News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by Synaesthesia on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:16AM (#31723813)
Its kind of a big deal since a currency luke this only has two stable points, 0 and 1.

Once people start attacking it by eg buying them for $0.97 and exchanging for $1 thrn it might be over for tether.

Who's to say tether did not just print that money BTW? We simply don't know.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by prvit on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:18AM (#31723837)
> Once people start attacking it by eg buying them for $0.97 and exchanging for $1 thrn it might be over for tether.

Or, alternatively, Tether is printing money every time someone posts a sell order for USDT at less than $1.

At 0.97 that would be an immediate 3% profit for each USDT they buy.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by spywaregorilla on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:23AM (#31723877)
If and only if they buy it and can sell it at again for $1.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by paulgb on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:26AM (#31723916)
It would still be a profit in the accounting sense. They could erase a $1 liability at a cost of $0.97.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by spywaregorilla on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:49AM (#31724114)
You're assuming they track tether as a liability. I doubt it, as they have no contractual obligation to redeem them.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by paulgb on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:01AM (#31724228)
Their transparency page counts issued coins as liabilities: https://tether.to/en/transparency/
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by spywaregorilla on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:31AM (#31724545)
Their transparency page also states they have 1:1 asset backings which is a lie so oh well.

This page is irrelevant. They are not obligated to redeem your tokens. They're not liabilities. They may pretend they are, but they're not, and if the money stops flowing, they can leave with all the remaining money in the bank laughing at their idiot customers.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by paulgb on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:49AM (#31724777)
I’m not saying that page is accurate, just that it reflects their treatment of outstanding tether as a liability, so buying it back for below par is profit in their books.

I think we agree on all the rest; I also believe that it’s a scam.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by shkkmo on Monday June 13, 2022 @09:18AM (#31725127)
> reflects their treatment of outstanding tether as a liability,

It reflects their desire to have is seem that way. Given Tether's well established history of lieing to try to seem more stable, this provides zero evidence for their real attitude.

That's the real question that all the bros and shills try to hide. It isn't about when Tether's price can't be kept stable, but about when Tether decides they can't make more money off the market so takes their marbles and goes home.

It is possible that Tether wouod decide to keep holding the peg, all the way until they run out of reserve assets, but it seems highly likely that there is a tipping point well before that where Tether decides to keep their remaining assets and let the peg die.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by spywaregorilla on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:00AM (#31726538)
Books are imaginary, and books that are not publically audited are even more imaginary.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by lxgr on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:46AM (#31724726)
As long as they have enough liquid assets they can sell for more than $0.97 on the dollar and still keep enough to maintain stability, yes.

The big question seems to be whether they do have these.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by solumunus on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:31AM (#31723960)
> Once people start attacking it by eg buying them for $0.97 and exchanging for $1 thrn it might be over for tether.

Am I missing something? That's literally how stablecoins are supposed to work. Arbitrage creates demand which maintains price.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by mhluongo on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:40AM (#31724027)
If a stablecoin allows redemptions, and it isn't completely backed, everyone trying to redeem at once can lead to a bank run and spiral as no one wants to be the last holder. The hope, of course, is that it is completely backed. It's also quite hard / expensive to redeem Tether, I've heard.

For arb, I think the trade here is: can I buy USDT and redeem fast enough that I make a low-risk spread, or am I further exposing my funds to risk over that redemption period? Versus selling USDT for USDC, for example, which I can do immediately if I trust USDC. I imagine the latter is what's happening on-chain.

