News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by kragen on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @12:58AM (#32234412)
Another entry in the list of "What is Bitcoin good for, anyway?"
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by Barrin92 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @02:09AM (#32234885)
"breaking the law" is the only entry in the "what is bitcoin good for" discussion that everyone already agrees on. I thought the point was getting away from that image though.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by s3tz on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @02:24AM (#32235010)
If the law is nonsense then breaking the law is a very good use case.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by kragen on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @09:53AM (#32238272)
At least for the time being the law does not prohibit Bitcoin transactions above NIS 6k, does it? So it's more like "getting the benefits of breaking the law, without breaking the law".
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by DocTomoe on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @02:28AM (#32235049)
lex iniusta non est lex. We've philosophically explored that idea for millenia. It's time to act on it.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by Barrin92 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:39PM (#32244412)
An unjust in that context is one that was passed without rightful authority or does not apply equally to all. It's not a shorthand for "I don't like the law".

Throughout the millenia I can assure you the idea of an unjust law has very little to do with the bitcoin mentality of "I like cash and I don't like high taxes, therefore I will evade state authority".

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by kragen on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @08:25PM (#32245656)
It sounds like your reading hasn't actually ranged through the "millenia". Sure, you can find people arguing what you're arguing (though mostly since the Renaissance) but you can also find plenty of people arguing the opposite.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by Barrin92 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:56PM (#32246436)
In The West (and certainly much more so in many Eastern traditions) the guiding principle has always roughly centered around what Tertuillian summed up as "render the image of Caesar, which is on the coin, to Caesar, and the image of God, which is on man, to God; so as to render to Caesar indeed money, to God yourself."

This idea to arbitrarily opt-out of the earthly authorities is a figment of internet anarchism. I'd honestly like to hear which historical thinker or regime suggests otherwise.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by kragen on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:28AM (#32247781)
Plato relates that everyone expected Socrates to evade state authority because he wouldn't like being sentenced to death; his Socrates is a daring rebel against conventional thinking by accepting his death sentence, not merely an expositor of that conventional thinking.

None of the characters of the Iliad would have recognized your idea that a law must apply equally to all to be legitimate; when Odysseus goes and smacks down the mutinous soldiers, he isn't appealing to some kind of abstract notion of equality before the law, but to inequality: namely, the superiority of kings like Agamemnon and himself over commoners, which rests on their martial virtue. Similar value systems can be found in Scandinavian sagas.

You don't find the idea of legal egalitarianism that is your sine qua non of legal legitimacy until after the Renaissance; until then it was taken for granted that some people naturally had more rights than others. Slaves, women, foreigners, veterans, nobles, and royalty were categories to which the law generally did not apply equally. Though, in some times and places, some of them were exempted from the special treatment that applied generally, that was the exception rather than the rule. Today usually only so-called "illegals", children, and felons find themselves outside the boundaries of legal egalitarianism. (Though any black person in the US who's visited white suburbs can tell you that sometimes equality before the law is only theoretical.) Switzerland, more egalitarian in most ways than the rest of Europe, didn't grant women the vote until 01959–71.

Tertullian and the whole Christian worldview to which he belonged were, like Socrates, rebels, against what they saw as the corrupt selfishness of the society around them—he wasn't just restating the conventional wisdom either. At the same time, though, Christianity was founded in lawlessness (Jesus casting the moneychangers out of the Temple was definitely not authorized by the authorities, and whether it happened or not it was evidently the sort of thing the early Christians approved of) and existed in open defiance of Roman law for over a century before Tertullian and another century after him, regardless of the fact that the laws they were breaking (against deprecating the Roman state religion) applied equally to all. Modern Christian sects have commonly preached disobedience to laws, including but not limited to laws requiring loyalty oaths, laws forbidding polygamy, conscription laws, laws establishing slavery, and, obviously, laws establishing state religions.

So, while many Christian sects do preach obedience, I think it makes more sense to read Tertullian as preaching poverty.

History is replete with tales of people rebelling against authority because they suffered under it, and just as replete with poets and philosophers glorifying and justifying their deeds. William Tell is the national hero of Switzerland, and Robin Hood was the national hero of England, for just such acts of rebellion. Today we have narcocorridos and gangsta rap. Sometimes philosophers argue against the legitimacy of particular forms of government or government in general (Proudhon, Marx, Bakunin, Goldman, Rorty's student Sartwell) and sometimes they argue for it.

Sartwell's Against the State is, I think, the most convincing modern argument I've read on the anarchist side of the aisle.

