News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by eropple on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:55PM (#32101342)
Godot is really cool, but a clear and publicly delineated path to console distribution (and not "go talk to these guys", as they currently do) is going to be necessary to get material interest out of most of the gamedev space.
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by wly_cdgr on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:04PM (#32102001)
Yes. This is the main and only major thing that is holding Godot back from mass indie adoption. I would choose GMS2 or Unity over Godot for a 2D commercial indie project even though GML is worthless on a resume and Unity has all the Unity problems, because they build to all the consoles. Or Defold, since it is really nice and at least can target Switch. And I would choose Unreal or Unity or maybe even Cocos Creator (which recently added Switch support) for a 3D project for the same reason.

If you want mass adoption, you need to make it financially viable for commercial indies to use your engine, and good luck convincing those people if they know they need to hire a 3rd party company to port to consoles.

Since Godot can't really go the console route, though, they basically need to do the work of figuring out how their users can make enough money on just web, mobile, and/or desktop, and then articulate and successfully sell that solution to them. Steam Deck could help for sure, but it's a big ask

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:15PM (#32102080)
> Since Godot can't really go the console route

Wait, why not? I thought it was a deliberate choice on the devs' part not to prioritize native support for consoles, not something that's actually impossible (since obviously other third party engines do it).

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by skneko on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:43PM (#32102272)
As explained in [0]:

- To develop for consoles, one must be licensed as a company. As an open source project, Godot does not have such a legal figure.

- Console SDKs are secret and covered by non-disclosure agreements. Even if we could get access to them, we could not publish the platform-specific code under an open source license.

[0] https://github.com/godotengine/godot-docs/blob/master/tutori...

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Thursday July 14, 2022 @07:28PM (#32102598)
1. This doesn't seem like a big deal. I'm sure there's some legal-fu you could do here to have a 'company' that's the primary contributor to Godot. Wikipedia has a company of some sort, does it not? And Mozilla's a company.

2. So what? Yes, the console-specific stuff has to be kept secret, that sucks, but it's better than not having support for consoles at all. I'd rather have a closed-source module to port to consoles than having no official method whatsoever.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by thristian on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:42PM (#32103656)
Is there a practical difference between "Godot does not target game consoles" versus "Godot does target game consoles, but we can't tell you where or how or help you in any way"?
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:04PM (#32103800)
That's not what we're discussing. From another comment:

> MonoGame gets around it by having core team members that grant access to private trees for approved developers. It's not open source, but it's available.

Not ideal, but better than the Godot status quo.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by esperent on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:56PM (#32104450)
Yeah I feel like there are definitely ways around this, technically and legally.

However, it seems they are not compatible with the goals and philosophy of the Godot project. That is their choice to make and if you don't agree with it, then your needs don't match with Godot and you should choose a different project.

I can understand where Godot is coming from. Getting involved with the corporate world is a slippery and corrupting slope and before you know it you'll be partnering with ad and malware companies like Unity is doing. Ok maybe not, but it's still not a decision to take lightly and in a world where everyone is motivated by money it is refreshing to see some communities like Godot and Blender who are doing things their own way.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:07AM (#32105492)
If Monogame can do it, I don't see why Godot couldn't. Godot clearly wants to compete seriously with Unity at least in the indie game dev space, I don't see how you do that without a decent console solution. The more mature Godot becomes, the weirder it's going to seem that they don't support consoles.

I think just doing the minimal amount of cooperation to get SDK's or what have you for consoles would be fine, and very few people would object even within the open source community. A few diehards would no matter what, but as long as the cooperation is bare minimum I think it'd go okay.

> Getting involved with the corporate world is a slippery and corrupting slope and before you know it you'll be partnering with ad and malware companies like Unity is doing.

Godot's team isn't a for-profit company, that's the key distinction here. Unity's primary purpose is to make money, offering a game engine is just a means to that end. Godot's primary purpose is to be a useful and easy-to-use game engine, so much less incentive to blatantly sell out.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by chii on Friday July 15, 2022 @04:48AM (#32106143)
why is it only when an engine support console do it mean "serious" competition?

An indie game dev may make their game for non-console platforms, and if that game proves to be a hit, a separate development effort could be made to target a console. Or a re-implementation. If console is the first, or only choice, i would argue that the team is not really indie (by which i mean self-funded and small).

And who knows - may be godot's popularity would change the way consoles engineer their legal contracts and not hide behind NDAs and secrecy to become more open.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by eropple on Friday July 15, 2022 @10:13AM (#32108423)
> a separate development effort could be made to target a console. Or a re-implementation

"Could." Sure. Or they "could" use an engine that doesn't require reimplementation to target Where The Market Is.

Which is why, even though people really don't like it much, Unity gets used.

> If console is the first, or only choice, i would argue that the team is not really indie (by which i mean self-funded and small).

This has not been a reasonable statement for at least five years. Indie games don't have lead platforms, but they do, as a matter of practice, need to be on all relevant platforms to have a chance of financial viability. (A grand strategy game might not need to deploy to consoles. Most other stuff really, really does.)

> And who knows - may be godot's popularity would change the way consoles engineer their legal contracts and not hide behind NDAs and secrecy to become more open.

Platform holders do not care about your engine and no indie developers, even en masse, have enough weight to make swing them. EA and Activision might not, at least not in a way that wasn't a special exception just for them, and they move a lot of product by themselves.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:43PM (#32110835)
This is ahistorical.

