News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by BenoitEssiambre on Friday June 17, 2022 @06:31PM (#31785278)
I made this game in order to try to wrap my head around central banks, inflation and macroeconomics, in order to get a better understanding of the aftermath of the global financial crisis and the current period of high inflation.

Here is a blog post that goes into further details: https://benoitessiambre.com/simcb.html

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by doubleunplussed on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:32PM (#31786224)
Thank you so much! I've similarly been trying to wrap my head around monetary things recently, and as with learning anything in physics (my field), I believe you don't really understand a model unless you can code up a simulator.

It's been maddening not being able to find a comprehensive model of how all the bits fit together, and I have many times wondered if the lack of existence of a game like yours meant that no such model actually existed. Happy to be wrong!

And of course a game is a brilliant way to build intuition whether you know the equations of the underlying model or not.

I haven't played it yet but am greatly looking forward to it, really hoping to answer various gaps in my knowledge. Thanks again!

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by Nition on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:16AM (#31787613)
This is exactly why MONIAC[0][1] was created in 1949. Not a real computer exactly - it simulates the entire system with water flow.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MONIAC

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rAZavOcEnLg

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by vanjajaja1 on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:04PM (#31786721)
I've been looking for something similar too, an explanation of the financial system written out in code so that I can try understand it.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by DennisP on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:25PM (#31786800)
Something I found recently is Steve Keen's Minsky, and his book The New Economics, which uses Minsky to go through a series of simple models of the modern fiat money system.

http://www.profstevekeen.com/minsky/

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by theptip on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:38PM (#31787068)
I was going to suggest this tool too as I’m not aware of others like it.

Worth the caveat that Keen is a heterodox economist. So if you pull his off-the-shelf models you are not getting the current accepted “mainstream” theory. I don’t think Economics is a field as mature as Physics where you should have extremely strong deference to the orthodoxy based on an incredibly strong prediction record, but it’s worth keeping in mind.

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:09AM (#31787590)
But, aren't finical systems a sociological science, rather than a mathematical model?

In economies, people, politics, and their dispositions, their sentiments, dominate.

How do you model human responses to local, national, regional, and global events. How do you model human cascades?

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by lottin on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:48AM (#31787729)
Mathematical models are that, models—a simplified version of a particular phenomenon. Economic models are no different, in particular they presuppose, among other things, that economic agents behave rationally [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_economicus

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by thelamest on Saturday June 18, 2022 @05:23AM (#31788415)
Economic “rationality” sometimes gets a bad rap, but it’s more defensible than it may appear and provides a well-circumscribed, workable general foundation to expand on. In simple versions: rational preferences (which include indifference) are transitive and complete, and people pursue these goals. That’s all. Symmetric violations wash away in the aggregate, and asymmetric can be included, e.g. as loss aversion. Criticism of “rationality” is often stuck in late 19th to mid 20th century debates that were since generally resolved.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday June 18, 2022 @03:47AM (#31787994)
Thank you for your response, I shall read that Wikipedia entry when I sober up.

Australian East Coast Saturday night wooo!

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by WanderPanda on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:24PM (#31787030)
While we are at it: I need this for climate change as well
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by pes23 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:16AM (#31787221)
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by evandale on Sunday June 19, 2022 @09:22AM (#31799112)
This game was ok until it asked about energy generation and didn't allow you to increase nuclear production.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by ephbit on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @03:24AM (#31821197)
This Climate Game by FT .. it feels a bit like promotion for carbon capture tech.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by ACow_Adonis on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:34PM (#31786832)
first of all, awesome job. I'm also a big believer in trying to code such models up to try to understand them.

But, and it pains me to say it, as someone with a bit of a background in economics, I dunno if realistic is quite the word i would use for your current model.

And I don't mean in a "all models are wrong but some are useful" kinda way. I think some of the limitations and simplifications might take away from the value of the model. I'd urge everyone to read the blog post to understand what's going on.

you've touched upon a lot of the apparent findings and paradoxes of macro, which is great.

to try to be constructive, I guess I would ask a rhetorical question to focus on a central (pun intended) issue: how are interest rates set by the central bank implemented? is it an independent variable that you kinda change, or is it implemented through changes in monetary + credit supply? I'm concerned that this is another one of those macroeconomic paradoxes built into the model that lessens its applicability: the idea that interest rates are a variable that the central bank issues by decree, as opposed to a rate that they target by adjusting other monetary/ policy settings?

anyway, good job. I love it when people actually code up and stimulate models :)

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by espadrine on Saturday June 18, 2022 @09:52AM (#31789824)
It is cool to make those simulations. The mechanics explained deviate significantly from any central bank I know.

