It also has an advantage over soil that the remaining bits don’t need much extra support for the load above. This doc talks about it: https://stateimpact.npr.org/texas/2012/11/21/why-texas-doesn...
There's other issues, too, such as the lake that runs through the middle of the city, the underground rivers and cave networks in the area, and the unstable clay on the East side of town that expands and contracts with rain, causing all sorts of problems.
I don’t have sources myself but to me the porous nature of limestone seems like a benefit since water would easily flow to the water table instead of flooding in the tunnel.
Erosion seems like it would be a far bigger problem for tunnels in soil or sand than it would be for limestone.
Limestone, because it dissolves in contact with acidic water (and rainwater is slightly acidic) is also prone to sinkholes. Best to keep the ground stable by not exposing it to more water. It happens so often in Florida there’s an FAQ page. https://floridadep.gov/fgs/sinkholes
Excavating limestone isnt that hard. Instead of one day to dig a basement in soil, it would take about 14 days to dig a typical basement in limestone (based on digging pools in limestone). It costs about 1500/day for the crew/equipment so an extra 21K for the excavation.
East austin has no limestone and basements are still rare.
In Minnesota, where I live, basements are definitely a byproduct of structural requirements. You have to dig 48 inches so that your foundation is under the frost line. But also consider that you don't want your front door to be at ground level, because then it might not open after a massive snowfall. So if you add up all that vertical space, you get about 7 feet, which is about the ceiling height of an unfinished basement.
East Austin doesn't have them because of the unstable clay that expands and contracts with rains, same reason the track surface at COTA has had so many issues. The ground doesn't stay put.
Couple those things with the frost line issue you mentioned, along with the likelihood of flooding, and it probably comes down to the fact that it's just too much work to be worth it.
If you did, land would be worth $21k less per lot - to make up for the cost to dig a basement.
Which is why most people water their foundations to ensure the soild maintains steady state of dampness- rain or shine.
Its worth noting you can generally still drill a hole into caliche.
I think once cities get older and more ossified in their shape is when basements start to appear.
Assuming there is no other reason to avoid it like flooding, hard rock, earthquakes, etc.
To me that sounded fishy but I looked it up and you seem to be right! https://www.brownstonedetectives.com/the-ancient-art-of-movi...
Might be worth sharing that in 2020 Austin voters approved via ballot referendum (58% to 42%) what's likely to be the largest expansion of public transit this decade. It authorized $7.1 billion in initial bond funds and established a dedicated sales tax to establish ongoing funding for 4 light rail lines, 1 subway, a dedicated BRT system, and a complete transformation of their public transit system.
The initial phase itself is already deep into the design and bid stage, groundbreaking should happen in the next couple years.
https://projectconnect.com/docs/librariesprovider2/maps/pcon...
Even the state government of Texas gave its permission to tunnel under a portion of what is state-owned land for the subway for a 99-year annual lease of $1, which some Austin advocates originally feared would be leverage that the state legislature would try to use to hold up the project.
The vote for the plan was purely within Austin city limits. The plan was not at all voted for by suburbanites, nor are they paid for by the suburbs (except for purchases those suburbanites make in Austin proper, generating sales tax revenue).
> More than 42% of voters here have a distaste for density, public transit, and urban living in general
Source, please? Because I doubt it. Austin has one of the most pro-urbanist city councils in Texas, and has densified at a rate most other cities have not over the past 20 years (and second only to Dallas and Houston in terms of nationwide growth). I'm a Texan myself, born and raised, and it's a completely different built environment than what it was even 10 years ago, and that's not by accident, but actual policy supported by voters. Skyscrapers, density, apartments, townhomes, rezonings in previous single-family-only enclaves – things California talks about in studies and papers and committees, Texas is actually doing (I've lived in Los Angeles for over 5 years now, and the sentiment here is much more anti-development than I see in Austin and Dallas, which is generally pro-build-it-and-they-will-come).
> Austin has one of the most pro-urbanist city councils in Texas
Setting aside the fact that "in Texas" is one hell of a qualification to that statement, the voters haven't been helpful in allowing growth to happen. They just haven't been given the opportunity to stop it. CodeNEXT got a majority in the council, but it would have been crushed if it had been put in front of voters.
I think the influx of pro-density residents into central Austin is changing things really fast, though.
I think you're mistaken, or (very understandbly!) applying Texas's social conservatism to their land policies, which are likely some of the most liberal in the nation.
As someone who grew up in a real estate family "in Texas" – it's probably one of the most "pro-development" states in the country. Sure, historically that development hasn't been "urban", but as the market heads that direction the development has adapted.
Texas cities have been very amenable to building density (Houston doesn't even have any zoning or density/height limits whatsoever!), it's just that in the past there wasn't the population density to justify it when you could spread ever outward. What we've seen in the past decade is a shift to the cities, and cities like Dallas/Houston/Austin have drastically increased density (I've seen entire single family blocks turned into mid-rise apartments in my neighborhood alone), no rezonings necessary.
Dallas and Houston _each_ built more homes last year than the _entirety of the state of California_, and routinely have been doing so since 2010. Here's one from 2014, but you can find articles from 2021 and 2020 with a cursory google search, too.
https://houston.culturemap.com/news/real-estate/04-02-14-boo...
In 2017, Austin/Dallas/Houston issued about 10% of nationwide housing construction permits that year. That's crazy!
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-08-16/texas-lea...
For better or worse, Texas also has an aversion to process and paperwork that seems to plague other cities' planning departments – getting a by-right ADU permitted in California, which is the law of the land, took me over a year in Los Angeles. In Dallas, it required council approval for a zoning exemption, but the process took 2 weeks total.
I frankly do not really understand where this idea that Texas is against development is coming from -- the sentiment for "more more more" has existed since the oil boom in the 80s. Houston and Dallas both have grand ambitions of being the Manhattan of the South. Maybe it's the coastal people from much more NIMBY cities moving in?
Are the ones from 2020 and 2021 also just straight-out lying? The 2014 one you link both claims Houston to be higher than CA as a whole (without providing numbers for current Houston starts or CA starts) and claims that the rate in Houston is expected to peak at around 50k starts/year a couple years later in 2016.
But, in 2014, single and multifamily starts in California were each already around 50k, and growing.
https://journal.firsttuesday.us/the-rising-trend-in-californ...
Context for non-Texans: Capital Metro is the name of Austin's public transit system, and the current plans for our passenger rail network include at least one large underground station ([0], [1]), so I think this comment is tongue-in-cheek. It's a relatively small component of a relatively small system compared to the iconic subways in other cities, but from a local perspective, a lot of people are having a bit of a "whoah I can't believe this is happening here" reaction, and I think that's what she is referencing.
[0] https://communityimpact.com/austin/central-austin/transporta... [1] https://www.fox7austin.com/news/capital-metro-subway-tunnel-...