Usually the ones who argued for the legitimacy of the current form of government were the ones who got a position at court instead of living out their years in poverty and toil to survive, so we hear from them more.

In the modern context, Thoreau's and Gandhi's concept of civil disobedience, rooted profoundly in self-denial, is that your obligation to the law only extends so far as accepting the punishment the law metes out, as Socrates did; while they are not advocating "arbitrarily opting out of earthly authorities", they also definitely are not limiting their advocacy of civil disobedience to laws that are "passed without rightful authority or do[] not apply equally to all".

Outside of philosophy, though, you'll find that most people break the law without a second thought when they're sure they won't get caught. They don't worry about whether the speed limit was constituted by rightful authority or whether the US's Schedule I classification of marijuana applies equally to everyone; they worry about whether they'll get punished, and if so, how badly. And this has evidently been the case as long as there have been laws.

Of course most people don't go around robbing and cheating just because they can get away with it, but that's not because it's illegal; it's because they think it's bad, somewhat independently of what the law says. They think the law should punish actions that are bad; they don't think that actions become bad because someone has passed a law against them.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by vxNsr on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:01AM (#32234433)
Bitcoin is actually worse than this. Bitcoin is easily traceable and doesn’t solve the “anonymous money” problem that cold hard cash solves. Not only is Bitcoin easily traceable the record exists forever and is impossible to erase. There are other crypto products that attempt to solve this issue but Bitcoin is definitely not one of them.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by redox99 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:13AM (#32234508)
Bitcoin is much better in that it's pseudonymous (instead of 100% associated to your real identity) and cannot be censored (instead of your government being able to freeze your funds, only allow transferring from/to X, up to Y amount, etc).
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by etchalon on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:18AM (#32234539)
Modern forensics techniques make Bitcoin's pseudonymous nature more or less irrelevant.

Worse, anti-censorship only extends within Bitcoin itself. The moment Bitcoin has to touch traditional financial networks it becomes more easily censorable.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by redox99 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:32AM (#32234636)
> Modern forensics techniques make Bitcoin's pseudonymous nature more or less irrelevant.

How so? If I buy some bitcoin face to face, and receive it on a brand new address (not reusing addresses was something that satoshi himself emphasized ever since bitcoin came out) it's highly anonymous.

And before you say "yeah but nobody does that", I do that and a lot of people in my country do that.

> Worse, anti-censorship only extends within Bitcoin itself. The moment Bitcoin has to touch traditional financial networks it becomes more easily censorable.

I don't see the point here? If it's no longer bitcoin then of course it's properties don't apply anymore.

By the way I don't consider Bitcoin specifically a good replacement because it's not scalable, but my point applies to other potentially similar but scalable cryptocurrencies (maybe ETH in the future if they figure out scalability)

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by etchalon on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:39AM (#32234678)
> If I buy some bitcoin face to face, and receive it on a brand new address (not reusing addresses was something that satoshi himself emphasized ever since bitcoin came out) it's highly anonymous.

It's only "anonymous until use". If you transfer some amount to me, I can then retroactively find its source, and likely find a good deal of information about you and the other wallets you've used.

This is fairly rudimentary forensics work, and an unmaskable, centralized store of all transactions makes it trivial.

> I don't see the point here?

"Anti-censorship" properties that are worthless in real-world usage seem to be a fairly important flaw if we're talking about a technologies anti-censorship properties.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by redox99 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @02:50AM (#32235178)
> It's only "anonymous until use". If you transfer some amount to me, I can then retroactively find its source, and likely find a good deal of information about you and the other wallets you've used.

How is that? Let's say I go to PornHub and purchase premium (which is only purchasable with crypto). Assume tor usage to not have to worry about any kind of side channel identity leak. How could PornHub know who I am? At most, if the person who sold me the crypto face to face messed up and the address he used to send me the coins becomes identified, PornHub could assume

A) This is another address of his

or

B) This is the address of someone he conducted business with

Either way you would need to personally inquire him to leak my identity, in case he even knows it.

And this is assuming a trivial case without the use of mixers and so on.

Ideally you would want your wallet software to automatically handle all this stuff, and automatically clean your coins for you, generate new addresses, etc without you even knowing.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by etchalon on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:04AM (#32239333)
As with any thing OpSec, all it takes is one mistake to make your digital footprint clear.

I do not have the time or expertise to explain all the ways in which blockchain forensics is able to trace identities and ownership, but behold, it's an entire industry now. And isn't that much different from other forms of forensic accounting, which has been tracing money through labyrinths of shell companies and offshore accounts for decades.

