News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by jacooper on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:36AM (#31896051)
Apple claiming security as a reason for monopoly, how classic.

The EU's digital markets act bans the only Safari lock on IOS, so this is gone whether apple likes it or not. (1 - sorry couldn't find a better source)

Safari is the new IE, there is a difference between a monopoly while still being able to use a competing product (like chrome in other platfroms), and forcing Safari(WebKit) while hindering the web because of Apples interests.(2-3)

1. https://www.fudzilla.com/news/54763-apple-loses-out-in-the-d...

2.https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/23/opinion_column/

3.https://www.theregister.com/2022/06/14/telegram_safari/

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by nicce on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:29PM (#31896913)
> Safari is the new IE, there is a difference between a monopoly while still being able to use a competing product (like chrome in other platfroms), and forcing Safari(WebKit) while hindering the web because of Apples interests.(2-3)

Ehm. Chrome is the new IE. Apple is using anti-competitive methods but its far far away from market domination.

Microsoft is doing even more, by pushing so much Edge-only stuff.

On iOS Apple forces the Webkit rendering, but for normal user it does not even matter much. They can download Chrome and get the UI they want.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by gunapologist99 on Monday June 27, 2022 @01:48PM (#31898064)
> Apple is using anti-competitive methods but its far far away from market domination.

Apple Safari has, literally, 100% marketshare across the entire iPhone market. Its App Store also has 100% marketshare and enforces the Safari marketshare.

I have an iPhone 13 Pro Max. I love the hardware, but I'd love to install other browsers; why can't I? I'd also love to run real PWA's or run WebRTC without major issues. Why shouldn't I be able to do these things?

Apple enforces its own browser, which it carefully and deliberately hamstrings, in order to force web apps to not bypass the App Store, so Safari also enforces the App Store marketshare.

They're tightly tied together (so tight that the Windows-IE tying isn't even in the same galaxy) in order to enforce the other's marketshare. At least Microsoft allowed third party browsers and installing apps from other locations. This is tying on a completely different level.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by irae on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:44PM (#31903185)
For all your criticisms against Safari you still bought the most expensive phone on their lineup. So I guess they got so many other things right so you apparently still believe they ship the best phone out there.

I used to wish for Firefox on my iPhone too. But after a while I got skeptical this would benefit me or other users. Apple was the one to make the hard decision to kill Flash, and Firefox is known to have done their missteps too. So what if they are right in their decision and Safari does have a role in the reason you and so many others consider the iPhone the best phone to buy?

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by gunapologist99 on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:03PM (#31903628)
Well, I actually don't consider it the best phone to buy; I consider it among the best hardware. I think a Google Pixel is a much nicer and more comfortable phone, although the iPhone has a far better screen and is a lot prettier, although its shape is uncomfortable to hold, even with a nice Otterbox.

I'm running GrapheneOS on the Pixel. It is perhaps ironic that the best phone to de-Google is actually a Google, and that Google both allows this and explicitly supports it, but it's not possible to de-Apple any iPhone.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by irae on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @07:34AM (#31906407)
Yours is not the only comment I see here that eventually comes down to the OS discussion.

We are supposedly talking about Safari, yet Safari is tied to iOS not to the hardware. People can install Brave or Firefox on Android. But they are not ever satisfied. I don't have the numbers, but I suspect the sum of GrapheneOS and other de-Googled Android distributions might be bigger than the sum of Firefox and Brave on regular Android.

In the end, maybe Apple should just allow you to download some software that voids your warranty and roots the iPhone, while removing iOS. People can then reverse engineer and do whatever they want. But Apple's drivers and some of the chips are proprietary, and that I don't see a way people would convince regulators to enforce them to open-source those.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by viktorcode on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:16PM (#31900185)
Your "marketshare" definition is bogus. I could claim that Firefox has 100% marketshare of PlayStation consoles.

There's no such market as devices of a single manufacturer.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by capableweb on Monday June 27, 2022 @05:16PM (#31900921)
If you buy a computer from ASUS, you can download whatever browser you want. If you buy a cellphone from a Android-manufacturer, you can download whatever browser you want.

But if you buy an iPhone, you can only download browsers that are using Apples own browser.

Just because smartphones have traditionally been locked down, doesn't mean that it should be like that.

