News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by nus07 on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:09PM (#31864546)
I fail to see what moderates can do in a two party system where gerrymandering is so heavily done that often Democrats have to win 3-1 to control any majority. At this point I see it as a fight between rich landowners+business owners+religion vs all the rest of the people . For a country where political lobbying and donations to effect legal decisions is common , I do not expect judgements to ever be fair. The battle between union and state rights only muddies the waters for legal speak.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by noslenwerdna on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:22PM (#31864857)
Where is gerrymandering so bad that Democrats have to win 3-1? This doesn't represent the experience of the median voter.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by pilotneko on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:44PM (#31865343)
Well, Tennessee literally just split the 5th Congressional District, represented by U.S. Rep. Jim Cooper, D-Nashville, among three different outlying districts. Literally makes it 3X harder for a Democrat to represent Nashville.

https://www.tennessean.com/story/news/2022/01/12/republican-...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by slg on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:27PM (#31864975)
Not exactly gerrymandering, but there is a systemic bias against Democrats due to the structure of our government. The most obvious example, Republicans have won the national popular vote once in the last 8 presidential elections.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by corrral on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:42PM (#31865296)
Those stats might hold regardless, but to be fair one would expect different voting patterns under the current system, versus a direct popular-vote election, so it's not accurate to say that anyone "won" the popular vote in any US Presidential election, since that wasn't the contest and the fact that it wasn't affected how voters and candidates behaved. It's like challenging someone to a foot race, losing, and then deciding afterward that you won on "style points" or something. That wasn't the contest, and the other participant might have done things differently under different rules.

The system as it stands makes voting pointless for people who are in districts that reliably go for the "other team". If they could at least influence the Presidential election, more of those voters might show up at the polls. GOTV and other campaign efforts take this into account, which magnifies the effect.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by slg on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:53PM (#31865551)
Fine, you want another example of systemic bias in our government? The 50 Democratic senators represent 41.5 million more people than the 50 Republican senators.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by NovemberWhiskey on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:10PM (#31865855)
Also: don't forget that the District of Columbia has no voting representation in Congress.

DC has a larger population than Wyoming or Vermont, and will probably overtake Alaska by the next Census based on its current trajectory.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by nonameiguess on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:02PM (#31867757)
Not just DC. American Samoa, Puerto Rico, Northern Marianas Islands, US Virgin Islands, and Guam are all American citizens but can't vote for president at all, don't get a Senator, and collectively only get a few representatives, most of whom are ceremonial and don't get to vote.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by dntrkv on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:06PM (#31865792)
I don't really have an issue with the way the senate is setup, since that was intentional. My issue is with the house, where we are supposed to have equal representation, but don't.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by dragonwriter on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:12PM (#31865890)
> I don’t really have an issue with the way the senate is setup, since that was intentional.

Why is bad intent less bad than bad accident.

> My issue is with the house, where we are supposed to have equal representation, but don’t.

House representation was supposed to be approximately equal limited by granularity and it remains approximately equal limited by granularity.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by slg on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:25PM (#31866121)
>House representation was supposed to be approximately equal limited by granularity and it remains approximately equal limited by granularity.

But the "limited by granularity" part is growing more and more limited. The size of the House originally grew as the size of the population grew. Once we capped the size of the House, we lost relative granularity allowing this problem worsen as the gap between the smallest and largest congressional districts increased.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by adamc on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:10PM (#31866876)
It was intentional and a big part of it was to protect slave-owners. Evil intent does not get a pass.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by refurb on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:31PM (#31866219)
That’s not a systemic bias against Democrats, that’s an intention design so that small states and large states have more balance of power.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by devmor on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:19PM (#31867038)
Which is literally a bias against democracy.

States are not fixed entities. It's people that should be represented, not an arbitrary geographic boundary.

That intentional design makes it so depending on where you physically live, your vote is worth many times less or more than someone else's. That makes no sense.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by refurb on Friday June 24, 2022 @04:06PM (#31868588)
Please bone up on government design. Democracy sucks, it’s majority rule. We’re a republic that is intentionally designed to provide balance rather than “51% voted to spend 99% of the budget on the cities so I guess rural folks can pound sand”.

Note that pretty much every country has something similar - some body that acts on a check of pure democratic representation.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by devmor on Saturday June 25, 2022 @02:44PM (#31877653)
Ah, yes, instead we should have 35% voted to end civil rights for an entire group but they live in more land, so 65% can pound sand.

