Why cant we break representation to be based on something else. I dont know what, and the simple answer it well geography is the easiest way but easy it often not the best
Two neighboring farmers in Alamaba are going to have a lot more in common with each other than with someone living in LA. For political representation purposes, it makes sense for those two farmers to share a representative.
You're correct that this isn't necessarily optimal, but I don't think it's that bad either. It's a pretty good heuristic in making sure that:
1) everyone has a representative.
2) each representative is representing a group of people who can reasonably be represented (because they have shared interests/goals/concerns).
Sure 2 Alabama Farmers farmers are in common.
But does a farmer in near Austin has more in common with the Farmer in Alabama or the Urbanites in Austin?
Would Occupation, be a better class than geographic, or age, or something else
Physical locality was the primary social constraint when the government was architected. I honestly have a great deal of difficulty imagining any other way of doing things that would make even a lick of sense in terms of information propagation.
Also my comment does not say to forego all geographic basis but more so questioning the idea that we need continuous geographic zones.
Maybe 3 counties in Iowa and 3 counties in Texas, and 3 counties in Montana all want for form a new zone....
False.
>the end game is proportional representation
True. As I've said before, there are so many ways to do it that it's hard to unite people behind a single one:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31347226
And in fact, even when I tried to make a list of all the methods in the comment above, I missed at least two:
https://electowiki.org/wiki/PLACE_FAQ
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequential_proportional_approv...
Until they're important for elections...
The house is screwed up largely because it's capped by a law passed a century ago. It's essentially impossible for it to be actually proportional with the current voter:representative ratio and districts being allocated along state lines.
The current ratio is over 700,000.
One could easily make an argument for geographic representation of 30,000 people. Those people should have a lot in common and have similar concerns. You could also make a good argument for 100k-200k people. However, 500k+ people cannot be properly represented by one voice in congress.
If we had even the ratio of representation when the number was fixed (1:210,000), we'd have over 1500 members of Congress.
https://history.house.gov/Institution/Origins-Development/Pr...