1) Bitcoin: It is attempting to establish hard money standard outside of state authority. It's slow going. Takes a long time to build and educate. Currently largely treated as a store of value, but there are efforts under way to make it usable as a method of payment (the Lightning network).
2) Tether and fully backed stablecoins: These provide dollar liquidity to the crypto ecosystem. More importantly, they are a very important store of wealth for the developing world, where they want dollars but laws and capital controls prevent stunt that.
3) Shitcoin casinos: The space for degenerate gamblers.
To be honest, payment systems are well-known for being a difficult, risky and low-margin business that are the front-lines of defense against fraud and malicious bots trying to take advantage of any tiny bug they can to swipe someone's funds. It's really not surprising that the crypto promoters have washed their hands of any responsibility about this, passing it around like a big game of musical chairs to whatever project makes the most empty promises it can about being a scalable solution (but still having no answer to the problem of massive fraud and bot attacks).
As for your second item, illegally circumventing capital controls in favor of a risky, unregulated offshore bank (that repeatedly denies they are a bank in order to avoid being shut down, because they couldn't possibly comply with banking regulations) is not actually helping anyone store or accumulate wealth in a developing economy.
[1]: https://blog.dshr.org/2020/01/bitcoins-lightning-network.htm...
1) The Lightning Network is fine and stronger than ever. That >2 year old outdated post is meaningless. There are MANY more routing nodes than ever, and markets have sprung up that allow nodes to make profit around selling liquidity to other nodes. Lightning is bigger, better, easier and more private than ever, and it only continues to improve.
2) The Bitcoin developers do not control Bitcoin. The Bitcoin miners do not control Bitcoin. The nodes control Bitcoin. There are tens of thousands, at least, of full nodes. Bitcoin developers and miners have tried many times to change the consensus rules of Bitcoin, and have failed every time, because the node operators just wouldn't run the code.
That's because Bitcoin is actually decentralized. The Bitcoin community reached a social consensus that the protocol consensus rules were probably never going to change, and it was preferable that they not change. Instead, the majority of the effort for scaling Bitcoin has gone into building higher Bitcoin layers, such as the Lightning Network.
Also, if the Bitcoin developers cared about miner profits, they wouldn't have implemented something like SegWit which is a backward-compatible change which dramatically reduced transaction fees to miners.
The truth is, no amount of block size or block time changes will ever make a cryptocurrency scale enough to remain decentralized and be a network for ALL payments. Building in layers is a sound engineering decision, and it allows people to create a payment network like Lightning without making potentially deadly trade-offs in the base layer.
Ah, but you repeat yourself.
> pokes Luna's corpse with a stick
Repeat that several times and add lending.
Now apparently we have just created 1$ out of thin air.
I like that example as it already shows one of the fundamental risks of crypto.
And now you can't even just say BTC or eth or stable coin because this is true for all.
As long as no one tries to cash it into real money the BTC price goes up and so does the market cap
Not that stock market and "wealth" loss there makes much sense to me either. Or that they own what ever, power plants, ships, factories. And they sell whatever they make. Ir I get point that company makes this much money and is expected to make it going forward. Still, if the number they are traded for drops something is lost? It wasn't there in first place.
This is a conversation about “public float”, and so your comparison or explanation of whats hard to understand for you should be about float.
Any stocks, bond, commodity, currency, set of assets, all experience the same phenomenon: where none of the daily or weekly marketcap changes have anything to do with the equivalent amount of money changing hands.
Stocks have two parts to the market cap values - the value of assets and revenue, and the speculative value of future asset/revenue values. Bonds have promises of their assigned values and dividend payouts. Commodities are useful.
Currency is the closest, of course, but then it has the promises of some government - a government that can tax the income of their people, and enforce that taxation.
