News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by chrisseaton on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:28AM (#32095122)
> the video was “designed to spread love and compassion”

Hmmm.... seems more likely designed to get engagement.

Presumably he doesn't love the woman, as he doesn't know anything at all about her, so that one is a lie for a start.

And I guess he doesn't feel any compassion for her either, as he hasn't taken it down without forcing her to contact him, which she probably doesn't want to do.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by titzer on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:34AM (#32095196)
The irony is it that shows the exact opposite of love and compassion. Self-aggrandizement and no regard for others, motivated only by the needs of self, and didn't even spend an extra second with her beyond what was required to execute this vapid stunt.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by highwaylights on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:41AM (#32095281)
I don't want to tar an entire generation with the same brush, but I have noticed that younger people seem to be really taken in with these very shallow like-farming operations on YouTube and TikTok.

Mr Beast is incredibly successful at this, in that his stunts produce massive numbers for very little outlay. A friend's kid in his teens was telling me about how he's the most generous person he's ever seen and it make me wince a little as I really don't want to be that guy and wade into it with a "well, actually".

Social media has made the world an incredibly vapid place.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by Nextgrid on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:07AM (#32095576)
This has also decreased the quality of content online in general since everything appears to be optimized for idiots with a 5-second attention span.

Whether it’s TikTok videos with that awful TTS voiceover reading the caption (I can read it myself, thanks) or YouTube videos that now always start with a ~5 seconds extract which spoils the entire video, or gaming videos with insufferable personalities. Oh and don’t forget to subscribe and hit the notification bell!

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by gnubison on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:24PM (#32103039)
> YouTube videos that now always start with a ~5 seconds extract which spoils the entire video

I vastly prefer this to the kind of “informational” video that’s designed to keep you watching a 10 minute video for the 10 second answer

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by antiterra on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:00AM (#32096196)
It’s definitely a commercial generosity, but I think it differs.

Mr. Beast’s brand, and presumably identity, centers around a Calvinist ethic that hard work is a virtue even when exerted to meaningless ends. There’s a ‘don’t act too big for your britches’ undercurrent as well, flashy cars are props returned at the end of the day, not the spoils. He trades a lot of the mawkish sentimentality for self-deprecation.

Another practical difference is that giving strangers money provides more actual utility vs a bouquet of flowers. His targets for interaction are usually more appropriate, often people he has a reason to interact with or where he asks for participation.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by jodrellblank on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:22AM (#32095752)
> "I really don't want to be that guy and wade into it with a "well, actually"."

Be that guy; what's your criticism about Mr Beast's generosity? He does a lot of content which could be fake; like giving his friends $20,000, but ones which look more serious and genuine and costly include:

- Opened a "free bank" where he loaned money into six figures to local people, then surprise! it's not a loan, they can keep it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORUX1lHbOa8

- Bought everything in a supermarket and donated it to a food bank: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ha4tRQwKIUg

- Donated $100k to plant trees, and organised a fundraiser which raised $21M to plant 20M trees: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPJKxAhLw5I

- Ran a contest of TV show style challenges (endurance, falling into goop) with some of his viewers as contestents, with a million dollar prize at the end that one of them won: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQ4m4zD7BBA

- Gave away three houses or free rent for a year in them: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJH28ICkCdU and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sfv1QaRzJg8 and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cCpZl8euLI

- Bought every car in a car dealership and gave them away: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LLnjRLrvLU

- Gives his credit card to people, encouraging them to spend tens thousands of dollars on things they get to keep: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IYVjOfoU3uI

What's vapid or not generous enough about these for your liking?

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by gambiting on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:32AM (#32095894)
I don't know how to explain it - if you make your living by being charitable, then the whole act of charity is somewhat lessened, no?

It's like when nestle announces they are going to plant 1 million trees - like yeah, it's very generous of you, no doubt - but you are doing it as a marketing exercise.

Mr Beast is making money this way. I am extremely far from saying that there's anything wrong with it - but it's not charity in my mind. It's just a business that happens to benefit random bystanders from time to time.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by ALittleLight on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:37PM (#32098294)
I'm sure he is making a profit off it but whatever good is happening is still getting done. He could be a famous YouTuber by playing pranks or video games and make millions too - is that better?

