News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by not2b on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @01:56PM (#32155506)
Ars Technica is pretty good, partly because so many of their writers are experts with advanced degrees.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by MBCook on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @02:01PM (#32155573)
I agree. They’re a site I trust much more than a random news site, and this isn’t the first “No, incredibly stupid science thing isn’t true” piece they’ve had to write lately.

Re-reading my comment it may be unclear what I meant. So to state it plainly it was the original claim I knew was bunk.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by AceJohnny2 on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @02:17PM (#32155810)
Definitely worth the subscription.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @02:45PM (#32156143)
no, not only is that an irrational appeal to authority, but ars spent the last two years fearmongering over covid for clicks just like all the other news sites. this story is also fishing for clicks, just from a contrarian perspective (relative to their audience) to keep things fresh.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by capableweb on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:25PM (#32156675)
What exactly counts as fearmongering for you? It seems like +6.37M people have died from COVID so far, most of them being in the US (which has more deaths from COVID than India, which has a larger population than the US).

It makes sense for a lot of people in the US to be scared of COVID, it is a dangerous, infectious disease after all.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by dangerwill on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @04:50PM (#32157781)
The Indian government has been obviously undercounting the death toll by nearly an order of magnitude since the Delta wave https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm5154
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:45PM (#32156957)
it makes no sense for "a lot of people" to be scared of covid. it makes sense for those at risk (the elderly and those with co-morbidities) to evaluate that risk and take concrete measures (principally vaccination), then move on. we did not need to be stuck in a fear cycle for over two years for what is a novel cold virus, not the black death.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by overtonwhy on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:52PM (#32157037)
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by MontyCarloHall on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:28PM (#32158228)
This is a sensationalized study that only looked at COVID cases that were serious enough to end up on someone’s electronic medical record:

>The authors mined electronic health records identif[ying] 353,164 patients diagnosed with COVID-19 between March 2020 and November 2021. They then matched each COVID-19 patient in a ratio of one to five with 1,640,776 control patients. All of the survivors and controls were monitored for at least a month and up to a year. Overall, 38.2 percent of COVID-19 survivors developed a post-COVID condition, compared with 16 percent of uninfected controls.

(Also note that the “post-COVID conditions” include things as minor as a persistent cough.)

The real headline should be "More than 1-in-5 COVID cases serious enough to be noted in medical records may result in long-term symptoms, greatly ranging in severity."

Upwards of 60% of the US had been infected with COVID as of April 2022 [0]. If serious long-COVID symptoms indeed occurred in upwards of 20% of COVID cases, that would mean >12% of Americans are currently suffering from debilitating long-term illness, which would be obvious on a societal level. We simply do not see this.

[0] https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20220426/almost-60-percent-i...

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:57PM (#32157112)
i don't, especially not on arstechnica of all places.

there is active research on the topic but no conclusive evidence that it's any more than a form of negative hawthorne effect and/or hypochondriasis.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by namecheapTA on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @04:12PM (#32157301)
So do you. Basically made up.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by rajup on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:19PM (#32158128)
I agree with you, but this comment of yours does not follow from the other comment you made up thread.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by Sparkle-san on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:28PM (#32156717)
It's not really irrational. Journalism is plagued with issues where journalists misconstrue a topic because they don't have the requisite background knowledge to adequately cover a topic. This becomes immediately obvious when you read an article on a topic you're knowledgeable about (see Gell-Mann amnesia effect). Expecting a site with more subject matter experts to have less of these types of errors seems perfectly rational.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:38PM (#32156855)
no, that's literally falling for the appeal to authority fallacy. just because a journalist has some experience in a field tells you nothing a priori about how they evaluate other information in the field. you have to evaluate their ability to evaluate that information to get any insight into how trustworthy they can be.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by Sparkle-san on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @04:23PM (#32157450)
You're conveniently ignoring that their writers are often writing within their domains of experience.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @04:31PM (#32157556)
no, i'm not. i'm saying that it doesn't matter a single iota. in the few domains where i can plausibly claim more than cursory knowledge, there are plenty of people who i give zero credence to, who otherwise claim "expertise".

and a science writer is often writing about science far afield of their narrow education/research. the author of this very article is the "automotive editor" at ars, not a marine biologist, or anything close to it.

