News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by causality0 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @01:17AM (#32124657)
In short, it is a writing tool. Are you a writer? Are you blogging? Are you working on developing a theory of something?

This is a very important sentence. Modern day knowledge workers are under constant cultural pressure that tells them everything they do is better if they shove it up its own ass. You don't have to create a document for every book you read, a record of every action you take. Without specific goals in mind obsessive self-documentation is just a massive level of busy-work that doesn't actually contribute to your skills or happiness.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by OskarS on Sunday July 17, 2022 @03:48AM (#32125165)
Reading the question I was in disbelief: what a miserable way to experience literature (even non-fiction). Just read the book! Enjoy it! What possible goal could be fulfilled by this kind of incessant note-taking?

Really brilliant people, the kind of people that can take different ideas from different sources and synthesize them into new things, they don’t read books in this way. They just read them. If they do take notes, it’s to check something with some other source or if it’s something they want to remember. They don’t make “120 notes about the most interesting ideas” or whatever. That just sounds like some kind of obsessive dedication to a note-taking system, not a way to actually learn anything, let alone as a good way to experience culture.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by huntoa on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:50AM (#32125399)
From an interview with Jim Keller: "I know people that read books, and they are really worried if they're going to remember them. They spend all this time highlighting and analyzing. I read for interest, right? [...] I meditate regularly, and then I think about what I'm thinking about, which is sometimes related to what I'm reading. Then if it's interesting, it gets incorporated. But your brain is this kind of weird thing - you don't actually have access to all the ideas and thoughts and things you've read, but your personality seems to be well informed by it, and I trust that process. So I don't worry if I can't remember somebody's name [in a book], because their idea may have changed, and who I was and I don't remember what book it came from. I don't care about that stuff." - https://www.anandtech.com/show/16762/an-anandtech-interview-...
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by celeritascelery on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:02AM (#32127416)
"I cannot remember the books I’ve read any more than the meals I have eaten; even so, they have made me." - Ralph Waldo Emerson
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by BeetleB on Sunday July 17, 2022 @06:41PM (#32132204)
I used to believe that my reading shaped me despite me forgetting 90% of what I read, but I no longer believe it. Or at least, I have no good reason to believe it - it seems more wishful thinking.

I've even had experiences where I was profoundly affected by some interesting material, only to later realize that I had encountered that material (in a different book) less than a year prior. I hadn't ignored the material the first time, and had been affected by it then as well. I'm pretty sure it didn't shape me at all.

Whether to take notes or not depends on the purpose of reading nonfiction. When I read biographies, I'd like to get the bigger picture rather than the details - so if I do take notes, they are very sparse (e.g. summarizing the major points - perhaps 1-3 pages worth). With some other books I copy quotes of insightful points (e.g. reading The Demon Haunted World, I was struck by how critical he is of the behavior of many skeptics, and noted the irony that many skeptics had recommended the book).

But when it comes to potentially useful self help books: There's really no point in reading them if you don't take serious notes. They don't make for great reading, and may actually have useful material for you for life.

Books like Gladwell's: They're mostly for entertainment. It's fine not to take notes, although it's probably better to read fiction itself.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by legutierr on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:46AM (#32127819)
Sound about right. But still, you remembered that quote somehow.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by evolvingstuff on Sunday July 17, 2022 @03:50PM (#32130522)
May have looked it up.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by foldedcornice on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:21PM (#32128159)
This is an interesting quote, though Keller's response appears to be framed in the context of business and/or self-help books: more explicitly, books Keller read "for interest," rather than books about technical subjects.

His response (immediately before much of your quote) was: "They spend all this time highlighting and analyzing. I read for interest, right? What I really remember is that people have to write 250-page books, because that's like a publisher rule. It doesn't matter if you have 50 pages of ideas, or 500, but you can tell pretty fast. I've read some really good books that are only 50 pages, because that's all they had. You can also read 50 pages, and you think, ‘wow, it's really great!’, but then the next 50 pages is the same shit. Then you realize it’s just been fleshed out – at that point I wish they just published a shorter book."

That doesn't sound like books that take more effort to really understand (e.g. Plato's works). In more technical subjects, such as mathematics textbooks, would it really be possible for most students to thoroughly understand the subject by just reading, without note-taking or at the very least, trying the practice problems? There is certainly value in note-taking for subjects and books worth thoroughly understanding, even accounting for edge cases where students can learn complex subjects just by reading, without writing.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:07AM (#32126420)
That's an interesting view and - I suspect - surprisingly correct.

We're shaped by unconscious gestalt understandings, not by small details.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by Parzival99 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:29AM (#32125327)
"Really brilliant people, the kind of people that can take different ideas from different sources and synthesize them into new things, they don’t read books in this way. They just read them. If they do take notes, it’s to check something with some other source or if it’s something they want to remember."

