Thinking about this more, at least in my city it seems like one of the problems is that for a generation now, politicians have consistently outsourced decisionmaking to a poll of the community.
In theory, one elects a politician to be independent decisionmaker for the constituent's interests, for the length of their term; and if at the end of the term the people didn't like their decisions, they're voted out. This gave politicians latitude to do what they thought was best, with the greater good of the community in mind.
In the past half century, (and again, only in my city) this model seems to have changed to politicians being elected, and then running every decision past the community as a kind of popularity poll. Developer wants to replace an auto lot that's been abandoned for a decade with dense apartments? Better poll the community to see what they think. Adding a protected bike lane to connect two existing bike networks? Let's ask the community first. And of course when they do that, the only people who show up are the NIMBYs, and the politicians get the impression that nobody wants development.
The NIMBYs have spoken, we better leave that disused auto lot abandoned and blighted! (And this is a real example from today's news!)
Any new bike lane require a community consultation (which is a problem in itself!, but let's forget that for a minute)... but who comes to those? The working class families that have to take care of their kids in the evening? Or older folks that have no other plans on a random week night? Before COVID all those meetings were in person at some community center. Of course for any cyclist to get there, they'd need to bike on a street with no bike lanes. So who shows up? People in cars!
Things are slightly easier now because lots of those meetings moved online with Zoom, making it more accessible to a bunch of new people. But I'd recommend (if you're not doing it already!) to keep showing up to all consultation meetings, because that's the only way things get done.
Concillor was telling me it was hard to make a case to the civic servant that they should keep pushing for bike lanes when ALL consultations kept only getting opposition. Even thought they all knew it was likely more popular, but it's hard to argue with the "democratic" process.
I wonder how much more a politician could accomplish if they simply stopped asking? Like, do the job they were elected to do, and not constantly be going to the popularity poll, where it's going to be nobody but NIMBYs filling out 'nay' forms?
Just do it! If it truly upsets the community, they can always knock it down at the next election, right?
The problem is that politicians run this weird highly skewed sampling method of "community input" and then think they've got the pulse of the community, where in fact they've just heard from loudmouths with too much time on their hands.
A statistical poll would at least show what the actual constituency wants, not the loud, bored subset.
The subset problem is also why we see much more extreme politics in cities among elected positions that have less visibility: city council members tend to be much more extreme than mayors, because the latter has greater voter participation.
This is very different from statistical polling.
Those constituents are the ones paying for said projects, so yeah it’s kind of important that everyone is on board before committing money.
An admittedly straightforward example: in my city, each street gets to decide for themselves if they want paid parking or not. (Residents and businesses can get a permit for a reasonable yearly fee.) A vote can be requested by any resident at most once every two years, in which case every house in the street receives a letter with information, a voting form, and a return envelope.
I think this is a lot better than basing decisions on the opinions of what's likely to be a vocal minority that shows up on consultation meeting.
I wonder if you could have something like jury duty for these meetings, where a dozen people from the community are selected to comment each week or something.
One example is Oregon State's Citizen's Initiative Review process, which is just like you describe.
https://medium.com/participo/citizens-initiative-review-help...
https://ballotpedia.org/Citizens%27_Initiative_Review
https://healthydemocracy.org/podcast/2020/01/06/podcast-demo...
And we should do this for each issues
If there was no vote then it's just some arbitrary evaluation of that consultation. I mean what's the procedure to calculate the for-against of a public comment?
Isn't the elected officials (supervisors, councilors) elected to do the campaign based on what they think their voters would want?
Isn't there a bike club or some other token NGO they ought to invite? :o
Nuanced messaging and debate is a thing of the past. It doesn't fit in tweets and sound bites. Now, if you disagree with me, easier for me just to say you're evil than try to rebut your points. And this in turn feeds the media amplification effect. Who has the most emotionally compelling narrative? Who can parade out the most horrifying pictures? It doesn't matter if they're from a completely unrelated incident two years ago (and were staged), or that the "victims" are paid activists.
"Politician" is now a career. This means perverse incentives for such people; instead of ONLY considering what is best for constituents. They must also think about getting reelected.