"expert" is a normative (aka political) nominative, not a descriptive one.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by kelnos on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:53PM (#32158468)
> plenty of people who i give zero credence to, who otherwise claim "expertise".

At the risk of committing the sin of No True Scotsman, perhaps these people don't really have the expertise they claim.

I would expect a journalist who has actual, real expertise in a particular field to be able to sort out the junk from the newsworthy, at least most of the time. If not, then I don't think their expertise really exists. Sure, everyone makes mistakes sometimes, but I would expect people with real expertise to be at least mostly reliable.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by Sparkle-san on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:06PM (#32157973)
> the author of this very article is the "automotive editor" at ars, not a marine biologist, or anything close to it.

The author has a PhD in Pharmacology. Biology is an integral part of Pharmacology.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by kelnos on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:59PM (#32158527)
Perhaps, but this is marine biology, which I expect is a bit different.

Not to mention that if you click through the author's article history, the most recent three pages of articles he's written (over 100 articles) are exclusively about cars, not science. (Ok, one exception, looks like he wrote an article about Disney's Obi-Wan series.)

While I wouldn't say he has no domain knowledge at all, I don't think it's fair to say he has "expertise in marine biology". And he doesn't even write about stuff related to his credentialed field, at least not recently.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:08PM (#32158006)
not marine biology.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by not2b on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:26PM (#32156696)
"fishing for clicks" from a "contrarian perspective" usually means "misinform the public for profit". Giving the best available reporting on what's currently known about a disease that has killed millions isn't "fearmongering", even if as we learn more some reporting needs to be revised.

Equating the two is just nihilism or solipsism, as if there's no reality, just people saying things.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:42PM (#32156917)
news outlets literally put out millions of stories about covid over the past couple years. do you really believe that that was all factual, objective reporting--that millions of "facts" were being rationally delivered--or were news outlets taking advantage of an opportunity to keep people glued to their screens (and speakers)?
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @04:58PM (#32157884)
You complain about a fallacy and then use this argument? Ars is just one news outlet and didn't put out all those millions of stories, so they don't have to answer for them. If you object to Ars, object to Ars.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:15PM (#32158083)
ars is part of a $2.5B media empire (advance publications). read any of their covid coverage, and it's pretty baldly fearmongering for clicks. they're not in this business for commonwealth, objective truth-seeking.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:25PM (#32158194)
"read any of their covid coverage" - whose - advanced publications as a body, or Ars? Because yet again, what someone else writes isn't Ars's problem.

> they're not in this business for commonwealth, objective truth-seeking.

This is an attempted attack on motives, and again, not on any real substance.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:49PM (#32158438)
and somehow

> "Ars Technica is pretty good, partly because so many of their writers are experts with advanced degrees."

passes the test for "real substance"?

read both, and any other favored news service. read a small sample of their coverage and their self-serving motives jump right out of the page and slaps you silly like a rubber chicken. it's that obvious. and it is their problem, by association, since you're trying to make a (unsubstantiated) claim on reputation.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:57PM (#32158501)
GP made an argument regarding Ars being staffed by experts. You've said nothing at all specific to Ars and instead tried to imply a bunch of guilt by association, so absolutely the original post had considerably more substance than, if I can paraphrase, "lots of the media lies therefore Ars does too" and "they are a business".
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @06:16PM (#32158706)
there is no argument there. just an unsupported assertion. just like your comment.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @08:13PM (#32159679)
Sorry, I guess I've been giving your tangential assertions too much benefit as well then.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by mempko on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:10PM (#32156481)
Ok, but over a million people in the US died from covid and even more with permanent damage.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:35PM (#32156825)
3.5M people died last year in the US. as usual, heart disease and cancer were the overwhelming leaders. covid claimed ~460K, but that's "deaths involving covid", not "from covid". there is no evidence of "permanent damage" from covid. a novel contagion of any kind will exhibit its highest mortality rates at the beginning of its epidemic incursion, and eventually reach steady state. from all indications, the steady state of covid will follow its coronavirus predecessors and settle at negligible death rates. heart disease and cancer will continue to kill millions into the foreseeable future.