I share an unsettled feeling about this. I think it is because things like this are a visceral reminder of differences between the rich and poor. A life altering struggle for a poor person is a solved by ten minutes of amusement from a rich person - "here, take my card and buy whatever you need."

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by gambiting on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:22PM (#32098932)
>>I'm sure he is making a profit off it but whatever good is happening is still getting done.

I'm not saying it's not. I don't want him to stop. But I don't think I'd call it charity personally(and some people do, that's why I'm making this point).

Like, let me try again with an example - if you pull $10k out of your account and give it to a homeless person, that's charity, right?

Ok, but what if you get someone to invest $10k into you making a youtube video, because you promise them they will make this money back from monetization, and you then record a youtube video of giving the homeless person that exact $10k. The video then proceeds to make way more than that $10k in revenue. Is that charity too? After all the end result is the same - the homeless person was given money. Or is it just good business?

The second example is exactly what Mr Beast has done. I'm not saying he shouldn't have - just observing that what he does, the entire spectacle of it - it's just a business venture.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by sorry_i_lisp on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:48PM (#32099984)
MrBeast is in the business of arbitrage.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by webkike on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:00AM (#32096887)
Mr Beast is making money this way for sure, but he’s also feeding that money back into being generous, so I think in this case it’s fine
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by highwaylights on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:52PM (#32100029)
Since you insist:

Any one of the aforementioned things could have been done at any time, anywhere, on an ongoing basis, that would have helped communities in a sustainable way.

When he gives the cars away, or makes loans to people, he often films people getting significantly different amounts (or items of significantly differing value) simultaneously. I would assume the reactions are more valuable when someone has gotten less than one of their friends in the same group - this in particular is cruelty, not kindness.

Even setting the above aside, the big issue I have with it is that it’s not charity or altruism but is masquerading as such for profit. This is his business. Every act is a carefully calculated profit/loss equation relative to how many views he thinks he can get.

Typically philanthropy would be considered willingly disposing of money you earned elsewhere when it’s not necessary for you to do so, in order to help a cause.

Beast isn’t doing this. He’s reinvesting his profits into growing his business.

You wouldn’t call a mechanic a philanthropist for fixing people’s cars for money, even though they’ve done something that people appreciated.

At best, Beast is redistributing the ad revenue from his viewers and skimming signifcantly from the top (given that it’s expected he’s approaching billionaire status).

For what it’s worth I do respect his business acumen. He’s found a good hustle and is working it very well.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by Zachsa999 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:28AM (#32095838)
This is important because Mr Beast doesn't actually spend a lot of time self aggrandising. He approaches philanthropy similarly to how many ultra wealthy people do; giving in public, only he makes more from it.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by nautilius on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:38PM (#32101142)
He makes money off of it. There’s nothing wrong with that, but that doesn’t make him a charity, imo.

You could make the same case for Walmart: look at all the people (employees) they hand money out to! With many of them likely having much tougher lives than I do and thus being absolutely deserving of the money. But Walmart does it for the sole reason that it improves their bottom line —- just like Mr Beast.

Do you think Mr Beast would insist on spending millions in a video if he could create the same income from just “Giving $1.5 to strangers!” videos?

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by mattgreenrocks on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:28AM (#32097283)
> I don't want to tar an entire generation with the same brush, but I have noticed that younger people seem to be really taken in with these very shallow like-farming operations on YouTube and TikTok.

I don't fault them. They're only responding the world that we, the older generation, are implicitly condoning. Fact is, our culture does not teach the benefits of generosity much, and the few instances we see are often highly public: "$FAMOUS_PERSON donates $LARGE_SUM to $NONPROFIT!" Anonymous donors are never trumpeted the same way.

There is a marketplace for virtues, and people need role models.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by tsol on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:07PM (#32098730)
>There is a marketplace for virtues, and people need role models.

Good luck convincing people of this. One of the primary purposes of religion was to provide that role model figure, but society has thrown out that concept altogether. Nowadays I see more of a "everyone is flawed and whoever you think is a role model is probably a secret pervert or something" philosophy as common. So what does anyone expect? If we decide the theological/moral foundation of society is false without replacing it, then obviously morality will change as a result. It's like throwing out the bath water, and then complaining that there's no baby for some mysterious reason.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:46AM (#32095339)
I don't think it's a generational thing, but a social media thing, and I think it looks like it's representative of "everybody" when in truth it's representative of the people who are more active on social media, which should be a small proportion of the general population.