In particular, the negative interest rate of SimCB does something very different from, almost the opposite of, what the ECB does (along with many other central banks). What they have is a negative interest rate on the deposit facility rate, which means that overnight deposits on a class of central bank accounts will incur a loss for the commercial bank of, say 0.5% yearly, which incentivizes instead investing those funds.

cf. https://www.ecb.europa.eu/ecb/educational/explainers/tell-me...

In SimCB, a negative interest rate makes everyone incentivized to take on a loan, as they will get free money at the expense of everyone else as long as they reimburse the principal, which is even easier when they don’t invest the money in orchards.

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by kkfx on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:08AM (#31787189)
Allow me to suggest a taste of history https://www.heritage-history.com/index.php?c=read&author=car... or if you want to cut corners just scroll to the bottom of the page.

To study central banks you need those history before the model :-)

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by eru on Saturday June 18, 2022 @03:20AM (#31787870)
You might be better off studying Scottish and Canadian monetary history, instead of the Bank of England.

https://www.amazon.com/Good-Money-Birmingham-Beginnings-Coin... is also really interesting.

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by wheelerof4te on Saturday June 18, 2022 @05:05AM (#31788345)
You are approaching this from the flawed neo-liberal assumption that, to have good economic model, only inflation has to be controlled.

The rate of inflation is hardly more important than, for example, tax rate. From the Central Bank viewpoint, how much money is annually generated could be anywhere between 15-350%. The key to a good economy lies in proficiency in other sectors, like industry.

The bulk of money is generated through private bank loans, anyway.

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by denton-scratch on Saturday June 18, 2022 @05:13AM (#31788374)
Thank you.

Many, many years ago I typed a BASIC program listing for a macro-economics simulation from a computer magazine into a computer. As with your game, the only lever was the bank interest rate. The outcome (for me) was always economic catastrophe.

I'd love to play an economic sim that also has a taxrate input; I realise that's normally not set by the central bank; but then again, it's often not the central bank that really sets central bank interest rates; it's the government.

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by spurgu on Sunday June 19, 2022 @05:58AM (#31797898)
> Although an instrument of the US Government, the Federal Reserve System considers itself "an independent central bank because its monetary policy decisions do not have to be approved by the President or by anyone else in the executive or legislative branches of government, it does not receive funding appropriated by Congress, and the terms of the members of the board of governors span multiple presidential and congressional terms."

I.e. the US central bank doesn't answer to anyone.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Reserve

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by lamename on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:52PM (#31786339)
Thank you! I've looked around for macroeconomic simulations before and found very little. Looking forward to learning from this.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by haupt on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:19PM (#31786485)
Excellent work, thank you.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by xrisk on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:55PM (#31786358)
Please remove the strip-ey overlay you have, it makes the text actively harder to read.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by xwolfi on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:18PM (#31786479)
Can we scam little people with crypto using central bank scapegoating as well ?
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by fartcannon on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:43PM (#31786874)
As in, scam people and then scapegoat 'crypto bros' for the current financial crisis that has more to do with printing money than anything else?
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by danielmarkbruce on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:33PM (#31787056)
What financial crises?
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by fartcannon on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:10AM (#31787392)
Denial works too, I guess.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by danielmarkbruce on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:41PM (#31792020)
The stock market going down and a decent potential of recession doesn't meet the definition of "financial crisis" that is used by people in finance.

I guess you can make up your own definition.

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by lottin on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:51AM (#31787744)
We're not in a financial crisis.
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday June 18, 2022 @05:43AM (#31788516)
To add to this, we’re in a bear market and possibly recession. But not a financial crisis. (We’re also not in a currency crisis. The dollar is gaining against pretty much every currency. It’s also gaining against practically every crypto.)
Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by vintermann on Saturday June 18, 2022 @04:37AM (#31788211)
Nobody is printing money.

Either you have this naive understanding that government is secretly printing money and hiding it from the auditors, in which case you are simply wrong.

Or you could have the more sophisticated opinion that, "yeah, I know that the so-called freshly printed money is actually already circulating money that government convinced people to give them in return for a promise in the form of a bond. But that's practically the same as printing money!"

But if you take that perspective, then crypto bros are ALSO printing money at a furious pace.

Re:Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic e... by kgwgk on Saturday June 18, 2022 @05:55AM (#31788557)
> already circulating money that government convinced people to give them in return for a promise in the form of a bond

The money printing part is not the Treasury issuing bonds (and getting money).

The money printing part is the Federal Reserve buying bonds (and giving money).