Haha came here to say the same thing. My stupid dog barks at everything. The wind, the sun, the rain, ants, if he thinks im home, if he thinks im leaving, if he sees me, if he doesnt see me, he even barks in his friggin sleep. Does he bark when he needs to take a piss or a shit and needs to go outside? Nope. Prick.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security
by worthless-trash on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @08:29PM
(#32258981)
Train your dog to piss or shit. If your dog likes food it should be very possible.
The dog also doesn't come with an off switch in case you have an important meeting with your CEO, taking it in your home office and there's a squirrel running around...
Oh dear. Can’t say I’ve had that problem...really ever.
How many squirrels have you had to chase/escort out so far?
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security
by andrewflnr on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @07:10PM
(#32258289)
Oh, I'm sure a squirrel outside is plenty to cause a problem. My dogs have historically not needed anything at all to actually be moving outside to trigger an endless barking spree.
Yep. Especially given big glass doors and squirrels that quickly realize barking dog behind the glass door poses no danger whatsoever, so it's ok to proceed with their business.
One of the cats in our neighborhood likes to sit in front of our glass doors to antagonize our dog. The dog goes nuts and the cat sits there washing itself.
The barking sure (though I set up my office in the basement because FAMILY LOUD and so when they go off, it's pretty well muffled and people on zoom calls don't even hear it), it was the "bringing a squirrel inside and then setting it loose in the house" part that I was wondering about, ha.
No I meant it is running around outside. Often literally around because there are fruit trees in the garden around the exit from the house, and there's a big glass door where the dog can see outside. The squirrels learn pretty quickly that we don't want the dog to actually catch the squirrel (who knows what it has eaten and what diseases it may have), but to the dog it's hard to see squirrel just going about its business right under his nose...
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security
by boomboomsubban on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @08:28PM
(#32258969)
I think you're confusing some awkward phrasing from the poster. They were taking the meeting with the CEO in their home office, and the squirrel was running around presumably outside causing the dog to bark.
But I can see how you read it as thet were having a meeting and the dog brought a squirrel into the home office and ran around.
That would be worse, but if we let the dog actually catch the squirrel it won't be running anymore... But we try very hard for that not to happen.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security
by technothrasher on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:29PM
(#32259384)
I don't know about during a meeting, but my count of squirrels I've had to chase/escort out of my house currently stands at two. Although only one escort was successful. The other one I thought had left, but I found its desiccated body under the ashes in my fireplace about a week later.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security
by rejectedstone on Thursday July 28, 2022 @09:57AM
(#32264355)
Certainly a feature. I recommend a sensitivity level which uses breeds for each level. I further recommend the highest sensitivity be "Great Pyrenees" as I can attest my dog barks at every false positive.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security
by FerretFred on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:37AM
(#32263456)
Came here to say that :) Our recently-adopted rescue terrier will bark at anything. Right now he's especially targeting birds that dare to land on our (his!) bird feeder.
It's definitely a feature. Next door get a delivery? Trigger!
Interesting! They might be both working from a similar algorithm.
That reminds me of the argument about sentience lately. Why can't a neural network be sentient if all our actions have been trained by interacting with the world since birth?
The operative word in your comment being "actions". What "actions" can (current generation) neural networks undertake? Can they initiate anything? Can they choose their own learning material? Can they even choose when or whether to repeat a certain training set?
There was a recent HN comment about this that I think illustrates the point well [0]:
experimentation is an act on the world to set its state and then measure it. That's what learning involves. These machines do not act on the world, they just capture correlations.
Wouldn't you say that a neural network that learns to play a game by playing the game does so via experimentation?
A lot of human "choice" is actually just a neuron firing or chemical in the brain going off
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security
by uj8efdjkfdshf on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @07:02PM
(#32258220)
Because most people define sentience as 'a black box that reacts meaningfully to inputs in a sufficiently unpredictable and inexplicable manner', and for most people (especially researchers in these fields), current neural networks do not meet this bar.
My real dog has the same feature, so you’re at least doing a good job mimicking nature, heh.