PCs were also pretty locked down the beginning. And Windows have tried a couple of times to move in that direction. But fortunately, we have a relatively open ecosystem when it comes to devices we use for "producing" things on. It's just missing that the devices we "consume" on works similarly.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by viktorcode on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:18PM (#31924528)
PCs weren't made "open" by the government regulations. Any company if it wishes so could start selling a locked down Windows machine with no ability to replace the browser. Nobody will call this company "a monopoly" for that fact alone.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by smoldesu on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:52PM (#31900624)
...which is equally ridiculous. If Sony is actively preventing Playstation owners from installing other browsers with their control over app distribution, then that too should be considered malicious and just further indicates how necessary sweeping legislation like this is.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by viktorcode on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:14PM (#31924489)
That's exactly why markets aren't defined in that way. See judge's notes from Epic v Apple trial.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by KerrAvon on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:06PM (#31899236)
Do you understand that you are spouting conspiracy theory brain poison?

Feel free to debate the end result. If you presume motive, you can be proven wrong.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by capableweb on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#31899565)
> Do you understand that you are spouting conspiracy theory brain poison?

Why don't you actually refute the points they made instead? If it's so obviously "conspiracy theory brain poison"

Webkit quite literally has 100% market-share on the iOS platform, as no other browser engine is even allowed. Same goes for the App Store, 100% market-share.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by zuhsetaqi on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:02PM (#31898265)
> Apple Safari has, literally, 100% marketshare across the entire iPhone market. Its App Store also has 100% marketshare and enforces the Safari marketshare.

And that’s the big difference between Safari dominance and IE at the time. Safari is only on iOS/iPadOS dominant not in the entire market like IE was

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by LMYahooTFY on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:53PM (#31899008)
That's what countered the claim that Windows+IE were 'one product' as opposed to separate, right?

Outside of legal-land this seems like a BS argument, and even more so now. But legal-land is what matter first I suppose.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by dcow on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:52PM (#31898988)
There was no mobile at the time.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by zuhsetaqi on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:34PM (#31899646)
It’s not about mobile or desktop, it’s about marketshare. So just all devices.

IE had a nearly 100 % percent marketshare and Safari is far away from 100 % marketshare.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by jacooper on Monday June 27, 2022 @01:22PM (#31897722)
IEs biggest problem isn't market domination, its hindering the entire web, and pushing proprietary stuff.

Safari is one of the worst browsers in terms of compatibility, like PWAs and notifications, they are unsupported on purpose to push developer to develop apps and give apple a cut. And when they do adopt new technologies, they are often super late like webp.

Please die WebKit.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by barkerja on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:56PM (#31900670)
These features were actually recently added. See https://www.apple.com/ios/ios-16-preview/features/

Web push notifications

Adds support for opt‑in notifications on iOS. Coming in 2023.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by jacooper on Monday June 27, 2022 @07:02PM (#31902063)
Hmm, preparing for market changes ?
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by dmitriid on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:57PM (#31899081)
Safari supports everything in PWA (which is a non-existent thing, but a dozen standards in a trenchcoat) except notifications.

By "compatibility" you mean "support all of the Chrome's no n-standards it pushes at breaking speed"?

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by the_gipsy on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:39PM (#31899712)
> except notifications.

Which is THE single selling points that brings everyone to make 2 native apps instead of one URL. It hs been available on Android for a decade, and is still undetermined when it will actually land in iOS.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by jacooper on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:14PM (#31900166)
It won't, they want to push you to make an app no matter what.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by jolux on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:58PM (#31902881)
Actually Web Push is coming in iOS 16.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by the_gipsy on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @02:56AM (#31904930)
It's not in the release...
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by jolux on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:39AM (#31932907)
Well iOS 16 is still in developer preview and it won't be launched for another 3 months almost, so it might not be in the currently released versions. But here: https://www.macrumors.com/2022/06/06/ios-16-support-web-push...
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by the_gipsy on Monday June 27, 2022 @06:03PM (#31901443)
I bet
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by niko001 on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:43PM (#31897142)
It might not matter to users in the sense that they ask themselves what rendering engine Chrome on iOS is using under the hood, but the effects do matter. I get a lot of support requests saying "Your [web] app is broken on my iPhone!", "Right, Safari doesn't support feature XYZ", "I'm not using Safari, I'm using Chrome", "..."
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by CharlesW on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:48PM (#31897232)
How does the developer story get better if you're required to support many web rendering engines on iOS instead of one? Or is the endgame that you'd just point people to Chrome/Blink and extend the web monoculture to Apple devices too?
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by jsnell on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:55PM (#31897324)
The endgame is that Apple is forced to actually make a working browser, rather than intentionally starve it of resources to benefit the App Store. Everyone wins.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by mynameisvlad on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:50PM (#31897260)
That seems to be a communication problem. Instead of saying "Right, Safari doesn't support feature XYZ", say "Right, iOS doesn't support feature XYZ".

