Speculators are forced to sell, because the cost of keeping too many houses locked down is high and starts to show on their books, so they have to explain it to the investors, that go away unsatisfied, and so on.
Of course, that only makes a difference if there are many unused houses.
Also the idea is that as prices fall, the absolute value of the tax falls, but speculators still do not have a motivation to buy them, because the price isn't expected to rise.
> If so, why not just get rid of speculative buying (simply make it illegal)?
Because you will need an entire book of rules, that lawyers will use to get a lot of money, and rich people will use to make the tax not apply to them. (But there are some simple rules that can only be gamed a bit. Maybe those are enough.)
Nobody is willing to pay as much up front for housing that has higher ongoing costs.
So how come there's ample low cost high quality housing in Chicago?
The same remark applies to home owners. Your property won't rise in value, so why buy it? You must really want to live in the area, I guess.
And yes, I know the point of a house is to live in it, but almost everywhere it has a double function in also being an appreciating retirement fund.
For now my theory is that a lot of speculative supply got dumped, leading to a one time effect.
That's true, but it's also a looming economic disaster as it prices out the younger generation and entrenches generational wealth.
Chicago are famous for their highest rate of 2.5% per annum, grown smoothly over 15+ years. Thought experiment: What happens if the land value tax rate keeps growing smoothly? What does it look like at 10% per annum? 20%? 100%?
At 100% per annum, the average land value of a house needs to be below $50k or so in current dollars (most would need to be much less). Any higher, and ~nobody is willing to pay the taxes.
A large home costs $200k or so to build vs a small/cheap home at 80k, so property prices now range from 50k (old cheap home) to 250k (new, high-end home).
That's a huge result for housing affordability! People are currently saving deposits of 80k to get a mortgage.
Instead of paying mortgage costs to capital holders, you're paying tax to a government that ostensibly exists to serve you. Instead of buying "the most I can afford so I get a retirement fund", now people are buying housing based on their willingness to pay an ongoing cost for access to amenities.
I think at that point you’re disincentivising capital works too strongly, since there’s a higher risk you’ll lose the property via default on taxes, but it’s not clear to me that the same effect would exist even at a 20% rate.
For example low property taxes encourages NIMBYism which results in lower density zoning which reduces new supply.
If high property taxes reduce NIMBYism by making homeowners feel the housing crisis themselves, that alone could ultimately increase affordability.
Obama should have let the bankers twist in the wind when the citizenry was out for blood in 2008. They repaid him by channeling money to Republicans. Put them all in jail.
Texas has an interesting solution to this. Homeowners over 65 can elect to defer the payment of their property taxes indefinitely, although the taxes eventually get paid when the house changes owners.
I guess that doesn't matter to you if you're dead.
What happens if the deferred taxes exceed the cost of the house?
I'm not sure what happens in the case where the accrued taxes exceed the value of the house, though.
Basically they put a tax lien on the property, they just don't collect on it while the original homeowner is occupying the property.
I'm not a lawyer, but my basic understanding of this is that if it exceeds the value of the property, the estate can just let the city/county seize the house. Otherwise, they'd need to pay the deferred taxes in order to transfer the title to the heirs.
Obviously this is not legal advice.
I'm uncomfortable with this phrasing. Are you implying that the bailouts were some kind of quid pro quo?
In general, as costs go up, the more there is incentive to try to cater to wealthier customers.
In the interest of being intellectually honest though, that's probably not the full story. It's worth pointing out that Chicago's population peaked in the 50's and that property taxes were probably lower back then.
Also worth pointing out that there's a lot of directions for sprawl to help meet housing demand. I actually grew up in Indiana and my dad worked in Chicago. We lived in Indiana because the property tax was significantly lower even though housing prices were comparable.
Homeowners are concerned with the size of the deposit required, the size of the loan needed, and ongoing costs (inc taxes). This tax will likely mean a smaller deposit and loan than would otherwise be the case. This could be offset by higher ongoing costs by the property tax.
For a speculator, they have the same concerns as a homeowner, but most significantly the potential for capital gains. Yield also comes into it, but let's face it - without strong capital gains no one would be paying these prices (homeowners included).
