For arb, I think the trade here is: can I buy USDT and redeem fast enough that I make a low-risk spread, or am I further exposing my funds to risk over that redemption period? Versus selling USDT for USDC, for example, which I can do immediately if I trust USDC. I imagine the latter is what's happening on-chain.
EDIT: Clarified my lazy language around low-risk arb versus peg speculation.
That's not an arb, that's just buying low and selling high at a later date. The arb is buying something for $0.97 but then getting $1 back, minus fees. The more people doing that the closer the peg stays to $1 through supply/demand. That's the whole basis of how a peg is maintained, arbitrage players provide huge amounts of liquidity and make small margins for doing so.
If tether fails to redeem USDT arbitrage will stop and nothing will prevent USDT from falling more.
Am I missing something? That's literally how stablecoins are supposed to work. Arbitrage creates demand which maintains price.