News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by jeppester on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:02PM (#32257616)
It's been known for years - and hardly takes a lawyer to understand - that sending user data to US-owned companies is illegal according to GDPR. The US laws are simply incompatible.

Yet everyone (including government entities) have been dragging their feet on and on hoping for some divine intervention to help them continue using Google, Amazon and Microsoft. And those companies have kept the hopes high by incorrectly claiming to be GDPR compliant.

It's been embarrassing to witnes how little willingness there's been shown towards protecting user data. Especially compared to the amount of whining over how difficult it is to comply.

Hopefully these - very predictable - rulings will finally start to get the ball rolling.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by mminer237 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:12PM (#32257693)
I think it's because over 40% of EU business use the cloud[1] and 70% of those use AWS, Azure, or GCS.[2] Enforcing the law consistently would devastate tons of EU businesses as you would suddenly eliminate all of their tech infrastructure overnight with no real alternatives.

[1]: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...

[2]: https://www.fiercetelecom.com/platforms/european-cloud-provi...

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by jeppester on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:23PM (#32257816)
The businesses have had more than enough time to comply with the law.

Now is the time to start enforcing the law enough to make them actually care.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by fjfbsufhdvfy on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:47AM (#32260859)
It is not possible to comply with this law as a small or even fairly large business if it prevents you from using the only viable major cloud services which are required for the operation of your business. Do you want the EU to delete the rest of their already behind tech industry?
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by martin_a on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:11AM (#32261333)
Bullshit.

Why would those cloud services be required to run a business?

We're doing just fine without them, hosting fonts locally, using Matomo, saving data on servers from EU companies.

Its's possible, although Google etc. will of course tell you otherwise.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by fastest963 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:23AM (#32262125)
Do these EU hosting companies also have servers available in other continents like North America? Could you operate a sufficiently global website from these hosting companies?

Do they have S3-style or Pub/Sub-style features or do you have to build those in-house or maintain something off-the-shelf?

If you're a small website maybe you can get by but if you get large you'll probably find you don't have many other options.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by nephanth on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:09AM (#32264506)
Yes they do

- https://www.ovhcloud.com/en/datacenters-ovhcloud/

- https://upcloud.com/about

and others. The european cloud providers clearly don’t have as many features or market share as the GAFAM (they also tend to be more specialized), but contrary to what a lot of people here seem to believe, they have enough for most uses

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by fjfbsufhdvfy on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:10PM (#32268127)
Let's compare some costs then. As a random example, but not an unreasonable one, we have 100 1GB files stored for one year, and we want to deliver each of them 10000 times.

With Cloudflare R2, this will cost roughly $16. With upcloud, this will cost roughly $10,000.

You see how this can easily be the difference between a business being viable and... not?

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by nephanth on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @09:19AM (#32331311)
You're taking a specific case (low amount of data, high egress) and comparing an offer specialized for that use case (r2) with a general-purpose offer. Amazon S3, for example, would not perform better than upcloud here (I calculated $50,000), and that comparison may be more adapted.

Though I agree that neither ovh nor upcloud have an offer tailored to that use (I think in that case using a CDN instead may be the more adapted). That offer may or may not exist on the EU market but I'm too lazy to search for it

On a sidenote, I didn't know about r2, thanks for the tip

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by fjfbsufhdvfy on Thursday August 04, 2022 @09:33AM (#32342661)
I don't think any offer exists that competes with R2 currently, if you want to deliver large amounts of data. That's why I consider access to this service critical for business.

The closest you can get is renting servers with unmetered 1-10gbit connections and serving it yourself, but because you don't have the economy of scale that Cloudflare does, it will still be much more expensive than R2. You can't balance out your costs against those of hundreds of other customers that don't serve as much data, or against customers serving data at different times where your unmetered bandwidth would be wasted.

Starting up a service with pricing like R2 is only really possible at Cloudflare scale too, so it's not like it's possible for someone like us to see this gap in the market and... fix it?

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by origin_path on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:05AM (#32262449)
The problems here will really start when someone notices that:

1. Everyone is using US based web browsers and operating systems.

2. Those systems do a variety of "phone home" tasks like phishing checks, OCSP checks, translations, search auto predictions etc.

What happens when CNIL follows its own logic further and bans Chrome, Android, iOS, Windows and macOS?

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by progval on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:09AM (#32262815)
CNIL and other GDPR enforcement agencies do not ban products directly; they fine companies infringing GDPR. The article above is about orders to companies using Google Analytics.