that's not to dismiss the threat of covid, but to merely put it in perspective. people at risk (elderly, or with co-morbidities) should get vaccinated and perhaps take other precautions. but none of that fearmongering did any good, and in fact, did a lot of bad, by sowing division rather than fostering unity.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by Johnny555 on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @04:01PM (#32157162)
there is no evidence of "permanent damage" from covid.

There is some evidence. But as you said, it's a novel disease and still being studied.

https://www.bcm.edu/news/what-eegs-tell-us-about-covid-19-an...

Some of the EEG alterations found in COVID-19 patients may indicate damage to the brain that might not be able to be repaired after recovering from the disease.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @04:07PM (#32157234)
note that EEGs are a very crude instrument relative the fantastic complexity of the brain. it's like putting a rock on the ground to try to understand geotectonics. it's not nothing, but it's not much at all. i wouldn't be surprised if in 100 years, it's viewed much like we now view leeching or lobotomies.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by peyton on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:56AM (#32162415)
“altered mental status” in EEG context means, like, coma. These aren’t very healthy people.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:02PM (#32157924)
In 2020 602,350 people died of cancer[1]. Seems odd to use it as an example of a bigger threat when it's entirely comparable, especially when we can argue the "with not of" distinction there - they may have died of systemic failure while also having cancer.

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/research/update-on-cancer-de...

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by kelnos on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @06:03PM (#32158577)
> that's "deaths involving covid", not "from covid".

Unless they all would have died at that time regardless, in the absence of COVID, isn't this a distinction without relevance?

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @06:29PM (#32158826)
death is often not as simple as "you died of dysentery". your liver might fail, and your lungs are full of fluid, and your arteries are clogged. you smoke like a chimney and drink like a fish, while eating like a recently unhibernated bear. how do you decide which caused the death, especially without some very detailed monitoring of all of the body's major systems?

"with covid" is the same. that's why co-morbidities are almost universally indicated in covid deaths. it's because the people dying of covid are pretty unhealthy already, and covid is not the primary cause of death, but a contributing one, often a minor contributor at that.

the distinction is also important because it has multi-faceted follow-on effects. in terms of treatment, a doctor could otherwise have focused more on treating a co-morbidity than covid. a researcher might focus more on other ailments than covid. the public might have been less fearful and tribal. public health guidance might have been different. it has lots of relevance actually.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by mempko on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:43AM (#32247246)
That's why you look at excess deaths. Covid increased excess deaths significantly. In other words, those unhealthy people would still be alive without covid, enjoying a longer life.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by robbiep on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @05:08PM (#32157995)
It would be reasonable to say, today, that the dominant varieties of SARS-CoV-2 are basically similar to an average to not great flu season, particularly for the vaccinated, where there is still a mortality benefit. In fact, I was at a talk 2 weeks ago where Sir Jonathan Van-Tam said exactly this.

However. This is a long way from where things started.

*> that's not to dismiss the threat of covid’

Actually, I think what you’re doing is worse. As a doctor I’m happy to treat current covid as something we need to live with and get on with, but you’re actually dismissing the prior threat of COVID as well. Dismissing all the people who did die. Dismissing the 140,000 children who were orphaned in the US alone. Dismissing the real contribution of COVID to actual deaths - your distinction of ‘deaths from covid to deaths with covid’ is meaningless when excess mortality clearly shows that without the impact of covid the US population would be 1m higher than it is today.