If you believe, "Well, I used a new address! And a mixer! I'm safe!", that entire industry would like to have words with you.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by olalonde on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @02:56AM (#32235214)
This is a Bitcoin transaction that was made recently: https://www.blockchain.com/btc/tx/2ade2fbc7260f7000696953d4f...

How much can you tell us about the sender and recipient, please?

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by etchalon on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:06AM (#32239364)
I'm not a forensic accountant.

This like someone pointing out that there are doctors who can cure a mild infection and then demanding that person heal your infection immediately.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by olalonde on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:32AM (#32239715)
You said that you could in your comment:

> It's only "anonymous until use". If you transfer some amount to me, I can then retroactively find its source, and likely find a good deal of information about you and the other wallets you've used.

Regardless, obviously you can't. And no forensic accountant can either. I think you're just misinformed. You can draw some unreliable statistical relationships between adresses but that's it. And schemes like CoinJoin makes that sort of analysis even more irrelevant.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by etchalon on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:39AM (#32239798)
There's an entire industry of people and court filings that disagree with you.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by olalonde on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:56AM (#32239995)
So we've gone from "you", to a "forensic accountant" and now to "law enforcement".

If by industry, you mean blockchain analysis software vendors, I'm well aware of them. It is snake oil meant to tick an AML checkbox and appear as though you are doing something to fight money laundering. It's pure security theater.

Regarding law enforcement, they can't simply link Bitcoin addresses to real identities. It's just not possible. What happens is that some criminals are dumb enough to volunteer their real identity to exchanges and get caught that way.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by jagger27 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:53AM (#32234764)
> How so? If I buy some bitcoin face to face [blah blah]

You just described the benefits of a cash transaction. If the government is your adversary in this scenario, what's stopping them from cutting network access and rendering your Bitcoin immobile? Starlink and solar panel? For everyone?

I'm really getting sick of this libertarian drivel.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by redox99 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @02:58AM (#32235223)
> You just described the benefits of a cash transaction.

Nobody is denying cash is good. But cash relies on the government issuing it, can't be sent through the internet, can't be transported across borders easily, or in large quantities, can be physically seized, etc.

> If the government is your adversary in this scenario what's stopping them...

Yeah and what's stopping them from throwing you in jail? Or just killing you?

I'm assuming an intermediate point here, in which the government isn't either fully libertarian/anarchist, neither fully authoritarian. Which is what most "free" countries are like nowadays.

If the government is fully authoritarian and you're an "adversary" you're fucked.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by etchalon on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:45AM (#32239868)
Bitcoin hasn't seen large scale, transactional adoption anywhere, but especially not in any "free" country, where Bitcoin's advantages aren't outweighed by its disadvantages outside of illicit usage.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by MerelyMortal on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:24AM (#32234590)
Bitcoin is censorable, and it has been censored in the past by miners refusing to include transactions that they viewed as spam. Because Bitcoin transactions are public, they can be discriminated against.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by kragen on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @09:17AM (#32237847)
It takes a "51% attack" majority of miners to refuse to include a transaction, and then only if they're willing to reject blocks mined by others that include it, at the risk of their own blocks being rejected by full nodes (like Coinbase's and Binance's) if their 51% majority turns out not to be as solid as they thought it was.

As far as I know this has never happened; the only transactions I've seen excluded from the blockchain are unanimous things like the spam transactions you're talking about.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by jondwillis on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:27AM (#32234606)
Yeah, Bitcoin doesn’t typically make sense for avoidance purposes while you are still interfacing with centralized entities. It was always supposed to be p2p but has largely failed at that because there’s no real need for most people’s use case (speculation.)
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by llanowarelves on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:32AM (#32234640)
Crypto now means Coinbase the same way that email now means Gmail. But it doesn't have to be that way.

Protocols > Platforms.

Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by kragen on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @09:17AM (#32237852)
Nobody here in Argentina uses Coinbase; they all use Binance.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by llanowarelves on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:59PM (#32246448)
Interesting. Yeah it's a few different exchanges + banks. The dependency on platforms is the problem here.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by kragen on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:17AM (#32247400)
I agree that it's a problem, but an oligopoly like that is much less of a problem than a Gmail-style near-monopoly would be.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by wolongong942 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @08:05AM (#32237146)
In reality it isn't pseudonymous though, because 99% of users are on centralized KYC exchanges for convenience.
Re:From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal by kragen on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @09:13AM (#32237799)
Maybe 99% of the users you know. When LocalBitcoins imposed KYC everyone in Argentina switched to Binance.