News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by willcipriano on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:30PM (#31783893)
Ignoring the effect on prisoners, this drives down wages for low skill people on the outside. No labor should be able to be sold below minimum wage, otherwise it really isn't one.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by giantg2 on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:58PM (#31784290)
Using this same logic would support things like import duties to offset the lower labor costs that we can't domesticallycompete with, right?
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by pessimizer on Friday June 17, 2022 @06:23PM (#31785183)
Yes, and the only reason we should have import duties is because of labor conditions and pay for foreign workers. If we don't we're not competing on PPP or efficiency, we're competing based on the willingness to abuse.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by thescriptkiddie on Friday June 17, 2022 @07:53PM (#31785979)
Economists call this border adjustment. The idea is that when goods are imported from a country with lower taxes (or lower wages or lax environmental protections), they are taxed at whatever rate is necessary to bring their price in line with domestic equivalents. Likewise when goods are exported, whatever tax has been paid is refunded to bring their price down. Every nation in the EU plus China, Canada, and Mexico all do this. The US is actually quite unusual for not doing this.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by kelseyfrog on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:22PM (#31784534)
Using the same logic, we could just as easily imprison the global south. While logical consistency is satisfying in theory, in practice it's a poor optimization strategy.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by xmprt on Friday June 17, 2022 @07:45PM (#31785912)
> just as easily imprison the global south

What do you mean by this? How does the US have the jurisdiction to imprison anyone outside of the US?

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by kelseyfrog on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:07PM (#31786077)
I'm going to say it is a metaphor for US international policy[1] and if you say, "that's just how international politics works" or "but that's not imprisonment" I'm going to make a face.

1. IMF policy, and the sheer number of US-backed coups in the global south.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by Rury on Friday June 17, 2022 @07:46PM (#31785929)
Not if this is more about fair labor rights than fair business competition within the US. Domestically we can enforce minimum wage, foreignly we cannot. Import duties won't necessarily impact the wages of foreign laborers...
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by giantg2 on Friday June 17, 2022 @07:54PM (#31785981)
Part of their argument is about lower labor value due to increased supply. Making that foreign supply less attractive by making it cost the same could increase labor demand domestically.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by Rury on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:20PM (#31786158)
Sure, import duties could help domestic businesses and potentially laborers for said businesses, but doesn't ensure domestic businesses would pay their workers a minimum wage even with increased business demand.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by sudosysgen on Friday June 17, 2022 @06:48PM (#31785441)
No, because of comparative advantage. How does that work in the context of prisoners doing the same work anyways, though?
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by missedthecue on Friday June 17, 2022 @06:40PM (#31785369)
Yes, that logic would lead to that. Many people are misled to believe that limiting competition produces net benefits for society.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by pastacacioepepe on Saturday June 18, 2022 @03:34AM (#31787948)
Yes!
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by micromacrofoot on Friday June 17, 2022 @06:37PM (#31785339)
yes
[dead]
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by sumy23 on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:37PM (#31783998)
The minimum wage applies to immigrants.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by itake on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:48PM (#31784156)
If we reduced immigration, businesses would have to compete for the smaller low-skill work force.

One of the "levers" in this article [0] is that Amazon could increase the wages to capture more of the labor market.

[0] - https://www.vox.com/recode/23170900/leaked-amazon-memo-wareh...

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by HideousKojima on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:42PM (#31784073)
Only if they're working on the books
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by bergenty on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:49PM (#31784182)
This applies to everyone, even citizens and residents.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by kube-system on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:51PM (#31784868)
With the significant difference that they have the ability to report their employers crimes without being blackmailed for their immigration status.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by bergenty on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:07PM (#31786074)
Why would this be any different for a legal immigrant?
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by kube-system on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:56PM (#31786364)
Because they have no reason to be afraid of deportation for being undocumented.

Employers of undocumented immigrants frequently break labor laws because they can get away with it because their employees are too afraid to do anything about it.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by bergenty on Saturday June 18, 2022 @12:14AM (#31787212)
This whole thread has been about legal immigrants. You’re referring to undocumented immigrants.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by kube-system on Saturday June 18, 2022 @11:10AM (#31790515)
It wasn't, though. You replied to this comment which was referring to undocumented immigrants: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31784073
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by bergenty on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:25PM (#31791899)
Nope. That was my very first point. Not being on the “books” can apply to anyone.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by kube-system on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:55PM (#31792681)
Legal workers who choose jobs off the books do so because they get a better deal out of the situation. They’re not being forced to work for under minimum wage, like many undocumented workers are.

Legal immigrants are not picking lettuce for $4/hr off the books. They’re working at their cousins store making legal wages off the books.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by giantg2 on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:45PM (#31784114)
Many work farm labor, tip work, or gig work.

Edit: why disagree?