Bureaucracies and government careers make decision-makers risk-averse, and most people react to having to make risky decisions by wanting more study before deciding. So the politicians and the bureaucrats only have up-side to accepting delays (they would call it "listening to constituents"), and suffer a huge risk of down-side if they green-light something that ticks off some noisy NIMBY or activist. And they rarely have the skill set or incentives to write contracts that result in the best outcomes.
The article talks about the perverse incentives associated with unions; these are only made worse with public sector unions.
Finally, our courts don't have loser pays and no longer are "speedy" by any reasonable definition. So you can tie things up for years with an activist lawyer on your staff, and make your opponent spend millions in legal fees to respond to all your noise. Plus, if you get lucky with a jury of people who don't understand the science of your issues and just buy the narrative, then you can win really big.
We need a lot of reforms in our republic. Most of them center around removing perverse incentives and externalities.
Politics used to be a hobby for the already successful who wanted to give back. These people were bound by a sense of what was right. Elitist as hell, yes, but at least they weren't trying to climb the corporate ladder.
See how many career politicians you get under those conditions.
I know Americans hate politicians but we treat mass murderers better than that. We definitely treat billionaires who are far more corrupt and have far more power than most politicians better than that. Why not go full Thomas Jefferson as well and just hang all the politicians every 20 years?
> I know Americans hate politicians but we treat mass murderers better than that.
The point is not to punish politicians but rather to ensure that there can be no conflicts of interest, or at least none rooted in a quest for material gain.
> if (I assume, given the tone of this premise) they get so much as a parking ticket.
"Malfeasance" goes a bit beyond parking tickets. What I had in mind was more along the lines of bribery or corruption, not simple mistakes.
When? It was just as often a way to have influence, power, and exploit them to get money.
Green Deals? Rainbow flags? Swings in abortion policies? Current levels and composition of immigration flows, be it in the US, Sweden or Greece?
A few of them perhaps, but the typical prime mover of politics is an active and loud minority which cares a lot - and whose cohesion and initiative puts pressure on politicians.
The NIMBYs are no exception.
You’d be surprised what you can accomplish if you’re organized. A prof I worked with was able to introduce a bill to congress (that he wrote with the congressmen’s staff) simply because he built a relationship and then proposed something the congressmen liked.
The issue is the vast majority of voters do nothing more than vote.
What we need is real leadership from politicians
who are willing to stake their tenure in office on
pushing projects through.
Easy to say, but our current system proves that it selects for politicians of exactly the opposite ilk.How do we change the system?
Well, nothing is broken, except non-NIMBYs dont care enough to do the same!
The answer is simple. Show up to council meetings and vote! If you don't, you don't care as much as the NIMBYs, and the result is clear.
Nothing is broken, it is called democracy.
Sometimes it ends up going all the way to Congress: http://www.startribune.com/obama-gives-his-approval-to-bridg...
You can't YIMBY generic things like "more bike paths" or "better roads" you have to identify particular projects and build a group that will support it, and work on it for years sometimes. For lots of things, there are groups that can help out there, you just have to find them. And part of that "working" at it is listening to the NIMBYs so you can understand their concerns (even if the leadership of a NIMBY group is batshit, the people "on their side" at least resonate with some of them) and work to mitigate/solve them.
And be prepared to take advantage of disasters to push your side forward.
The zoning meeting for my city is the same night as my kid has scouts. This is why I don't show up: I have other things going on in my life. Even if they did pick a night where there is nothing else, I really want to get into my shop and build something and this meeting is taking that time away from me.
There is another problem: the people showing up for school board and causing problems are not the same as showing up for zoning and causing problems. And there is also the library and parks board, each either their own meetings I could show up for. Different groups show up for each, and I cannot counter them all.
Neither side can tackle anything that can't be roi positive by election time. Most of those projects are "deck chairs on the titanic" value propositions.
[any] project that is longer than a politician's term
will leave them open to sound bites they can't recover
from. It puts them in a position at reelection time
of having all the cost, and none of the payoff.
