News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by dvdhsu on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:14AM (#32264581)
Hi all, founder @ Retool here. We've made a lot of progress over the past few years, but we first started on HN, and certainly wouldn't be here without all of you!

For example, here's when we launched: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14515494. Hilariously, we described Retool as "Excel with higher order primitives", and people understood it! (Only on HN!)

After that, we spent around a year polishing the product and getting customers, and we launched officially on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17725966.

Today, we have tens of thousands of paying customers, are ~cashflow-positive, and have substantial revenue. But we are yet still so far from changing how internal software is built. Our thesis is that a Visual Basic-like application builder is a better way of building a certain segment of software (namely, internal CRUD apps). If you have any feedback or ideas on how we can improve the product, please do let me know (in comments or via email).

Oh, here's our blog post too: https://retool.com/blog/series-c2/. It has some details about our weird fundraising strategy (smaller rounds, lower valuation), which we think is more employee-friendly (lower dilution, more upside for employees). Happy to talk through that as well; here's another article about it: https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexkonrad/2021/12/22/retool-un...

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by Mandatum on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:02PM (#32271094)
I love the demo. I love the tooling.

Demo tips: Name your queries. Following along "query1, query2, query3" is confusing. You should following best practice (where it makes sense) during demos, and you're definitely not doing it.

The selling point of this tool shouldn't be for the developer, it should be for the manager. So add some "here are some other examples of tools we've created in a similar amount of time through a similar process" - then have UX's for different companies, industries, regions.

Non-technical management need ideas. This demo doesn't give it beyond "hey look you can create a button to update a table". So what? Every ERP and CRM SaaS has that!

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by krithix on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:52PM (#32271484)
(I work at Retool.) Appreciate the feedback! We are re-recording this video in the next few months. I'll make sure that we use better query names (and other best practices) in that video.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by pxue on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:47PM (#32272619)
Hey David, late last year my cofounder convinced me to try out Retool so we can rapidly spin up a prototype for a potential customer.

We spun up the prototype in a couple of weeks without much hassle. It was a huge success. so much so that the customer who we created the prototype for decided to invest 6 figures into our business.

it's 6 months later, albeit we've outgrown the prototype, I've learnt valuable lesson in prototyping fast, like as fast as you can and get it out the door.

looking forward in seeing what retool can become next. more stability, or ability to write/perform some automated testing would be amazing.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by alextapper on Friday July 29, 2022 @12:24AM (#32273117)
Alex here from the Retool team. We recently added a feature to write tests in your Retool apps: https://docs.retool.com/docs/testing

Coming to CI soon as well: https://docs.retool.com/docs/testing-in-ci

Thanks for being a customer! Glad that it worked out for you and your team :)

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by doctor_eval on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:35PM (#32271360)
Congrats. I think retool could be great, and I really wanted to use it for our internal tooling, but we operated in Australia and the lag was just nuts. Latency was over 1 second for a page view, compared to ~10ms for a locally hosted UI - it was unusable, and there didn’t seem to be any way to get a local server instance.

Hopefully this is something money can fix :)

the problem was the sum of UI latency to US(?) plus latency of serial API calls to get the data. We could probably have lived with a full rendering time of 100ms or so, but responsiveness requirements don’t scale linearly. So with a few round trips, it quickly became insurmountable.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by dvdhsu on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:43PM (#32271415)
Yes, this is something our infra team is working on right now. As of today, somebody in Australia, with a database hosted in Australia, experiences two round-trips in order to get data (client => our backend => database => our backend => client). We are working on deploying our database connector in far more regions so this won't be a problem. I think ETA is ~next two months? Will check in with team now...

An alternative is our self-serve on-premise product: https://retool.com/self-hosted/, which you can host in your own EC2. Given this latency issue is our fault, if you want a discount, just reach out to me; I'm david AT. Happy to provide a discount until we go multi-region with our backend.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by snir on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:46PM (#32271810)
Hi all, I'm Snir -- I lead engineering here at Retool.

