News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by krisroadruck on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @02:39PM (#32086975)
You also pay way less. DoorDash and all the others don't just charge the fees and the tips and what not, they also inflate the food cost by a pretty hefty amount. A simple example:

McDonalds has a 2 for $2 deal on sausage mcmuffins & hashbrowns - been around forever. Let's say you and the wife want a McMuffin & a hashbrown each - you're in for $4 dollars and a bit of change for tax.

Here is the same meal via DoorDash:

McMuffins: $2.87ea Hash browns: $1.91ea

Subtotal: $9.56 (just below the 10 dollar minimum to wave the fee if you have DD+)

Delivery fee: $1.99 Service fee: $3.00 Tax: $0.91 Dasher Tip: $5 (good luck getting your order on time if you tip less than this)

Grand Total: $20.46 for $4 of food.

You can "optimize" by ordering an additional hash brown to get over the $10 hump so you can wave the delivery fee and reduce the service fee - which will instead cost you a total of $17.91 for $5 worth of food. Either way it's a shit deal. Not included here are the costs associated with 1 in every 4-5 orders being incorrect, or delivered to the wrong house and the hassle that adds to your life.

Obviously I went with low cost items to illustrate a point but often any food prices you see on DD are a good 50% markup vs going in person regardless of the restaurant before you even get into fees and tips.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by apalmer on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:23PM (#32087600)
This to me is what killed delivery as a service. It doesn’t work even when they are charging what works out to be double the salary the restaurant pays its own delivery people. And it works out for no one, restaurant, driver, even the delivery as a service providers since they are all hemorrhaging money.

It’s a fake industry held up by VC money.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by Nextgrid on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:28PM (#32088343)
Even the VCs ultimately don't make a profit on it. I think the only winners here are the employees of the delivery companies who get paid hefty salaries to work on a guaranteed failure.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by slotrans on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @11:16PM (#32091576)
The early VCs make money as long as they can sell their stake to a different set of VCs in a later round.

The later VCs make money if the thing IPOs before the universe proves it can never be profitable (as with Uber).

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by bombcar on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:48PM (#32088559)
The VCs could make money if everyone became dependent on it, they drove the actual delivery restaurants out of the market, and then jacked prices.

But I don’t see Dominos dropping delivery.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by Nextgrid on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:50PM (#32088583)
Only one company must win for this to work. If they compete (and use their respective VC’s money to subsidise orders) then they all lose.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by propogandist on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:12AM (#32093376)
most of the VCs dumped these POS companies onto retail investors by going public

personally I would to like to see their share prices go to zero

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by NavinF on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:34PM (#32087731)
Who would be dumb enough to pay $20.46 for that?

I looked at my most recent receipt for something more realistic: A $12 (in store) pizza was listed on doordash at $14.25 and I paid $17.30 in app with the Chase CSP discount. I guess not everyone has the card, but IMO it’s financially irresponsible not to.

Note that this restaurant is a 20 minute drive each way. Even if I worked minimum wage ($15/hr in CA) it would have cost me a lot more ($10 time + $5 gas!) to pick it up myself.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by kelnos on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:14PM (#32088204)
> it would have cost me a lot more ($10 time + $5 gas!) to pick it up myself.

Can we stop doing this? Our free time has zero monetary value. Every minute of our lives is not billable, and it's disingenuous to frame it that way.

Sure, avoiding 40 minutes of driving time might be worth $10 to you (it is to me, too), but... just say that, maybe?

And I agree with you in general that the grandparent's example was maybe not the common case. Sure, sometimes people get late-night munchies and make a small delivery order to Taco Bell, but I would hope that most orders are at least for a single, full, lunch- or dinner-sized meal, and will often be for multiple people. Delivery is still certainly more expensive than going into the store, but not having to deal with driving somewhere to pick it up also has value to many.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by pcthrowaway on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:25PM (#32088308)
If you're a contractor and set your own hours, the relationship is pretty clear.

You could spend 30 minutes to pick something up, or that same 30 minutes has a value of half your hourly rate (minus taxes). Why would you be opposed to anyone doing the calculus on how to best utilize their time?

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by bombcar on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:45PM (#32088523)
I think it’s because people use it to justify being lazy - if you were going to sit there waiting for your food and then use that time not driving to justify the delivery costs - you’re kind of kidding yourself that you’re “saving money”.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by fancyfish on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:36PM (#32088421)
Agreed, I see this often where people confuse their marginal income (e.g. $0) with their total income. Most are paid a salary and don’t just choose to work an extra hour on a moment’s notice. Let alone the possibility of working 24x7 and having billable hours like a switch they can flip at any time.

The framing of something “costing me my time” has never made sense to me especially when someone tries to actually quantify it.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by vageli on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:54PM (#32088624)
Even if you can't make money during that time, time is inherently limited and most people value their limited time on the planet. Some may value that time more than some arbitrary dollar amount.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by Dylan16807 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @06:23PM (#32089478)
You can't reallocate time and money "on a moment's notice", but why does that matter?

Most events can be moved around, so even if there's a big delay on changing your work hours you can still exchange extra free time with extra money.