Much better.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by refurb on Sunday June 26, 2022 @06:38PM (#31888792)
But it’s not ending civil rights? The legislature is still free to pass laws protecting abortion. All the heavily blue states that support abortion won’t see any change at all.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by devmor on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:24AM (#31907384)
It is in fact, ending civil rights for hundreds of millions of people.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by i5Aj7PXGjUPy on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:10PM (#31866877)
idk why you're getting downvoted. This was literally a compromise made by the founders to protect smaller states from larger states
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by corrral on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:06PM (#31867824)
The downvotes are probably because intentional bias is still bias.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by claystu on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:34PM (#31866272)
That's not a systematic bias. The senate was DESIGNED from the beginning to be immune to population differences: each state gets two senators, regardless of population. It was one of the compromises that convinced the small states to join the union in the first place.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by corrral on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:06PM (#31866803)
Intentional, designed-in bias is still bias. Right?
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by SirensOfTitan on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:01PM (#31865686)
Democrats in general have some unhealthy obsession with the presidency that leaves important downstream races from local municipal government to gubernatorial races ignored. Republicans have been doing the grueling work for decades to dominate local politics and it shows.

Roe v Wade is so devastating of a defeat largely because democrats who support it don’t care enough about state and local government.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by setr on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:45PM (#31865359)
That statistic seems pointless? Republicans won 3/8 of the last elections (bush x2 , trump x1) with 2 losing the national vote. So 6/8 rounds came through properly.

More importantly, there’s apparently only been 5 presidents elected where popular vote != electoral vote[0].

Based on this metric… everything seems to be working mostly fine, with no apparent bias?

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_presid...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by lotsofpulp on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:35PM (#31866289)
That is not my definition of mostly fine.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by etchalon on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:25PM (#31866113)
The issue is the trend is accelerating. It used be rare. It is no longer rare.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by prepend on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:34PM (#31867309)
It’s not accelerating, you’re just biasing your sample based on what’s happened recently. These are different things.

It’s pretty hard to declare a trend with such small numbers.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by TimedToasts on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:44PM (#31865337)
If the Presidential vote was decided on popular totals then this stat would mean something.

Everyone knows the rules going in.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by lostdog on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:51PM (#31865503)
The crown was passed down by primogeniture. Everyone knew the rules going in, so it was fair and democratic.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by giaour on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:03PM (#31865741)
Before 2000, it was an interesting thought experiment but dismissed as highly unlikely that a president could technically win office without winning the popular vote. Republicans (but also some purist democrats) were apoplectic when Bill Clinton took office with an electoral majority and a mere popular plurality in 1992.

The ground shifted has shifted around the rules many times in the past, but the current rural vs urban divide of the two parties combined with the majority of Americans living in urban and suburban areas has led to some really distorted and unintended outcomes of the rules.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by chimprich on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:32PM (#31866237)
> Everyone knows the rules going in.

Does knowing that a system is undemocratic make it more democratic in some way?

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by sandworm101 on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:02PM (#31865707)
Exactly. Everyone must know and accept that some people's votes are worth more than others. Whether it is for a senator in Iowa, or for the electoral college that selects the president, the people in some areas of the country are allotted more power than those in others. It has always been that way and so shall it remain.

Anyone not happy with the power allotted their vote is free to up stakes and move somewhere where votes are worth more, from California to Iowa or New York to New Hampshire.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by jofer on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:42PM (#31865310)
> The most obvious example, Republicans have won the national popular vote once in the last 8 presidential elections.

Isn't that the other way around? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_presiden... (i.e. Democrats have won the popular vote in the last 8 presidential elections, but have only won the office in 5 of those).

Also, I had forgotten this (and it was huge at the time, and I voted in those elections, so I should remember), but Bill Clinton didn't win the majority popular vote either. The democrats had a larger popular vote that the republicans, for sure, but not over 50% due to third party / independent candidates.

Contrast that with the last 6 elections where the democratic party has had more than 50% of the popular vote each time.