Regarding browsers and operating systems, the companies selling them will be fined until they either comply with the law (ie. either by removing any "phone american home" task, or by using any of the alternatives provided by article 6 paragraph 1) or stop doing business in the EU.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by fjfbsufhdvfy on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:05AM (#32264460)
Please suggest an EU based competitor to Cloudflare services with comparable performance and pricing in the same order of magnitude.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by hansel_der on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:07AM (#32261298)
good point!

it's far from 'required for the operation' it's just convenient.

i.e. dumping waste enywhere is convenient and cheap, but if your business cannot survive otherwise, it's hard to argue for it's right to exist.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by closewith on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:38AM (#32260824)
Most businesses affected by this would have gone bankrupt if they had pre-emptively complied. Compliance means being unable to effectively use any of the major online advertising services.

So while you could theoretically migrate from US cloud services (although where to is the question. Hertzner for cloud compute? Open Office for Office 365?), there’s no search engine or social network controlled in a country with a data adequacy decision.

That means effectively no online advertising. If a company followed that route while all their competitors did not, their demand generation would have plummeted and they'd be out-of-business.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by tpxl on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:38AM (#32261133)
> That means effectively no online advertising.

Wat.

You can't sell out your users to google ads, that doesn't mean you can't advertise on google.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by closewith on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:49AM (#32261210)
In practice, it does. It's impossible to use any of the major ad networks effectively without conversion tracking (which is what I'm assuming you're calling selling out? I disagree with that sentiment, given it amounts to sending a single pseudoanonymous ID with user consent).

Edit: To be clear, most European enterprise companies would happily dump Google Analytics if not for Google Ads and the Search Console integration. Almost all will be already be using another tool for user analytics, but most online B2C companies are reliant on Google for demand generation, and Google Ads is only effective with conversion tracking.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by tpxl on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:49AM (#32262325)
Does conversion tracking require you to track your users (a la google analytics), or is it actually just a pseudo'anonymous' parameter when visiting a website (like referrer could be, if advertisers hadn't killed it).

And even then, advertising without tracking worked just fine without internet.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by closewith on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:39AM (#32262659)
It requires getting consent and sending the value of a query parameter that was appended to the ad link the user clicked (GCLID for Google, FBCLID for Meta, etc) with some random (but now pseudonymous, because Google/Facebook/etc can link the session ID to the click ID to a user account) session ID and then sending that same session ID when the user converts/does the thing you want.

If you get consent, you can also set a longer-lived cookie to determine if a user converts in a future visit.

> And even then, advertising without tracking worked just fine without internet.

There is even now a form of online advertising without any tracking (except in the most opt-in form of a discount code) which is sponsorships of videos, podcasts, articles, etc.

However, for search and display ads, which drives a huge amount of traffic to EU businesses, there's no effective way to run ads without conversion tracking. Obviously you can just throw money at Google/Facebook, but without conversion tracking, the average return on advertising spend will be 1-10% of what it would be otherwise and you will pay for a lot of junk traffic.

It's not unusual for B2C companies in the EU to make 80%+ of their online revenue from forms of ads that require conversion tracking, so it's impossible to expect businesses to refrain from online advertising unless all their competitors are required to also.

This all relies on getting consent as a lawful basis for processing, and is currently acceptable under the GDPR except that the major networks are all US companies who could be compelled to transfer the data to US authorities.

Even now, it is much more likely that a US CLOUD carve-out or other work-around for an adequacy decision with the US will be made than the CNIL interpretation will be followed to its logical conclusion, which is that EU businesses process personal data with any US-controlled vendor, even if it occurs in the EU.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by tpxl on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:38AM (#32262995)
Sorry for asking so many questions, but I don't know much about this and you seem knowledgeable.

> However, for search and display ads, which drives a huge amount of traffic to EU businesses, there's no effective way to run ads without conversion tracking. Obviously you can just throw money at Google/Facebook, but without conversion tracking, the average return on advertising spend will be 1-10% of what it would be otherwise and you will pay for a lot of junk traffic.

1. Can you not track conversion in aggregate by running X number of ads and checking how much extra traffic you got? It's obviously noisy and you can't run multiple campaigns at the same time, but conceptually I don't see why it wouldn't work?

2. I'm assuming you put links in your ads, so if you run ads for lander.example.com, can you not put the URL in google/facebook as lander.example.com?src=g and src=fb? Or, if you can't use query params, g.lander.example.com and fb.lander.example.com? Tracking stats for those and seeing how much ads you ran should give you conversion, similar to 1. but better?

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by closewith on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:02AM (#32263178)
No problem.

> 1. Can you not track conversion in aggregate by running X number of ads and checking how much extra traffic you got? It's obviously noisy and you can't run multiple campaigns at the same time, but conceptually I don't see why it wouldn't work?

You can and many companies will have a first-party (or partly first-party, feeding into PowerBI or Tableau or something) system for this kind of reporting completely independent of the ad networks (to independently verify the numbers the ad networks claim, to include other data that a company would never share with Google, and for fraud detection).

However, without conversion tracking, Google Ads' "Smart Bidding" and "Remarketing" targeting features don't work. For a lot of businesses, being unable to, for example, stop advertising to existing customers or to use a certain bidding strategy means that the Return On Advertising Spend (ROAS - the big metric for enterprise marketing departments) goes below 1.