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by karaterobot on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:41PM (#31784061)
Not sure I follow. The person you're responding to is saying there should not be a situation in which anybody is working for less than minimum wage. If that premise were granted, low skilled immigrant workers would be making the same minimum wage as everyone else, wouldn't they? So while there may be a larger pool everyone would be competing for jobs in, the wages would still be the same.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by itake on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:57PM (#31784281)
According to this[0] article, Amazon is considering raising wages for min wage employees to increase the size of their labor pool. If there was an abundance of min wage workers, then Amazon would not need to raise wages.

https://www.vox.com/recode/23170900/leaked-amazon-memo-wareh...

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by bergenty on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:48PM (#31784164)
Why do you think legal immigrants are being paid less than minimum wage?
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by _-david-_ on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:02PM (#31784344)
I don't think he was saying legal immigrants get paid less than minimum wage, but less than a citizen. Immigrants are in a more precarious situation depending on which visa they have (assuming they don't have a green card) which can make it more of a challenge to switch jobs which drives down their wages.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by mhb on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:40PM (#31784037)
On its own, this is not a good argument since there is a benefit to having cheap goods produced by low wage producers.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by willcipriano on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:12PM (#31784431)
There is benefit to firms that hire prison labor, it isn't clear that it results in any benefit to consumers. Well connected firms able to hire prison labor may just keep all the surplus.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by toss1 on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:48PM (#31784153)
And that, right there, is the argument of the standard sociopathic capitalist.

Just because there is a benefit, does not mean that there is not also a greater harm that more than offsets the benefit on a societal scale.

Privatizing the profits from the benefits while socializing the harms, and justifying any harm based on a profitable benefit, is far too often the business model - take the money while poisoning the well.

This is neither sustainable, nor a good argument for something to exist.

EDIT: insert missing "not also"

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by brightball on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:05PM (#31784370)
It's no different than having less expensive foreign labor do the work and then importing the goods. The only thing the minimum wage does here is ensure that nobody is allowed to perform the task at that rate.

Toss out the minimum wage and institute a survival level "basic income" instead. If it is truly the desire of a society to set a minimum acceptable amount of money that a person deserves, let the cost be paid by society itself. Then people can have an open, unquestioned choice about what rate they are willing to accept to perform a job to supplement their income: be it unpaid internships or working at a fruit stand.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by mhb on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:53PM (#31784232)
If license plates were harvested for free, there would be fewer jobs making license plates. Ceteris paribus, the reasoning that we shouldn't use the free license plates because they're reducing the number of jobs making them doesn't make sense.

This is independent of your separate objections that prisoners should not be taken advantage of.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by toss1 on Friday June 17, 2022 @06:29PM (#31785256)
>> the reasoning that we shouldn't use the free license plates because they're reducing the number of jobs making them doesn't make sense.

Yes, once the things are made, simply wasting the things on principle is, well, simply wasteful.

That said, if that step of wasting them is required in order to stop the practice of (near-)slavery, then the waste could be worthwhile.

Either way, slavery is bad both in it's own right and to the extent that it harms wider society by degrading the value of others' labor.

This could also be solved by requiring all jobs to pay a bona-fide living wage, as in, you cannot hire anyone unless you are paying them for 40 hours of work an amount that is sufficient to support them and dependents for all basic needs, i.e., food, housing, health, transport, etc. Perhaps an exception for dependents who are entering the workforce, who could be paid lower rates for a certain time. With this, then slavery wouldn't have so much outside harm in addition to its intrinsic harm.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by mhb on Friday June 17, 2022 @07:22PM (#31785753)
I think I wasn't clear. It seems like there are two things that you are suggesting are bad:

1. Slaves

2. People losing jobs because goods can be produced more cheaply than they should be paid for producing them.

I'm saying that #2 isn't bad on its own. Air is free. It is available for less than it would cost people to produce it. That's not a problem.

The cost of what you're proposing is that some jobs won't be done at all. Maybe that is acceptable to you.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by toss1 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @06:42AM (#31788714)
>>The cost of what you're proposing is that some jobs won't be done at all. Maybe that is acceptable to you.

Interesting.

I think that it is acceptable, and actually inevitable - only the threshold of [won't get done] changes.

At some point, if a thing has so little value that people won't pay enough for it to be done, whether the threshold is living wages or prison wages, why should it be created?

We already have far too much junk in the world.

If the thing is sufficiently valuable, then its cost can increase to a sustainable level. E.g., water used to be free also, and paying for bottled water when tap or stream water was right at hand was mocked. But now, people are happy to pay often stupid-money for bottles of water.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by xtracto on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:27PM (#31784584)
I don't know... the capitalist model works well to a certain extent. I would agree with the grand parent idea if (and only if) it included extremely heavy taxation law. It's OK for corporations to compete on extracting the most efficient labor, but only if we can "socialize" the gains through taxation.

The problem in the current capitalist system is that private companies have managed to corrupt that other size of the system (taxation) through bribes to the government.

Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by joshgroban on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:10PM (#31784412)
Sociopathy isn't a recognized diagnosis among psychiatrists. It's narcissism these days.
Re:US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and service... by toss1 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @07:07AM (#31788790)
Ok, "standard dark-triad-personality-trait capitalist"

... or is it "quad" these days? ;-)