Ah yes, let me take a note of that and remember to mimic these "really brilliant people" who all operate in one way.

I think my own view is not too far off yours, oops, but the way you wrote it as a statement of fact (which is really like 4 propositions in one) made me chuckle.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by foldedcornice on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:11PM (#32128049)
To add an example of a brilliant person who operated in a different way via heavy note-taking, philosopher Mortimer J. Adler advocated for note-taking for books that are important to study, after doing an initial read deliberately without note-taking (called "superficial reading").

He wrote a book about it—"How to Read a Book," published in 1940—which was summarized by the Farnam Street blog: https://fs.blog/how-to-read-a-book/

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by szundi on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:45AM (#32125382)
Lot of comments are mocking this one, but it has a point.

These people make connections in their heads while reading. They don’t just read but gaze away sometimes and play games in their heads about these ideas. They vet it. Thinking about them in connection with other stuff just come up in their minds.

Notes are to not to forget to follow up something for them mostly.

Taking lots of notes are inefficient and diverts you from doing the stuff above.

I think.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by larve on Sunday July 17, 2022 @06:55AM (#32125784)
That is the point of the article indeed. Think about the book and come up with your own ideas, then write those down and put them into the context of your other ideas.

(I read almost exclusively programming/product/art related non-fiction).

I am someone who “thinks while writing”. Taking notes while reading a book (I usually write into the book margins) allows me to clarify what I think the author is saying, start bringing in some of my ideas and juxtapose them, reformulate some important points. It is the opposite of taking away from the book reading experience: it makes it oh so more vivid. This also applies to articles on the web and my twitter stream.

Seeing how fallible my memory is, I envy people who can recall what they were thinking even just yesterday when reading a complex piece of literature, let alone retrace the complex arguments I make to myself (and the reified author) when reading.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by LegitShady on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:05AM (#32126406)
counterpoint - if taking notes by hand, the reading and then rewriting of an idea is far superior in terms of my ability to recall the fact/idea/etc in the long run. Taking notes can be miserable but it improves my recall 100x.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by BbzzbB on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:57AM (#32126797)
>if taking notes by hand

From what I had found when reading about hand- vs keyboard-written notes on Scholar, it didn't seem to make a difference what method you used w.r.t. studies in the contexts of students and grades or memory (citations needed).

If the point is recall, which for me is the main reason I want to take note from reads, intuitively I don't see why the method of writing would make a difference on my recalling process which happens in my head. Keyboard has the advantage that it's easier to organize and keep around, so you have the option to reread your summaries more available.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by LegitShady on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:32AM (#32127134)
My experience has been the opposite, significantly so, and just because you can't intuit why writing and typing might differ doesn't mean our brains are doing the same things when doing one or the other.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by causality0 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:40AM (#32126656)
Taking notes can be miserable but it improves my recall 100x.

Exactly. Taking notes is great if you have a goal in mind, like incorporating ideas into your own writing or quickly grasping a complex system you're learning about. It doesn't make sense to apply to everything you read unless you don't read for pleasure at all.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by LegitShady on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:33AM (#32127144)
I agree. I definitely don't take notes on everything I read.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by marttt on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:04AM (#32126399)
I think this resonates really well with an old HN comment (one of my all time favorites) by Alan Kay on reading and remembering: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11809285

"The simple heuristic is 'relax'." In other words: sleep on it?

Might be due to my soon 40yo brain, but I've come to more and more value forgetting things -- hoping that the really relevant to me bits of any information will "float to the surface" of my brain by themselves, over some time.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by marttt on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:39AM (#32127757)
Some more context -- Alan Kay discussing whether he has read 20,000 books in his life or not, and he also drifts to things like remembering and knowledge accumulation in general: https://www.quora.com/How-did-Alan-Kay-read-20k-books

I don't know what it is, but I feel like I could read prof Kay's musings over and over again. There's always an almost magical clarity in the way he explains things, and a lot of empathy and respect towards the listener. What a great mind.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by rsanek on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:01AM (#32125212)
Always funny to read sweeping generalizations about "really brilliant people"
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by lbrito on Sunday July 17, 2022 @01:09PM (#32128723)
There's a lot of truth there about the obsessive nature some people might take, but I don't think it's that black and white.

Some books are denser than others. Sometimes you can stumble into information very dear to your own interests, and the best way to keep preserve that memory is probably taking a note. This might be solely for personal education and fulfillment, by the way.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by panarky on Sunday July 17, 2022 @02:01PM (#32129291)
Some of us aren't "really brilliant people". Some of us are trying to make the most of an average intelligence.

While reading 500 pages of fiction or non-fiction, we're introduced to dozens of people, places, events and ideas that we'd like to know more about, but don't want to interrupt the flow of the book to pursue at that moment.

Some of these people, places, events and ideas are new to us. Some are familiar but from a different perspective. Sometimes there's a different context or frame that provides new insights into what we thought we already understood.