And people generally can choose how many hours they want to be paid for.

It's easy to quantify, it's just something that happens in bigger shifts. One hour by itself probably doesn't make you change your work hours. But as more and more hours pile up, eventually you might chose to reduce your work week by half a day. Or if you find yourself doing unimportant and uninteresting things very often, and with a shortage of cash, you might increase your work week by half a day.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by throwaway675309 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @05:23PM (#32088923)
"Our free time has zero monetary value"

You're right... it's priceless. Some of us really do place a high value on our finite quantity of time that we have on this planet.

I remember being absolutely flummoxed by how much time people were willing to just throw away to camp overnight for some hot commodity Black Friday sale at Best Buy back in the day.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by NavinF on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:50PM (#32088581)
I do freelance work so I really can convert 40 min into money when I want to.

> avoiding 40 minutes of driving time might be worth $10 to you

My point was that avoiding 40 minutes is worth the price increase for almost everyone, not just me! You’d have to go out of your way to find exceptions such as the GP’s McDonald’s deal.

And yeah doordash pretty much forces you to order at least $12 off food which often works out to 2 meals. I’m sure a lot of orders are larger too.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by dawnerd on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:55PM (#32087984)
A lot of people surprisingly. People all the time late night ordering Taco Bell.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by bombcar on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:46PM (#32088543)
Not around here. For some reason they went to 7am to 7 pm hours because of short staffing - breakfast tacos must be big business.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by seoaeu on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @05:07PM (#32088777)
In other words, you paid $17.30 for $27 of goods and services ($19.50 if the driver avoided the return trip). Which means someone was losing money on the deal and the price is unlikely to be sustainable long term
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by NavinF on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @07:43PM (#32090144)
The driver almost always avoids the return trip because of how these routes are scheduled. I also see the driver dropping off 1 or 2 other deliveries on the way to my place so your math is way off.

That aside, you’re mostly right about people losing money: Doordash nets -10% of revenue. Most restaurants also pay a commission to Doordash which effectively gets passed on to me as a discounted delivery fee, but I dunno if you’d count that as “losing money”.

I think it would be pretty easy for them to turn a 10% profit though. All they have to do is increase prices by ~15% and cut their R&D budget in half (currently 10% of revenue). I’ll enjoy the cheap deliveries while it lasts.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:01PM (#32087316)
But guess how much money I can save by not having a car?
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by krisroadruck on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:11PM (#32087444)
None. If you live in a city that has enough stuff nearby or public transit sufficient to be considered "walkable" your housing costs are 2-3x higher than they would be otherwise and your taxes are probably higher as well. Far more than the cost of a car.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:20PM (#32087551)
You keep forgetting other scenarios - someone who works remotely and can just take Uber when he needs to go somewhere during the weekend.

In fact, my son started working at a pizza place before he had his driver's license. It was cheaper to pay Uber $350 a month than his current car note + car insurance.

Just to give you a hint about "affordability", we paid $335K in 2016 to have our house built - 3100 square feet - in the "good school system" in the burbs of a major metropolitan area.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by mrguyorama on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:43PM (#32088501)
$350 a month would cover a $22ish thousand car loan. I know the used car market is a bit absurd right now but I think you're being a bit excessive
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @05:00PM (#32088689)
You're forgetting about how much car insurance is for an 18 year old male. Car insurance alone is $200+/month for a new driver.

https://www.valuepenguin.com/18-year-old-car-insurance.

It's slightly cheaper bundled with a parent's insurance.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by mrguyorama on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @06:47PM (#32089696)
Are you getting screwed over for how much liability your state requires you to carry? The insurance on my $0 value dodge neon in 2012 AFTER a fender bender was $400 a year, because it was on my mom's plan, and had $0 of coverage for my car and only the minimum liability required by the state (which is a reasonable amount).

All of my high school friends have the same experience as I do, a car with near zero value, and no collision coverage, just liability, and paid similarly dirt cheap rates. My friend had coverage on his old dodge van for $120 a year.

My car insurance on my nearly new car is actually double the price, despite me now being significantly older than 18, because I pay for coverage so I could repair it if it gets in an accident.

Consider switching insurances?

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by staringback on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @07:12PM (#32089899)
> just get the state minimum for liability!

This is absolutely terrible advice in almost all circumstances. I am curious, what you consider a reasonable amount? People in California with the state minimum end up with $5,000 worth of property damage liability. Hope you have the remaining $75,000 sitting around when you accidentally run into a nice car.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by bombcar on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:49PM (#32088572)
The era of kids driving old hand-me-down cars is over. Now at 16 you need a $85k SUV or why even bother!
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @05:03PM (#32088721)
Well, seeing that my (step)son is six foot 3 and couldn't even fit in my car at the time -- a Chevy Sonic -- that wasn't an option.