I hope anyway.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by Graffur on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:08AM (#32095590)
What is your opinion on Mr Beast? I just watched a video of his for the first time and he gave away over $500,000.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by WesleyJohnson on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:30AM (#32095869)
Mr. Beast's driving motivation, as he's stated many times in interviews, is to make the best YouTube videos he can. He spends millions on his videos these days, all in an effort to outdo the previous one and provide the best content he can. So while he certainly does give away money in some of his videos, he films it in order to make money while doing it. I don't doubt that he's some level of generous, but his motivations are not solely benevolent.

His first viral "giveaway" video was him giving a homeless person $10,000. That wasn't his money. He got a company to invest in him by giving him the money to donate (while filming it) and promised them a return on their money. It's been a business venture from the outset.

That said, it doesn't really bother me. If he makes $1m dollars giving away $500k, so be it. He reinvests that money back into his business, that employs many, many people and sometime finds its way back to those in need. He's not inherently rich, he needs to make money to donate it and his means of making that money is sometimes exploiting the very act for likes, clicks and ad revenue.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by slillibri on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:19AM (#32095727)
Mr Beast is a game show host. He’s not giving away his own money yet everything is framed as the giant act of generosity on his part. He’s giving away money much like Bob Barker gave away kitchen sets.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by maest on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:29AM (#32095852)
Honest question - how does he fund these giveaways?
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by chrisseaton on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:40AM (#32095971)
YouTube has advertising, as his videos have sponsorship. His audience is like double the level of an episode of Friends at its peak, so I guess the slots are worth a lot.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by onion2k on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:13AM (#32096336)
He made $24m in advertising and sponsorship in 2020.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by CPLX on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:14AM (#32096342)
The same way Bob Barker did.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by epups on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:48AM (#32096055)
But he owns his channel, no? So any money not spent in giving reverts back to him.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by tipsytoad on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:56PM (#32098561)
No. A sponsorship would give a clear budget, if blizzard gives him 500k for video expenses the rest would go back to blizzard, not him.

Blizzard would probably require him to spend all the money though, as more money = more clicks.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by highwaylights on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:56PM (#32100076)
I’m stealing this comparison. It’s mine now. I came up with it.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by Graffur on Saturday July 16, 2022 @05:35PM (#32122198)
Okay.. but it's his platform right?
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by TrickyRick on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:24AM (#32095786)
Yeah to me he seems genuinely generous. Obviously there is a part of it being done to attract more viewers (Otherwise he could simply not upload the video at all) but from my, granted limited, experience of his videos a lot of the money he makes goes in to making (I.e. donating more) new videos. Very different from getting millions of TikTok views for the price of a flower bouquet.
Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by titzer on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:13AM (#32097041)
The discerning questions are: would he do this a) with his own money and b) if no one is watching?

I think both are no.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by hderms on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:38PM (#32098306)
Why are those questions the end all be all of the discussion? Many good things are done in the world that have a variety of motivations. He could get views in a variety of ways but the fact that he's doing it by helping people shouldn't be dismissed just because he wouldn't spend millions of dollars with no one watching.

Not to suggest he's operating in any way like a non-profit, but they all receive money and then distribute that money in ways that either increase the future money they can use for their mission or directly on the mission itself. The fact that he's built a self-sustaining model for helping individuals without merely forking over his own assets is impressive.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by kkielhofner on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:53PM (#32098525)
It’s amazing how many people don’t realize this and post some comment/reply/like that reinforces this behavior.

Some of these incidents even make the news, positioned as some heartwarming feel good story.

In short from the perspective of the attention seeker/clout beast - it works.

Re:Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her co... by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday July 14, 2022 @08:43AM (#32095306)
>> And I guess he doesn't feel any compassion for her either, as he hasn't taken it down without forcing her to contact him, which she probably doesn't want to do.

I think it's not lack of compassion but lack of understanding. He probably thinks the lady is trying to milk the episode for likes. I'm guessing he has no capacity to comprehend that her life may not revolve around social media likes.