Some of the first well known "indie" games were on Xbox live arcade on the 360, like Braid, Super Meat Boy, and Castle Crashers.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by chii on Friday July 15, 2022 @10:54PM (#32114859)
super meat boy was first released as a flash game on new grounds. The success there lead to the future release on console and PC (and i recall seeing it was rewritten for these platforms, rather than porting the flash version, but now i can't find a reference).

And while braid is indeed released first on console, there's at least one citation of Blow decrying the process: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braid_(video_game)#cite_ref-xb... . Blow likely had no choice at the time because steam (in 2007) wasn't as big a platform as it is today.

I am still of the opinion that console-only releases are not good for indie developers, despite the apparent contradiction of it being more profitable. And the reason Braid had xbox live arcade release is more to do with the industry connection Blow has, rather than the merits of the platform. Even Blow himself initially thought he'd be making a PC release for this game (until the financial side-benefits of xbox arcade back then kicked in).

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by eropple on Thursday July 14, 2022 @07:16PM (#32102502)
MonoGame gets around it by having core team members that grant access to private trees for approved developers. It's not open source, but it's available.
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by Mikeb85 on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:11AM (#32104529)
It absolutely can. It's just not open sourced.
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by remram on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:26PM (#32102156)
The consoles make this explicitly incompatible with open source though. That could possibly be a separate entity I suppose, or hopefully if Godot becomes big enough the consoles could arrange something.
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by remram on Saturday July 16, 2022 @02:50PM (#32120785)
Seems like they might be reading HN, posted yesterday: Godot and consoles, all you need to know https://godotengine.org/article/godot-consoles-all-you-need-... (discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32119337)
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by juanuys on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:23PM (#32109769)
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by to-too-two on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:00PM (#32101964)
I'd love official console support but it's not possible being open-source. Porting it yourself is an option, but not many will be inclined to do that and would have to opt for paying a third-party to do so.
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:16PM (#32102088)
Couldn't you just have a bridge library of some sort that's not open source and contains only the console-specific code?
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by to-too-two on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:42PM (#32102266)
From the official Godot docs:

The reason other consoles are not officially supported are:

- To develop for consoles, one must be licensed as a company. As an open source project, Godot does not have such a legal figure.

- Console SDKs are secret and covered by non-disclosure agreements. Even if we could get access to them, we could not publish the platform-specific code under an open source license.

- Consoles require specialized hardware to develop for, so regular individuals can't create games for them anyway.

Source: https://docs.godotengine.org/en/stable/tutorials/platform/co...

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Thursday July 14, 2022 @07:27PM (#32102594)
1. This doesn't seem like a big deal. I'm sure there's some legal-fu you could do here to have a 'company' that's the primary contributor to Godot. Wikipedia has a company of some sort, does it not? And Mozilla's a company.

2. So what? Yes, the console-specific stuff has to be kept secret, that sucks, but it's better than not having support for consoles at all.

3. Okay? Godot isn't just being used by "regular individuals", whatever that means, it's being used by people who want to make games and then sell them -- including, yes, companies -- and those people want to be able to publish games to consoles.

That last one is just bizarre. Who do they think their userbase is, exactly? "People who want to make games for PC and mobile but have zero interest in any consoles ever"?

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by Aeolun on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:38PM (#32103143)
> People who want to make games for PC and mobile but have zero interest in any consoles ever

I don’t understand why you are surprised by this? By your own admission, nobody that wants to develop for consoles would use Godot, so logically, their entire userbase are people that don’t want to do that.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:02PM (#32103780)
Can't tell if serious or satire.

There are absolutely people interested in using Godot as a game engine, including using it to make games for consoles. But many don't, because porting to consoles is painful and expensive, apparently involving third parties as a general rule.

Obviously people for whom porting to consoles is a high priority are unlikely to choose Godot right this second, but we're talking about potential users as well, not just the current exact userbase.

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by Aeolun on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:14AM (#32104544)
I just don’t think that ‘potential users’ are a really strong consideration for what ultimately amounts to a hobby project (or a project with no corporate backing anyway).
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by TulliusCicero on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:50AM (#32105377)
I don't know what your objection is. They make a game engine, they support PC and mobile by default, console is the obvious missing piece of functionality. I can understand why it's lower priority because yeah, it's harder to support, but at least one of the devs works on this full time, and the two core devs have been working on this for several years now. I think it's a bit beyond hobby project, they're clearly trying to compete with Unity, even if it's not a for-profit company.

If you read articles like this, it doesn't sound like a small hobby project anymore: https://godotengine.org/article/donation-changes

Granted, it's still small potatoes compared to Unity, no doubt.

edit: huh, looks like they have several people full-time, from the article

> Godot is developed by more than a thousand contributors, and coordinating this massive community requires a full-time involvement of several of us (and hopefully soon even more full-timers), which your generosity enables.

edit2: holy shit Unity had 5000 employees in 2021 according to Wikipedia. I knew they were fairly big but goddamn, didn't think they'd be that big.

Man, now I'm also confused at how they can have a successful, popular game engine with a flourishing asset store and yet still be losing money. Just hired too many people?

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by to-too-two on Friday July 15, 2022 @06:47PM (#32113570)
@TulliusCicero

This was posted earlier today by the Godot team: https://godotengine.org/article/godot-consoles-all-you-need-....

The Reddit discussion regarding the post: https://www.reddit.com/r/godot/comments/vzo8tk/godot_and_con....

Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by Aeolun on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:34PM (#32103116)
I don’t think that’s necessary at all, since it’d take away from core Godot development.
Re:It’s time to make that indie C# game in Godot by Mikeb85 on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:10AM (#32104526)
Why? It's dependency-free C++. It's easy to port.