removing "Advanced Search" from the main google.com and from the top of a search results page beats out moving "cached" to the preview page in terms of "stupidest decision Google has ever made".
Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by Matt_Cutts on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @12:37AM (#3241988)
I'll ask about the halo query. In the mean time, it looks like [halo -halo.2 -halo.3] does what you want.

Do you see a gear symbol in the top of main google.com and the results page? I think that's where Advanced Search is now.

Re:Google adds verbatim search mode for your exact search terms by drivebyacct2 on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @12:42AM (#3242004)
Thanks for the query recommendation. Curious why the other didn't work, I feel it (or similar ones) have worked as I might expect in the past.

>Do you see a gear symbol in the top of main google.com and the results page? I think that's where Advanced Search is now.

Seems Android action-bar-esque almost, but yes, thanks.