News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by klipt on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:21AM (#32293386)
It's funny how atheists believe in evolution in theory, but fervently religious groups like this are the ones winning at evolution in practice.

My theory is having kids is just really hard work, but a deeply ingrained religious belief that children are a blessing from God helps groups like the Amish push forward with it anyway.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by lalaland1125 on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:23AM (#32293395)
Evolution isn't a moral theory.

Evolution only makes predictions about reality, it doesn't tell you what is more moral or what you should do

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by klipt on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:25AM (#32293408)
Sure, but it's literally the definition of evolutionary fitness that having more kids makes you more evolutionarily fit.

Nobody said fitness implies morality. But the Amish by definition have higher evolutionary fitness than average Americans.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by jb_gericke on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:33AM (#32293452)
I think the greater human population is doing just fine - almost exclusively due to scientific and technological advancements. (https://lighthouse.mq.edu.au/article/why-has-the-world-popul...)
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by tresqotheq on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:43AM (#32293748)
> scientific and technological advancements.

sure, it does not matter that things that we pay for and consume ends up having a million things that makes us sick in multiple ways, and if you are in some developing nation, you would be hard pressed to find food to feed your babies that is not laced with some kind of harmful pesticides or fertilizer, but hey, we can always pay more in healthcare to extend our diseased misery. We are doing just fine, in the mean while, there are more and more existential threats as the day progress, but hey, say it with me, we are JUST.DOING.FINE.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by poser-boy on Sunday July 31, 2022 @03:48AM (#32294005)
Most countries (including those outside the west) are falling, or have fallen below replacement rate.

If we extrapolate this over the next few decades, and accept the conclusion that more technology = less children, and we can expect to see more technology in the future. Almost no new children will be born from within these high-tech societies, we will have to rely on immigration from Africa (the only place where replacement rate is high), and low-tech traditional religious societies.

What good is technology in this future scenario?

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by kwhitefoot on Sunday July 31, 2022 @04:53AM (#32294300)
People still have children and most countries do not need to be any more crowded than they are already. In fact many countries would benefit from having a lower population density.

Technology has already replaced most agricultural workers in most developed countries and I can't imagine anyone wanting to return to pre-industrial agriculture.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by darebak on Sunday July 31, 2022 @05:40AM (#32294438)
100 present day South Koreans will have 6 great-grandchildren total. That's an extinction level event.

Ofcourse if the current trends continue.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by falcor84 on Sunday July 31, 2022 @07:59AM (#32294966)
It's only extinction if you extrapolate this continuing over many generations, but of course every generation reevaluates their priorities
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by Alt-F4 on Sunday July 31, 2022 @08:34PM (#32300381)
Wow, interesting. Though my math comes out to 6.64 (== 100*(.5*0.81)**3).

https://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20220223000644

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by croes on Sunday July 31, 2022 @03:42AM (#32293981)
Nope, more children doesn't mean more evolutionary fit.

More kids surviving does and on that part the Amish benefit from technology because they can and some do to seek medical help if it's necessary.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by barry-cotter on Sunday July 31, 2022 @04:54AM (#32294304)
Enough food, clean water and knowledge of germ theory does most of the work there. New England has higher rates of natural increase for most of two centuries without benefit of modern medicine, as did Quebec.
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by kwhitefoot on Sunday July 31, 2022 @04:49AM (#32294281)
It only works for the Amish because they are a tiny minority in a larger society that supports, or at least tolerates, them and their lifestyle.

If they become dominant or even merely competitive with the larger society then there will be conflict.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by ajb on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:52AM (#32293527)
Don't know if this is true of the Amish, but fundamentalist groups who target large families generally lose a large fraction of those kids to mainstream culture (source: Bob Altmeyer, The Authoritarians). Hence, their culture does not outcompete mainstream culture.
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by klipt on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:03AM (#32293572)
There are comments elsewhere on this post saying around 85% of Amish raised children remain Amish.
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by Thorrez on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:45AM (#32293753)
From the article:

>Reasons for Population Growth. The primary forces driving the growth are sizable nuclear families (five or more children on average) and an average retention rate (Amish children who join the church as young adults) of 85 percent or more. A few outsiders have joined the Amish, but the growth is almost entirely from within the Amish community.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by MandieD on Sunday July 31, 2022 @10:36AM (#32295776)
While they have Rumspringa as late teens and can theoretically choose not to get baptized and become adult members, choosing not to means exclusion from the only community they've ever known, into a world they have not been educated to make a living in - particularly, the girls.
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by lawn on Sunday July 31, 2022 @04:15AM (#32294140)
The same reason that countries with higher child mortality have higher birth rate.

Go figure, this has nothing to do with religion.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by woodruffw on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:38AM (#32293476)
> It's funny how atheists believe in evolution in theory, but fervently religious groups like this are the ones winning at evolution in practice.

There's a logical disconnect here: I can believe in death, but I really don't want to "win" at death.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by klipt on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:48AM (#32293518)
At least some people do want to "win" against death by becoming immortal. Physics suggests true immortality is impossible, but maybe people will live a lot longer in future...
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by kenneth on Sunday July 31, 2022 @06:40AM (#32294671)
Biological immortality could be possible. Certain organisms are biologically immortal, and it's possible we can achieve that through technology. I think it's actually not at all unlikely we will get very close within a couple centuries, and that life expectancy will shoot through the roof. (We would have to fix some serious societal issues especially around pollution first though, beyond just the medical breakthroughs.)
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by skissane on Sunday July 31, 2022 @04:04AM (#32294093)
If the human mind is a product of evolution, how can we be sure that it is reliable at arriving at the truth? What if false or irrational beliefs produced greater evolutionary fitness than true and rational ones? But, if that were so, it would undermine all our confidence in the very belief that the human mind is a product of evolution, making that a self-defeating idea.