Those of us with average intelligence sometimes find it difficult to remember what we thought was important when we were on page 206 of 500.

Even though we're not extraordinarily brilliant, we also want to synthesize different ideas and make connections among various sources for better understanding, and for inspiration into what to read and research next.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by quickthrower2 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:06AM (#32125235)
As someone without a photographic memory I am quite interested in trying a note taking system like this to increase my enjoyment of reading, and long term benefit of it.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by zozbot234 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:00PM (#32127947)
You can write the notes up in an SRS and make sure that the ideas stay in your long-term memory. While not without their drawbacks (such as a lack of explicit support for dependency hierarchies, that might enable higher-level learning beyond raw "ideas") SRS systems really are ridiculously efficient once you go past the effort of inputing content and first committing it to memory.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by larve on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:06AM (#32127452)
For me, taking notes is writing, thinking, intellectual stimulation, not passive copying and interrupting the reading. It is engaging with the work, savoring the insights one can gather. If it is not enjoyable, if you feel it is pointless and tedious, then of course don't do it.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by mejutoco on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:56AM (#32125419)
I think writing on the margins of the book and underlining (even vertical underlining, which is very quick) is a good compromise.

I rarely read without a pencil these days. It is low effort and helps me find interesting bits later and engage with the book.

I am probably not really brilliant, so YMMV :)

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by ChildOfChaos on Sunday July 17, 2022 @06:19AM (#32125653)
I think notes so I can remember though.

When I have a thought or an idea, I can then refer to the book I read years ago with my relevant notes, else it's just in one ear and out the other.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by bachmeier on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:32AM (#32127131)
> Modern day knowledge workers are under constant cultural pressure that tells them everything they do is better if they shove it up its own ass.

I wonder what this sentence means.

"Your vacation is going to be way better if you shove it up its own ass."

???

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by synu on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:32AM (#32127688)
I don’t know if I agree, but it means to overanalyse and overoptimize everything. Being too meta instead of experiencing things directly.

You’d do that to a vacation by having a series of emotional goals for the journey, with a plan for daily photo session highlights for your social media audience, and five-point-plans for each waking hour with target goals, contingencies, and meta-analysis of how it all fits into your optimal vacation experience. You’d be taking notes throughout for your pre-planned four post blog series on how to optimise vacations at the end. Presumably all of this would be tied up into some deeply researched simple trick to get the best out of life, the universe, and everything, or get rich quick, or live forever. Something like that.

Instead of going somewhere, having a bit of an agenda, and trying to go with the flow and see what happens/enjoy it.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by atoav on Sunday July 17, 2022 @07:00AM (#32125799)
> Without specific goals in mind obsessive self-documentation is just a massive level of busy-work that doesn't actually contribute to your skills or happiness.

I don't think this is true. Taking notes like this is shown to help with the ideas and knowledge you retain after having read the book (surprisingly: if you take the notes by hand it is better than if you type them somewhere).

I often take notes while I read books or attend meetings without ever having the intention of using them for anything. It helps me memorize the important bits of the thing I spent some time of my life on. And then it can simmer within me, mix with some other books, movies, music, experiences and come out as an really new idea. And then potentially I could go back to the notes (I rarely do) if there is something I was not sure about.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by burntoutfire on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:24AM (#32126182)
I had to basically memorize a particular academic book for a tough university entrace exam. I created around 50 pages of dense hand-written notes on it, and could recall all the arguments contained in the book with detail. 15 years later, all I remember from that is that the book was about early humans, tool making... or something along those lines. The note making helped with short-term retention, but did nothing for long term retention.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:04AM (#32126397)
You need spaced repetition for long term retention.

Human memory is like dynamic RAM: you have to keep refreshing it.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by greymalik on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:04AM (#32126401)
Did you ever revisit the notes? I would expect spaced repetition to help with that.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by causality0 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:43AM (#32126681)
Why would he? Forgetting irrelevant information is not a problem to be solved; it's garbage cleanup.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by BbzzbB on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:02AM (#32126828)
I think the point is that you could occasionally read thru your relevant (for whatever interest you have) notes to keep those ideas ~refresh in memory. I doubt anyone's advocating for reading every note you've taken in school 20 years ago.

AFAIK our brains are not saturated SD cards, learning something doesn't remove an older file.

Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by greymalik on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:26PM (#32128212)
I inferred from the comment I was replying to that the commenter was disappointed to have forgotten this particular information. You can’t regret forgetting something while also considering it irrelevant garbage.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by causality0 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:54PM (#32131147)
I read it as him pointing out that taking notes only helped him while the information was immediately useful and at this point he's forgotten it as thoroughly as if he hadn't taken notes at all.
Re:I just finished reading a book and took lots of notes. No... by baxtr on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:04AM (#32126076)
Has anyone come across a decent summary service? Asking for a friend.