Ah... And W's second term the republicans had more than 50% of the popular vote...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by phpisthebest on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:50PM (#31865488)
National Popular vote for President is about the most worthless static one can cite to bluster their position for political balance

National Popular vote should not be used for any reason for any purpose, unless you want to completely change the American system of government ending federalism completely, which I have no desire for, I like federalism

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by slg on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:00PM (#31865678)
>National Popular vote should not be used for any reason for any purpose, unless you want to completely change the American system of government

Well, yes, that is exactly what many people want, a government that is more representative of the will of the people. We don't have to throw out federalism to get there, but a system that was not intentionally designed to support minority rule would be nice.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by phpisthebest on Friday June 24, 2022 @04:36PM (#31868979)
The system was intentionally designed to reserve power to the people AND the states, just not the people. Aka Federalism

If you remove the power of the states, leaning only on "the will of the people" you are getting rid of federalism,

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by giaour on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:07PM (#31865806)
Yes, we'll need to completely change everything about our government, just like we did when we mandated elections for senators in 1913. /s
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by guelo on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:00PM (#31867732)
You like federalism because you're a conservative and there is a higher percentage of conservative states than conservative people. And that is just a result of political territory gerrymandering battles of the 1800s. For example splitting Dakota into two states or admitting Wyoming as a separate state were all political gerrymandering battles that benefit your ideology today.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by hollerith on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:07PM (#31867827)
We just had a demonstration in the US of the desirability of a process that unambiguously reveals the winner of a presidential election. Well, having 50 smaller elections, then combining the results in an electoral college is one such process. In particular, if it werent for the federalized structure, i.e., if we had a purely popular vote, in 2000 we would've had to re-count not just the Florida ballots, but also the ballots in the other 49 states.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by phpisthebest on Friday June 24, 2022 @04:39PM (#31869003)
I am far far far from conservative so that is fail.

1990's democrat platform I was probally 60-70% aligned with, 2020's democrat platform I am 20% aligned with

Republicans I probably agree maybe 40% with, 50% on a good day.

In this context as an example, I do not agree with banning abortions, but I also think Roe was bad law and decided incorrectly so.....

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by guelo on Friday June 24, 2022 @04:41PM (#31869023)
The point I was trying to make is that federalism is dumb because states are arbitrarily gerrymandered based on 1800s politics.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by purephase on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:00PM (#31865683)
It's easy to like it when it provides you the outcome that you're favourable towards. For people, the majority in this case (as evidence by the popular vote count), who do not agree with these outcomes, federalism is a fucking mess.

In no way it makes sense that the Senate should wield the power it has when South Dakota has the same weight as California. It's ludicrous.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by Der_Einzige on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:25PM (#31866122)
Getting rid of the electoral college is not the same as killing federalism. It's not even close.

What planet are you living on? Seems not to be earth...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by mypalmike on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:33PM (#31867289)
They seem to live on a planet where "PHP is the best". It's definitely one of the stranger parallel universes.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by IndySun on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:54PM (#31865566)
>Republicans have won the national popular vote once in the last 8 presidential elections.

You mean Democrats.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by IndySun on Friday June 24, 2022 @07:40PM (#31870904)
Ah, I misread. In common parlance, my bad. I publicly take it back.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by yowzadave on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:17PM (#31865994)
3-1 is an exaggeration, but e.g. in Wisconsin 2018, Democrats won 54% of the popular vote and ended up with only 36% of the state assembly seats:

https://www.reddit.com/r/VoteBlue/comments/fwa7sa/regarding_...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by mjochim on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:22PM (#31867092)
If the numbers 54 and 36 is correct, then one could be inclined to a simplified calculation and say that 1.5% of popular vote (54/36) equals 1.0% of seats. In that case, 75% of popular vote would equal 50% of seats. Or in other words: 3-1.

(and 50% of seats are not even a majority)

Another model would require 15% more to go from 36% to 51% of seats. In this case, 69% of popular vote (54+15) would be required for a majority of seats, or in other words: 2-1. Which effectively is just as egregious as 3-1.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by seanp2k2 on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:33PM (#31867297)
Between gerrymandering and electoral college it’s pretty bad, see https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-new-national-congre... recently
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by Symbiote on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:30PM (#31865073)
I don't know the numbers, but this article was linked from the Guardin's coverage of the decision:

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2021/nov/...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by ehsankia on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:52PM (#31865513)
Forget 3-1, what about 65-1?

Legislation needs to pass both Senate and the House, and in the senate, someone from a state like Wyoming has 65x more voting power than someone living in California.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by dahfizz on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:57PM (#31865626)
That is intentional. The same mechanisms exist in the EU to protect smaller states, for example.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by bluesnowmonkey on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:15PM (#31865956)
States don’t need to be protected. States are not people. Government is of the people, by the people, for the people. Not of the states, by the states, for the states.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by prepend on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:37PM (#31867351)
Do small countries in Europe not need to be protected?

I think the issue is that small states and countries would not join if they would be subject to whatever large states decided.