Hence, if the human mind is a product of evolution, evolution must ultimately prefer truth to falsehood. But, what then to make of evidence that, in the long-run, natural selection prefers religious beliefs to non-religious belief? Can you see how that might be a problem for those who are convinced that all specifically religious beliefs are false and irrational?

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by einherjae on Sunday July 31, 2022 @04:47AM (#32294278)
Nah, if religious belief helps group cohesion in such a way that we get societies that overall increase the likelihood of survival, then the truth of said religion is irrelevant.

Religions themselves are to some degree affected by their own evolutionary pressures. The views on missionary work, procreation and possibly also military all will effect the group of people that adhere to the religion, and if they lead to a higher survival/birth-rate then the religion itself will also win against alternatives. The truth of its dogma isn’t really relevant for this factor (unless we start considering interventionist deities, but that’s a different discussion entirely, as the above would apply across shared value/belief systems without the need for interventionism)

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by skissane on Sunday July 31, 2022 @06:23AM (#32294593)
> Nah, if religious belief helps group cohesion in such a way that we get societies that overall increase the likelihood of survival, then the truth of said religion is irrelevant.

Would you still endorse the same statement if one replaced “religious” with something else, say “philosophical”?

Also, is that saying “the truth of a belief is irrelevant, so long as it has pragmatic benefits”? But, doesn’t that undermine one of the key arguments for the truth of scientific claims - the pragmatic technological benefits of their acceptance?

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by woodruffw on Sunday July 31, 2022 @10:41AM (#32295818)
The person you’re responding to is making a positive claim, not a normative one: from the anthropological perspective, religions solve coordination problems. That doesn’t mean we ought to solve coordination problems with religion, it just means that it has a moderately successful track record.

See above re: fundamental misunderstanding of truth in science.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by einherjae on Sunday July 31, 2022 @07:20PM (#32299845)
Not quite sure where you’re going with the religion vs philosophy question, in the context of my statements the only real difference would be removing any threat of divine intervention, which itself may have some effect on the how well groups align with their shared beliefs. Read like that then yes, I would agree that the statement would apply for philosophy, but weaker.

As for your original post, you make a jump to stating that evolution would prefer truth, but that’s not a given simply from the fact that we perceive our world in such a way that we consider evolution. Evolution as we understand it is without intent, and only “prefers” that which in the long run yields further offspring.

A point I was trying to make was that the truthfulness of for instance religiosity doesn’t impact whether or not it has an effect on “fitness”. A religion can be entirely false, and yet contain memes that make its adherents’ genes procreate more successfully.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by woodruffw on Sunday July 31, 2022 @10:38AM (#32295791)
What does any of this have to do with the Amish?

You can’t be sure you’re arrived at the truth. Nothing about the philosophy of science expects you to be sure; it’s an inductive process that encourages increasing confidence, but never absolute certainty.

Evolution doesn’t “prefer” anything. It’s a stochastic adaptation process. The existence of religious beliefs is incredibly interesting from an anthropological perspective, but doesn’t really tell us anything about evolution itself.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by QuadmasterXLII on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:55PM (#32297245)
Oh shit you're right now I belive in thor and loki
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by skissane on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:11PM (#32297374)
It isn’t an argument that we should believe in any particular religion. So, even if it works, yes it works just as well for Norse paganism as for anything else.

But still, an argument that “some religion is probably true” would have value even if it can’t tell us which religion is true

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by tomcam on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:41AM (#32293737)
Having kids is probably no more work for them that it is you, and probably less. They’re willing to put kids to work doing substantial jobs from an early age.
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by praptak on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:30AM (#32293690)
> by winning at evolution

You may roll down a hill but it doesn't mean you win at gravity theory.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by deepdriver on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:48AM (#32293775)
In the fullness of time, those who name the winners are the ones who reproduced.
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by legitster on Sunday July 31, 2022 @01:35AM (#32293462)
Kids are actually pretty easy if you don't have a ton of distractions. Most complaints about how kids are difficult are about how they keep you from the things you want to do.

They also have huge economies of scale.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by _delirium on Sunday July 31, 2022 @02:25AM (#32293668)
> They also have huge economies of scale.

One of my grandmothers was one of 10 kids, and liked to relate that her parents always said it was the first 4 kids who were the hardest. After that, they start to look after themselves! Older kids act as babysitters for younger kids, etc.

Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by kenneth on Sunday July 31, 2022 @06:36AM (#32294652)
If your goal is simply to increase population as the end goal, then sure I guess the Amish are winning. I know it's generally accepted that population growth is always desirable, but I am not at all convinced of it. I would love to see a significant reversal of the trend and see population decline — especially in deeply religious families. (It's my opinion that religion is a net negative for the world these days, some more than others.)
Re:2022 Amish Population Profile by Gatsky on Sunday July 31, 2022 @06:26AM (#32294607)
Beyond the lack of belief in deities part, atheism is not really a coherent philosophy or a label which reliably defines a group of people. As such it doesn’t make sense to put forward an atheism versus X argument. Atheism is the rejection of various belief systems, not an alternative to them. It simply has none of the advantages or disadvantages of such belief systems. It does not even imply that the atheist has actually contended with any metaphysical questions.