Also car insurance for a teenage male ain't cheap...

https://www.valuepenguin.com/18-year-old-car-insurance

Not to mention that the old car needs maintenance and repairs.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by googlryas on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:25PM (#32088303)
Huh? Yes your housing costs will be higher but your salary will probably be higher too. I was able to save/invest insane amounts of money by ditching my car and job in suburban NJ and moving to Manhattan.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @05:05PM (#32088757)
I was able to ditch my car and work remotely for "a FAANG" while living in the South....
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by horsawlarway on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:21PM (#32087566)
You say this like it's either/or.... which is dishonest.

I have no car, but between grocery delivery and an e-bike, why would I want to continue paying an exorbitant tax to get shitty, cold food two hours after I order it?

Basically - you having a car or not has zero (zilch, nada, nothing) to do with the insane markup these companies charge.

And if the difference in you having a car or not really was doordash... jeez man. Go re-evaluate your life.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:25PM (#32087618)
Yes my difference between spending money on the average price of car + car insurance + gas + maintenance and using Uber for the weekend and a delivery service for the week is great.

I bet you live in a higher cost of living area and not in the cheaper burbs to be able to take an e-bike everywhere.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by horsawlarway on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:42PM (#32087825)
You keep conflating the type of wholesale delivery services talked about here (doordash/uber/grubhub/etc) with delivery in general.

I have no problem calling a restaurant and ordering delivery. Or ordering groceries for delivery.

Neither of those delivery services is charging me a 50%+ markup to get food from them. And the quality of the food is generally much higher.

Doordash and Uber are charging me a 50%+ markup.

Basically - I have no problem with you preferring delivery instead of a car (hell - I made a similar choice and take public transit and bike when delivery doesn't work)

I'm saying that's unrelated to the fact that you're getting swindled by these companies.

If you're coming out ahead by using doordash, imagine how much money you could save if you literally just called the same fucking restaurant and ordered delivery directly.

---- As for your bet...

I live in SW Atlanta. For comparison - cost of living in Atlanta is almost exactly the national average (101.8%), and the south side of the city is MUCH cheaper (I paid less than you for our house, slightly smaller at ~2200 sqft, but we got nearly a full acre of land)

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @05:08PM (#32088793)
I happen to live in North Atlanta off of 400.

Most restaurants don't have there own delivery service.

If these companies aren't making money, how are they "swindling" anyone?

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by horsawlarway on Thursday July 14, 2022 @10:05AM (#32096259)
If you're in Cobb I'm going to laugh my ass off. No wonder you're averse to public transit (can't have those "undesirables" coming in).

Unless you mean you're actually out near cummings or something and just claim it's Atlanta still. In which case... maybe - I don't really head up near Lake Lanier all that often.

Otherwise... plenty of delivery in brookhaven/perimeter/roswell. Honestly, you probably have more options for local delivery than we have across all of these services.

---

> If these companies aren't making money, how are they "swindling" anyone?

Well - outside of the obvious damage discussed in the article, a simple answer might be that it's entirely unsustainable, and you're making long term plans based on services that won't exist in a year or two if interest rates keep climbing (even the CEO of grubhub calls food delivery a "crummy" business and wants to pivot to handling the advertising while kicking the delivery service back to the individual restaurants).

In the mean time you're not doing anything to address the real problems with transportation in that area, and you continue to live in an area that's extremely hostile to your long terms goals of being a "digital nomad".

Further... even though these companies aren't making money, it's cheaper to order your food for pickup and pay someone on taskrabbit $18/hour to go get it for you rather than add $3-$5 to every item, a $5-$10 delivery fee, and tip on that new inflated price. So yes - I'd say you're getting swindled still.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by scarface_74 on Friday July 15, 2022 @01:28PM (#32110646)
> If you're in Cobb I'm going to laugh my ass off. No wonder you're averse to public transit (can't have those "undesirables" coming in).

I'm one of those "undesirables". When I use to go pick up my son, they immediately knew who my son was just by looking at me. Trust me, I'll be invited to a BLM rally way before I would ever be invited to a Klan rally.

> Unless you mean you're actually out near cummings or something and just claim it's Atlanta still. In which case... maybe - I don't really head up near Lake Lanier all that often.

Cumming is very much part of the Atlanta-Sandy Springs-Roswell, GA MSA

https://dch.georgia.gov/sites/dch.georgia.gov/files/Atlanta%...

> In the mean time you're not doing anything to address the real problems with transportation in that area, and you continue to live in an area that's extremely hostile to your long terms goals of being a "digital nomad".

I'll be "living" across the US and taking advantage of Uber/Uber Eats by the end of the year.

> Further... even though these companies aren't making money, it's cheaper to order your food for pickup and pay someone on taskrabbit $18/hour to go get it for you rather than add $3-$5 to every item, a $5-$10 delivery fee, and tip on that new inflated price. So yes - I'd say you're getting swindled still.

There is a markup. But UberEats is much more integrated into the food delivery system than a random task rabbit worker and it is still cheaper.

Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by shyn3 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @02:54PM (#32087176)
UberEats in Canada inflates the regular menu price as well.
Re:DoorDash and pizza arbitrage (2020) by tomcam on Thursday July 14, 2022 @01:13AM (#32092271)
Wherever you’re living, stay there! I haven’t seen prices like that at my local McDonald’s for years