Yeah, this is my take. We've designed a system in which literally all that matters is continually preparing for the next election, which is typically not more than four years away for any politician.I challenge anybody who thinks this is okay to take a long, hard look at their own lives and think about what they've accomplished in the last four years. Hell, it took me three years just to get my garage door replaced for a variety of reasons.
Four years might have been enough time to do something meaningful back when a mayor's biggest project might have been, I don't know, installing new hitching posts for horses on Main St. It's not enough time to do anything today, and that's why nothing gets done.
And yet, I don't know the answer. Longer terms for politicians seems like they would create as many problems as they would solve.
I'd go even further than that. It's not just politicians who engage in short-term thinking, corporations engage in even shorter term thinking as well.
In fact, I'd posit that much of the division in our society is related to such short-term thinking.
When manufacturing and farm jobs (primarily, but not entirely through automation) started to go away, it was clear that things needed to change in order to maintain a semblance of parity throughout the country.
Rather than slashing funds for infrastructure and transportation 40+ years ago, we should have employed those folks who were losing their jobs to build high-speed rail, housing and infrastructure throughout the country, making it possible for folks to continue living where they were and have jobs elsewhere.
And 25 years ago, we should have started building out municipal Internet infrastructure all over the country, even in rural areas, instead of giving giant corporations tens of billions to do nothing.
But instead we ignored these problems (as such projects would take decades) and folks in exurbs and rural areas became detached from the economic engines that drive the economy -- causing many folks (especially young folks) to abandon the places their families had lived for generations.
This devastated many communities. Having high speed transporation and Internet could revitalize many of these communities, through start ups, work from home and fast transport to regional population centers.
That would bring money into the local economies and create incentives for new housing, business (all those people will need stuff -- food, housing, household appliances, etc., etc., etc.) and include those areas in the economic engine that made the US so successful.
But since we didn't do that, folks in well connected (transportation and network-wise) areas have flourished, while people in areas that don't have seen their communities shrivel, their outlook sour and their futures crumble before their eyes.
Is it any wonder that many of those folks feel neglected and left out? No. Because they have been.
And as the population centers prosper, the folks who have been left behind see their fellow Americans as destroying their world by ignoring and neglecting their infrastructure, talents and the enormous human capital that they represent.
But no. The politicians won't think past the next election (although the infrastructure bill is a start -- just 40 years too late) and corporations rarely look past the next quarterly (or if we're lucky, annual) earnings reports.
And if we don't alter course to make all Americans welcome and part of the larger society, we're just going to see more suspicion and ill will that will continue to divide us.
I wish I knew how to fix that, but I don't. So all I can hope for at this point is that I'll be dead before we rip our country apart.
And more's the pity.
And, holding public comment hearings outside of traditional working hours so that non-retired people have a fair shot?
IDK seems pretty hopeless..
Could just put a ballot at the end of tax forms. Just piggy back the ID confirm the IRS does. Doesn't have to be mandatory. Give a $5 tax credit for filling it out. People who don't pay taxes can vote normally or by mail.
Universal mail in voting. I'd go as far as to make mail in voting the only way to vote.
Make every state have the same voting day (primaries/general). This helps reduce media influence on the elections.
Get rid of first past the post voting. Allows for more political parties, increasing the odds people are engaged with one of the parties. Something like ranked choice would keep their vote relevant even if their preference didn't make the cut.
It's infuriating to me when people recognize there is a problem, yet toss up their hands and not try new things. How is repeating the same thing going to get different results?
I don't think that's quite fair. Look at the statistics of who actually turns up to vote. The median voting age for mayoral elections is 57 [1]. Seniors are 15x more likely to vote than those aged 18-35. If I had to guess, this would only get worse if you get into even more obscure elections like city council. Incidentally, Boomers are much less likely to bike everywhere, so you can't really blame the politicians for catering their policy to them.
Real leadership is to do what politicians are already doing because most people who pursue high-level leadership positions do it for selfish reasons.
As for why they care about NIMBYs so much - it is because our current class of politicians aim to be career politicians. Therefore, they look to remain in power at all costs, and part of that means not pissing off the most vocal members of their community.
What we need is real leadership from politicians who are willing to stake their tenure in office on pushing projects through.