I wanted to follow up on the above. Solving the round trip problem David mentioned above involves multi-region for our entire backend, inclusive of our DB. This is definitely a priority and something we plan on having by EoY.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by doctor_eval on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:53PM (#32271858)
Hi, thanks to both for your answers. I could see that it was a round trip problem, and it’s good to know you’re aware of it. Despite trying really hard, the latency made it unusable.

Also IIRC, there was way more than 2 round trips .. I think my UI made a few (GraphQL) API calls and they appeared to be serialised, so it really was in the order of 1-2 seconds for a page to load. This was 18 months ago so both my memory and your implementation might have changed since then.

In terms of using retool, unfortunately that particular ship has sailed for me, but I’ll be quite happy to reconsider it in any of my new projects once you have a solution that is a couple of hundred light-milliseconds closer :)

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by mullwaden on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:21AM (#32273757)
We are also having the same issue, even in Europe the round trips add up. Our sales team uses retool as their crm system and for them the slowness is quite painful. We will be self hosting soon, but it is some work so this is unfortunate.

Another topic of interest is managing queries. What happens if a database column is renamed for example? Now we manage it though stored queries in our db - this creates some dependencies and there is always a risk that old queries are no longer used or some query has not been updated. A single place to manage and overview all queries would go a long way (maybe this exists, I have only had a small part in the implementation).

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by alistairw on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:51PM (#32271477)
In the exact same boat. Love retool and using it a lot for interfaces we want to whip up quickly, but the performance is terrible. We're just copping it at the moment since we don't have the time to invest in any other options!
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by dvdhsu on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:10PM (#32271596)
Performance is our #2 priority for our engineering team this quarter. We have made some notable gains, but there is much more work to do. Thank you for the feedback and for sticking with us; we are hard at work on it, and expect to deliver more performance wins over the next few months. (If there are tips you want on improving app performance, feel free to reach out to me; we are happy to get an engineer from our side to help debug why things are slow.)
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by alistairw on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:20PM (#32271642)
Thanks for the reply! Sounds like your response to the parent — database connectors in other regions — will help resolve this. So we're happy to stick it out for now
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by jollybean on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:50AM (#32265113)
Congrats. You guys are actually doing a 'holy grail' type thing and having some success, that's very cool. I don't think it's about 'what' these days, ideas are easy, but always in the 'how' i.e. how it's executed. Very impressive, well done.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by alexk307 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:24AM (#32264736)
Congrats on the funding and evaluation! At first, I was admittedly skeptical of yet another low code tool, but this seems pretty powerful. I think there is a large segment of the market that needs a drag and drop Visual Studio editor to build simple data workflows. Do you manage the underlying database for the customers, or are they connecting their own managed data stores? What are the most common use cases that you've seen large customers use this for?
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by dvdhsu on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:28AM (#32264788)
Yes, that is our target market too. We don't think people will be building airbnb.com (say) in Retool, but not all software is like that. (In fact, we think most software is probably just CRUD apps, haha.)

We don't manage the database for customers; we instead connect to your data (whether it's behind an API or database). That was one of the first decisions we made — as a developer, if my data is already in postgres, I certainly wouldn't want to have to ETL / sync it anywhere. :)

Use cases: probably our most common use case is a CRM for a consumer company (e.g. Doordash). The reason that is so popular is because if you have (say) 1M orders a day, you aren't able to put that data in Salesforce anymore. And so the only way for you to manage all that stuff is by building custom software (instead of buying anything off the shelf). Retool is good at that: you can build CRUD-y screens very quickly. Retool, today, is not good at making everything pixel perfect (e.g. we have a grid layout engine, and you can't break out of the grid), but a CRM doesn't need to be pixel perfect.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by tofuahdude on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:15PM (#32266386)
> if you have (say) 1M orders a day, you aren't able to put that data in Salesforce anymore

Could you clarify in what way you can't put 1M orders a day into Salesforce?

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by Mandatum on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:09PM (#32271150)
Salesforce has a limitation of 50,000 records for any operation. 1,000,000 records for read-only operations.

If you go beyond that, you talk to Salesforce about it, because they can make adjustments for you - and you can likely afford it.