EDIT: Clarified my lazy language around low-risk arb versus peg speculation.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by solumunus on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:01AM (#31724226)
> I think you've got it backwards. The arb would be people buying it at $0.97 and hoping it repegs to $1, not redeeming

That's not an arb, that's just buying low and selling high at a later date. The arb is buying something for $0.97 but then getting $1 back, minus fees. The more people doing that the closer the peg stays to $1 through supply/demand. That's the whole basis of how a peg is maintained, arbitrage players provide huge amounts of liquidity and make small margins for doing so.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by mhluongo on Monday June 13, 2022 @09:00AM (#31724922)
Ah, true, apologies for the lazy early-morning comment. Editing.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by lottin on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:52AM (#31724144)
The arbitrageurs buy USDT at a discount and redeem it, pocketing the difference. This creates a buying pressure, that tends to bring the price back up to $1. Buying USDT and hoping that it repegs is not arbitrage.

If tether fails to redeem USDT arbitrage will stop and nothing will prevent USDT from falling more.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by jfk13 on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:06AM (#31724287)
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by capableweb on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:18AM (#31723829)
That's simply not true. Tether almost hit $0.9 quite some time ago, and managed to recover. What's to say it's not true today too?

I have no love for Tether and love to see it crash and burn. But until it gets close to $0.9 again, I'm sitting back and not enjoying the show, yet.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by Synaesthesia on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:56AM (#31724180)
I know it managed to recover, I'm not saying that this is definitely it, but it is possible and there is a tipping point.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by luka-birsa on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:19AM (#31724419)
TLDR:

USDT is shady. USDT is not depegging. USDT FUD is a classic bear market move. Whales make a killing swapping USD for USDT and pocketing 5% for zero risk.

It feels like we'll just keep repeating the same story of tether depegging, without anyone actually looking at the redeem process and what would it truly mean for USDT to depeg.

What you're seeing is USDT-USD slip on an exchange that provides that trading pair. As it is with any other traded asset, if all of a sudden you get this huge demand for USD trading, to the point that the liquidity dries up, of course this will push the price up. Take that graph and zoom out, perhaps looking at 5 year scale. This slip actually happens once or twice a year, depending on the FUD that's on the market. Market is in extreme fear with cataclysmic level events occurring (Celsius and Terra events are close to what happened to banking in 2008 or worse) weekly. Obviously every news will cause increased sell pressure on USDT and eventually arbitration between entities will not occur fast enough.

Now let's look at what happened during the last "depegging". Price dropped to .90 cents per dollar and after a while it returned to 1 USD. Look at the circulating supply of tether - in the aftermath of Terra people actually cut 20% of all supply of USDT and converted it into alternative stable coins BUSD (by Paxos/Binance) and USDC (by Coinbase/Circle) being the primary benificiaries of the flows.

Now let's look at the "depegging" claims. Tether would need to not honor the promise of USD payout when you send them USDT. BitFinex is the exchange thats behind tether and you can redeem tether for USD. During the height of the last "depegging", you could always send your USDT there and get USD back at ~1:1 ratio (https://trading.bitfinex.com/t/UST:USD?type=exchange).

While we can talk about the USDT reserves and we can talk about shady/enron level practices and the court trials, we can also say that after 5 years of they have yet to break USDT. They've cut 20% of their circulation without breaking a sweat. USDT will not crash until there is a bigger functioning alternative. All the key players will ensure that; it's game over for crypto otherwise.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by unknown_apostle on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:31AM (#31724552)
Now let's look at market cap. Redemption is no longer "looked at" but in progress.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by imron on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:18AM (#31723834)
How it a bigger deal than any of the significantly larger and longer drops that have happened in tether’s history?
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by donkeyd on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:25AM (#31723904)
Larger drops have had clear news about Tether to blame for the drop. From what I can tell, this one is more natural and caused by turmoil in crypto markets themselves. That's what makes this interesting to me.

Edit: Apparently there's some news: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31723878

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by FabHK on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:59AM (#31724909)
As Hemingway memorably said: "Gradually, then suddenly."

https://quoteinvestigator.com/2018/08/06/bankrupt/

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by tiku on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:41AM (#31724035)
they have reports on their site by external parties that check their funds. anyway they have a lot of bonds etc.

we don't care when banks only have 50% of their client's money but we do when it's tether for some reason.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by greenthrow on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:50AM (#31724118)
This is an extremely disingenuous argument on so many levels.

