Ask HN: What's the Deal with Tailscale?
Hello HN! Could somebody explain to me why tailscale appears so frequently on the HN front page? I see posts from tailscale or about it every 2-3 days. I haven't observed such behaviour with anything else.
Even if these posts are 100% legal (ie there's no upvoting ring behind them) I still feel that the moderators should manually demote them from the front page because right now it feels like some form of cheap advertising trick.
Why not add a rule? Only one front page post about a product every month.
I'd really like to get some insights from the community and the moderation about that.
Thank you!
(
47 comments
| 35 points
| on HN
)
Blame the game, not the player.
I know I will click on a Tailscale post because people have said it's cool, I tried, and it is indeed cool and it feels like I'm only scratching the surface.
There is astroturfing on HN but don't forget we're a bunch of enthusiastic tech nerds. Do you complain because there is a big number of Linux or M1 posts? People really like them.
Disclaimer: not affiliated with Tailscale or any of its employees, haven't interviewed with them, not even giving them any money. I am not from a marketing or ad agency but just a lowly SWEng nerd.
However as I propose to the ask HN, the HN could add a rule to impose a limit to the amount of product related articles on the front page per month (or some specific time duration). This will protect other companies in the same space and improve the quality and interest of the site.
HN has grown too big to ignore this.
Let HN regulate itself. You don't like it, hide or flag it or ignore it. People will soon move onto the next shiny thing, and that time, you might be one of the enthusiastic commenters being excited about it.
The more the rules, the more ways to exploit and game the system. Not everything has to be codified.
That's not how it works today though, the moderator (dang) can move posts to and from the top of the frontpage, one example being posts about YC funded companies being artifically bumped to the top at times.
It'd be more like one Apple ipods article, one Linux Debian article etc.
These intricacies is why we have lawyers and Reddit moderators killing your post because there is an arbitrary exception to their 15 rules you hadn't considered. We can do without these.
(This whole conversation thread reminds me of my time reading Bakunin & co. :)
No thanks.
As for your rule limiting submissions to the front page to only one every month. Who’s gonna moderate that? Are blog posts about the product also prohibited? Cause that is how I learned about Tailscale in the first place.
My point being, no I wouldn’t want a rule to moderate something like this. Because I come to hackernews to learn about these types of stuff.
Learn to ignore stuff in live you don’t enjoy.
I wrote about this phenomenon here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30070287 - in the bottom third of the comment, starting with "Stripe succeeded on HN". (Skip the tedious stuff before that.)
* It allows for faster transfer speeds.
* It's less laggy.
* It takes less time to negotiate the P2P routes on "difficult" topologies (both peers behind CGNAT, for instance)
* It actually just works (with ZT it was hit-and-miss. mostly hit but very frustrating when miss)
* It was easier to run on my router and just use that as a gateway, as opposed to meshing all my devices (I did this with ZT but there was quite a bit of configuration and trial-and-error required -- TS just works)
Perhaps TS gets more coverage because people like it better?
Disclaimer: not affiliated with either company, just a happy user - despite the issue with identity providers.
Makes sense, but it should be transparent.
There is one big exception to this, which is Launch HNs as described in https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html#yc. Each YC startup only gets one of those, and they're clearly indicated.
Tailscale goes for adoption by convincing enthusiasts that might also be decision makers.
ZeroTier thought it could just survive on its own merit, in a time where "Zero Trust" as a concept was almost entirely unknown.
ZeroTier founder here. We never did anything remotely like that, so I'm curious about where in the world you heard that. Is someone out there saying that?
We regularly tell people about FOSS stuff like this:
https://github.com/key-networks/ztncui
We did adopt an AGPL or SSPL style licensing strategy a while back to discourage closed for-profit attempts to basically expropriate the product. We are considering going back to a more liberal license in the future since that issue seems to have lessened. But we never had any issue with FOSS or not-for-profit stuff using ZeroTier.
Can you point me to more information about this? According to my limited understanding, the ZeroTier coordination server is open source.
No i haven't tried it since it's not something I need. However my point was not about Tailscale being a good or bad product. My point was about the amount of a product related articles in the front page of HN.
Let's suppose I had a product in the same space as Tailscale. How was I supposed to get any customers if everybody in HN knew about Tailscale?
About the rule: I think once a month is enough; the article would get traction and you d still see it and learn about it. The duration is not really important, it could be 15 days is a month is too long. But definitely not every 3 days like it is now!
Finally, the moderators would do the moderation. Users would flag frequent Tailscale articles and the moderators would demote them.