It's also technically more correct, the best kind.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by snowwrestler on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:26PM (#31899540)
Just wait until Google has Chrome running natively on iOS and introduces nonstandard behaviors to break Safari rendering intentionally.

Then at least you’ll be able to tell all your customers that you recommend switching to Chrome for all browsing. What a great victory for browser diversity and the open web!

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by lenkite on Monday June 27, 2022 @01:23PM (#31897739)
Both Safari and Chrome are the new IE's. Regulation should force folks to download a browser or have competing browser (with relevant competing engines) already pre-installed on both iOS and Android.
Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by mtomweb on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:51AM (#31896281)
Source was the DMA final text: https://twitter.com/OpenWebAdvocacy/status/15271019882567229...

Also many have now spoken up against it:

### Electronic Freedom Foundation (EFF) Apple’s restrictions on third-party browsers, and the limitations it puts on Safari/WebKit (its own browser tools) have hobbled “web apps,” which run seamlessly inside a browser. This means that app makers can’t deliver a single, browser-based app that works on all tablets and phones - they have to pay to develop separate apps for each mobile platform.

That also means that app users can’t just switch from one platform to another and access all their apps by typing a URL into a browser of their choice.

### Mozilla Mozilla believes that major platforms should be under an on-going duty to:

Stop practices that distort competition on the merits and inhibit consumer choice, such as: ● interfering with consumer selection of alternative browsers and use of those browsers to access the internet from links and queries on their devices; and ● dictating or controlling browser components, such as browser engines, which prevent consumers from accessing and using their preferred browser across all operating systems and devices.

### Google By contrast, PWAs—and the web writ-large—receive a small fraction of this support on iOS. This is primarily because of Apple’s requirement that all browsers use its proprietary WebKit browser engine. Not only does this prevent browsers from differentiating from Safari—Chrome is unable to access the user’s camera, preventing users from using products like Google Lens—it also harms user security. A recent study from Google’s Project Zero security research team found that WebKit is significantly slower than other browser engines to fix reported bugs.

### Microsoft Apple requires that any mobile browsers on iOS, including those offered by Apple’s competitors (e.g., Google’s Chrome app), use Apple’s own WebKit browser engine. This restriction harms competition and consumers.

### Meta Apple requires all web browsers on iOS to use WebKit, a degraded version of Apple’s Safari browser, to render web pages. Apple thus sets Safari as a functionality ceiling for mobile browsers on iOS. The restrictions on Safari’s and other iOS web browsers’ capabilities prevent web pages and web apps from providing consumers with robust, cross-platform experiences that would lower switching barriers

### Telegram We suspect that Apple may be intentionally crippling its web apps to force its users to download more native apps where Apple is able to charge its 30% commission

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by JCWasmx86 on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:01PM (#31896463)
> proprietary WebKit

That is not true. WebKit is opensource, there are other browsers that use it (GNOME Web), it is used in a lot of other applications, like GNOME Builder, Devhelp.

Re:Apple's claim is that it bans other browsers for security by mtomweb on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:13PM (#31896669)
It doesn't matter if WebKit is open source or not (in the context of the topic) because only Apple can make modifications to the WebView on iOS. Adding or removing functionality, fixing bugs is entirely under Apple's control.

On iOS third party browsers: ● Can't pick their own browser engine ● Can't pick which version of Webkit they wish to us ● Can't turn browser engine features on or off using flags ● Can't add entirely new browser engine features ● Can't edit browser engine features ● Can't entirely remove browser engine features ● Don't even get all the features of Webkit that iOS provides Safari ● Get a more restricted version of Webkit than the one iOS provides Safari Safari and the WebView that browsers use do not get the same level of access) ● Use a version of Webkit provided that is tied to iOS system updates as opposed to packaged with the third party browser

On Android third party browsers: ● Can use their own browser engine ● Can pick which version of Blink they wish to use (if they are using Blink at all) ● Can turn browser engine features on/off using flags ● Can add entirely new features to Blink ● Can edit existing features in Blink ● Can completely remove features from Blink ● Don’t have to use Blink at all