Lower potential for capital gains effects speculator demand more than homeowner demand.
Not if the tax base goes down. Which is the point.
> If so, why not just get rid of speculative buying (simply make it illegal)?
This makes the lawyer rich too. It’s not a smash-and-grab at a Walgreens. You can’t put real estate cops on every deal. If price is expected to go up, people will speculate.
I also doubt that developers would bother with a market like the one described. Why not go to some other state/city where construction costs are low and property taxes are also low?
General contractors don't just do general contracting, and it's not like tech where you can pick up and move anywhere there's internet.
source? On one hand they could be as you said, but the alternative could be that investors think that "cheapest of the big 6" makes real estate there undervalued and therefore a good investment.
Why not make property tax cumulative with the amount of property owned and impose a progressive tax here? It would have an equalizing effect on ownership and speculation would be less attractive for those that already own o lot of properties.
Sure, you have to fix a lot of holes to circumvent taxes so that not every company creates a large amount of holdings, but such strategies are a problem with every tax.
To now say a high property tax would scare away investors doesn't sound workable at all.
This was such a laughable comparison because BOTH of these cities have high property taxes compared with more affordable cities in other states.
I rented a house once in West Portal where the landlord was paying property taxes on the 1970 value of the home, which was something like $70k. The owner was gifted this house and taxes basis from their parents, who originally bought it. The tax bill came out to just a few thousand dollars as of 2020.
Meanwhile my neighbor at the time bought their house for $3m and was paying something like $35k.
I thought about writing the property taxes in front of each house on the sidewalk with sidewalk chalk to make a point how messed up this tax policy is, but I opted instead to keep the peace and do nothing.
This loophole is used by families in CA as a way to pass assets to their heirs. The worst part is the tax rate also gets passed down, but one generation tops.
https://www.officialdata.org/ca-property-tax/#37.74219147779...
As a result, my neighbor has a house with an effective tax rate of <0.1% ($3,000/yr on a single family house worth >$3M).
I'm less familiar with San Francisco, but I wouldn't be surprised if they had low property taxes due to Prop 13.
For instance, there's loads of large family houses being occupied by empty-nesters, while those trying to raise a young family are squashed into undersized townhouses.
Shifting the cost-base from "pay a huge mortgage and a tiny property tax" to "pay a moderate mortgage and an moderate property tax" means it's more likely to be worth the hassle of moving to a smaller house when you no longer need the space.
Longer term, the impact on rental costs depends on whether you think this policy would increase the amount of housing available for people to live in.
Where I live, many properties are bought and kept empty - the rental income isn't worth the hassle and they are being held for capital gains. High property taxes would presumably result in some of those properties being sold to occupiers.
Consider an extreme case - a land value tax of 20% (meaning you pay the government the full value of the unimproved land every 5 years). Land values would plummet, right? Lets say it were introduced over 30 years, so prices could adjust smoothly instead of crashing. What does the steady state look like after 30 years?
Policing is definitely possible, but I don't think the added cost and operational complexity make it advisable.
If the tax is high in a location where they think they can flip the house for a 50% gain in a few years that's still better profit than a lower tax in a place where they'll gain 5% in a few years. So the property tax doesn't, all by itself, matter to the speculator. It's just a cost of doing business.
A high property tax does, however, hurt the person who just wants a house to live in it and doesn't care about being a speculator.
How do you propose to do that in the US?
"The high cost of property taxes have long pushed away speculative investors as it has pushed the carrying cost beyond what is profitable to hold as a passive investment long-term."
Alright, so now the speculative buyers are gone and we're dealing with ordinary home buyers that actually occupy their home. These genuine owners are paying high property taxes. Next:
"This has led to is a glut of high quality housing at very low prices. The amount of money one needs to save up for a downpayment in Chicago on a 2BR in the city center is 5x lower than in San Francisco or New York."
How does specifically a high property tax for genuine buyers lead to lower prices? Because of less demand from speculators? If so, why not just get rid of speculative buying (simply make it illegal)? What does it have to do with property tax for ordinary citizens?
And what on earth does Chicago have to do with San Francisco or New York?