> 2. I'm assuming you put links in your ads, so if you run ads for lander.example.com, can you not put the URL in google/facebook as lander.example.com?src=g and src=fb? Or, if you can't use query params, g.lander.example.com and fb.lander.example.com? Tracking stats for those and seeing how much ads you ran should give you conversion, similar to 1. but better?

Companies often do this, with Google Analytics-compatible UTM parameters, custom source IDs, and very often unique marketing landing pages for each ad campaign.

As above, though, reliable reporting of conversions/revenue isn't the difficult part. It's being able to reliably target the ads/campaigns without conversion tracking.

Right now, targeted search and display advertising can be 10-100x more effective (in terms of Return On Advertising Spend) than keyword- or context-only targeting. That's not an advantage a company can forgo unless the entire market is forced to simultaneously.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by GekkePrutser on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:15AM (#32261364)
No online advertising sounds amazing . Although that's really the status quo for me the last few years with the amazing adblockers we have now.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by closewith on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:35AM (#32262228)
It's not really the status quo you've experienced, as it's likely you've used ad funded services in that time.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by macinjosh on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:39PM (#32257969)
Clearly, even the EU doesn’t care enough to enforce the law or they would have already. They’ve literally had years.

What does it say about the credibility of the EU that it passes laws it doesn’t even enforce?

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by josefx on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:25AM (#32262144)
> They’ve literally had years.

Almost exactly 2. The last agreement between the US and EU was nuked by Schrems II mid 2020.

> What does it say about the credibility of the EU that it passes laws it doesn’t even enforce?

Companies have already been successfully sued over it.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by krageon on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:35AM (#32261465)
> devastate Not having AWS/Azure/GCS is not devastating. It's just a little bit different. Those platforms quite simply don't add many interesting features and the reason people use them in the EU is largely based on cargo-culting.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by theplumber on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:13AM (#32261653)
The cloud business is now a commodity.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by Nursie on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:00AM (#32260641)
I'm still annoyed that gov.uk, all the while being praised for great web design, happily recorded all interactions between UK citizens and UK government, and sent them off to google.

And refused to engage on why that might be a bad idea, because hey, we find it useful, and Google pinky-swear they anonymise everything.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by closewith on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:43AM (#32260846)
Ireland uses Microsoft's Azure Active Directory to auth for the national digital ID system, MyGovID.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by GekkePrutser on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:19AM (#32261386)
Ireland is a sucker for big tech interests though. Because so many of them use the country for tax avoidance they have a really big influence on politics. Like when the EU made Apple actually pay the small amount of tax they should have, Ireland jumped up to oppose. They were opposed to receiving a billion euros.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by oliwarner on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:20PM (#32257782)
It was legal under the "Privacy Shield" until Schrems II, and is still legal under Standard Contractual Clauses with extra caveats for the US.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by closewith on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:40AM (#32260832)
What's happening now is that CNIL (and other DPAs) are ruling that SCCs are not sufficient protection (in certain specific cases).
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by matkoniecz on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:15AM (#32261661)
Not really - Schrems II revealed that it was actually invalid and illegal.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by shakamone on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:43PM (#32258019)
This answer is accurate but no one seems to realise it. Under standard contracts users waive their rights including privacy rights under GDPR. Their are no user agreements anymore, only contracts.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by rtsil on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @07:59PM (#32258713)
The CNIL's page says that standard contracts do not offer adequate protections and as such are insufficient.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by martin8412 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:39AM (#32260548)
No such thing. You can't sign away your rights. The end.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by abigail95 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:03AM (#32260936)
If you're in the EU you don't have the right to give your IP address to a US company?

Your own IP address?

What's the point of having personal data if you aren't allowed to make decisions about it

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by martin8412 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:30AM (#32261091)
You can absolutely choose to share your data with an US company, but you can also withdraw consent five seconds later, making it illegal for them to further process the data. The point is, that it is your personal data, and only you get to say what can and can't be done with it. That right can't be signed away.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by xalava on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:42AM (#32261159)
European laws have a different approach regarding most individual rights. They are socially defined and distinguished from ownership.

Your body for instance is probably better protected in terms of chemical additives, healthcare and now pregnancy choices, but you can't easily sell body parts or be a surrogate.

Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by GekkePrutser on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:17AM (#32261374)
You do but you can't be forced to agree, including by not being able to use the service if you decline.
Re:CNIL makes Google Analytics almost illegal in France by oliwarner on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:56AM (#32274212)
I'm not sure about that second part.

If a service operator decides they don't want you using their service, they don't have to let you use it. That only gets murky around protected characteristics (race, sex, gender, orientation, etc) which "privacy" is not.

They could make access contingent on being allowed to process your data.