Salesforce will bend over backwards and make internal engineering changes for large customers, including adjusting governor limits, dedicating hardware and running backend queries directly for the customer.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by te_chris on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:15PM (#32268183)
Because you measure your fees in yachts at that point.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by njudah on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:18PM (#32268239)
Having any object / table in Salesforce > 1M rows is somewhat exceptional; doing that daily (using standard Salesforce capabilities) is off the charts -- just moving amount of data into Salesforce within a 24 hr window is questionable. Its built for B2B, where the data volumes are much lower, and conversely the kinds of operations / workflows you want to do on that data are typically more complex.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by madrox on Thursday July 28, 2022 @11:10PM (#32272739)
Wanted to say that I love your product. I've only started using it in the last two months, but it's the best backoffice tool I've had the pleasure to work with. You guys are really onto something. I wish you all the success.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by drunkpotato on Thursday July 28, 2022 @09:36PM (#32272164)
A combination of building back-end services and retool admin apps to interact with them has been super successful for us. Congrats on the great product!
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by no_wizard on Thursday July 28, 2022 @11:00AM (#32265272)
I do see you pivoted away from some developer tooling things, like mock APIs generated from your database schema (that was a thing previous, no?). While I see you have the mock api generator service, I seem to recall you guys had a more robust paid offering that would read your database schema and spin up a mock API.

Any reason you pivoted away from that product? I quite literally am in search of a company that will do this that doesn't also want to be our API provider in production.

EDIT: I also want to point out, I really like how mature the product has become from the time I looked into it last (I wan to say maybe a year ago, maybe year and half). Seriously considering replacing some internal admin functionality with it.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by dvdhsu on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:58PM (#32271524)
Ah, we still have a way of generating mock APIs: https://retool.com/api-generator. You can upload a CSV (we'll parse the columns and guess types for each one), and then generate mock data and put it into an AIP for you: https://retool.com/utilities/generate-api-from-csv.

In the future, we'd love to make it more robust; we're currently working on a database-y product (think Airtable, but backed by postgres). It would be really cool to have mock data-generation built in to that product.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by hanniabu on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:19AM (#32273415)
Wow this is amazing, how have I not seen this before. Looking forward to all the continued improvements and additional features!
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by tomhallett on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:01PM (#32266166)
I have nothing todo with Retool, but I'm curious about the problem you are trying to solve. What do you want to consume the mock api?

a) Is this for rapid prototypes? (web? mobile?) b) Do you have a microservice architecture and you want to mock out one of the services? (dev? ci?) c) something else?

Lets say the generator looks at your schema and generates an api, how much would you want to tweak/customize that api?

Is the mock api returning data based on what's in the database? If so, can the mock api mutate data in the database?

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by no_wizard on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:37PM (#32266702)
Cloud services have a real problem, they don't all have nice emulators for data or seeding. I'd love to setup a sandboxed test database automatically, and seed it with random data based on that schema (and perhaps some heuristics, like intentionally breaking some entries or random incomplete data sets)

and I'd like do it without incurring the cost of maintaining this fully in house. I know in some cases, like with GraphQL, I can do this somewhat easy if I use a 3rd party service, I know with something like AppSync there is some potential to run it locally via an emulator, but honesty the DX story around Cloud services is kind of crappy, and this would go a long way in solving that story.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by Hansenq on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:47PM (#32268599)
Interesting...would it be accurate to say that the issue you're facing is being able to generate and access mock data for testing purposes?

I'm working on building something in this space. Would love to chat with you about your use case; mind emailing me at hq@ withcodex.com? Thanks!

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by Dyac on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:07PM (#32270120)
Hi, congrats on the funding!

I've been really interested in trying retool since my head of ops pointed me to it a few months back. I think it should meet my use-case but I'm not entirely sure.

I run an experimentation program and I think retool might give me a way to build views on experiment performance for me and my stakeholders, but what I think it may be missing is some way of running statistics on the data, perhaps using python or R.

Data "about" my experiments (descriptions, tags, dates & times, stakeholder details etc) lives in airtable. I think I can get that into retool using sequin, right?

Performance data lives in bigquery. Sessions, clicks, conversions - all that stuff.

Right now I build ad-hoc reports in R/excel/data studio but as our velocity increases I need to streamline this.