So the option would be to have a country without Vermont and stuff or to have them in the current config. Because that’s the math that was done 250 years ago that resulted in NY and VA choosing to accept it, and also smaller states.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by oezi on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:38PM (#31867381)
And it is has led Europe to serious problems when there are two countries (Hungary and Poland come to mind) which protect each other from anything inconvenient.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by scythe on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:02PM (#31865726)
I can't endorse his specific numerical claim, but if you look at the FiveThirtyEight projections for Georgia, a state that voted for Biden in 2020 and elected two Democratic Senators in statewide elections, also with Democrat Stacey Abrams coming within 2% of the governor's seat in 2018, you see four blue districts, one toss-up, and nine safe Republican seats:

https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/redistricting-2022-maps...

I think any reasonable person would find it unfair that a 2% difference in the popular vote (for governor, before the major Trump controversies) leads to doubling the number of Congressional seats.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by thebooktocome on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:27PM (#31864987)
Some of the maps proposed by the Ohio GOP this year (and rejected as unconstitutional by the Ohio Supreme Court) are close to this. I believe I read an estimate that the dems would need to average 70-30 statewide to control half the seats.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by mbreese on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:33PM (#31865124)
Note: All of those unconstitutional rejections by the Ohio Supreme Court are moot. The committee ran out the clock and even though the maps were ruled unconstitutional, they are the ones that will be used. The law that forced the committee to be formed left no way for the courts to force a valid map to be used. So, even though there was a very successful anti-gerrymandering campaign in Ohio a few years ago, it ultimately didn't matter. How that came to be is another story entirely.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by heymijo on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:34PM (#31865145)
In Ohio we passed a state law demanding fair districts. The GOP led Ohio congress and governor repeatedly submitted districts that the courts struck down.

It went to a federal court who ruled the districts not fair but will let them stand for the 2022 elections.

The GOP ignored the rule of law, ignored the courts, and ran out the clock. They will cement their hold on the state in 2022.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by api on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:42PM (#31865311)
The far right has been fighting a locality-by-locality state-by-state war of attrition for a long time. There's far too much focus on national elections when local and state elections can sometimes influence your life a lot more.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by api on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:27PM (#31864985)
Gerrymandering needs to be tackled possibly at the level of a constitutional amendment, but like the filibuster it's a nonsense loophole power that neither side wants to give up.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by mbreese on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:38PM (#31865220)
There is no way to tackle gerrymandering that doesn't ultimately end geographic representation. If you try to balance a map for every potential group, the end game is proportional representation. I think that's the bridge that people would be afraid to cross.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by bergenty on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:31PM (#31866216)
Why do we need geographic representation? People that eat everyone’s tax dollars and contribute very little to the economy should not have an order of magnitude in voting advantages just because they decide to move to places no one else would. Those might have been worthy incentives during the frontier days but are completely unnecessary now.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by phpisthebest on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:54PM (#31865559)
One thing I have been thinking more on lately is just that. Why are we so attached to geographic representation, why does a congressional district, or even a state need to be a continuous polygon on a map.

Why cant we break representation to be based on something else. I dont know what, and the simple answer it well geography is the easiest way but easy it often not the best

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by dahfizz on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:06PM (#31865797)
A geographically connected population is going to have a lot in common, and it makes sense that they would share a representative.

Two neighboring farmers in Alamaba are going to have a lot more in common with each other than with someone living in LA. For political representation purposes, it makes sense for those two farmers to share a representative.

You're correct that this isn't necessarily optimal, but I don't think it's that bad either. It's a pretty good heuristic in making sure that:

1) everyone has a representative.

2) each representative is representing a group of people who can reasonably be represented (because they have shared interests/goals/concerns).

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by phpisthebest on Friday June 24, 2022 @04:44PM (#31869051)
I think that breaks down if you dig even a little deeper.

Sure 2 Alabama Farmers farmers are in common.

But does a farmer in near Austin has more in common with the Farmer in Alabama or the Urbanites in Austin?

Would Occupation, be a better class than geographic, or age, or something else

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by smileysteve on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:30PM (#31866211)
Alabama is an interesting look, because of metro Atlanta, metro Birmingham, Huntsville in the North - and then the blue belt that is the Piedmont.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by salawat on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:11PM (#31865884)
Because of it wasn't geographic, it would end up going resident centric, and if you think the system is toxic or confusing now, imagine switching it up such that your representatives seat was assigned to you like a Social Security Number, and followed you through life. Also imagine that seat's occupant's job, trying to represent a bloc of people sharing little more than an accident of being born in a particular jurisdiction at a particular time, that have spread hither and yon with no geographical anchor to point to and go, "that's where the stuff is happening that I'm here on behalf of".