Banning Rust for example, would be a massive improvement for the overall quality of the site but would deter a lot of conversations and site traffic. HN is an important part of making sure that YC companies have built-in exposure and marketing by using the site to ensure that a lot of people will see certain posts. In this same way, Tailscale is important to saturate the audience with, recently.
I don’t envy the job, however poorly I think it might be being done. It’s like being a world leader or something. It’d be miserably stressful for most people who complain about it, but absolutely catastrophic if they tried themselves. Someone has to do it, at the end of the day.
Tailscale posts is like free advertising to the Tailscale company. There's a whole community behind Rust that would benefit from these posts, and not a single company.
So no surprise that the product he made is also interesting to HN
My personal opinion is that missing either one of those posts through a "once a month" rule would be a negative to me. I personally read both and interacted with both and got value from them.
Deno and fly.io are also things that seem to have been mentioned a lot lately and while I'm not in the "market" for them like I am for Tailscale, I still find it useful to see those mentions.
Much of what I get from HN, like going to Python conferences, is just hearing the "word on the street". Artificially muting that word on the street because something similar has been mentioned within the last month, is a disservice.
Finally, your point about "Say I have a tailscale alternative, how do I overcome the Tailscale inertia?"... You do cool stuff. Tailscale SSH is something they recently built and is very cool. However, the first mention can ride on the coattails, much like one of those tailscale references I mentioned above: "netbird is a tailscale alterantive". But it just didn't generate enough interest.
If you can show legitimate vote fraud or the like that is leading to Tailscale showing up unreasonably frequently (again, it seems your perception is skewed, because TS has only been frontpage twice this month), then that's one thing. But muting what other people seem to be legitimately finding interesting is totally unreasonable.
Tailscale doesn't seem to be cool to me. It just solves a common problem using cool open source technologies. There are thousands much more cool and interesting and important projects that don't get to be twice a month on the front page of HN. Actually they have never been on the front page of HN so we never know about them and they never take off!
Showing off a project so frequently does not offer anything to the HN community, only to the pockets of the Tailscale owners.
Seems like the voting public of HN hold a different opinion to that :).
> Showing off a project so frequently does not offer anything to the HN community, only to the pockets of the Tailscale owners.
I don't use tailscale, and I found both of those posts around VPN meshing into AWS and their abstract ssh command quite interesting. Different people enjoy different articles. There are plenty of topics here (Rust, US politics, etc) that I skip over.
From a privacy perspective Tailscale never see the keys to decrypt this traffic, and as mush as possible the traffic goes point to point, not through a Tailscale server.
That said you do have to trust them to orchestrate setting up the keys across machines.
Other than that, keep in mind that major updates of software/services often result in a flood of secondary "literature" about the topic.
• Once you have tried Tailscale - you are hooked;
• The team behind Tailscale is capable of changing the industry;
• Tailscale users become evangelists;
Sincerely yours, Tailscale fan
“Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, bots, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email [email protected] and we'll look at the data.”
“Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.”
Disclaimer: I am not a mod. I just believe the guidelines are worthwhile following.
I am old enough to have seen fans of many companies write kool-aid comments with zero shilling involved, and I really find it difficult to tell the difference between fans and competent marketing. An analogue to Poe's law (parody vs sincerity).
I honestly want to learn from you: how you differentiate comments written by true fans, versus saccharine shilling written by marketing droids?
Going forward, consider properly researching pricing and consider that what you might find easy might not be what the vast majority of people agree with.
Disclaimer: I have no relation to Tailscale, but the company I work for pays for the business tier service.
Comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31957379 is exactly right.
I used the 'disgusting' reference because the parent did. I could have lightened the language perhaps, but I truly do find it detestable when people use subscription services to pave over something that takes a small amount of time to learn. The comment is certainly no more egregious than the parent.
> and had both objectively false info (tailscale is in free for individual use)
Dunno what that means, I never disputed that in my comment, you seem to be reading it out of context.
With regards to the pricing, your comment said "pay a subscription fee", which implies all tiers of Tailscale are paid, which they aren't, similar to AWS free tier services.
I looked closely at that data (though not in recent weeks) and saw zero evidence of that.
People reach for this conclusion much too quickly when they see a topic (or opinion) they're not fond of showing up repeatedly on the site. That's why the site guidelines specifically ask you not to post these insinuations when you don't have any evidence (and why they ask you to email us if you think you do).
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
However the fact that this product is about networking makes me even more suspicious about a very elaborate voting ring.
However I agree, without any proof perhaps it's just a very smooth product.