I think what I'd like is for a stakeholder to be able to select the experiments and timeframes that they're interested in from a list, then behind the scenes the ID details to then be used to run a query in bigquery and that to pull back performance data. I'd like to show that in charts and tables on screen with how much impact the experiments have had (I think so far this should be reasonably straightforward with retool), but crucially I want to calculate confidence bounds for each metric.

Is there any way of bringing Python or R into the data flow somehow to do the heavy statistical lifting?

Am I looking at this the wrong way? Should I be trying to pre-calculate this nightly as some sort of scheduled job and just use retool as a presentation layer?

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by jkradddic on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:41PM (#32271777)
Retool PM here. This sounds like a good use case for Retool! (I built something similar to join performance data with metadata using Retool in my last role).

While we don't currently support using Python or R in apps, we do have something new shipping soon that'll make it easier to run heavier statistical lifting server side. If you're interested in a beta access, or even pairing on a build session, let me know at [email protected].

Also, I think pre-calculating values and storing them in a database table is a smart idea if your velocity is increasing and you want folks to be able to access reports themselves. Your users will get a snappier app and you'll have a historical record of experiment results to reference.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by throw12321 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:01PM (#32266169)
Just to say that we're actively switching away from retool because you insist on charging £10 a month users who are a simply view form thats already built. I can understand charging for building and launching a form, I can understand charging something for a view only, but the same as builder? na I think not. Good luck with your pricing
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by arjie on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:22PM (#32266478)
A long time ago, I was at their offices and I asked them about this. If this is a limiter for you, I'm sure you could get a customized pricing plan from them if you reach out.

I believe AppSmith is a FOSS alternative, otherwise.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by santa_boy on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:41PM (#32271399)
Yes Appsmith, Tooljet and Budibase are great FOSS alternatives.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by foxbee on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:55AM (#32273611)
Thanks for mentioning Budibase. I'm the cofounder and I'd like to add one or two points.

On top of Retools functionality, Budibase also comes with an automation platform, internal db and a lot more flexibility when it comes to design and deployment.

Here's our GitHub repo for anyone interested: https://github.com/Budibase/budibase

#devtoolsshouldbeopensource

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by Mandatum on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:13PM (#32271180)
It's certainly not a cheap SaaS, but if you get enough value out of it - it makes sense. For your use-case, it sounds like it doesn't scale and you can't justify the pricing structure they've setup.

The best thing you can do is what you've already done. Post about it publicly, let your AE know.

Hope Appsmith, Budibase, Tooljet, Bubble, et al work out!

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by dvdhsu on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:05PM (#32271568)
I'm sorry; we are actively working on our pricing model right now. (We today launched a 5-seats-for-free plan: https://retool.com/blog/new-free-plan-2022/.) I think charging for end-users does make sense, but we need to think about exactly how much (as you note). Thank you for your feedback!

Oh, while we are actively thinking about pricing, if Retool is out of budget for you, please do reach out to david AT. We are always happy to be flexible on price; our goal is to convince more people that Retool is a better way for building CRUD software, not to maximize revenue. We never want pricing to a blocker for anybody. (Reaching out to me is obviously not a long-term solution, but is a good one while we think about what our future pricing plans look like.)

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by Closi on Friday July 29, 2022 @07:19AM (#32275543)
I think charging for end users does make sense too in the context of building internal tools, it just means that other use cases (e.g. building public apps) is not possible.

Love retool! This new 5-seat plan will mean we can get started with Retool internally properly now on a trial basis, and hopefully upgrade in the future when we decide to roll it out!

(Although there do seem to be some bugs with the new plan - it keeps repeatedly telling me that i'm not licenced to edit things and that my trial is over so I can't quite start using it yet).

Also I can't use it for my personal projects as the commercial model doesn't quite work, so I use AppSmith for that.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by antonybello on Friday July 29, 2022 @10:51AM (#32277678)
Hi there, super happy the new Free plan would work well for you!

