The limitations of what float can convey may be the same across all asset classes, but other asset classes do not suffer the limitation that there is no source of value except for the float.
A corollary of this is that market caps of stocks, bonds or commodities may reflect valuation metrics other than Greater Fool Theory.
That’s true for some crypto assets as well.
So in a conversation about float you should stick to float.
> So in a conversation about float you should stick to float.
It is true that in some crypto assets value can be realised as claims to the sort of value the OP said they understood, like future revenues of a business (or "DAO"), instead of solely by finding buyers for the crypto. But it is not true for the typical "insular, self-contained" cryptocurrency they sought to contrast it with, in which the market cap can be realised solely by sufficiently deep-pocketed Greater Fools purchasing the float.
In a conversation about the fundamental weirdness of assets whose value can only be realised by float, one probably should stick to assets whose value can only be realised by float.
Well good chat. I hope it is insightful to someone that passes by.
But yes, your persistence in insisting the conversation should be about what you care about, and not about the original subject matter got me to acknowledge that some cryptoassets - which are unlike the high profile, high market cap unbacked cryptoassets the OP was talking about - imitate stocks and may generate future revenue streams from selling things other than tokens. Glad you enjoyed that bit. I do hope the insight passers by come away with isn't that DAOs and stocks have equally strong legal claims and rosy expectations and float is all that matters though.
you also have said nothing to the contrary
basically the commonality is that you two are attempting to have a conversation on differences valuation models, when this isn't a conversation on valuation models. everyone understands that this is thinly veiled copypasta for why you respect one asset class and don’t respect another asset class, some people love to read that stuff but this isn’t what this conversation is about.
its a conversation on float and what float does and does not convey. the limitations of what float can convey is the same across all asset classes which is that the last traded price of a small portion of the supply is multiplied by the total supply, and this does not factor in how much could be sold at that price and does not factor in how the buyer and seller agreed upon that price or if there was any pricing projections or valuation metrics involved at all.