Only cryptocurrency, among them, only has the value of what you hope to sell it for. In the moment, it's a consensus price, but the value only goes up based on speculation that it will go up enough for your individual purposes, or somehow that particular cryptocurrency will useful enough to hold value beyond speculation.
you have said nothing to the contrary
you also have said nothing to the contrary
basically the commonality is that you two are attempting to have a conversation on differences valuation models, when this isn't a conversation on valuation models. everyone understands that this is thinly veiled copypasta for why you respect one asset class and don’t respect another asset class, some people love to read that stuff but this isn’t what this conversation is about.
its a conversation on float and what float does and does not convey. the limitations of what float can convey is the same across all asset classes which is that the last traded price of a small portion of the supply is multiplied by the total supply, and this does not factor in how much could be sold at that price and does not factor in how the buyer and seller agreed upon that price or if there was any pricing projections or valuation metrics involved at all.
The limitations of what float can convey may be the same across all asset classes, but other asset classes do not suffer the limitation that there is no source of value except for the float.
A corollary of this is that market caps of stocks, bonds or commodities may reflect valuation metrics other than Greater Fool Theory.
That’s true for some crypto assets as well.
So in a conversation about float you should stick to float.
> So in a conversation about float you should stick to float.
It is true that in some crypto assets value can be realised as claims to the sort of value the OP said they understood, like future revenues of a business (or "DAO"), instead of solely by finding buyers for the crypto. But it is not true for the typical "insular, self-contained" cryptocurrency they sought to contrast it with, in which the market cap can be realised solely by sufficiently deep-pocketed Greater Fools purchasing the float.
In a conversation about the fundamental weirdness of assets whose value can only be realised by float, one probably should stick to assets whose value can only be realised by float.
Well good chat. I hope it is insightful to someone that passes by.
But yes, your persistence in insisting the conversation should be about what you care about, and not about the original subject matter got me to acknowledge that some cryptoassets - which are unlike the high profile, high market cap unbacked cryptoassets the OP was talking about - imitate stocks and may generate future revenue streams from selling things other than tokens. Glad you enjoyed that bit. I do hope the insight passers by come away with isn't that DAOs and stocks have equally strong legal claims and rosy expectations and float is all that matters though.
US dollars
Whereas most of the "cryptocurrency" stuff is a scam, sometimes a scam onion, with layers of scams performed on other scammers. It me reminds of a juice MLM I ran into. At first I see the usual pyramid structure, there's no way you can "make money selling this" unless you're near the top of that pyramid, there are celebrity "endorsements" paid for with a nice chunk of money, and so on - but then I realise there's a whole other level. The real scammers don't waste their lives on this "fake it til you make it" crap. The MLM company has an exclusive supply deal with a single manufacturer, every bottle of crappy juice a victim pays for as "stock" for their "home business" is coming from one company owned by the scammers who dreamed all this up. They're nothing to do with any pyramid scheme, even if the Feds bust the whole thing, they're innocent, they just own a business which sells 10¢ of juice for $5 to the MLM company, just Capitalism red in tooth and claw. For every $1000 some fool spends on juice they'll never drink, $100 may end up going to some shark with great charisma and no conscience who reeled in that MLM fool, but $500+ ends up with the faceless juice makers.
It's 1T worth of... what?
I can kinda sorta understand 1T of car factories and farms and food plants. I can understand the over-simplified-into-nothingness capital model of I give you $1000, you build a factory, you build cars, you create value, eventually you give me back $1100. Or something.
I can even intuitively understand (or fool myself) as to 1T of services - tourism, accounting, software, consulting. I can see its place in the world, the interconnectedness with industry and people and products and markets.
I cannot visualize/intuitively understand 1T of crypto. It feels so... insular, self-contained. 1T of... companies running datacentres running random calculations... for money, kind of? People giving each other more and more non-crypto money and making it very complex? It feels like this whirl-storm of activity, vortex that sucks stuff ("real world money") in, but I don't understand its connectivity to outside world, it's output, the balance of interfaces. My mental image is incomplete and clearly wrong.
(I suppose I should think of it more along the lines of, say, Gold market, but I don't understand that either :D )