I’d try visiting our billing page under settings/billing and see if you can select the free plan from there. If that doesn’t work, send me a note at [email protected] and we’d be happy to fix this.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by jarek83 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:40PM (#32268502)
I jumped on to see a demo and got stuck at the start where it wants me to add DB credentials. First thing is that I just wanted to fool around to see what I can do with it - it would be nice to have some playground DB for that instead of having to connect an existing set. Second thing - I'd be kind of hesitant giving access to my production DB to it this way. Do you consider adding some credentials store so I could feel that you guys cannot use it from your side (in case you get hacked)?
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by eeke on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:00PM (#32271537)
We have something for exactly this situation shipping very soon! Happy to give you beta access if you'd like to drop me a quick note from the email you signed up with ([email protected]).
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by jarek83 on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:16PM (#32281862)
Well, no wonder your business has great traction when you are so involved :) Thank you for the invitation! I've just sent you a msg from an inbox starting with tylkointernet
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by eeke on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:17PM (#32271629)
On your second question, there is a zero-trust way of using Retool via our self-hosted version, which installs in a few minutes via Docker (https://retool.com/self-hosted/). If you want, you can even fully airgap your Retool instance such that no data goes in or out. (In the future we are also thinking about how we can integrate with credentials stores!)
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by barking_biscuit on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:31PM (#32272522)
Wait, how new is the new free plan? A co-worker of mine linked me this recently saying it might be good for some internal tooling (which I totally agree!) and I wanted to hack around with it in anger on my own first before being comfortable making any sort of pitch internally for it but when I checked the free plan (at the time) it put me off. But now it looks like quite a bit more friendly...
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by onphonenow on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:40AM (#32273533)
I'll check it out again myself if there is a useable free plan! We are paying 20k per year for some apps we got hooked on for free - nothing beats actully trying product and I'm often so busy it takes 45 days to get back to something
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by aliasxneo on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:38PM (#32272563)
Must be pretty new. I used it earlier this year and was also turned off by the free plan. It used to be for one admin and you could only look at it through the editor view.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by antonybello on Thursday July 28, 2022 @11:34PM (#32272873)
Hi! It’s hot off the press— we just launched it today!
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by hanniabu on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:13AM (#32273394)
Hey, I started a free trial a while back and didn't have the time to dig in, but this post made me go back and check it out. I have a red message bar at top saying "Your trial has ended. You will be unable to create or edit Retool pages."and it seems I can't use the new free plan.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by tsemenov on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:18AM (#32273414)
Hi there, so sorry to hear that. I’d try visiting our billing page under settings/billing and see if you can select the free plan from there. If that doesn’t work, send me a note at [email protected] and we’d be happy to fix this
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by hanniabu on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:34AM (#32273492)
Took a few minutes but I realized that white downgrade was clickable. The color and text difference threw me off.

I do have a question about plans if you happen to know the answer. I see there's an option to share an app publicly (I'm assuming this wouldn't require people to log in to view?), but when I select it I'm shown and error that my current plan doesn't support this. But when I go to view the plans none of them mention a public view feature so I have no idea which one I would actually need for that.

Also do you guys have any programs to sponsor small open source projects with free or discounted higher tier plans? I'd love to migrate my open source project over (a dashboard that tracks various metrics), but I would need the publicly viewable options and I'm not sure I can cover the cost since I'm doing this pro-bono.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by dvdhsu on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:49AM (#32273844)
I just sent you an email. We love open source, and would love to support you in any way possible!

On public apps: we are in the process of creating a separate pricing package for that based on something other than users (e.g. pageviews). Since you're working on an open source project, we're happy to offer it to you for free; will follow up over email.

Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by barking_biscuit on Friday July 29, 2022 @06:47AM (#32275333)
Awesome! Super excited to try this out properly now.
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by password4321 on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:49AM (#32273582)
Maybe support GitHub auth?
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by joshu on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:11PM (#32269523)
It's amazing how far you've come since Demo Day! I regret not making time for you then!
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by snarkypixel on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:36PM (#32267683)
Product looks really cool, well done
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by dgudkov on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:36PM (#32269165)
Quite rapid growth! I'm curious, what in your marketing strategy worked best?
Re:Retool raises $45M at a $3.2B valuation by jinen83 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:49AM (#32265094)
Founder of DronaHQ here - a semi bootstrapped retool alternative with hundreds of customers. As someone playing along side in this huge market - this is awesome news to hear and congrats to the retool team.