Physical locality was the primary social constraint when the government was architected. I honestly have a great deal of difficulty imagining any other way of doing things that would make even a lick of sense in terms of information propagation.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by phpisthebest on Friday June 24, 2022 @04:48PM (#31869098)
That seems like a False Dilemma there is no technical or logical reason to assume that anything other than geographic would mean you are assigned a seat at birth that would follow you for ever with no ability to "move" to a different seat.

Also my comment does not say to forego all geographic basis but more so questioning the idea that we need continuous geographic zones.

Maybe 3 counties in Iowa and 3 counties in Texas, and 3 counties in Montana all want for form a new zone....

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by scythe on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:13PM (#31865915)
>that doesn't ultimately end geographic representation.

False.

>the end game is proportional representation

True. As I've said before, there are so many ways to do it that it's hard to unite people behind a single one:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31347226

And in fact, even when I tried to make a list of all the methods in the comment above, I missed at least two:

https://electowiki.org/wiki/PLACE_FAQ

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequential_proportional_approv...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by ochoseis on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:56PM (#31865590)
I have been wondering about this. Every state gets two senators representing the _entire state_, so you can’t gerrymander senate seats. I wonder if we need something similar for congressional districts, perhaps by allotting no less than two seats per district, which themselves are composed of one or more counties (the idea being county lines are not drawn by election boards).
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by stormbrew on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:08PM (#31865818)
> the idea being county lines are not drawn by election boards

Until they're important for elections...

The house is screwed up largely because it's capped by a law passed a century ago. It's essentially impossible for it to be actually proportional with the current voter:representative ratio and districts being allocated along state lines.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by mbreese on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:17PM (#31867996)
Originally, the ratio was one representative for ~30,000 people. When the number was capped at 435 in 1929, the number of constituents for a representative was ~ 210,000.

The current ratio is over 700,000.

One could easily make an argument for geographic representation of 30,000 people. Those people should have a lot in common and have similar concerns. You could also make a good argument for 100k-200k people. However, 500k+ people cannot be properly represented by one voice in congress.

If we had even the ratio of representation when the number was fixed (1:210,000), we'd have over 1500 members of Congress.

https://history.house.gov/Institution/Origins-Development/Pr...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by silisili on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:43PM (#31865328)
It's important to remember gerrymandering cuts both ways. In my state, the D's just redistricted into a crazy looking map that will effectively give them a clean sweep.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by colinmhayes on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:46PM (#31865379)
What choice do they have? It's an arms race.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by ZainRiz on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:10PM (#31865852)
I mean, the other side can make the claim too, right?

Then it just becomes two kids pointing at each other shouting "he started it!"

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by colinmhayes on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:31PM (#31866215)
Yea, that's the problem. Our government is dysfunctional and unable to pass laws even if they have widespread support.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by Daishiman on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:36PM (#31866307)
Someone starting an arms race is very significant point and not the minutiae you consider it to be.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by silisili on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:06PM (#31865785)
Neither is right, obviously. Wish they'd codify into law something that restricts the shapes...something like that all districts must be contiguous, and smallest possible perimeter of a given area size.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by achenet on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:03PM (#31865733)
it shouldn't be. If party loyalty trumps good governance, you messed up somewhere.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by colinmhayes on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:16PM (#31865965)
Is sitting back and letting you political opponent steam roll you good governance?
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by achenet on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:39PM (#31866364)
The fact that you view this as a fight (using the word "opponent") is the problem.

It's not a boxing match. The fact that it has become one means your electoral system is flawed.

In a proper system, you have different people with different goals (eg Greens who want less pollution, businesspeople who want lower taxes, socialists who want worker's rights, etc) and they have to compromise (greens cancel the carbon tax is businesspeople accept to ban a certain type of very toxic manufacturing, for example) and WORK TOGETHER.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by colinmhayes on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:43PM (#31866422)
> electoral system is flawed.

Obviously this is the problem. But its flaws have lead us to a situation that makes it impossible to fix them. Either we work within the system we have or we're left powerless.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by scythe on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:17PM (#31865981)
That's hardly a defense of gerrymandering. If anything, it shows that fixing gerrymandering should be an issue anyone can get behind.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by silisili on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:32PM (#31868221)
Oh no not a defense. I would never defend it, it's disgusting behavior.