The fact that you choose to see the COVID information as having sowed division speaks more to the bizarre information landscape you have in the US. Many other countries found the last couple of years intensely frustrating but managed to forge a sense of national spirit in fighting it, and as a result have significantly lower excess deaths, significantly less orphaned children, and significantly lower societal scars to bounce back from.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by clairity on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @06:15PM (#32158692)
so where are the heartwrenching anecdotes about heart disease or cancer deaths? otherwise you're just projecting a recency and availability bias. but none of that matters for how we, and especially the press, should have handled the topic.

no country has "significantly lower"-ed anything. at most, we have slightly different diffusion curves, but mortality and morbidity rates are going to be pretty similar regardless of how we were "fighting it". every single person on earth will get covid at some point. at best, we've delayed that point a little bit for some people, not to mention some shifting of mortality. note that liver disease and chirrosis deaths rose last year - why aren't we making video montages and pouring one out for them, or their orphaned children, again?

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by robbiep on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @10:04PM (#32160473)
Every untimely death is a tragedy. That's why every country has widespread public health campaigns extolling the virtues of stopping smoking, healthy diets, exercise, maintaining a healthy weight. But these are background noise to most people, and most people don't change their behaviour anyway. If your point is the news should be plastered with images of people suffering heart attacks or cancer wards, i'm not sure what the utility of that argument is. The hospital system has capacity for steady state burden of disease. If Heart disease and cancer patients were dying in hospital corridors, or at home unable to get to hospital, can you actually tell me with a straight face there wouldn't be widespread outrage?

>no country has "significantly lower"-ed anything. at most, we have slightly different diffusion curves, but mortality and morbidity rates are going to be pretty similar regardless of how we were "fighting it".

This is simply not true. Countries that avoided early surges, avoided overrunning hospitals and were able to get their populations vaccinated and dealing with lower virulence covid strains have had lower overall deaths over the 2 and a half years of the pandemic.

Australia for example, had largely flat excess deaths in 2020 & 2021 (actually a reduction in 2020, due to no covid, reduced travel, no flu season). Australia started dealing with the actual burden of COVID in late 2021 and 2022, and has seen 10,000 COVID deaths so far. Excess deaths in 2022 is 17.5% above average for the year to end of May. [0, 1].

If the US had of been able to pull together, instead of, as you have, variously dismissing it as 'nothing more than the flu', 'no more important than Cancer and Heart disease deaths', or moving the goal posts and declaring that, essentially, the area under the curve will be the same but the timing will be different (which is at conflict with earlier points) - ie if the US had of been able to pull an Australia (or one of many other countries that didn't just totally shit the bed and hide their heads in the sand) than COVID deaths, scaled for population, could have been in the 150-200k range.

Or, to put it another way, if Australia had of shit the bed as badly as the US did, then Aus would have had 60,000 deaths.

[0] https://www.abs.gov.au/articles/measuring-australias-excess-... [1] https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/health/causes-death/provis...

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by goatlover on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @03:54PM (#32157060)
That's less than 1% of the population. If you're not in the high risk category or living with someone at high risk, and you got vaccinated, then there isn't reason to be overly concerned. Take precautions as you feel the need, but otherwise, life goes on. This isn't the bubonic plague or smallpox.
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by namecheapTA on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @04:13PM (#32157323)
Over a million people died with covid, not from covid. If after 2 years you haven't got this distinction, do you think possibly you're just severely confused on the topic and shouldn't be discussing it publicly for fear of spreading misinformation?
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by kelnos on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @06:11PM (#32158648)
How is the distinction meaningful? Would these people who "died with COVID, not from COVID" certainly still died if COVID hadn't been a thing?
Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by namecheapTA on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @07:42PM (#32159439)
Certainly? No. Probably? Yes. The average age of a covid death in the UK was higher than the actual life expectancy age.

Add in how overly sensitive the tests were, especially pcr, testing for the virus and not for actual proof of infection... It's all a joke.

Re:We haven’t killed 90% of all plankton by mempko on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:50AM (#32247276)
Ok, then explain the excess deaths. Explain how more people dying than normal is a joke.