1) Banks don't run their own currencies.

2) Banks don't claim to have a dollar on hand for every dollar in account balances at all times.

3) Banks are FDIC insured. Even if the bank collapses, you will get your money back.

Crypto bros, it's time to stop defending Tether. It will collapse and you will look just as foolish as the people who backed Luna and Safemoon and all the other scams.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by beojan on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:04AM (#31724261)
> 1) Banks don't run their own currencies.

Some do, namely the Scottish and Northern Irish note issuing banks. These have to be fully backed though.

https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/banknotes/scottish-and-north...

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by beefield on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:54AM (#31724169)
If the value of assets of a bank drops under certain limits [1], regulators can and will take action. To be clear, every single bank that is currently alive (and regulated by relevant western authorities) has assets way more than what the deposits are worth. They may not be liquid assets, but they are there.

[1] you may want to search for terms like "regulatory capital" or "capital adequacy"

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by elliekelly on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:04AM (#31724256)
And banks segregate assets. If the bank entity goes under the customer deposits shouldn’t be at risk and vice versa. Tether, on the other hand, is a whole big mess of co-mingled corporate and customer cash.
Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by lxgr on Monday June 13, 2022 @09:00AM (#31724914)
> And banks segregate assets.

That's inaccurate. The entire idea of a bank is to connect supply of and demand for money across heterogenous creditors and debtors, which includes retail depositors and commercial lenders. There isn't a "secure savings account department" and a "risky commercial loans department"; it's all on the same balance sheet.

What does protect retail depositors (to a certain limit) are schemes like FDIC. Any retail deposits not covered by that, and any commercial deposits, will receive a haircut when the bank goes under. In the EU and UK, this has happened at least twice in the last few years.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by elliekelly on Monday June 13, 2022 @10:36AM (#31726233)
When I say “segregate assets” I mean the bank’s assets from the customers’ assets. Tether comingles Tether Corp assets with Tether customer assets. That’s a big no-no. If tether goes under its much more difficult to discern which dollar is a Tether dollar vs a customer’s dollar.

Edit: Re-reading your comment I understand the confusion. I’m assuming Tether, if it were a bank, would function and be regulated like the Trust Department of a bank.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by lxgr on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:15AM (#31726755)
There really is no such separation between "the bank's assets" and "the customers' assets".

A bank has liabilities (customer deposits, financial contacts with other banks etc) and assets (loans, cash in a vault, their central bank balance, real estate of their office locations, office furniture etc). These are absolutely all on the same balance sheet, and the difference between the two is the bank's equity. Take a look at the Fed's balance sheet, for example: It explicitly lists the land that its branches are located on, and owned by it, as an asset [1].

What's regulated is, among other things, the required equity in relation to total assets/liabilities (capital adequacy requirements) and a high enough ratio of liquid reserves to total liabilities to handle various stress scenarios (liquidity requirements).

Importantly, and this cannot be stressed enough in this context, Tether is not a regulated bank.

[1] https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_fedsbalanc...

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by elliekelly on Monday June 13, 2022 @12:03PM (#31727372)
No, fiduciary assets are segregated. See, 12 USC 92a(c) and corresponding implementing regulation 12 CFR §9.13(b).

The Fed is not a good example of how banks typically operate or how banking regulations are typically implemented because the Fed is not a typical bank.

12 USC 92a: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/12/92a

12 CFR §9.13: https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/12/9.13

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by lxgr on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:55PM (#31729942)
Regular bank deposits are not fiduciary assets though, no? If they were, what would be the point of FDIC?

Securities are a different story – in that case, a bank or brokerage really only acts as a custodian for the accountholder, not adding them to their balance sheet.

Re:Tether is starting to depeg from USD again by surfmike on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:44AM (#31724061)
That’s because of FDIC. Nothing will save you if tether peg fails.