I'm just pointing that out because the parent said gerrymandering screws Democrats. It does. But it also screws Republicans, and well, all of us.

I understand it's now a tit-for-tat so I'm not blaming either side more than the other. I just want it gone.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by vlunkr on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:06PM (#31865793)
If you look at the popular vote then this is clearly wrong in two ways. Rich land and business owners don't make up half the population. And if you're implying that most religious people vote republican, then they should be absolutely destroying the popular vote. This is just the worldview that's been sold to you by social media.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by colinmhayes on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:17PM (#31865987)
The religious are in control because you can't win a republican primary without their support.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by i5Aj7PXGjUPy on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:35PM (#31867319)
> At this point I see it as a fight between rich landowners+business owners+religion vs all the rest of the people

Based off of the responses itt, it's clearly not "all the rest of the people". But you know, maybe if you keep insisting that the political coalition in favor of Roe represents "all the rest of the people" it might magically become true

> I fail to see what moderates can do in a two party system where gerrymandering is so heavily done that often Democrats have to win 3-1 to control any majority.

Ofc democrats don't gerrymander. The Illinois redistricting wasn't a gerrymander, it was a fair process. Wherever the democrats have a hard time winning it's always because there was a gerrymander, and not because the people don't want them in office. /s

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by achenet on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:58PM (#31865639)
Change to proportional representatin or runoff elections. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by jamie_ca on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:24PM (#31867137)
Canadian here, I also would like to see multi-member districts of any variety rather than the status quo.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by kolanos on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:44PM (#31865339)
> In New York Democrats want to add four new seats through gerrymandering, to try to retain control of the U.S. House. One district is designed to guarantee the reelection of Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.), the chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, which has held hearings on the evil of — you guessed it — gerrymandering. [0]

[0]: https://thehill.com/opinion/campaign/592968-dismantling-demo...

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by dang on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:31PM (#31867256)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31864204.
[dead]
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by hackyhacky on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:23PM (#31864881)
This is backwards thinking. It's not a sports game, this is not about "winning" and "losing."

The goal is not to have voters choose their representatives, not the other way around. In a contested or closely divided district, the representatives must adapt to appeal to a majority, resulting in a more moderate position. In a gerrymandered district, the politician can do anything they want, because they know they effectively won't lose.

You're right that gerrymandering is not new, but it's gotten more aggressive, thanks to new technology and de facto sanctioning by SCOTUS.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by the_lonely_road on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:45PM (#31865364)
This is blatantly untrue to the level of fear mongering. The politician can’t do whatever he wants. The election simply moves from republican candidate against democrat candidate to the primaries where the top 3 politicians from the dominant party are running against one another for the nomination. If they adopted policies the majority of their party didn’t like they would be replaced by another member of the party in the next election.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by zackees on Saturday June 25, 2022 @03:43PM (#31878114)
This isn’t about winning or losing? Then why do representatives say they “won” a race? Winning and losing appears to be the cornerstone of a democracy.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by liminvorous on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:32PM (#31865107)
Gerrymandering is where you make sure all your districts are 51/49 in favor of you, and all your opositions are 90/10, so you get more representatives
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by zackees on Saturday June 25, 2022 @03:33PM (#31878034)
What you are complaining about is actually the exact tactics of the left, which is to expand their city boundaries so that their dense homogenous voters swing elections in the surrounding districts.

When the left does it’s called redistributing, when the right does it it’s called gerrymandering.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by germinalphrase on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:33PM (#31865120)
Gerrymandering is an explicitly anti-democratic mechanism to allow for persistent minority rule. Both parties are engaging in this process and benefit in a localized way - but the US population a whole loses.
Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by zackees on Saturday June 25, 2022 @03:39PM (#31878091)
Someone has to draw the lines.

It’s either going to be the representatives which are directly elected by the people or it’s going to be an unelected bureaucrats.

Your solution, being the latter, is far far more undemocratic. The framers of the constitution knew this and that’s why they put redistricting into the hands of the ELECTED BODY.

Re:Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade by germinalphrase on Saturday June 25, 2022 @04:16PM (#31878380)
In my home state of Wisconsin, redistricting used to be completed by a panel of elected judges. This process Created competitive districts that both parties grumbled about but lived with. This process was take away from the judges and put in the hands of the elected representatives, but those representatives have a direct personal interest in trying to draw those lines such that the districts are non-competitive in their favor. I’m not sure why you view this outcome as more democratic.