News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Give up GitHub: The time has come by duxup on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:00PM (#31935373)
This isn't very compelling to me.

SourceForge went bad ... and everyone left. That doesn't seem like a bad thing and there's no reason for me to think any given site / service will or won't go bad too. I expect that for any number of reasons I might need to move from one site to the next.

The rest too is kinda hollow to me. The fact that they're for profit doesn't upset me. I figured they wanted to make a profit when I signed up even ... not sure how that would surprise anyone now.

Co-pilot, I personally don't feel there is a compelling reason to leave github due to that either.

Maybe I'm not versed enough in some of this but as a rando dev I'm just not having any problems on github these days ...

I'm not saying the author is wrong or right or that I'm right or wrong, just that I'm not finding that article very convincing.

Re:Give up GitHub: The time has come by phodge on Thursday June 30, 2022 @08:05PM (#31940395)
There actually _is_ a good argument in there, but the article is really poorly written and all the preamble about SourceForge ends up being a distraction from what you really need to stop and think about:

FOSS projects like the Linux kernel use the GPL license because the developers want their code to be free not just for themselves, but for everyone everywhere for all time. It's not acceptable terms for you to take their work and use it to build an alternate operating system that you aren't going to share. If this wasn't important to them they could have just published their code under MIT/BSD licenses.

If you were to build an AI that used the Linux source code to generate a "new" closed-source operating system, in a very real sense all you've done is invent a new way to plagiarize the Linux community's work so that you can weasel your way out of their license terms. Even if you got away with this in the courts, it's obviously very unethical.

What Copilot does is enable the mass plagiarizing of open source code from everyone all at once, mixed up together so that it's hard to know who the original authors were, and then pretend that somehow this makes it ethical.

Re:Give up GitHub: The time has come by bink on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:42PM (#31935891)
It's been years, but as I remember it SourceForge's primary downfall was the bundling of malware with binaries. That's why people I know stopped using it completely rather than because it was run on a proprietary platform.
Re:Give up GitHub: The time has come by bombcar on Thursday June 30, 2022 @06:13PM (#31939345)
Sourceforge, for all of it's name, wasn't really a place to get source - I'd say some immensely large percentage of users used it to download binaries for Windows.

And then it killed itself in its confusion.

Re:Give up GitHub: The time has come by duxup on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:51PM (#31936018)
Yup that's how I remember it. Suddenly I didn't touch anything on SourceForge.
Re:Give up GitHub: The time has come by shrimpx on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:36PM (#31936627)
Also the UI sucked. I never looked forward to using it.
Re:Give up GitHub: The time has come by flurdy on Thursday June 30, 2022 @05:54PM (#31939162)
Yes the UI turned into a car crash. So many ads, and restrictions.

Also they kept changing the services they offered to projects so often I gave up on that as well.

Re:Give up GitHub: The time has come by account42 on Friday July 01, 2022 @08:00AM (#31945202)
OTOH uploading was a lot nicer than GitHub since you could just rsync over SSH.